- 1 - ! ! "# $ % &$ ! # % '()'*+,-' ++ & !" " !" ! # !! $ ! !" % & ' ( Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ) ! !" % & ( ' ( !*+ ) ( & ' ! ( &$' ( !))+) ( + # !)+ !)! $ ( (( !)" $! ( ( $ , #$# & , #$#' -./ 0.1.234 56./.72 859.9.72 :2;50 5<9.72 !*+ 053; =.9- 5<9.72 ! 7> -3039.?3 3@30.A3 :03A/-3 32-.93)!./>.45;=.9-3803?5097/593/.;59-570;50 ;395; !))+) 83//5; B? ;;.9.7234 ./90.<9 32; 5//.72/#:;@57:0939343B:03@..27!)+ )! - 3 - 530;9-5453025;<7:2/54>709-58309.5/ ! -5 859.9.7250/ -505.2 -365 B552 <-30@5/-559 >70 9-5 7>>52<5 8:2./-3B45 :2;50 5<9.72 !)" 053; =.9- 5<9.72 ! 7> .2 0.15 7!+ ) 05@./9505; B? 3;32-.88303@3874.<5939.72343B:03@.-5?30527= >3<.2@90.34>709-5<-30@5/-5595;7>>52<5/B5>7059-590.34 7:09 .2 7!)+ )! 2 9-5 /3.; 807<55;.2@/ 9-5? -3;>.45;323884.<39.72:2;505<9.72+7>0=.9- 3 803?50 97 ;./<-30@5 9-51 -5 /3.; 3884.<39.72 =3/ 7887/5; B? 9-5 807/5<:9.72 B? >.4.2@ 7BC5<9.72 -5 90.34 7:09 6.;5 .18:@25; 70;50 ;395; !))+) -3/ ;./1.//5; 9-5 /3.; 3884.<39.72 >.45; :2;50 5<9.72 + 7> 0 B? 9-5 859.9.7250/ 32; B5.2@ 3@@0.565; B? 9-5 /3159-5?305B5>7059-./7:09 53025; <7:2/54 >70 9-5 859.9.7250/ -36.2@ 05.950395; 9-5 @07:2;/ :0@5; .2 9-5 859.9.72 /:B1.9/ 9-39 72 9-5 3445@39.72/ 13;5 3@3.2/9 9-5 859.9.7250/ 9-5? <32279 B5 807/5<:95; >70 9-5 7>>52<5 8:2./-3B45 :2;50 5<9.72!)"7>-505./2725D:/B59=5529-53445@5; - 4 - 3<9 <711.995; B? 9-5 859.9.7250/ 32; ;539- 7> 9-5 ;5<53/5; -5 0.34 7:09 -3/ >3.45; 97 38805<.395 9-./ 3/85<9 7> 9-5 139950 32; -3/ 5005; .2 05C5<9.2@ 9-5 3884.<39.72 >.45; :2;50 5<9.72 + 7> 0 B? 9-5 859.9.7250/<<70;.2@4?-5803?/973447=9-5859.9.72 50 <72903 453025; .@- 7:09 765021529 453;50 388530.2@ >70 05/872;529 7 -3/ 7887/5; 9-5 859.9.725/:B1.9/9-399-5859.9.7250/-3;>3.45;9783? 9-5529.05/345<72/.;5039.72317:29:2;509-505@./9505; /345 ;55; ;395; ))) =-.<- =3/ 5D5<:95; B? 9-5 ;5>3<97 <71843.2329 .2 >367:0 7> 3<<:/5; 7 -5 ;5<53/5; =3/ <72/./95294? ;5132;.2@ 9-5 /3.; 317:29 32;.2/8.957>9-5/315859.9.7250/-3;27983.;9-5/3.; 317:29 32; 72 9-5 79-50 -32; 9-5? -3; 3B5995; 9-5 ;5<53/5;97<711.9/:.<.;5-505>705/:>>.<.52913950.34 ./ 363.43B45 97 90? 9-5 859.9.7250/ >70 9-5 <-30@5 /-5595; 7>>52<5/ <<70;.2@4? -5 803?/ 97 ;./1.