- 1 - !! "#$ % &$ ! #% & !" #$ % & ' '( ' )*!*+ % &' ( ", ' + ++! $ Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "+ - ' ++ !*++ $# *+++) ,&.(&//( ) + - ' ' ' ++* - 0 $ ' -$ % & 0 $ ' -$ ( 1/2 34/5/678 49:/2/;6 <9=/=/;6 >6?94 93=/;62 ", 497? @/=1 +;A4/2A/89?.B=19733>29?7227/8/6C=19D>?C596= 76?;4?94;A3;6:/3=/;676?296=9639?7=9?++<7229? .B =19 ;>4= ;A $ AE78<>4 /6 ;!*+ 76? =19 D>?C596=76?;4?94?7=9?+ ++!<7229?.B=19;>4=;A ??8922/;62$>?C9787.>47C//648;"+ 974?=19897469?;>6298A;4=19<74=/92 " 19 62<93=;4 ;A 4>C2 787.>47C/ 17? A/89? 7 <4/:7=9 3;5<87/6= 7C7/62= =19 <9=/=/;6942 1949/6 76? 76;=194 A;4 =19 - 3 - ;AA9639 <>6/217.89 >6?94 93=/;6 ,&.(&//( ;A =19 4>C2 76? ;259=/32 3= + &A;4 21;4= F=19 3=( 19 733>29? @1; 7<<9749?.9A;49=194/78;>4=/6=1927/?<4;399?/6C2387/59? =;.9=4/9?76?=1949A;49=19<4;293>=/;6/6;4?94=;<4;:9/=2 3174C92 7C7/62= =19 733>29? 17? 9G75/69? 3174C9)2199= @/=692292 72 -2) =; C;= 574H9? + ?;3>596=2 72 G2)=;)+76?+57=94/78;.D93=2@949C;=574H9?72 2)=;+ ;@9:946;?9A96399:/?9639@7289?;6.9178A ;A =19 733>29? 6;= @72 76B ?;3>596= 574H9? /6 2><<;4= ;A =19/4?9A9639 19 4/78 ;>4= :/?9 =19 D>?C596= 76? ;4?94 /5<>C69? 3;6:/3=9?=19733>29?A;4=19;AA9639<>6/217.89>6?9493=/;6 ,&.(&//( ;A =19 3= 76? 296=9639? =195 =; >6?94C; 2/5<89 /5<4/2;6596= A;4 7 <94/;? ;A ;69 B974 76? <7B A/69 ;A 2*+++) 9731 19 27/? D>?C596= 76? ;4?94 ;A 3;6:/3=/;6 76? 296=9639 <7229? .B =19 4/78 ;>4= @72 >62>33922A>88B 3178896C9? .B =19 <9=/=/;6942 1949/6 .9A;49 =19 D>4/2?/3=/;678 922/;62 ;>4= /6 48;"+ @1/31 @72 ?/25/229? ;6 + ++!1949A;49=19B749.9A;49=1/2;>4= - 4 - * 97469? ;>6298 A;4 =19 <9=/=/;6942 2>.5/=2 =17= =19 /5<>C69? D>?C596= 76? ;4?94 ;A 3;6:/3=/;6 76? 296=9639 <7229?.B=193;>4=2.98;@/2;69@/=1;>=D>4/2?/3=/;676?=19 ;478 76? ?;3>596=74B 9:/?9639 @72 6;= <4;<948B 7<<493/7=9? .B =19 3;>4=2 .98;@ @1/31 172 492>8=9? /6 /889C788B 3;6:/3=/6C =19 <9=/=/;6942 A;4 =19 7889C9? ;AA96392 9 2>.5/=2 =17= =19 <9=/=/;6942>6?/2<>=9?8B198?7:78/?8/39629=/88"++76? @/=1/6=19=/59<49234/.9?A;4A/8/6C767<<8/37=/;6A;44969@78 ;A=1927/?8/39629=198/39629@722>4496?949?19872=?7=9 =; A/89 2>31 7 4969@78 7<<8/37=/;6 @72 "++++ 76? ;6 +++/=298A<9=/=/;694217:92>4496?949?