- 1 - !" # $ "%%&'&(( $ !" # $ % " & & & ' !" & & " !" # $ ( " % ( "!$% ( $% ) * *! Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & (( "!) "!+ "! )!" )*+ )! )* *! *, "! ( )$%$-% )$%$-.% ( $% ( / !*+*! " *! ( ( ( 0 " $ 0 % 112345 6) 78 9417.: .34 6** *! 948578; <4=6>4 ?@4 62>? 6= 557?768.: 73?>71? .85 4337683 25;4 75.> 37??78; .? .3.-.A.:B.8 .>7378; 62? 6= >7C4 6 *! >4;73?4>45 <B .88. A@4::7 6:714 ?.?768 75.> =6> 6==48143 92873@.<:4 2854> 41?7683 "!) "!+ "! )* )*+ )! )!" *! *, >4.5 D7?@ 41?768 "! 6= .85 41?7683 )$%$-% .85 )$%$-.% 6= 1@452:45 .3?4 .85 1@452:45 >7<4 $>4-48?768 6= ?>617?743% 1? " $=6> 3@6>? 01? 6= " % 73 <4=6>4 ?@73 62>? 78 ?@73 - 3 - .994.: =7:45 2854> 41?768 "!$% 6= ?@4 1? 6= " .33.7:78; ?@4 6>54> 5.?45 !*+*! 9.3345 78 >:7316" *! <B ?@4 62>? 6= 557?768.: 73?>71? .85 4337683 25;4 75.> 37??78; .? .3.-.A.:B.8 4.>5 :4.>845 162834: =6> ?@4 .994::.8? .85 :4.>845 7;@ 62>? 6-4>8C48? :4.54> .994.>78; =6> >43968548? 6" 43968548? 6 D@6 73 34>-45 78 ?@4 C.??4> @.3 >4C.7845 28>49>4348?45 <4=6>4 ?@73 62>? ) ( 78 >7C4 6 *! D.3 >4;73?4>45 <B .88. A@4::7 6:714 ?.?768 75.> =6> ?@4 .=6>43.75 6==48143 .;.783? 684 78;.>.E .85 6?@4>3 68 ?@4 <.373 6= ?@4 =7>3? 78=6>C.?768 5.?45 "**"*! >4147-45 =>6C 7:.A.8?@ D@6 73 ?@4 368 6= 5414.345 .::7A.>E28 @4 .994::.8? @4>478 73 .>>.B45 .3 .112345 6) 78 ?@4 ( 2>78; ?@4 162>34 6= 78-43?7;.?768 @4 D.3 .>>43?45 68 ""*"*! .85 >4C.8545 ?6 E25717.: 123?65B @4 78-43?7;.?768 6= ?@4 1.34 73 16C9:4?45 .85 1@.>;4 3@44? @.3 <448 =7:45 .;.783? "* .112345 94>3683 @4 .994::.8? - 4 - 73 .>>.B45 .3 .112345 6) 78 ?@4 1@.>;4 3@44? @4 <.7: .99:71.?768 =7:45 <B ?@4 .994::.8? <4=6>4 ?@4 E2>73571?768.: 4337683 62>? 78 >:7316" *! D.3 >4E41?45 68 !*+*! @4>4=6>4 @4 73 <4=6>4 ?@73 62>? ! 4.>845 162834: =6> ?@4 .994::.8? 32<C7?3 ?@.? .112345 6 @.3 <448 ;>.8?45 >4;2:.> <.7: <B ?@73 62>? 78 >7C78.: 994.: 6**", *! .85 .112345 63! , .85 "* @.-4 <448 ;>.8?45 >4;2:.> <.7: <B ?@73 62>? 78 >7C78.: 994.: 63**) *! **"+ *! .85 **! *! @4 .994::.8? @.3 86 6?@4> 1>7C78.: .8?414548?3 116>578;:B @4 9>.B3 ?6 .::6D ?@4 .994.: 4> 168?>. :4.>845 7;@ 62>? 6-4>8C48? :4.54> .994.>78; =6> >43968548? 6" @.3 6996345 ?@4 9>.B4> C.54 78 ?@4 .994.: 4 5643 86? 57392?4 ?@4 32<C733768 C.54 <B :4.>845 162834: =6> ?@4 .994::.8? , 4>23.: 6= ?@4 C.?4>7.: .-.7:.