// 9-5 056./.72 859.9.72 - 5 - " -5 >.0/9 .2>701329 .2 9-5 805/529 <3/5 ./ 9-5 -:/B32;7>;5<53/5;1B.A329-5>.0/9.2>70139.72-5 -3//9395;9-39-532;-./=.>5-3;/74;"3<05/@:293/ 7> 432; 3B7:9 2.25 ?530/ 80.70 97 9-5 ;395 7> >.0/9 .2>70139.72973<<:/5;7:2;50305@./9505;/345;55; 32;9-5529.05/345<72/.;5039.72:2;509-5/345;55;=3/ 279 83.; B? 3<<:/5; 7 5 34/7 /9395; 9-39 -./ =.>5 1B.A3-3;.44.<.905439.72/-.8=.9-3<<:/5;732;3>950 -5<31597A27=3B7:99-5/315-5-3;E:5/9.725;-./ =.>5 3B7:9 -50 .44.<.9 05439.72/-.8 32; 9-5053>950 -5 -3; /93095;05/.;.2@397438:0.2<53<<:/5;7-3;>3.45; 97 83? 9-5 317:29 =-.<- -5 =3/ ;:5 97 83? 1B.A3 3445@5;4? -3; 13.293.25; ;./932<5 >071 -.1 >70 9-5 43/9 725?530<<:/5;7F.;;3883=3/85/950.2@-5097 <729.2:5 9-5 05439.72/-.8 2 )) ) 9-5 >.0/9 .2>70139.72 =3/ .2>7015; B? -./ 05439.65 9-39 9-5 ;53; B7;? 7>-./ =.>5 =3/ >7:2; .2 9-5.0 =544 32;.115;.3954? 9-5053>950 -5 =529 97 9-5 /3.; /879 32; 3>950 .;529.>?.2@ 9-5;53;B7;?7>-./=.>5-5-3;388073<-5;9-5874.<5 - 6 - 9./:2;509-5/5<.0<:1/932<5/(.20.157!+ ) =3/05@./9505;3@3.2/93<<:/5;732;9-05579-50/ + <<:/5; 7 ./ 9-5 >39-50 7> 3<<:/5; 7 32; 3<<:/5; 7 ./ 9-5 =.>5 7> 3<<:/5; 7 <<:/5; 7! .//3.; 97B5 3 ;./9329 05439.65 7>;5<53/5; 1B.A3 2 9-5 <-30@5 /-559 =-.<- ./ 27= >.45; 3/ 3@3.2/9 9-5 3<<:/5; .9 ./ 3445@5; 9-39 /.2<5 9-53<<:/5;850/72/ -3; 279 83.; 9-5 /345 <72/.;5039.72 317:29 3>950 -36.2@ 8:0<-3/5; 9-5 8078509? :2;50 3 /345 ;55; 8:2<-3?39/ =505-54;32;.29-5/3.;8:2<-3?39/9-7:@-3<<:/5;-3; 3@055;970583?9-5/3.;317:299-5?-3;>3.45;97A558 :8 9-5.0 8071./5 32; =-52 ;5<53/5; 388073<-5; 9-5 3<<:/5; 05E:5/9.2@ 9-51 97 83? 9-5 317:29 9-5? 3445@5;4?3B:/5;-5032;/9395;9-39.>/-5;.5/9-5?<32 4.65 -388.4? 9 ./ 3445@5; .2 9-./ B3<A@07:2; 72 )) ) 1B.A3 -3; ;5<.;5; 97 <711.9 /:.<.;5 32; 3<<70;.2@4? -3; .2>7015; $+ 32; 9-5053>950 <711.995;/:.<.;5B?C:18.2@.2973=544.29-5.0>.54; - 7 - 29-5>.0/9.2>70139.72.9.//9395;9-399-5>.0/9 .2>70132932;-./=.>5-3;/74;"3<05/@:293/7>432; .2:065?7 973<<:/5;73B7:92.25?530/80.70 979-5>.0/9.2>70139.72-5<78?7>9-5/345;55;;395; ))) ./ 13;5 363.43B45 97 9-5 7:09 B? 453025; <7:2/54>709-5859.9.7250/=-.<-=7:4;80.13>3<.5@797 /-7= 9-39 9-5 /345 9032/3<9.72 ./ B59=552 9-5 ;5>3<97 <71843.2329 32; 3<<:/5; 7 32; 9-5 529.05 /345 <72/.;5039.727>/+))) =3/83.;32;/3.;83?1529 -3/ B552 3<A27=45;@5; .2 9-5 3>705/3.; /345 ;55; 5 9-393/.913?565279-50=./59-53445@5;/3459032/3<9.72 ./ 2.25 ?530/ 80.70 97 9-5 ;395 7> ;5<53/5; <711.99.2@ /:.