=19/48/3962972 <94 G) 76? =1949A;49 =19B 3;>8? 6;= 17:9 .996 <4;293>=9? A;4 =19 7889C9? ;AA9639 33;4?/6C8B 19 <47B2 =; 788;@=19<9=/=/;6 94 3;6=47 897469? 172 ;<<;29? =19 <9=/=/;6 9 2>.5/=2=17=>6?/2<>=9?8B7A=94"++<9=/=/;6942?/?6;= 17:978/3962976?=19<4;293>=/;6172<4;:9?=17=7A=949G</4B ;A=198/39629<9=/=/;694217?2;8?=19?4>C29=/=/;694217:9 6;=A/89?76B7<<8/37=/;6299H/6C4969@78;A=19/48/39629@1/31 172 9G</49? ;6 "++ 76? /6 =19 7.29639 ;A 2>31 76 7<<8/37=/;6 =19B 3766;= 3;6=96? =17= /6 =19 9:96= 2>31 76 - 5 - 7<<8/37=/;6@72A/89?=198/396293;>8?17:9.9964969@9? 9 2>.5/=2=17=767<<8/37=/;6A/89?299H/6C4969@78;A=199G</49? 8/39629 3;>8? .9 96=94=7/69? ;68B ;6 <7B596= ;A <9678=B 76? >6?/2<>=9?8B<9678=B1726;=.996<7/?/6=19<49296=3729.B =19<9=/=/;69421949A;4919<47B2=;?/25/22=19<9=/=/;6 , 9=/=/;694217:9.996<4;293>=9?/6=19<49296=3729A;4 17:/6C 3;55/==9? =19 ;AA9639 <>6/217.89 >6?94 93=/;6 ,&.(&//( ;A =19 3= 19 27/? <4;:/2/;6 ;A 87@ A7882 >6?94 17<=94)';A=193=@1/31<4;:/?92A;4576>A73=>49278976? ?/2=4/.>=/;6;A?4>C276?3;259=/3293=/;6";A=193=@1/31 782;A7882>6?9417<=94)';A=193=<4;:/?92A;43;C6/E7639;A ;AA9639293=/;6";A=193=497?272>6?94 I'()*+,)-..)-./0&(;<4;293>=/;6 >6?94=1/217<=9421788.9/62=/=>=9?9G39<=.BJ &7( 7662<93=;4K;4 &.( 76B C7E9==9? ;AA/394 ;A =19 96=478 ;:946596= ;4 7 =7=9 ;:946596= 7>=1;4/29? /6 @4/=/6C /6 =1/2 .9178A .B =19 96=478;:946596=;47=7=9;:946596= ;4 .B 7 C969478 ;4 2<93/78 ;4?94 57?9 /6 =1/2.9178A.B=17=;:946596=K;4 &3( =19<942;67CC4/9:9?K;4 - 6 - &?( 7493;C6/29?3;62>594722;3/7=/;6@19=194 2>31 <942;6 /2 7 595.94 ;A =17= 722;3/7=/;6;46;= &( 7:9 72 ;=194@/29 <4;:/?9? /6 =1/2 3= 6; 3;>4=/6A94/;4=; =17=;A7;>4= ;A922/;621788=4B76 ;AA9639<>6/217.89>6?94=1/217<=94 &"( ;=1/6C 3;6=7/69? /6 =1/2 17<=94 21788 .9 ?9959? =; <49:96= 76B <942;6 A4;5 .9/6C <4;293>=9? >6?94 76B ;=194 87@ A;4 76B 73= ;4 ;5/22/;6 @1/31 3;62=/=>=9276;AA96397C7/62==1/217<=94L ! 4;57497?/6C;A=197A;4927/?<4;:/2/;6;A87@/=/2:94B 38974=17=<4;293>=/;6A;476;AA9639<>6/217.89>6?9493=/;6 ,&.(&//( ;A =19 3= 21788 .9 /62=/=>=9? ;68B .B <942;62 72 596=/;69?/6387>292&7(=;&?