Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11812 (KAR)
RUSTUM @ MAHD RUSTUM AHMED v. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
CRL.RP/200152/2024 · 2025-01-06
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11812 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11812 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
! #$
"% &" ! $
% '()'*+,(-'++ &
!" #
$%
" #
%
"&$
"'(( $ $
$
)
" $
"
""
"
"
"
"" (
!"
#$
"
"(%
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" ( *+
, ( " # % ,,,)(#%
" $ "
) ), " ( (
" ) ) ), "
$"
"
(
'-$ -
#" '-$ - %
./0 1/2/345 67/0/83 "69/9/83 :3;61 6<9/83 *+ 164; =/9. 6<9/83 , 8> 8;6 8> 1/2/345 "18<6;:16 /0 >/56;
?14@/3A 98 069 40/;6 9.6 81;61 ;496; ) ), B641/3A 84;/?41:)44) ),?4006;B@9.6160?83;639 8 /3 6C61</06 8> ./0 ?8=610 :3;61 6<9/83 8> 9.6 413494D4"85/<6<9
*
#.616/34>96116>6116;9840E9.6<9 *F% 6C9613/3A 9.6 ?69/9/8361 >81 4 ?61/8; 8> 836 @641 =/9. 6>>6<9>182 ) ),
) 641;9.6564136;<8:3065>819.6?419/60
.6 ?69/9/8361 =40 06176; =/9. 43 63G:/1@ 389/<6 ;496;)* ) ),/00:6;B@9.6160?83;6398/36C61</068>
- 3 -
./0 ?8=610 :3;61 6<9/83 164; =/9. 6<9/83 8> 9.6<9 *.604/;389/<6=40>8558=6;=/9.4389.6163G:/1@389/<6 ;496; *) ), ?61:045 8> 9.6 4>81604/; 63G:/1@ 389/<60 =8:5;16>56<99.49
9.604/;389/<60=616/00:6;839.6B40/08> 9.6?85/<616?819;496; +) ),16<6/76;>1829.630?6<981 8>"85/<6
4A41"85/<6949/83
454B:14A/316?5@989.6 63G:/1@ 389/<6
9.6 ?69/9/8361 .4; 0:B2/996; 4 094962639 8> 8BH6<9/83 83 * *) ), B6>816 9.6 160?83;639 8 .6164>961
9.6 81;61 /2?:A36; .40 B663 ?4006; B@ 9.6 160?83;639883 ) ),6/3A4AA1/676;B@9.60426 9.6?69/9/8361/0B6>8169./08:19
, 64136;<8:3065>819.6?69/9/8361.47/3A16/96149/3A 9.6 <839639/830 :1A6; /3 9.6 ?69/9/83
0:B2/90 9.49
9.6 16G:/1626398>6<9/838>9.6<9
*
/0389<82?5/46;98 9.6 ?160639 <406
38 ?18?61 8??819:3/9@ =40 A/763 98 9.6 ?69/9/8361 43; 9.6 /2?:A36; 81;61 /0 ?4006; B@ 7/8549/3A 9.6 ?1/3</?5608>349:145H:09/<6
"61<83914
564136; "8??806;9.6?69/9/8343;
0:B2/90 9.49 9.6 63G:/1@ 389/<6 ;496; , ) ), /0 /3 <82?5/43<68>16G:/1626398>6<9/838>9.6<9
*.6
- 4 -
?69/9/8361/0/378576;/32:59/?56<1/2/345<406016A/09616;:3;61 741/8:0 8>>63<60 43; 4 ?1/24>4</6 <406 /0 24;6 8:9 >81 /378D/3A6<9/838>9.6<9
*
43;4<<81;/3A5@
.6?14@0 98;/02/009.6?69/9/83
?61:0458>9.624961/45=8:5;A8980.8=9.49
9.6 0.8= <4:06 389/<6 ;496; )* ) ), 43; *) ), =./<. =616/00:6;989.6?69/9/8361B@9.6160?83;6398
=616389 4<<82?43/6;=/9.9.6?85/<616?819;496; +) ),B406;83 =./<. 9.6 63G:/1@ 389/<60 =616 /00:6; .616>816
9.6 04/; 389/<60=616389/3<82?5/43<68>9.616G:/1626398>6<9/83 8>9.6<9
*(819.6?:1?8068>/378D/3A6<9/838>9.6 <9
* 9.6 16?819 0:B2/996; B@ 9.6 "85/<6 >>/<61 0.8:5;
?1/24>4</6 0.8= 9.49
9.616 416 1640834B56 A18:3;0 >81 9.6
"85/<6>>/<6198B65/6769.49
9.6?69/9/8361/05/D65@98<822/9 9.68>>63<604009496;/36<9/838>9.6<9
*819.616 0.8:5;B624961/45980.8=9.49
9.6=/9360060/39.6<1/2/345 <4060 16A/09616; 4A4/309 9.6 ?69/9/8361 =616 B6/3A 9.1649636; B@9.6?69/9/8361
+ .6 <881;/349663<. 8> 9./0 8:19 /3 9.6 <406 8>
49 ?414A14?. 8
.40 .65;40:3;61
- 5 -
! " #$%
&
"'
&
"
&
(
"'
")* &
" )* & + ,-. + ,-. " $ ,%. ,/. "0
- 6 -
, . "
!
