Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 11551 (KAR)

MAHAVEERCHAND DHOKA S/O LATE KISHANALALJI DHOKA v. MITHALAL DHOKA S/O LATE PURANMALJI DHOKA

WP/202672/2022 · 2025-02-21

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!" #$% % &$ ' !" # $ % &' ( ( ! ' )" # $ % ( * )) * * ( * ( Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - *( % )&+))) , , , -')" * * * ( ,! * * ./ ( 0 12 345678699 67 :-')" :7 812 9642 :9 276:; 6<64 =>?2 5>?6;6 6@ A29:;2 816@ :=;8 B154427?67? 812 :;>2; >582> )&+))) AC D16B1 : , 9642> =7>2; ;>2; =42 " :9 :, 9642> =7>2; ;>2; , =42 " 57> :, 9642> =7>2; 2B86:7 " " :9 D2;2 ;2E2B82> ) 12 @=68 67 :-')" D5@ 9642> 9:; >2B45;586:7 :9 86842 57> 9:; 32;328=54 67E=7B86:7 8: ;2@8;567 812 >2927>578 9;:F 6782;92;67? D681 812 325B29=4 3:@@2@@6:7 57> 27E:CF278 :9 812 345678699 67 812 @=68 3;:32;862@ - 3 - - 12 345678699 B456F2> 8: A2 812 :D72; :9 812 @=68 3;:32;862@ 57> 5442?2> 8158 812 >2927>578 15> F575?2> 8: ?28 16@ 75F2 2782;2> 67 812 F=76B6354 ;2B:;>@ 67 ;2@32B8 :9 812 @=68 3;:32;862@ 12 345678699 812;29:;2 9642> 5 B:F345678 A29:;2 812 E=;6@>6B86:754 3:46B2 D1: 5982; 67<2@86?586:7 @=AF6882> 5 B15;?2@1228 57> :" )") D5@ ;2?6@82;2> 12 345678699 B456F2> 8158 812 F=76B6354 5=81:;6862@ 15> >2F:46@12> 812 A=64>67? 8158 2G6@82> :<2; 812 @=68 3;:32;862@ 9:; 812 3=;3:@2 :9 D6>2767? 812 ;:5> 57> 85H67? 5><5785?2 :9 812 278;62@ 67 F=76B6354 ;2B:;>@ 812 >2927>578 D5@ 8;C67? 8: ?;5A 812 3;:32;862@ 12 >2927>578 B:782@82> 812 @=68 57> B456F2> 8158 812 345678699 D5@ 7:8 812 :D72; :9 812 @=68 3;:32;862@ A=8 68 D5@ ; 6@157454 : 5857454 6;5454 D1: D5@ 812 :D72; 2 >2762> 8158 812 345678699 D5@ 812 @:7 :9 6@157454 2 B456F2> 8158 812 @=68 3;:32;862@ D2;2 57B2@8;54 3;:32;862@ 67 812 157>@ :9 16@ ?;57>95812; 4582 6;5454 2 B456F2> 8158 812 345678699 D5@ 7:8 2786842> 9:; - 4 - 57C >2B45;586:7 8158 12 6@ 812 @:42 :D72; :9 812 @=68 3;:32;862@ 5@2> :7 812@2 B:782786:7@ 812 @=68 D5@ @28 >:D7 9:; 8;654 57> 5982; 812 2<6>27B2 :9 812 345678699 D5@ B:7B4=>2> 812 B5@2 D5@ 46@82> 9:; 2<6>27B2 :9 812 >2927>578 8 8158 @85?2 812 345678699 9642> 57 53346B586:7 $:"-% =7>2; ;>2; =42 " :9 8: 3;:>=B2 5 B:3C :9 812 B:F345678 4:>?2> D16B1 D5@ 67<2@86?582> 5982; D16B1 5 B15;?2 @1228 D5@ 9642> 67 :)-')" 2 54@: @:=?18 8: 345B2 :7 ;2B:;> 812 B15;?2 @1228 9642> 5@ D244 5@ 5 ;23:;8 :9 5 9:;27@6B 2G32;8 2 9642> 57 53346B586:7 $:"% =7>2; ;>2; , =42 " :9 8: ;2B544 (! " 9:; F5;H67? 812 >:B=F278@ 57> 57:812; 53346B586:7 $:" % =7>2; 2B86:7 " " :9 9:; ;2!:32767? 345678699/@ 2<6>27B2 & 12@2 53346B586:7@ D2;2 B:782@82> AC 812 >2927>578 D1: B456F2> 8158 812 >:B=F278@ 3;:3:@2> 8: A2 3;:>=B2> AC 812 345678699 D2;2 7:8 ;242<578 9:; 812 3=;3:@2 :9 >2B6>67? 812 @=68 - 5 - 12 ;654 :=;8 5982; B:7@6>2;67? 812 B:782786:7@ ;2E2B82> 812 53346B586:7@ 67 82;F@ :9 812 6F3=?72> :;>2; :7 812 ?;:=7> 8158 812 345678699 15> 9642> 812 53346B586:7 A24582>4C 8158 8:: D127 812 B5@2 D5@ @28 >:D7 9:; 2<6>27B2 :9 812 >2927>578 8 124> 8158 812 345678699 D5@ 812 B:F34567578 67 812 B;6F6754 B5@2 57> 812;29:;2 812 3;:B22>67?