(;A2>.)293=/;6&(;A93=/;6" ;A =19 3= >.)293=/;6 &( ;A 93=/;6 " ;A =19 3= <4;:/?92 =17=6;3;>4=/6A94/;4=;=17=;A7;>4=;A922/;621788=4B76 ;AA9639<>6/217.89>6?94=1/217<=94 6=19<49296=3729=19<4/:7=93;5<87/6=172.996A/89? .B=1962<93=;4;A 4>C2@1;@72.996?>8B7>=1;4/E9?76? =1949A;49<4;293>=/;6172.996/6/=/7=9?7C7/62==19<9=/=/;6942 /63;5<8/7639;A=1949M>/49596=;A2>.)293=/;6&(;A93=/;6 ";A=193=>.)293=/;6&(;A93=/;6";A=193=<4;:/?92 - 7 - =17=6;3;>4=/6A94/;4=;=17=;A7;>4=;A922/;621788=4B76 ;AA9639<>6/217.89>6?9417<=94)'93=/;6";A=193= <4;:/?92A;4<93/78;>4=2A;43;6?>3=/6C=19=4/78;A;AA96392 >6?94 =19 <4;:/2/;62 ;A =19 3= 93=/;6 " ;A =19 3= <4;:/?92 =17= =19 ;?9 ;A 4/5/678 4;39?>49 ," 21788 .9 7<<8/37.89=;=19<4;399?/6C2.9A;49=19<93/78;>4=93=/;6 " ;A 4 <4;:/?92 A;4 3;C6/E7639 ;A ;AA96392 .B =19 922/;62;>4=@1/31497?272>6?94 I1' ()*+,)-. .)-./ 23 456/ .//*) G39<= 72 ;=194@/29 9G<49228B <4;:/?9? .B =1/2 ;?9 ;4 .B 76B ;=194 87@ A;4 =19 =/59 .9/6C /6 A;4396;;>4=;A922/;621788=7H93;C6/E7639;A76B ;AA9639727;>4=;A;4/C/678D>4/2?/3=/;6>68922=193729 172 .996 3;55/==9? =; /= .B 7 7C/2=47=9 >6?94 =1/2 ;?9L + >.)293=/;6 &( ;A 93=/;6 " ;A =19 3= @1/31 <4;:/?92 =17=6;3;>4=/6A94/;4=;=17=;A7;>4=;A922/;621788=4B=19 ;AA9639<>6/217.89>6?9417<=94)'?;926;=<4;:/?9=17==19 ;>4=;A922/;62376?/493=8B=7H93;C6/E7639;A=193;5<87/6= @/=1;>= =1949 .9/6C 76 ;4?94 ;A 3;55/==78 .B =19 ;>4= ;A 7C/2=47=9 - 8 - 6 2<93/78 9673=596=2 8/H9 319?>89? 72=92 76? =19 319?>89?4/.92&49:96=/;6;A=4;3/=/92(3=!&A;421;4= F 3=( 76? =19 49:96=/;6 ;A ;44><=/;6 3= !! &A;4 21;4= F3=( <4;:/2/;6 /2 A;>6? @1949 2<93/78 3;>4=2 749 <4;:/?9? =; 1;8? =4/78 A;4 =19 ;AA96392 >6?94 =19 27/? 3=2 93=/;6 ;A =19 3= 76? 93=/;6 * ;A =19 3= <4;:/?92A;4=19<;@94;A2>312<93/783;>4=2 93=/;6 ;A=193=497?272>6?94 I 7.-*,8 456 ,)9 :-84/*;. 7.-*,8 456 &( ;4 =19 <>4<;29 ;A <4;:/?/6C A;4 2<99?B =4/78=19=7=9;:946596=21788@/=1=193;63>449639 ;A=191/9A$>2=/39;A=19 /C1;>4=.B6;=/A/37=/;6/6 =19AA/3/787E9==992=7.8/2176 G38>2/:9<93/783;>4= A;4;69;45;49 /2=4/3=2 4;:/?9? =17= /6 /2=4/3=2 @1949 8922 6>5.94 ;A 37292>6?94=1/23=/2493;4?9?=19=7=9;:946596= 21788 @/=1 =19 3;63>449639 ;A =19 1/9A $>2=/39 ;A =19 /C1;>4=.B6;=/A/37=/;6/6=19AA/3/787E9==92<93/AB A;42>31 /2=4/3=2=19 ;>4= ;A 922/;6 =;.97<93/78 ;>4==;=4B=19;AA96392>6?94=1/23= 4;:/?9?A>4=194=17==19;>4=22;92=7.8/219?;4 2<93/A/9?2178817:9<;@94=;?