122 132 1322 4 ! " 5 6
7
2
7
&
"56
&
8
" ! 4 ! 92
"
7
:
7
8
- 7 -
;
&
& -#-'%- ! :
&
&
2
"56
!2 4
2
"56
:
7 ! , . "
>9.6?85/<616?819;496; +) ),43;9.681;61 /2?:A36; /0 6C42/36; /3 9.6 B4<DA18:3; 8> 9.6 8B061749/830 24;6 B@ 9.6 <881;/3496 63<. 8> 9./0 8:19
/3 9.6 <406 8> /9 4??6410 9.49
9.6 16G:/162639 >81 ?400/3A 43 81;61 :3;61 6<9/83 8> 9.6 <9
*
.40 389 B663 24;6 8:9 /3 9.6 ?160639 <406 3 4;;/9/83 98 9./0
40 09496; 6415/61
- 8 -
9.6 ?18<6;:145 /116A:541/9@ B@ 389 <82?5@/3A =/9. 9.6 16G:/162639 8> 6<9/83 8> 9.6 <9
*
7/9/4960 9.6 /2?:A36;81;61.8:A./9/0B18:A.9989.6389/<68>9./08:19 9.49
9.6 63G:/1@ 389/<6 ;496; , ) ), /0 /3 <82?5/43<6 8> 9.616G:/1626398>6<9/838>9.6<9
*
6C42/349/838> 9.6 16<81;0 =8:5; A8 98 0.8= 9.49
9.6 63G:/1@0.8=<4:06 389/<6 ;496; , ) ), =40 06176; 83 9.6 ?69/9/8361 83 ) ),494B8:9 *?243; .6=4040D6;984??641 B6>8169.6160?83;639849 4283 + ) ),.6 /2?:A36; 81;61 .40 B663 ?4006; 9.6164>961 83 ) ), .64>81604/;40?6<908>9.6249961=8:5;A8980.8=9.49
9.6 ?69/9/8361 =40 389 A/763 ?18?61 8??819:3/9@ 98 16?5@ 98 9.6 63G:/1@0.8= <4:06 389/<6 ;496; , ) ), =./<. .40 160:596; /3 7/8549/83 8> ?1/3</?560 8> 349:145 H:09/<6 .6 1/A.9 A:4143966;989.6?69/9/8361:3;6119/<56)8>9.68309/9:9/83 8>3;/4/0/3>1/3A6;B@9.681;61/2?:A36;43;9.616>816
9.6 2/3/2:2 9.49 /0 6C?6<96; >182 9.6 <82?69639 4:9.81/9@ /0 98 <82?5@ 9.6 ?1/3</?560 8> 349:145 H:09/<6 B6>816 ?400/3A 43@ 6C9613263981;610
- 9 -
* 3;619.6</1<:20943<60
428>9.68?/3/839.49 9.681;61/2?:A36;?4006;B@9.6160?83;6398<43389B6 0:094/36;<<81;/3A5@
?4009.6>8558=/3A
#/% .61/2/34567/0/83"69/9/83/04558=6;I #//% .6 81;61 ;496; ) ), B641/3A 84;/?41:)44) ),?4006;B@ 160?83;6398/006940/;6
.,
'% &" !+
"
$ /09858,
"