<:4 68 >416>5 D62:5 ;6 ?6 3@6D ?@.? .::4;.?768 6= .33.2:?78; 5414.345 .::7A.>E28 68 @73 @4.5 D7?@ .8 .F4 73 =6285 68:B .3 .;.783? .112345 6" .85 ?@4 963?C6>?4C >496>? 6= - 5 - 5414.345 .::7A.>E28 D62:5 ;6 ?6 3@6D ?@.? 1.234 6= 54.?@ D.3 524 ?6 78?>.1>.87.: .85 32<52>.: @4C6>>@.;4 341685.>B ?6 @4.5 78E2>B 3 94> ?@4 1@.>;4 3@44? .994::.8? .112345 6) @.5 .::4;45:B .33.2:?45 " D@6 73 ?@4 78E2>45 78 ?@4 9>4348? 1.34 D7?@ ?@4 C.1@4?4 1.2378; <:665 66G78; 78E2>743 .85 @4 .:36 @.5 .33.2:?45 5414.345 .::7A.>E28 D7?@ ?@4 -4>B 3.C4 C.1@4?4 6D4-4> ?@4>4 73 86 39417=71 .::4;.?768 .3 .;.783? .994::.8? .112345 6) ?@.? @4 @.5 .33.2:?45 .::7A.>E28 D7?@ ?@4 C.1@4?4 68 @73 @4.5 683754>78; ?@.? 86 .::4;.?768 73 =6285 .3 .;.783? .8B 6?@4> .112345 94>3683 .<62? .33.2:?78; .::7A.>E28 68 @73 @4.5 D7?@ .8B 54.5:B D4.968 ?@73 62>? @.3 ;>.8?45 >4;2:.> <.7: ?6 .112345 6 .85 6?@4> .112345 94>3683 78 ?@4 .=6>43.75 1>7C78.: .994.:3 857392?45:B ?@4 .994::.8? @4>478 @.3 86 6?@4> 1>7C78.: .8?414548?3 .85 @4 73 78 123?65B =>6C ""*"*! @4>4=6>4 .C 6= ?@4 6978768 ?@.? ?@4 9>.B4> C.54 <B ?@4 .994::.8? =6> ;>.8? 6= >4;2:.> <.7: 84453 ?6 <4 .83D4>45 .==7>C.?7-4:B 116>578;:B =6::6D78; 6>54> 73 9.3345 - 6 - @4 .994.: 73 .::6D45 @4 7C92;845 6>54> 9.3345 <B ?@4 62>? 6= 557?768.: 73?>71? .85 4337683 25;4 75.> 37??78; .? .3.-.A.:B.8 78 >:7316" *! 5.?45 !*+*! 73 34? .3754 @4 .994::.8? .112345 6) 78 9417.: .34 6** *! 73 57>41?45 ?6 <4 48:.>;45 68 <.7: 78 >7C4 6 *! 6= .88. A@4::7 6:714 ?.?768 75.> >4;73?4>45 =6> ?@4 6==48143 92873@.<:4 2854> 41?7683"!) "!+ "! )* )*+ )! )!" *! *, >4.5 D7?@ 41?768 "! 6= .85 41?7683 )$%$-% .85 )$%$-.% 6= 1@452:45 .3?4 .85 1@452:45 >7<4 $>4-48?768 6= ?>617?743% 1? " 948578; <4=6>4 ?@4 62>? 6= 557?768.: 73?>71? .85 4337683 25;4 75.> 37??78; .? .3.-.A.:B.8 32<E41? ?6 ?@4 =6::6D78; 16857?7683 .% 994::.8? 3@.:: 4F412?4 94>368.: <685 =6> . 32C 6= 3"***** D7?@ ?D6 32>4?743 =6> ?@4 - 7 - :7A432C ?6 ?@4 3.?73=.1?768 6= ?@4 E2>73571?768.: 62>? <% 994::.8? 3@.:: .994.> >4;2:.>:B 68 .:: ?@4 5.?43 6= @4.>78; <4=6>4 ?@4 >7.: 62>? 28:433 ?@4 >7.: 62>? 4F4C9?3 @4> .994.>.814 =6> -.:75 >4.3683 1% 994::.8? 3@.:: 86? 57>41?:B 6> 7857>41?:B ?@>4.?48 6> ?.C94> D7?@ ?@4 9>63412?768 D7?843343 5% 994::.8? 3@.:: 86? 78-6:-4 78 37C7:.> 6==48143 78 =2?2>4 )' &# $ ( 73? 6 " : 6 &