- 1 - ! " #!$ %! # &&'()&(( % ! "# ! "# $ % ! "# # % ! %& ! " # Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! "# ' ( % ) & ! "* +% % $ & ! "# ' ( % ) #! () ! () & % % * "# $$ "#$" $()( ) ( )# "# - 3 - %% % % ,% (,% ) --./01 2/ 32 45 60-478 7/0 ( ) 2# "# 6051459 :0;2<0 3=0 2.<3 2; 114342578 4/3<4-3 751 0//425/ .190 787:.<794 7<4/459 2.3 2; <4>02* "#<094/30<01:?54@0</43?284-0 373425 787:.<79443?;2<3=02;;05-0/6.54/=7:80.510< 0-3425/ $$ "# 751 $" 2; 751 .510< 0-3425/ $()(@) 2; -=01.801 7/30/ 751 -=01.801 <4:0/ (<0@053425 2; 3<2-4340/) -3 A!A (;2< /=2<3 B () -3) 7<0 :0;2<0 3=4/ 2.<3 .510< 0-3425 #! 2; < C43= 7 6<7?0< 32 D.7/= 3=0 0534<0 6<2-001459/ 45 3=0 7;2<0/741 -7/07/79745/33=0> 45 <4>0 2* "# C7/ <094/30<01 :? 54@0</43? 284-0 373425 787:.<794 43? 45434788? ;2< 3=0 2;;05-0/ 6.54/=7:80 .510< 0-3425/ $$ "# " $" - 4 - <071C43= 0-3425#A2;751 0-3425$()(@)2; () -3 79745/3 3=0 603434250</ =0<045 25 3=0 :7/4/ 2; 3=0 ;4</3 45;2<>73425 17301 "" "# <0-04@01 ;<2> 7E>46.3<7:<23=0<2;10-07/01./=675@0/349734252; 3=0 -7/0 4/ -2>680301 751 -=7<90 /=003 =7/ :005 ;4801 79745/3;4@060</25/751603434250</=0<0457<07<<7?017/ 7--./01 2/ 32 45 3=0 -=7<90/=003 =0 <4782.<3 7;30< 37E459 -2954F75-0 2; 3=0 -=7<90 /=00301 2;;05-0/ =7/ 4//.01 /.>>25/ 32 3=0 603434250</ //748459 3=0 /7>03=0603434250</7<0:0;2<03=4/2.<3 $ 07<501 -2.5/08 ;2< 3=0 603434250</ =7@459 <0430<7301 3=0 9<2.51/ .<901 45 3=0 60343425 /.:>43/ 3=73 50-0//7<? 459<014053 32 45@2E0 0-3425 $" 2; 4/ 523 ;2.51 45 3=0 6<0/053 -7/0 7/ 79745/3 3=0 603434250</ =0<04/52/.-=7-3C=4-=C7/-2>>43301:?3=07--./01 60</25/ 4>>0147308? 6<42< 32 3=0 10-07/01 -2>>433459 /.4-410C=4-=C2.81=7@0043=0<45/34973012<7:03301=0< 32 37E0 3=0 1<7/34- /306 2; -2>>433459 /.4-410 --2<14598?=06<7?/327882C3=060343425 - 5 - # 0< -253<7 807<501 49= 2.<3 2@0<5>053 80710<76607<459;2<<0/62510532C=2=7/2662/01 3=0 60343425 :<459/ 32 3=0 5234-0 2; 3=4/ 2.<3 3=73 10-07/01=7180;3:0=45171073=5230C=4-=-807<8?<0;0</ 32 3=0 7-3 -2>>43301 :? 3=0 7--./01 60</25/ =0 10-07/01=7/57>017883=07--./0160</25/453=01073= 5230--2<14598?=06<7?/3214/>4//3=060343425 0/62510532C=24//0<@01453=0>7330< =7/<0>74501.5<06<0/05301:0;2<03=4/2.<3 4</3 45;2<>73425 45 3=0 6<0/053 -7/0 C7/ /.:>43301 :? 3=0 :<23=0< 2; 3=0 10-07/01 7;30< /=0 =71 -2>>43301/.4-410253=04530<@05459549=32;"A" "# 751 "" "# :? =759459 =0</08; 5 3=0 ;4</3 45;2<>73425 43 4/ 7@0<<01 3=73 10-07/01 C7/ 45 82@0 C43= 7--./01 2 751 /=0 C7/ /37?459 /067<7308? ;<2> =0< ;7>48? >0>:0</ --./01 2 C=2 =71 6<2>4/01 32 >7<<?3=010-07/01751=717<0873425/=46C43==0<;2<7 60<4212;>2<03=753=<00?07</=71<0;./0132>7<<?