- 1 - ! "#" $%#!!&! '# ! " % (()*+,(!!** ' !"#"$ %& %# ' ' $ (#&(( ((% ' ( $& %$ $$% $( "% ")( '$%& Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' *' *' $ ++,-./ 0$ 12 314. 0(#&(( 3.51-6.3./ 78 92:10;1+.69610291+<,3=036<.0==.2+.->,21-<97;. ,2/.3 .+6102- ( %$ $& $$% $( "% ")( 3.9/ ?16< .+6102 $%& 0= 1- 7.=03. 6<1- 0,36 ,2/.3 .+6102%&0=3-..1253.5,;93791; ( .93/6<.;.932./+0,2-.;=036<.>9361.- 12 314. 0(#&(( ?9- 3.51-6.3./ 78 92:1 0;1+.69610291+<,3121619;;8=036<.0==.2+.->,21-<97;. ,2/.3.+6102-(%$$&3.9/?16<.+6102$%&0= 95912-6 .-<9: 92/ $$ 06<.3- 02 6<. 79-1- 0= 6<. =13-6 12=03496102 /96./ $(( 3.+.1:./ =304 931-?948 =96<.3 0= /.+.9-./ 39-9/ 2 6<. >.616102.3 ?9- 9339152./ 9- 9++,-./ 0$ ,3125 6<. +0,3-. 0= 12:.-61596102 >.616102.3 ?9- 933.-6./ 02 $$$(( 92/ - 3 - -,7-.@,.26;83.492/./60A,/1+19;+,-60/82:.-61596102 126<.+9-.1-+04>;.6./92/+<935.-<..6<9-7..2=1;./ 95912-6$"9++,-./>.3-02-92/>.616102.31-9339152./9- 9++,-./ 0$126<.+<935.-<..691;9>>;1+96102=1;./78 6<. >.616102.3 7.=03. 6<. A,31-/1+61029; .--102- 0,36 12 3;1-+ 0&((% ?9- 3.A.+6./ 02 $)((% <.3.=03.<.1-7.=03.6<1-0,36 % .932./ +0,2-.; =03 6<. >.616102.3 <9:125 3.16.396./ 6<. 530,2/- ,35./ 12 6<. >.616102 -,7416- 6<96 9++,-./ 0-92/%<9:.7..253926./3.5,;93791;786<1-0,36 123; 0("%((%++,-./ 0-"60$"<9:.7..2 53926./ 3.5,;93 791; 7.=03. 6<. A,31-/1+61029; .--102- 0,36.616102.31-12+,-60/8=036<.;9-6403.6<9202. 8.93 92/ 6<. 6319; 12 6<. +9-. 1- 8.6 60 +044.2+. ++03/125;8<.>398-609;;0?6<.>.616102 " .3 +02639 ;.932./ <9- 0>>0-./ 6<. >.616102 <.-,7416-6<96'$(1-6<..8.?162.--606<.12+1/.26 12 @,.-6102 ++,-./ 0-$ 92/ ( 93. 6<. >.3-02- ?<0 <9:. 9--9,;6./ 6<. /.+.9-./ ?16< /.9/;8 ?.9>02- - 4 - .+.9-./<9--,==.3./212.+<0>12A,31.-02<1-70/8-9 3.-,;6 0= 6<. 9--9,;6 =125.3- 0= 315<6 <92/ 92/ ;.=6 <92/ 0:.3 6<. ?31-6 ?.3. -.>9396./ ++03/125;8 -<. >398- 60 /1-41--6<.>.616102 ) 3049>.3,-9;0=6<.496.319;9:91;97;.023.+03/16 1- -..2 6<96 6<.3. ?9- 1;;!?1;; 7.6?..2 /.+.9-./ 39-9/ 92/ 9++,-./ 0" =03 >0;161+9; 3.9-02- 9361.- <9/ 6<.3.9=6.3 =0,5<6 95912-6 .9+< 06<.3 9-. 92/ +0,26.3 +314129; +9-.- ?.3. 3.51-6.3./ 7.6?..2 6<.4 <.3.=03. 9++,-./ 0"<9/+02->13./?16<06<.39++,-./>.3-02-60 +044166<.4,3/.30=/.+.9-./39-9/92/12=,36<.392+. 0= -,+< +02->139+8 9++,-./ >.3-02- <9/ /.+1/./ 60 +04416 6<. 4,3/.3 0= 39-9/ ++,-./ 0" <9/ <92/./ 0:.3 9 -,4 0= -$" ;9B<- 60 9++,-./ 0-$ 60 % 60 +044166<.4,3/.30=39-9/92/02$((96970,6 C94?<.239-9/?.2660<1-=1.;/9;025?16<'$( 9++,-./ 0-$92/(?<0?.3.934./?16<;02592/9D. 9--9,;6./02<1-<.9/92/06<.3:169;>936-0=<1-70/892/ +044166./ <1- 4,3/.3 <.3.9=6.3 9++,-./ 0-$ 92/ ( - 5 - 9;;.5./;8 .-+9>./ =304 6<. ->06 12 6<. 40603 +8+;. 0= 9++,-./ 0 ++,-./ 0% ?9- 9;;.5./;8 -692/125 96 9 /1-692+. 92/ <. <9/ 9;;.5./;8 -<0?2 6<. /.+.9-./ 60 9++,-./ 0-$92/(02-1/.31256<.296,3.0=9;;.596102- 95912-6 9++,-./ 0- 92/ % 6<.8 <9:. 7..2 53926./ 3.5,;93 791; 78 6<1- 0,36 12 3; 0("%((% <. 9;;.59610295912-69++,-./ 0-$92/(92/6<.9;;.596102 95912-6 9++,-./ 0- 92/ % 93. /1-612+6 ++,-./ 0-$ 92/ ( 9;;.5./;8<9:.9--9,;6./ 6<./.+.9-./ ?16< /.9/;8 ?.9>02-<.0-6036.43.>0360=/.+.9-./?0,;/5060 -<0?6<96<.<9/-,==.3./212.+<0>12A,31.-02<1-70/8 - 9 3.-,;6 0= 6<. 9--9,;6 78 9++,-./ 0-$ 92/ ( ?16< /.9/;8 ?.9>02- <1- 315<6 <92/ =125.3- 92/ ;.=6 <92/ 970:.?31-6?9--.>9396./26<.0-6036.4.>03616 1- 4.26102./ 6<96 /.96< ?9- 9- 9 3.-,;6 0= <.4033<95. 92/-<0+B9-93.-,;60=4,;61>;.+<0>12A,31.--,-6912./60 6<.<.9/92/+<.-60=6<./.+.9-./<.12A,31.-=0,2/02 6<. /.+.9-./ 93. 9;; 02 6<. :169; >936- 0= <1- 70/8 6 1- 730,5<6606<.2061+.0=6<1-0,366<969++,-./ 0-$92/ (93.>.3-02-?16<+314129;926.+./.26-'$(1-6<..8. - 6 - ?162.-- 60 6<. 12+1/.26 12 @,.-6102 ?<0 ?9- >3.-.26 9;; 9;025 ?16< 6<. /.+.9-./ ?<.2 9++,-./ 0-$ 92/ ( 9--9,;6./ <14 ?16< /.9/;8 ?.9>02- 2/.3 6<. +13+,4-692+.-940=6<.0>121026<966<.>398.349/. 78 >.616102.3 =03 53926 0= 3.5,;93 791; +92206 7. 53926./ ++03/125;8>.6161021-/1-41--./ !-+ (!&! '# ! "* # 1-6 0$; 0$%