- 1 - !! " # # $$%& '( $$)%& ' ( ! " #! $ % % $$ ! % % $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ! % % $ & % '( # ! % ) # ) # ((&$ ( % &%$& % ) &$ " # # $ &* + % $!* #% $, ( (! $! - $, $ %$' # + # - 3 - )' ( $ % ( % $ % $ % %. $ & % '' %# ) # ) # " # # #! $ % + &%$& % ) &/$ - 4 - $$%$%$/%(, $ $ $($ $ $/ $ $/ " # * #% $, ( $! $! - $, $ %$' # # # 0 # 0 ! 123456473896:;46<23=4569:>>6:;?4@83;A37B7B6 >:;7?65 7B6:>>6:95:;67:C64=>83;8?4:9<?5>35:9 7B3=@B 7B61:;659:76<83;;<6;5 B656 :>>6:95 :;6 <?;6276< :@:?457 7B6 D=<@E647 :4< :F:;< <:76< $ >:556< ?4 3 %$' A1 7B6 96:;46< 64?3; ?G?9 =<@6 :4< <<9 :4< 3EE?55?346; 83; E>931665 3E>645:7?34 :7 - 5 - :5:G:C:91:4 B6;6?4:876; ;686;;6< 73 :5 H -83;5B3;7! 3;7B65:C638234G64?6426 7B6>:;7?65F3=9< A6 ;686;;6< 73 :5 >6; 7B6?; ;:4C?4@ A683;6 7B6 3EE?55?346; & 1 7B6 ?E>=@46< D=<@E647 :4< :F:;< 7B6 3EE?55?346; B:5 :993F6< 7B6 29:?E >67?7?34 ?4 >:;7 :4< :F:;<6< : 5=E 38 5 $ / $% :5 23E>645:7?34 :4< <?;6276< 7B6 45=;:426 3E>:41 73 <6>35?7 7B6 5:E6 6?4@ :@@;?6G6< A1 7B6 5:?< D=<@E647 :4< :F:;< 7B6 45=;:426 3E>:41 B:5 8?96< 3 &% 2B:9964@?4@?759?:A?9?7173>:17B623E>645:7?34 FB6;6:5 7B6 >67?7?346;5 B:G6 8?96< 3 %( 566C?4@ 64B:426E6473823E>645:7?34 ( 6:;< 7B6 96:;46< 23=4569 :>>6:;?4@ 83; 7B6 45=;:426 3E>:41 :4< 7B6 96:;46< 23=4569 83; 7B6 29:?E:475 - 6 - / 876;B6:;?4@7B696:;46<23=456983;A37B5?<65 7B6 3491 5=A57:47?:9 I=657?34 38 9:F 7B:7 :;?56 83; 2345?<6;:7?34?4A37B7B656:>>6:95?5 B67B6; 7B6 96:;46< 3EE?55?346; F:5 D=57?8?6< ?4 :55655?4@ 7B6 E347B91 F:@65 :7 5 ' % >6; E347B 6G64 7B3=@B 7B6 437?8?2:7?34 ?55=6< A1 7B6 647;:9 3G6;4E647 =4<6; 627?34 &$! 38 7B6 E>931665 3E>645:7?34 27 $, 437?8?6< 5 %:5F:@65:4<7B:7?4437<6<=27?4@(J :5 >6; 627?34 & 38 7B6 E>931665 3E>645:7?34 27K ' B68:27=:9E:7;?L387B62:56?57B:7 >67?7?346; 3 $ F:5 7B6 F?<3F 38 <626:56<:5:;:7B :4<>67?7?346; 35 :4< :;6 7B6 E?43; <:=@B76; :4< 534 38 7B6 <626:56< ;65>627?G691 B61 234764<6< 7B:7 <626:56< :5:;:7BF:5:<;?G6;347B693;;1A6:;?4@3 &% $&34E347B91F:@6538 5 $ %:4< 5 %>6; <:1:5A:77::4<34$ $/FB?96B6F:5>;3266<?4@ ?47B65:?<93;;1 E67F?7B:4:22?<647:4<<=6732399?5?34 F?7B 2347:?46; 93;;1 A6:;?4@ 3 $%M/(, :4< 7B6 7;:273; 7;:?96; =4?7 A6:;?4@ 3 $%,'& :4< ,&$$ - 7 - :4<<?6<?47B6:22?<647 4688627 ?7F:5:2B:?42399?5?34 :22?<647 B6;683;6 >67?7?346;529:?E23E>645:7?34=4<6; 7B6>;3G?5?345387B6 278;3E7B63F46;:4<?45=;6; 387B693;;1 ?4FB?2B7B6<626:56<F:5:<;?G6; B68:27 7B:77B6;6F:5:;69:7?345B?>386E>9316;:4<6E>93166?5 437 <?5>=76< A=7 B3F6G6; ;65>34<647 3 $ <?< 437 5>62?81 7B6 F:@65 7B:7 F:5 A6?4@ >:?< 73 <626:56< :5:;:7B B6 45=;:426 3E>:41 7B3=@B <?5>=76< ?75 9?:A?9?71347B6@;3=4<7B:77B676;E5:4<234<?7?345387B6 >39?21F6;6 G?39:76< 23=9<4375:7?58:273;?91 657:A9?5B 7B6 5:?< 8:27 :4< 7B6;683;6 7B6 3EE?55?346; >;3266<6< 73 2345?