Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11705 (KAR)
SADHANA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
CRL.RP/200141/2024 · 2025-02-01
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11705 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11705 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! "#$ % &$ ! #% '(
')*+(,' ** &
! " #
$%
! &
! &
'
$ #% &$
(
$ ) !*! $
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! " #&! ' $&%
&
+)&#
%
'& # % %
&
$ % ' )' '
**' ' & & ! % &
,
&
&
&
-
$
# -
$ %
! ./0/012.3 04 5.613. /704 183/ 94490:02; /7. 13<.3 <9/.< ' )' ' =944.< 5> /7. 183/ 16 <<0/0129: 04/30?/ 92< .4401248<;.0<930230@. 1**' 'A7.3.02.=13/ 60:.< 5> /7. 0<93 1@.2 1:0?. /9/012 0<93 794 5..2 9??.=/.<92<?94.3.;04/.3.<9;9024/3.4=12<.2/A94?:14.<
' .93</7.:.932.<?1824.:613/7.=93/0.4
- 3 -
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
.932.< 309: 183/ B0<. /7. 13<.3 0@=8;2.< <9/.< ' )' ' 96/.3 ?1240<.302; /7. ?12/.2/0124 83;.<125.79:616/7.=./0/012.35.02;49/0460.<A0/7/7.6029: 3.=13/ 60:.< 02 /7. =3.4.2/ ?94. 794 9??.=/.< /7. 49@. 92< ?:14.</7.?94.949;9024//7.3.4=12<.2/.02;9;;30.B.<5> /7.49@./704=./0/0120460:.<
.932.< ?1824.: 613 /7. =./0/012.3 485@0/4 /79/ /7. 3.941249440;2.<5>/7.:.932.<309:8<;.6139??.=/02;/7. 6029:3.=13/0421/=31=.3.9:41485@0/4/79/@.3.:>613/7. 3.9412 /79/ /7.3. A94 9 <04=8/. 5./A..2 /7. =93.2/4 16 /7. B0?/0@;03:/7.B.3401216/7.B0?/0@;03:?9221/5.<185/.<. - 4 -
485@0/4 /79/ B0?/0@ ;03: 794 @9<. 4=.?060? 9::.;9/0124 9;9024/ 3.4=12<.2/9??84.< A70?7 A18:< 9//39?/ /7. 9::.;.< 166.2?.4 92< /7.3.613. =1:0?. ?18:< 21/ 79B. 60:.< 3.=13/ 02 /7. =3.4.2/ ?94. 7. 309: 183/ 794 690:.< /1 9==3.?09/. /704 94=.?/16/7.@9//.392<794.33.<029??.=/02;/7.3.=13/ ??13<02;:>7.=39>4/19::1A/7.=./0/012
.3?12/39:.932.<?1824.:6133.4=12<.2/ 19??84.< 485@0/4 /79/ /7.3. 93. @8:/0=:. =31?..<02;4 =.2<02; 5./A..2 /7. =./0/012.3 92< 3.4=12<.2/ 1 1:0?. 79B. ?1::.?/.< 2.?.4493> @9/.309: <8302; /7. ?1834. 16 02B.4/0;9/012 92< 79B02;9==3.?09/.</7.49@.79B.30;7/:>60:.<6029:3.=13/02 /7. =3.4.2/ ?94. 02?. 6182<9/0129: 69?/4 16 /7. ?94. 04 <.6.?/0B.21=3.48@=/012?925.3904.<02/7.=3.4.2/?94.94 9;9024/ /7. 9??84.< . 485@0/4 /79/ =./0/012.3 79< @9<. 9 <.@92<613=9>@.2/164'?313. :9D74A70?704123.?13< 92< 79< /73.9/.2.< /1 60:. 69:4. ?30@029: ?94. 9;9024/ /7. 9??84.< .?.4493> @9/.309: /1 =31B. 48?7 <.@92< @9<. 5> /7.=./0/012.3A946832047.</1/7.=1:0?.<8302;/7.?1834.16 02B.4/0;9/01292<48?7@9/.309:04=93/16/7.?793;.47../7. 309:183/79B02; 9==3.?09/.<9::/7.4.94=.?/416/7.@9//.3 794 30;7/:> 9??.=/.< /7. 6029: 3.=13/ . 485@0/4 /79/ 12:>
- 5 -
A0/7 92 02/.2/012 /1 A3.?D B.2;.92?. 9/ /7. 024/92?. 16 /7. =./0/012.3?30@029:=31?..<02;4613/7.9::.;.<166.2?.402/7. =3.4.2/ ?94. A94 020/09/.< 92< 02 40@0:93 ?03?8@4/92?.4 /7. 12,5:. 8=3.@. 183/ 02 /7. ?94. 16
3.=13/.< 02 794 E8947.< /7. ?30@029: =31?..<02;4
* ./0/012.3 7.3.02 ?:90@4 /1
5. /7.