/493=8B=7H93;C6/E7639;A ;AA96392>6?94=1/23= - 9 - &(=21788.9=19?>=B;A=19=7=9;:946596= =; 92=7.8/21 7?9M>7=9 6>5.94 ;A ;>4=2 =; 962>49 =17= 37292>6?94=1/23=749?/2<;29?;A@/=1/6 7<94/;?;A =@;5;6=1272A7472<;22/.89 &"( 6 9:94B =4/78 /6 =19 <93/78 ;>4= ;4 =19 G38>2/:9 <93/78 ;>4= =19 <4;399?/6C2 21788 .9 3;6=/6>9? A4;5 ?7B)=;)?7B >6=/8 788 =19 @/=692292 /6 7==96?7639 17:9 .996 9G75/69? >68922 =19 <93/78 ;>4= ;4 =19 G38>2/:9 <93/78 ;>4= A/6?2 =19 7?D;>46596=;A=192759.9B;6?=19A;88;@/6C?7B=;.9 69392274BA;44972;62=;.9493;4?9?/6@4/=/6C 4;:/?9?=17=@196=19=4/784987=92=;76;AA9639 >6?94 =1/2 3= =19 =4/78 21788 72 A74 72 <;22/.89 .9 3;5<89=9?@/=1/67<94/;?;A=@;5;6=12A4;5=19?7=9 ;AA/8/6C;A=193174C92199=L " 93=/;6*;A=193=497?272>6?94 I5-.945.,)97<.5//7.-*,8$49(. &( 2<93/78 $>?C9 57B =7H9 3;C6/E7639 ;A ;AA96392 @/=1;>= =19 733>29? .9/6C 3;55/==9? =; 1/5 A;4 =4/78 76? /6 =4B/6C =19 733>29? <942;62 21788 A;88;@ =19 <4;39?>49<49234/.9?.B=19;?9;A4/5/6784;39?>49 ,"&;A, (A;4=19=4/78;A@74476=37292.B=19 7C/2=47=92 &(2<93/78$>?C957B@/=17:/9@=;;.=7/6/6C =19 9:/?9639 ;A 76B <942;6 2><<;29? =; 17:9 .996 ?/493=8B ;4 /6?/493=8B 3;639469? /6 ;4 <4/:B =; 76 ;AA9639=96?947<74?;6=;2>31<942;6;63;6?/=/;6;A - 10 - 1/2 57H/6C 7 A>88 76? =4>9 ?/238;2>49 ;A =19 @1;89 3/43>52=76392 @/=1/6 1/2 H6;@89?C9 4987=/6C =; =19 ;AA9639 76? =; 9:94B ;=194 <942;6 3;639469? @19=194 72 <4/63/<78 ;4 7.9==;4 /6 =19 3;55/22/;6 =1949;A 76? 76B<74?;62;=96?949?21788A;4=19<>4<;292;A2>.) 293=/;62&(=;&*(;A293=/;6"+!;A=19;?9;A4/5/678 4;39?>49,"&;A, (.9?9959?=;17:9.996 =96?949?>6?94293=/;6"+,;A=17=;?9 &"( 7:9 72 <4;:/?9? /6 2>.)293=/;6 &( ;4 2>.) 293=/;6 &( =19 <4;:/2/;62 ;A =19 ;?9 ;A 4/5/678 4;39?>49 ," & ;A , ( 21788 2; A74 72 =19B 749 6;=/63;62/2=96=@/=1=1/23=7<<8B=;=19<4;399?/6C2 .9A;4972<93/78$>?C9K76?A;4=19<>4<;292;A=1927/? <4;:/2/;62 =19 ;>4= ;A =19 2<93/78 $>?C9 21788 .9 ?9959? =; .9 7 ;>4= ;A 922/;6 76? =19 <942;6 3;6?>3=/6C7<4;293>=/;6.9A;4972<93/78$>?C921788.9 ?9959?=;.97<>.8/3<4;293>=;4 & ( 6 <74=/3>874 76? @/=1;>= <49D>?/39 =; =19 C969478/=B;A=19<4;:/2/;623;6=7/69?/62>.)293=/;6&"( =19 <4;:/2/;62 ;A 293=/;62 " 76? ,* ;A =19 ;?9 ;A 4/5/678 4;39?