<6; 7B6 ?423E6 38 <626:56< :5:;:7B :7 5 ' % >6;E347B:4<:F:;<6<7B623E>645:7?34 3F6G6; FB?96 2:92=9:7?4@ 7B6 23E>645:7?34 7B6 3EE?55?346; <?< 437 <6<=27(J38F:@65:564G?5:@6<=4<6;627?34&387B6 27 A683;6E=97?>91?4@F?7B7B6;696G:478:273; 6:;46< 23=4569 :>>6:;?4@ 83; 7B6 45=;:426 3E>:41 F3=9< 5=AE?7 7B:7 7B6 96:;46< 3EE?55?346; 6;;6<?4437:>>91?4@7B6E67B3<382:92=9:7?3464G?5:@6< - 8 - =4<6; 627?34 & 38 7B6 27 :4< ?7 5B3=9< B:G6 <6<=276< (J 38 7B6 F:@65 ?4 2:565 38 <6:7B :4< 7B64 E=97?>91 7B6 5:E6 F?7B 7B6 ;696G:47 8:273; =4<6; 7B6 2B6<=96737B6 27 , 6; 2347;: 96:;46< 23=4569 :>>6:;?4@ 83; 7B6 >67?7?346;5 234764<6< 7B:7 7B3=@B 7B6 ?423E6 38 7B6 <626:56< F:5 34 7B6 B?@B6; 5?<6 7B6 96:;46< 3EE?55?346; 6;;6< ?4 B39<?4@ 7B6 ?423E6 :7 5 & % >6;E347BA1:<<?4@7B6<:?91A:77::4<737:99?4@7B65:E6 :7 5 ' %>6;E347B $ 4 7B6 :A3G6 2?;2=E57:4265 ?7 ?5 6G?<647 7B:7 7B6 96:;46< 3EE?55?346; 23=9< 437 B:G6 ;6<=26< 7B6 F:@65 38 7B6 <626:56< A693F 5 % FB?2B ?5 7B6 :E3=478?L6<=4<6;7B6437?8?2:7?34?55=6<A17B6647;:9 3G6;4E647 =4<6; 627?34 &$! 38 7B6 27 B6;683;6 7B6 3EE?55?346; 296:;91 6;;6< ?4 B39<?4@ 7B6 F:@65 38 7B6 <626:56< :7 5 ' % >6; E347B :4< 73 7B:7 6L7647 7B6 :>>6:9 8?96< A1 7B6 >67?7?346;5 F3=9< - 9 - 5=2266< 223;<?4@91 7B6E347B91F:@65387B6<626:56< ?52345?<6;6<:7 5 % $$ 3 8:; :5 7B6 2347647?34 38 7B6 45=;:426 3E>:41?523426;46< 6G?<647917B6>;3G?5?34538627?34 &$!387B6 27E647?347B:7FB6;67B6<6:7B;65=975 8;3E7B6?4D=;1 :4:E3=476I=:973(J387B6E347B91 F:@65 38 7B6 <626:56< E=97?>9?6< A1 7B6 ;696G:47 8:273; B:5 73 A6 :F:;<6< B6;683;6 7B6 96:;46< 3EE?55?346; B:G?4@8:?96<73:>>917B62;?76;?:38N(JO:564G?5:@6<?4 627?34&$! B:56;;6<?42:92=9:7?4@7B65:E6 $ 4 7B6 ;65=97 7B6 >67?7?346;5 :;6 647?796< 83; 23E>645:7?34 38 5 L (J L $/, && P 5 / '' '/% $ B6 23E>645:7?34 :F:;<6< A1 7B6 3EE?55?346;=4<6; 7B6 B6:< 38 8=46;:9 6L>64565737B6 7=4638 5 %;6E:?45=4:976;6< $& B=5 7B6 >67?7?346;5 :;6 647?796< 83; : 737:9 23E>645:7?3438 5 / ,' '/%F?7B?476;657 - 10 - $( 3; 7B6 83;6@3?4@ ;6:5345 A37B 7B6 :>>6:95 <656;G673A6:993F6<?4>:;7 6426 7B683993F?4@ ?! B6:>>6:95:;6:993F6<?4>:;7 ??! B6 ?E>=@46< D=<@E647 :4< :F:;< >:556< A17B63EE?55?346;?5E3<?8?6< ???! B6 >67?7?346;5%:>>699:475 ?4 3 %( :;6 647?796< 83; : 737:9 23E>645:7?34 38 5 / ,' '/% ?4576:< 38 5 $ / $% :F:;<6< A1 7B6 3EE?55?346; 73@67B6;F?7B?476;657:7$J > : 8;3E7B6<:7638<:15:876;7B6<:76 38 :22?<647 6L29=<?4@ 7B6 ?476;657 83; 7B6 <69:16< >6;?3< 38 $ <:15 ?4 8?9?4@ 7B?5 :>>6:9 ?G! 65>34<647 3 45=;:426 3E>:41% :>>699:47?43 &%?5<?;6276< 73 <6>35?7 7B6 647?;6 23E>645:7?34 :E3=47 - 11 - F?7B?4:>6;?3<385?LF66C58;3E7B6<:7638 7B?53;<6; ?8437<6>35?76<:9;6:<1 G! B6 :E3=47 ?4 <6>35?7 A683;6 7B?5 3=;7 ?8 :41 A67;:45E?776< 73 7B6 3EE?55?346; 83; <?5A=;56E647 G?! 657387B63;<6;>:556<A13EE?55?346;?4 ;65>627 38 7B6 :>>3;7?34E647 ;696:56 :4< <6>35?7672 ;6E:?45=4:976;6< <% % # & # ?573 $93 &