Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11829 (KAR)
NAGARATNA v. THE COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/202885/2023 · 2025-01-27
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11829 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11829 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%""
&% '
! "##
$
%
%%
&
%
%%
'
( &
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
! "
(#% )
% $
*
%
& + %
% * %
' '
,
' ' $
* %
+ % ,
%
-. *
/ (
(
01 2134345617 089 :08;;16<1= 86 57=17 =831= ' ' 28991= >? 719256=163 5 8@30574A46< 719256=1635357@6B847274:1=125356:5C2899456831 >89491343456170898;9595@<03B578D74346301683@715B C86=8C@9 35 =471:3 719256=163 5 35 :5694=17 017 822;4:83456B57<78635B8@30574A83456
- 3 -
134345617 :56316=9 3083 301 B83017 5B 719256=163 5 D89 <78631= 8@30574A83456 35 7@6 8 B847 274:1=125383571>8;E4;;8<15B46<89@<@738;@F86=01 =41=56 ' 833018<15B+ ?1879;18E46<>1046= 049 D4B1 86= 9569 46:;@=46< 719256=163 5 86= 8 949317 134345617 B4;1= 86 822;4:83456 911F46< 8;;53C163 5B 301 984= B847 274:1 =1253 4C4;87;? 719256=163 5 8;95 B4;1=86822;4:8345656 B57:56346@834565B301 B847 274:1 =1253 56 :5C2899456831 <75@6= 46:1 301 822;4:83456 B4;1= >? 719256=163 5 D89 653 :5694=171= 01B4;1=*5 & '86=30495@7346317C95B301 57=17 =831= G & ' 8;;5D1= 301 D743 21343456 86= =471:31=301719256=16353571:5694=17301822;4:83456 B4;1=>?719256=1635B57:56346@834565BB847274:19052 56 :5C2899456831 <75@6=9 B317 71:1423 5B 301 8B571984= 57=17 719256=163 5 28991= 301 4C2@<61= 57=17 :56346@46< 301 8@30574A83456 46 301 68C1 5B 719256=163 5 56 :5C2899456831 >8949 01 2134345617 49 30171B571 >1B57130495@73:56316=46<3083719256=1635=4=653
- 4 -
:5694=17301822;4:83456B4;1=>?017D04:0D89C@:027457 35301822;4:83456B4;1=>?719256=1635
' 18761= :5@691; B57 301 2134345617 :56316=1= 3083 @6=17 @;1 ' 5B #876838F8
9916348; 5CC5=43419
"@>;4: 49374>@3456 ?931C$ 56375; 7=17 & 4B 301 8@30574A1= =18;17 =41= >1B571 01 8338461= 301 8<1 5B & ?1879 3016 301 8@30574A83456 :5@;= >1 37869B1771= 35 049 925@91 57 956 57 @6C87741= =8@<0317 1 :56316=9 3083 946:1301B830175B719256=1635D89+ ?18795;=83 301 34C1 5B 049 =1830 H@193456 5B 37869B17746< 301 8@30574A83456 35 719256=163 5 =519 653 87491 83 8;; 16:13018@30574A83456B1;;E8:86386=86?5611;91D89 16343;1=35822;? 17:56378;18761=:5@691;B57719256=1635 9@>C439 3083 8@30574A83456 D89 37869B1771= 35 719256=163 5468::57=86:1D430@;1'5B301#876838F8
9916348;
5CC5=43419 "@>;4: 49374>@3456 ?931C$ 56375; 7=17 &1:56316=930838557=4683116:05B30495@73 46*5'G 86=:5661:31=21343456908=@201;=
- 5 -
30125D175B30138315E176C163354C2591:56=434569 D04;1:5694=1746<301822;4:83456B57<78635B8@30574A83456 56 :5C2899456831 >8949 86= 89 8 561 34C1 C189@71 =471:31= 301 3831 5E176C163 35 37183 8;; 30591 :8919 D4305@3 71B1716:1 35 8<1 86= 71<87=;199 5B 301 H@193456 3083 D013017 301? 08= 28991= 1I8C4683456 57 653 130171B571:56316=93083719256=16354916343;1=35 :56346@13018@30574A83456
6 712;?
