- 1 - !"! # $"% &" ! $ '(')*+('** & !"## $ % & ' ' ' ( ' ! #) $ % & ' !*'% & *! ' %& + '('#* ***# ' ,#**# % ",*#-& ' Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '' )%&%&)%#&%&%*&' #-%,&%,)& ' ' ( #-! + ' . % . & //01234#564 ,#**#726356892:4;2<=2 335<546>? 5@5? 0382 >63 ' 40;< 5A>B>70;> ;2851<2;23 :4; <=2 4::26/2 70651=>9?2 0632; 2/<5461 )%#&>%*& 4: <=2 1126<5>? 4CC435<521 /< #- %:4; 1=4;<D<=2/<#- E&;2>3F5<=2/<546#-%,&%,G)&4: <=2 '2;<5?5H2; 46<;4? ;32; #-! 51 92:4;2 <=51 40;< 0632; 2/<546 !* 4: 432 4: ;5C56>? ;4/230;2 F5<= > 7;>B2; <4 I0>1= <=2 26<5;2 7;4/2235681 56 <=2 >:4;21>53 />12>1>8>561<=5C * 2>;3<=2?2>;623/40612?:4;<=27>;<521 , 7;5@><2 /4C7?>56< F>1 :5?23 92:4;2 <=2 <;5>? 40;< 9B <=2 A0;5135/<546>? '2;<5?5H2; 6172/<4; >63 11< - 3 - 5;2/<4; 8;5/0?<0;2 5A>B>70;> F=2;256 <=2 72<5<5462; =2;25651>;;>B23>1;21746326<4#=2>??28><54656<=2 /4C7?>56< 51 <=>< <=2 >//0123 4# 51 <=2 4F62; 4: <=2 ;2<>5? 1=47 J64F6 >1 1 C48=>153321=F>;> 6<2;7;5121 F=5/= 51 12??568 <=2 '2;<5?5H2;1 C>60:>/<0;23 9B 1 >8>;A06> '2;<5?5H2;1 >63 =2C5/>?1 B32;>9>3 =26<=28;5/0?<0;2::5/2;=>3@515<23>63/4630/<23<=2 56172/<546 4: <=2 ;2<>5? 1=47 4: <=2 72<5<5462; 1 C48=>153321=F>;> 6<2;7;5121 46 #,-*#) <=2 1>53 :2;<5?5H2;1F2;2:4063<4924:1091<>63>;3=2;2:4;246 <=2 >??28><546 4: @54?><568 <=2 7;4@515461 4: 2/<5461 )%>&%9& >63 )%#&%>& )%*& 4: <=2 1126<5>? 4CC435<521 /<#- ;2>3F5<=2/<546#-%,&4:<=2'2;<5?5H2;46<;4? ;32; #-! /;5C56>? 7;4/2235681 F2;2 565<5><23 >8>561< <=2 >//0123 72;146 :4; <=2 >:4;21>53 4::26/21 =2 <;5>? 40;< =>@568 <>J26 /4865H>6/2 4: <=2 >??2823 4::26/2 70651=>9?20632;2/<5461)%>&%9&>63)%#&%>&)%*&4:<=2 1126<5>?4CC435<521/<#- ;2>3F5<=2/<546#-%,& %, G )& 4: <=2 '2;<5?5H2; 46<;4? ;32; #-! =>1 511023 - 4 - 10CC461 <4 <=2 >//0123 72;146 >63 92568 >88;52@23 9B <=21>C2<=272<5<5462;5192:4;2<=5140;< 2>;623/40612?:4;<=272<5<5462;109C5<1<=>< 56 @52F 4: 2/<546 # 4: <=2 1126<5>? 4CC435<521 /< #- <=2 /4C7>6B F=5/= =>1 >??2823?B C>60:>/<0;23 1091<>63>;3 :2;<5?5H2;1 51 > 62/211>;B 7>;<B <4 <=2 5C708623/;5C56>?7;4/2235681>63<=2;2<>5?1=474F62; />664<927;412/0<2356<=2>9126/24:<=2/4C7>6B92568 >;;>B23>1>//0123<4<=25C708623/;5C56>?7;4/2235681 2; /46<;> ?2>;623 4774123 <=2 72<5<546 >63109C5<1<=><<=2;2<>5?1=474F62;4:<=2/4C7>6B51 C>32 >1 > 7>;<B >63 <=2;2:4;2 <=2;2 51 /4C7?5>6/2 4: 2/<546#4:<=2/<#- " 2/<546 # 4: <=2 1126<5>? 4CC435<521 /< #- ;2>31>10632; ! !! !! - 5 - ! !! !! ! " # $ !! !! % ! % ! & !! ! ' ( $ ) ! ! !!! ! !!!! ! *&! + , ! !- , ! , ) ;2>3568 4: <=2 >:4;21>53 7;4@51546 4: ?>F C>J215<@2;B/?2>;<=><F=26<=24::26/21>;2>??2823<4 =>@29226/4CC5<<239B>/4C7>6B<=272;14656/=>;82 4: <=2 /4C7>6B >63 F>1 ;21746159?2 :4; <=2 1>?21 4: <=2 /4C7>6B >1 F2?? >1 <=2 /4C7>6B 1=>?? 92 322C23 <4 92 805?<B4:<=2/46<;>@26<546>631=>??927;4/22323>8>561< >63 70651=23 >//4;3568?B =2;2:4;2 /4C7>6B 4: F=5/= <=2>//0123>;22C7?4B221>;2;2I05;23<492>;;>B23>1 - 6 - >//0123 56 <=2 5C708623 7;4/2235681 >63 <=2 /4C7?>56< />664< 92 7;4/22323 >1 >8>561< <=2 >6>8568 5;2/<4; 5;2/<4;4;>6B2C7?4B224;4F62;4:<=2;2<>5?1=474:<=2 /4C7>6B56<=2>9126/24:<=24C7>6B92568C>32>1> 7>;<B <4 <=2 /;5C56>? 7;4/2235681 6 15C5?>; /5;/0C1<>6/21 <=51 40;< 56 ;5C56>? 2<5<546 4*"!"**351741234:46*!"**=>1I0>1=23 <=25C708623/;5C56>?7;4/2235681 ! 632; <=2 /5;/0C1<>6/21 >C 4: <=2 4756546 <=><156/2<=2/4C7>6B=>164<9226>;;>B23>1>//0123 56<=27;2126</>12<=2/;5C56>?7;4/2235681565<5><2382<1 @5<5><23:4;64</4C7?B568<=2;2I05;2C26<4:2/<546#4: <=2/<#- 26/2<=25C708623/;5C56>?7;4/2235681 />664<92101<>5623//4;3568?B7>11<=2:4??4F568 %5& =2/;5C56>?72<5<54651>??4F23K %55& =2 26<5;2 7;4/223568 56 4 ,#**# 726356892:4;2<=2335<546>?5@5?0382 - 7 - >63 ' 40;< 5A>B>70;> ;2851<2;23 :4; <=22/<5461)%>&%9&>63)%#&%>&)%*&4:<=2 1126<5>? 4CC435<521 /< #- ;2>3 F5<= 2/<546 #-%,& %, G )& 4: <=2 '2;<5?5H2; 46<;4? ;32; #-! 51 I0>1=23 >1 >8>561< <=272<5<5462;=2;256 %555& 4F2@2;<=514;32;F5??64</4C256<=2F>B 4:<=2;21746326<1<>J568>/<546>8>561<<=2 72<5<5462;56>//4;3>6/2F5<=?>F ,+ '% &" !* " 51<4#?4