A06. 16 /7. 9??84.<3.4=12<.2/ 1 $0?/0@ 04 /7. <98;7/.3 16 =./0/012.3 631@ 7.3 6034/ @93309;. & 02 30@. 1**' ' A94 3.;04/.3.< 9;9024/ 3.4=12<.2/ 1 613 /7. 9613.490< 166.2?.4 12/7.5940416/7.6034/02613@9/012<9/.< !!' '3.?.0B.< 631@3.4=12<.2/ 1'A71A94A13D02;948=.302/.2<.2/16 1B.32@.2/ 03:4 1@. 90:113 02 0<93 04/30?/ 2 /7. 6034/ 02613@9/0120/044/9/.</79/B0?/0@;03:A7104/7.<98;7/.316 =./0/012.3 4/8<>02; 02 ! /7 /< 02613@.< /79/ A7.2 47. A94 4/8<>02;02*/7/<9??84.<84.</1471A7.3154?.2.B0<.1402 704@150:.=712.92<12 + ' '9/9518/!' 9@02/7. @0<20;7/7.79<4.F89::>94498:/.<7.3718;70/049::.;.< 02 /7. 6034/ 02613@9/012 /79/ 12 + ' ' 9??84.< 79< 4.F89::> 94498:/.< /7. B0?/0@ ;03: <8302; /7. ?1834. 16
- 6 -
3.?13<02;/7.4/9/.@.2/16/7.B0?/0@;03:47.79<21/4/9/.< /7. .F9?/ <9/. 12 A70?7 47. A94 4.F89::> 94498:/.< 5> /7. 9??84.<
) 7.@9/.309:123.?13<A18:<;1/1471A/79/=./0/012.3 7.3.0279<.93:0.360:.< 1*' ''5.613./7.C8304<0?/0129: &9@0:>183/9;9024//7.9??84.<A0/79=39>.3/1<.?:93./79/
47. 04 704 A06. 92< 9:41 /1 ;392/ <.?3.. 3.4/390202; 70@ 631@ ?12/39?/02; 9 4.?12< @93309;. 7. 9:41 79< 60:.< 9 ?30@029: ?94.9;9024/3.4=12<.2/ 19??84.<0230@. 1*' '613 /7.166.2?.4=8204795:.82<.3.?/012+' *92< !+1692<02/7.490<?94.=1:0?.96/.302B.4/0;9/01279B. 60:.< 9 G,6029: 3.=13/ 12 ' *' ' 7. <.?3.. A70?7 A94 =944.< 02 1*' '' 794 5..2 E8.4/012.< 5> 3.4=12<.2/ 1 02 & 1' ')' ' A70?7 04 =.2<02; ?1240<.39/012 5.613./704183/
./0/012.3 7.3.02 79< 020/09/.< 4.=939/. =31?..<02;4 12 ' )' ' 5.613. /7. C8304<0?/0129: 183/ 9;9024/ 3.4=12<.2/ 1 82<.3 /7. =31B040124 16 /7. 31/.?/012 16 1@.2 631@ 1@.4/0?$01:.2?.?/023:04? 1*' '92<02/7.490< =31?..<02;447.7944=.?060?9::>=:.9<.</79/631@/7.@12/7
- 7 -
16 &.53893> ' '' 12A93<4 3.4=12<.2/ 794 21/ 5..2 B040/02;
7.37184.92<47.A949:4121/3.?.0B02;7.3=712.?9::47. 9::.;9/01221A@9<.02/7.6034/02613@9/01204/79/3.4=12<.2/ 1 79< 4.F89::> 94498:/.< /7. B0?/0@ ;03: 12 + ' ' 6 /7. 4/9/.@.2/ @9<. 02 /7. =31?..<02;4 82<.3 31/.?/012 16
1@.2 631@ 1@.4/0? $01:.2?. ?/ A70?7 A94 60:.< 02 /7. @12/7168:>' '04?133.?//7.20/04<0660?8://15.:0.B./7. 9::.;9/0124 6182< 02 /7. 6034/ 02613@9/012 9;9024/ 3.4=12<.2/ 1/79/7.79<4.F89::>94498:/.</7.B0?/0@;03:12/7.20;7/ 16 + ' '
+
7. =1:0?. <8302; /7. ?1834. 16 02B.4/0;9/012 02 /7. =3.4.2/ ?94. 79B. ?1::.?/.< @9/.309: A70?7 04 /7. 485C.?/ @9//.3 16 & 1 ' ' 94 @.2/012.< 02 /7. ?793;. 47../ A70?7 3.:9/.4 /1 <.@92< @9<. 5> =./0/012.3 A0/7 3.4=12<.2/ 1 613 =9>@.2/ 16 4' ?313.4 :9D74 /1A93<4 4.//:.@.2/ 690:02; A70?7 47. 794 /73.9/.2.< /1 4.2< 70@ /1 C90: 7. <.@92< @9<.