;18761= :5@691; B57 301 2134345617 9@>C4331= 3083 8 557=46831 16:0 5B 3049 5@73 46 * 5G 08= 01;= 3083 2134345617 3017146 08= 653 B@;B4;;1=301:56=4345692719:74>1=46275E49535@;1'5B 30156375; 7=17 &86=71J1:34565B04971H@193 B57 :56346@83456 5B 8@30574A83456 56 :5C2899456831 <75@6=9D89J@9386=2752171:56316=930834C2@<61= 57=1728991=>?719256=1635:56346@46<8@30574A83456 46 B8E5@7 5B 719256=163 5 30171B571 D8778639 46317B1716:1
- 6 -
& 01 B83017 5B719256=163 5 D89 <78631= 86 8@30574A83456357@68B847274:1905283571>8;E4;;8<13 4965346=492@31308301=41=56 ' 86=D89+ ?1879 5;= @;1 ' 5B #876838F8
9916348; 5CC5=43419
"@>;4: 49374>@3456 ?931C$ 56375; 7=17 GG D04:0 D89 46 1I49316:1 83 301 34C1 5B <7863 5B 8@30574A83456 35 301 B83017 5B 719256=163 5 4695B87 43 71<87=9 35 37869B175B8@30574A83456718=989B5;;5D9
+ 0171B571 83 301 71;1E863 25463 5B 34C1 D016 8@30574A83456 D89 <78631= @256 301 =1830 5B 8@30574A1= =18;17 301 925@91 57 956 57 @6C87741= =8@<0317 D89 16343;1= B57 37869B17 D430 27457 82275E8; 5B 301 5E176C163 049 7@;1 D89 8C16=1= 46 301 ?187 & D04:0718=989@6=17
- 7 -
! " #
#
#
#
$
#
#%&'
'
(
& ) *&
+ &
,&
#'
-
. #'
# $
0497@;1@6=17D1638:086<146301?187 + D04:0718=989@6=17 $ / '
'
0
#
# %1'
( &)*&
%1
+ 223-'
# ! ,&
#2
-
' 4' -
2 -
" 5
. '
#
$
- 8 -
G 831743D898C16=1=46301?187 D04:0 718=989@6=17
"
- 66/
7
8 9 -
5
2 )-
+:';&%' -' '
'
6 $ '
.6
'
' 6
20 .6 0
<
0
<
0
=
& 2
>
. ! 2
-
' 4' -
2
-
" 5 .
'
$
01H@193456D013017301275E4945695B301@;1 ' 5B 301 7=17 89 D89 46 B57:1 83 301 34C1 5B <786346<
- 9 -
8@30574A83456 905@;= >1 C8=1 822;4:8>;1 57 D013017 301 275E49535@;1'5B301 7=1789D8946B57:18330134C1 5B37869B175B8@30574A1==18;17905@;=>1C8=1822;4:8>;1 :8C1 @2 B57 :5694=1783456 >1B571 557=46831 16:019 5B 30495@7346*5 ' '86=43D8901;=3083301 719374:34569 46375=@:1= 46 275E495 35 @;1'5B301 7=17 D171 275921:34E1 46 683@71 86= :5@;= 653 >1 822;41= 35 8@30574A83456 <78631= @6=17 @68C16=1= 56375; 7=17 GG
653017 557=46831 16:0 46 * 5+& 86= :5661:31= D743 213434569 01;= 3083 719374:34569 @6=17 30156375; 7=175B & +86= 871822;4:8>;1 35301822;4:8639911F46<8@30574A8345686=653351I49346< 8@30574A1==18;1795730147;1<8;01479
6301:89156086=434965346=492@313083301 8@30574A83456D89<78631=35301B830175B719256=1635 @6=17 7=17GG46 317C9 5B D04:0 46 3011E163 5B049 =1830 301 ;4:16:1 :5@;= >1 37869B1771= 35 049 925@91 57 956 57 @6C87741= =8@<0317 0171B571 >? 822;?46< 301
- 10 -
@;19 2719:74>1= @6=17 301 56375; 7=17 GG 719256=163 5 D89 16343;1= B57 :56346@83456 5B 8@30574A83456 01 2134345617 08= 65 ;5:@9 9386=4 35 911F B57 <7863 5B 8@30574A83456 C571 28734:@;87;? D016 65 6534B4:83456D89499@1=46E4346<822;4:834569B578;;53C1635B B847274:1=12535B571>8;E4;;8<1
' 6 3083 E41D 5B 301 C83317 D743 21343456 49
()
&"'
"
( 4935;5'