>49 ," & ;A , ( 21788 2; A74 72 57B.97<<8B=;=19<4;399?/6C2.9A;4972<93/78$>?C9 76? A;4 =19 <>4<;292 ;A =19 27/? <4;:/2/;62 7 2<93/78 $>?C921788.9?9959?=;.977C/2=47=9 &*( 2<93/78 $>?C9 57B <722 ><;6 76B <942;6 3;6:/3=9?.B1/576B296=96397>=1;4/29?.B87@A;4=19 <>6/21596= ;A =19 ;AA9639 ;A @1/31 2>31 <942;6 /2 3;6:/3=9? - 11 - &( 2<93/78 $>?C9 @1/89 =4B/6C 76 ;AA9639 <>6/217.89>6?94=1/23=217889G943/29788=19<;@942 76?A>63=/;629G943/27.89.B7 /2=4/3=$>?C9>6?94=19 4/5/678 7@ 596?596= 4?/67639 &4? "! ;A (L 4;5 7 497?/6C ;A 293;6? <4;:/2; =; 2>.)293=/;6 &( ;A 93=/;6 ;A=193=76?A4;57497?/6C;A2>.)293=/;6 &(;A93=/;6*;A=193=/=/2:94B38974=17==193;>4=;A <93/78 $>?C9 /2 782; <4;:/?9? @/=1 =19 <;@94 =; =7H9 3;C6/E7639 ;A =19 ;AA96392 >6?94 =19 27/? 3=2 @/=1;>= =19 733>29?.9/6C3;55/==9?=;=1927/?;>4=A;4=4/7876?2>317 <4;:/2/;6/26;=A;>6?/693=/;6";A=19 4>C276?;259=/32 3= + * 6?94 =19 3/43>52=76392 =19 3;5<87/6= A/89? .B 7 3;5<9=96=;AA/39472<4;:/?9?>6?942>.)293=/;6&(;A93=/;6 " ;A =19 3= .9A;49 =19 ;>4= ;A D>4/2?/3=/;678 7C/2=47=9 /2 49M>/49?=;.93;55/==9?=;=19;>4=;AD>4/2?/3=/;678922/;62 $>?C9A;4=4/7872<4;:/?9?>6?942>.)293=/;6&(;A93=/;6" ;A=193=6=19<49296=3729=19897469?7C/2=47=91/5298A 172=4/9?=19733>29?<942;62A;4=197889C9?;AA963976?172 <7229? =19 /5<>C69? D>?C596= 76? ;4?94 ;A 3;6:/3=/;6 76? 296=9639 3;6:/3=/6C =19 733>29? A;4 =19 ;AA9639 <>6/217.89 - 12 - >6?9493=/;6,&.(&//(;A=193=@1/31/26;=<945/22/.8919 <<9887=9 ;>4= 172 A7/89? =; 7<<493/7=9 =1/2 72<93= ;A =19 57==9476?1729449?/63;6A/45/6C=19/5<>C69?D>?C596=76? ;4?94 ;A 3;6:/3=/;6 76? 296=9639 <7229? .B =19 897469? 7C/2=47=9 6?94 =19 3/43>52=76392 =19 /5<>C69? D>?C596= 76?;4?94;A3;6:/3=/;6<7229?.B=193;>4=2.98;@3766;=.9 2>2=7/69?33;4?/6C8B=19A;88;@/6C;4?94 1949:/2/;6<9=/=/;6/2788;@9?19D>?C596=76?;4?94 ;A 3;6:/3=/;6 76? 296=9639 ?7=9? ++ <7229? .B =19 ;>4=;A$AE78<>4/6;!*+76?=19D>?C596= 76? ;4?94 ?7=9? + ++! <7229? .B =19 ;>4= ;A ??8 922/;62 $>?C9 787.>47C/ /6 48;"+ 749 1949.B 29= 72/?9 19 <9=/=/;6942 749 73M>/==9? ;A =19 ;AA9639 <>6/217.89 >6?94 93=/;6 ,&.(&//( ;A =19 3= /69 75;>6= /A 76B?9<;2/=9?.B=19<9=/=/;694221788.949A>6?9?=;=195 9= > % &$ !? $