<.;532;9-505>705.9<32279B5/3.;9-399-53445@5;3<9 <711.995;B?9-53<<:/5;850/72/-3;;.05<925D:/=.9- 9-5 ;539- 7> ;5<53/5; 2 >.0/9 .2>70139.72 .9 ./ /9395; 9-39;5<53/5;-3;.44.<.905439.72/-.8=.9-3<<:/5;732; B5<3:/57>9-5/315>.0/9.2>701329-3;/93095;05/.;.2@ .2 7438:0 32; .9 ./ 724? >70 9-5 43/9 725 ?530 ;5<53/5; -3;13.293.25;;./932<5-50/54>>0713<<:/5;7-5 3445@39.72 9-39 3<<:/5; 7 =-7 -3; 8:0<-3/5; 9-5 - 8 - 8078509?>0719-5>.0/9.2>70132932;-./=.>5-3;27983.; 9-5 529.05 /345 <72/.;5039.72 97 9-51 32; 9-5 3445@39.72 9-393<<:/5;7-3;.44.<.905439.72/-.8=.9-9-5;5<53/5; =-7./9-5=.>57>>.0/9.2>701329<32279B5/.1:493257:/4? B54.565;97B5<7005<9-505./27/:<-3445@39.72.29-5 >.0/9 .2>70139.72 70 .2 9-5 <-30@5 /-559 9-39 9-5 3<<:/5; 850/72/-365<711.995;32?/:<-3<9.115;.3954?80.7097 ;5<53/5; <711.99.2@ /:.<.;5 =-.<- =7:4; -365 5.9-50 3B5995; 70 .2/9.@395; -50 97 <711.9 /:.<.;5 -5 3445@39.72 9-39 /.2<5 3<<:/5; 850/72/ -3; 279 83.; 9-5 529.05 /345 <72/.;5039.72 .2 05/85<9 7> 3 /345 9032/3<9.72 9-39-3;93A52843<53B7:92.25?530/80.70979-5;3957> ;5<53/5; <711.99.2@ /:.<.;5 ./ 9-5 053/72 70 <3:/5 >70 ;5<53/5; 97 <711.9 /:.<.;5 <32279 B5 <7:295232<5; 32; 72 /:<- 32 3445@39.72 9-5 859.9.7250/ -505.2 <32279 B5 807/5<:95; >70 9-5 <-30@5 /-5595; 7>>52<5/ -5 0.34 7:09 -3/ >3.45; 97 38805<.395 9-./ 3/85<9 7> 9-5 139950 -5B3/.< .2@05;.529/ =-.<- 305 05E:.05;97 <72/9.9:95 32 7>>52<58:2./-3B45:2;505<9.72!)7>./3B/529.29-5 >.0/9.2>70139.723/=5443/.29-5<-30@5/-559-505>705 - 9 - 9-5 859.9.7250/ <32279 B5 3/A5; 97 /932; 90.34 >70 <-30@5 /-5595;7>>52<5/ * 2;50 9-5 <.0<:1/932<5/ 31 7> 9-5 78.2.72 9-399-50.347:09-3/5005;.205C5<9.2@9-53884.<39.727> 9-5 859.9.7250/ >.45; :2;50 5<9.72 + 7> 0 <<70;.2@4?>7447=.2@70;50./83//5; -5<0.1.234056./.72859.9.72./3447=5; -5.18:@25;70;50;395;!))+)83//5;B? 9-57:097>;;.9.7234./90.<932;5//.72/#:;@5 343B:03@. .2 5//.72/ 3/5 7!)+ )! ./ /59 3/.;5 32; <72/5E:5294? 9-5 3884.<39.72 >.45; B? 9-5 859.9.7250/ :2;50 5<9.72 + 7> 0 /932;/ 3447=5; 32; 9-5 859.9.7250/ 305 ;./<-30@5; 7> 9-5 <-30@5/-5595;7>>52<5/ ., ' % &$ !+ $ ./9747