5> =./0/012.3 04 9:41 3.?13<.< 02 98<01 ?:0==02; A70?7 04 9:41 =93/ 16 /7. ?793;. 47../ ??13<02; /1 /7. =./0/012.3 /7. B0?/0@ ;03: 79< 4866.3.< /7. 9::.;.< 9?/ ?1@@0//.< 5> 3.4=12<.2/ 1 02 40:.2?. 92< 47. 79< 21/ 3.B.9:.</7.49@./17.37.79<613/7.6034//0@.3.B.9:.<
- 8 -
/7. 49@. /1 7.3 404/.3 3.@9D8@930 A71 9:41 04 A13D02; 94 .9<04/3.4402/7.?711:02A70?7/7.B0?/0@;03:044/8<>02; 2 /7. &029: .=13/ 0/ 04 @.2/012.< /79/ =./0/012.3 92< 3.@9D8@930 79< 921/7.3 404/.3 5> 29@. >1/70 A71 A94 @9330.</1$..3.2<396/.3/7.<.9/716>1/703.@9D8@930 79< 020/09/.< =31?..<02;4 5.613. /7. C8304<0?/0129: 183/ 9/ 0<93 9;9024/ $..3.2<39 ?12/.2<02; /79/ 47. A94 /7. A06. 16 $..3.2<3992<79<@9<.9?:90@613?84/1<>16704?70:<3.202 H 1' ''7.C8304<0?/0129:183/79<<04@044.<7.3 ?:90@92<9?1=>16/7.13<.3=944.<02H 1' ''04 9:41=93/16/7.3.=13/60:.<5.613./7.309:183/
! 2 /7. 59?D;3182< 16 B930184 :0/0;9/012 A70?7 A.3. 60:.< =3013 /1 & 3.;04/.3.< 02 /7. =3.4.2/ ?94. 92< 9:41 79B02;
3.;93< /1 @9/.309: @9<. 9B90:95:. /1 /7. 2B.4/0;9/012 660?.3 5> 3.4=12<.2/ 1 <8302; 02B.4/0;9/012 A70?7 A18:< 3.B.9: /79/ 9 <.@92< A94 @9<. 5> /7. =./0/012.3 613 =9>@.2/ 16 4' ?313.4 :9D74 690:02; A70?7 47. 79< /73.9/.2.< /1 4.2< 70@ /1 C90: =1:0?. 96/.3 02B.4/0;9/02; 79B. 60:.<6029:3.=13/02/7.=3.4.2/?94.=.3849:16/7.6029: 3.=13/A18:<;1/1471A/79//7.49@.0460:.<96/.3.F/.240B.:> 02B.4/0;9/02; /7. @9//.3 92< 96/.3 ?1::.?/02; 9:: /7. 2.?.4493>
- 9 -
@9/.309: 7. 309: 183/ /7.3.613. 79B02; 9==3.?09/.< /7. ?12/.2/4 16 /7. 3.=13/ 794 30;7/:> 9??.=/.< /7. 49@. 92< ?:14.</7.?94.9;9024/3.4=12<.2/ 1
!! 7. 12,5:. 8=3.@. 183/ 02 /7. ?94. 16
02 9 ?94. A7.3. ?30@029: ?94. A943.;04/.3.<613/7.166.2?.4=8204795:.82<.3.?/0124' *92<'1692<.?/01216/7.?/ /9D02; 02/1 ?1240<.39/012 /79/ =930/0.4 A.3. 60;7/02; B930184 :0/0;9/012 5./A..2 /7.@4.:B.4 .93:0.3 92< /7.3.613. ?30@029:
=31?..<02;4A94020/09/.<12:>/1A3.?DB.2;.92?.9;9024//7. 9??84.<794E8947.<40@0:93?30@029:=31?..<02;42/7.?94. 12 792< 2B.4/0;9/012 660?.3 79B02; 7.:< 9 <./90:.< 02B.4/0;9/01279460:.<6029:3.=13/92</7.?12/.2/416/7. 6029: 3.=13/ A18:< ;1 /1 471A /79/ 2B.4/0;9/012 660?.3 A94 C84/060.<02485@0//02;/7.49@.2<.3/7.?03?8@4/92?.4<1 21/602<92>;11<;3182</1.2/.3/902/704=./0/012??13<02;:> =./0/01204<04@044.<
-+
' % &$ !* $
04/ 1!: 1+