=0< - 6 - 73 3=0 45/375-0 2; 23=0< 7--./01 60</25/ =0<0;2<0 3=0 10-07/01=71-2>>43301/.4-410:?=759459=0</08; * %730<478 25 <0-2<1 C2.81 92 32 /=2C 3=73 3=0 10-07/01 =71 80;3 :0=451 7 1073= 5230 6<42< 32 /=0 -2>>433459/.4-4100<./782;3=0/7411073=5230C=4-= 4/767<32;-=7<90/=003;4801453=06<0/053-7/0C2.81 <0@078 3=73 /=0 =7/ 523 >710 75? /60-4;4- 7880973425/ 7/ 79745/3 7--./01 2 751 45 3=0 6<0/053 -7/0 5 3=0 1073= 5230 /=0 =7/ /37301 3=73 7--./01 2 C=2 =71 6<2>4/0132>7<<?=0<=71/.:/0D.0538?<0;./0132>7<<? =0< 73 3=0 45/375-0 2; 23=0< 7--./01 60</25/ =0 =7/ 78/2 /37301 3=73 7--./01 2# =71 -2>0 32 3=0 6<0>4/0/ C=0<0/=0C7/84@4597517;30<7:./459=0<=71/373013=73 /=0C4885237882C=0<:<23=0<32>7<<?=0< =0=7/78/2 /373013=737--./012$=717:./017517//7.8301=0<45 7 6.:84- 687-0 2C0@0< 52 7880973425 C=73/20@0< =7/ :005>71079745/37--./012/751 :?3=010-07/01 45=0<1073=5230@05453=0;4</345;2<>734253=0<07<0 52/60-4;4-7880973425/C=4-==7@0:005>7107/79745/3 - 7 - 3=07--./012/751 C=4-=C2.816<4>7;7-40733<7-3 3=0 7880901 2;;05-0/ 79745/3 3=0> 2< 3=0 6.<62/0 2; 733<7-3459 3=0 2;;05-0 6.54/=7:80 .510< 0-3425 $" 2; 3=0 7-3 -2>>43301 :? 3=0 7--./01 60</25/ /=2.81 =7@0043=0<7:033012<45/34973013=010-07/013237E03=0 1<7/34-/3062;-2>>433459/.4-4107513=0/7417-32;3=0 7--./01 60</25//=2.81 =7@0 /2>0 50G./C43=3=01073= 2;3=010-07/01 ! 5 3=0 6<0/053 -7/0 3=2.9= 3=0 10-07/01 =7/ >710-0<37457880973425/7/79745/37--./0160</25/45=0< 1073= 5230/=0 =7/523>710 75?/60-4;4- 7880973425/ 7/ 79745/3 7--./01 2/ 751 751 45 3=0 7:/05-0 2; 50-0//7<? 459<014053/ 4; 7--./01 2/ 751 7<0 6<2/0-.301 ;2< 3=0 -=7<90 /=00301 2;;05-0/ 3=0 /7>0 C2.817>2.53327:./02;6<2-0//2;87C A 510< 3=0 -4<-.>/375-0/ 7> 2; 2645425 3=73 6<7?0<>710:?603434250<2/751 7--./012/751 5001/ 32 :0 9<75301 751 6<7?0< >710 :? 603434250< - 8 - 2/ $ 751 # 7--./01 2/ $ 751 # 5001/ 32 :0 <0H0-301--2<14598?3=0;2882C4592<10<4/67//01 =0-<4>4578603434254/67<38?7882C01 =0 4>6.9501 -<4>4578 6<2-001459/ 45 60-478 7/0 ( ) 2# "# 6051459 :0;2<0 3=0 2.<3 2; 114342578 4/3<4-3 751 0//425/ .190 787:.<794 7<4/459 2.32;<4>02* "# <094/30<01 :?54@0</43? 284-0 373425787:.<79443?;2<3=02;;05-0/6.54/=7:80.510< 0-3425/ $$ "# 751 $" 2; 751 .510< 0-3425 $()(@) ()-345/2;7<7/43<08730/32603434250< 2/751 7--./012/751 /3751/D.7/=01 0343425 4/ 14/>4//01 7/ 79745/3 603434250< 2/ $ 751 # 7--./01 2/ $ 751 # 751 3=0 <478 2.<3 /=788 6<2-00179745/33=0/7417--./01457--2<175-0C43=87C *) &$ %! ( ! 4/32 82#