@ 67 812 B;6F6754 B5@2 D5@ H7:D7 8: 16F A=8 12 >6> 7:8 3;:>=B2 812 >:B=F278@ 58 812 86F2 :9 5>>=B67? 2<6>27B2 12;29:;2 68 124> 8158 812;2 D5@ 7: E=@8696B586:7 9:; 812 345678699 8: 9642 812 >:B=F278@ A24582>4C <27 :812;D6@2 68 124> 8158 812 >:B=F278@ 3;:>=B2> 67 812 B;6F6754 B5@2 D:=4> 7:8 1243 812 345678699 8: 2@85A46@1 16@ ;6?18@ :<2; 812 @=68 @B12>=42 3;:32;862@ 12;29:;2 812 345678699 6@ A29:;2 816@ :=;8 ' 25;72> B:=7@24 9:; 812 345678699 B:7827>@ 8158 812 >2927>578 15> B456F2> 86842 8: 812 @=68 @B12>=42 3;:32;862@ A5@2> :7 57 5996>5<68 5442?2>4C 2G2B=82> AC 812 345678699 57> 8158 812 157>D;6867? 2G32;8 15> :3672> 8158 812 @6?758=;2@ 9:=7> :7 812 5996>5<68@ D2;2 7:8 812 - 6 - @6?758=;2@ :9 812 345678699 2 812;29:;2 B:7827>@ 8158 68 6@ 72B2@@5;C 8: 3;:>=B2 816@ >:B=F278 57> 812;29:;2 57 :33:;8=768C F=@8 A2 ?;5782> 8: 812 345678699 8: F5;H 81:@2 >:B=F278@ + 25;72> B:=7@24 9:; >2927>578 B:7827>@ 8158 812 345678699 15@ 5>>=B2> 2<6>27B2 57> 15@ 54@: 3;:>=B2> >:B=F278@ 67 @=33:;8 :9 16@ @=68 9:; >2B45;586:7 :9 16@ 86842 8: 812 @=68 @B12>=42 3;:32;862@ 2 B:7827>@ 8158 812 >:B=F278@ 7:D @:=?18 8: A2 3;:>=B2> 5;2 726812; ;242<578 7:; 72B2@@5;C 9:; 812 3=;3:@2 :9 >2B6>67? 812 @=68 2 9=;812; B:7827>@ 8158 812 345678699 B577:8 F5;H 812 ;23:;8 :9 812 157>D;6867? 2G32;8 5@ 812 345678699 6@ 726812; 812 5=81:; 7:; 812 ;23:;8 6@ 3;235;2> 58 16@ 67@857B2 12;29:;2 12 B:7827>@ 8158 812 >:B=F278@ 5;2 7:8 72B2@@5;C 9:; 812 3=;3:@2 :9 >2B6>67? 812 @=68 " 15<2 B:7@6>2;2> 812 @=AF6@@6:7 :9 425;72> B:=7@24 9:; 812 345678699 57> 425;72> B:=7@24 9:; 812 >2927>578 - 7 - "" @ ;6?184C B:7827>2> AC 425;72> B:=7@24 9:; 812 >2927>578 812 345678699 15> 4:>?2> 5 B:F345678 5?567@8 >2927>578@ 67 812 C25; )" 68@249 12 67<2@86?586:7 678: 812 B;6F6754 B5@2 D5@ >:72 AC 812 E=;6@>6B86:754 3:46B2 57> 812 B15;?2 @1228 D5@ 9642> 67 812 C25; )" 57> :)-')" D5@ ;2?6@82;2> 12 67@8578 @=68 D5@ 9642> 67 812 C25; )" 57> 812;29:;2 812 345678699 15> H7:D42>?2 57> 7:86B2 :9 812 3;:B22>67?@ 67 812 B;6F6754 B5@2 12;29:;2 812;2 D5@ 7: E=@8696B586:7 9:; 812 345678699 8: B:7827> 8158 12 B:=4> 7:8 3;:>=B2 812 >:B=F278@ 58 812 25;462@8 3:678 67 86F2 <27 :812;D6@2 812 >:B=F278@ 8158 812 345678699 67827>@ 8: 3;:>=B2 5;2 5 B:F345678 4:>?2> 812 B15;?2 @1228 9642> 5@ D244 5@ 812 ;23:;8 :9 812 157>D;6867? 2G32;8 D16B1 D5@ 35;8 :9 812 B15;?2@1228 12@2 >:B=F278@ >: 7:8 67 57CD5C 6F3;:<2 812 B5@2 :9 812 345678699 @ 5 F5882; :9 95B8 2<27 69 812 345678699 6@ 32;F6882> 8: 3;:>=B2 812 :3676:7 :9 812 157>D;6867? 2G32;8 8158 D:=4> 7:8 1243 812 B5@2 67 57C F5772; =742@@ 812 345678699 @=FF:72> 812 157>D;6867? 2G32;8 57> F5;H2> - 8 - 68 81;:=?1 16F @: 8158 812 >2927>578 B:=4> B;:@@ 2G5F672 812 @56> D6872@@ ") 7 8158 <62D :9 812 F5882; 812 ;654 :=;8 D5@ ;6?18 67 7:8 2782;856767? 812 ;2I=2@8 :9 812 345678699 27B2 816@ D;68 328686:7 6@ :D2<2; 46A2;8C 6@ ;2@2;<2> 9:; 812 345678699 8: 9642 533;:3;6582 53346B586:7 9:; 533:678F278 :9 5 157>D;6867? 2G32;8 9 57 53346B586:7 6@ 9642> 812 ;654 :=;8 @1544 B:7@6>2; 812 @5F2 67 5BB:;>57B2 D681 45D A5@2> :7 812 2<6>27B2 5>>=B2> () &%' % 6@8 : " 4 :