Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11492 (KAR)
THE MANAGER IFFCO-TOIKO v. DASHRATH AND ORS
MFA/202489/2018 · 2025-02-14
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11492 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11492 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#
$
$
%
! ! " #
!" ! $
%&"
%
'
%&"
%
! $
() ! &&
$'
"$
" %* %
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
() ! && #
!"
$ $ ) ! + $
$ ! "
,
" -
"
,
$*
* ! ' !"
*
-
-
"* '
$ %
% .! * *
$ %.! * *
/01 233425 01 67 8/4 91:;29<4 =>3297 6409? 2??;04@4A 67 8/4 B:A?>498 29A 2C2;A A284A - 32114A 09
=- 32114A 67 8/4 =>>0110=94; D=;
>35=7441 =>3491280=9 !0A2; 29A ;09<0325 490=; 0@05 *:A?429A*28!0A2;D=;1/=;8E8/4=>>0110=94;,
42;A 542;94A <=:9145 D=; 8/4 233455298 29A 34;:14A8/4>284;0252@2052654=9;4<=;A
- 3 -
/4;4 01 9= ;43;41498280=9 =9 64/25D =D 8/4 ;413=9A4981
/4 1:618298025 F:4180=9 =D 52C 8/28 /21 6449 ;2014A678/01=:;80121645=C%
&
/4D2<8:25>28;0G=D8/4<2148/2801;454@298D=;
8/4 3:;3=14 =D 8/01 233425 01 8/28 8/4 A4<4214A /0@H:>2;
C21 8/4 1=9 =D 8/4 348080=94;1 C=;H09? 21 2 526=:;4; 09 2 8;2<8=;8;=5547 642;09? = 29A :9A4;
8/44>35=7>498=D;413=9A498=I/2992@21C2 4AA7 9 C/49 /4 C21 C=;H09? 21 2 ==504 :9A4;
;413=9A498 = /4 25=9? C08/ =8/4; 5=2A4A 8/4 8;2<8=; 8;=5547C08/D=AA4;29A8/47C4;4108809?=98/48;=5547C/054 8/4 8;2<8=; C21 8= <;=11 2 ;0@4; 09 8/4 15=34 542A09? 8= 8/4 ;0@4;8/4A;0@4;233504A8/46;2H41212;41:588/4A4<4214A /0@H:>2;D455A=C91:182094A09B:;04129AA04A
- 4 -
J
/4 348080=94;1 C/= 2;4 8/4 32;4981 =D 8/4 A4<4214A233;=2</4A8/4=>>0110=94;<=9849A09?8/288/4 A4<4214A/0@H:>2; C21 42;909? 1& 34; A27 29A 8/4;4D=;4 8/47 2;4 4980854A D=; <=>3491280=9 D;=> 8/4 4>35=74; 29A 8/4 091:;4; =D 8/4 @4/0<54 9 6409? 14;@4A C08/8/49=80<4;413=9A498=23342;4A29A2A>0884A8/28 8/4 A4<4214A C21 /01 4>35=744 29A 526=:;4; 29A /4 251= 2A>0884A8/288/42<<0A498=<<:;;4AA:48=8/494?50?49<4=9 8/4 32;8 =D 8/4 A;0@4; =D 8/4 8;2<8=; 413=9A498 = 91:;29<4=>329723342;4A29A<=984984A8/288/48;2<8=;
C21 091:;4A 6:8 8/4;4 01 @0=5280=9 =D 8/4 84;>1 29A <=9A080=91=D8/43=50<78C21<=9849A4A8/288/4A4<4214A C21 108809? =9 8/4 49?094 =D 8/4 8;2<8=; 29A 8/4;4D=;4 08 /2@09? =957 =94 142809? <232<087 8/4 A4<4214A C21 62;;4A D;=>108809?=@4;0829A211:</8/491:;29<4=>329701 9=85026548=3278/4<=>3491280=9
- D84; D;2>09? =D 8/4 233;=3;0284 011:41 8/4 =>>0110=94; ;4<=;A4A 8/4 84180>=97 4@0A49<4 =D ' 29A
- 5 -
G18=C4;4>2;H4A098/44@0A49<4 413=9A498= 4G2>094A08.1=DD0<02521 '29A
G1 8=-C4;4>2;H4A
D84; /42;09? 6=8/ 10A41 8/4 =>>0110=94; /45A 8/28 8/4 A4<4214A C21 108809? 09 8/48;=5547 6:89=8 =9 8/4 49?094=D8/48;2<8=;29A8/4;4D=;48/491:;29<4=>3297 01 502654 8= 327 8/4 <=>3491280=9 29A 2C2;A4A 1:> =D 1JJ ?20918 C/0</ 8/4 91:;29<4 =>3297 01 64D=;4018/01=:;8
42;94A <=:9145 23342;09? D=; 8/4 233455298 91:;29<4 =>3297 1:6>081 8/28 8/4 D:;8/4; 18284>498 =D 348080=94; = 64D=;4 8/4 9@4180?2809? DD0<4; C/0</ 01 3;=A:<4A28
GC=:5A1/=C8/288/4A4<4214AC21108809? 678/410A4=D8/4A;0@4;=98/449?094=D8/48;2<8=;25=9?
C08/ 8C= =8/4;1 /4 91:;29<4 =>3297 01 9=8 502654 8= <=@4; 1:</ 34;1=91 C/= C4;4 9=8 34;>0884A 8= 108 =9 8/4 8;2<8=;
/4 142809? <232<087 21 34; 8/4 3=50<7 A=<:>498 6409?E,8/4A4<4214AC2162;;4AD;=>108809?=@4;0829A 8/4;4D=;4 8/4;4 01 D:9A2>49825 6;42</ =D 8/4 3=50<7 <=9A080=91 /01 2134<8 /21 9=8 6449 <=910A4;4A 67 8/4
- 6 -
=>>0110=94; 29A 8/4;4D=;4 /4 144H1 09A:5?49<4 =D 8/01 =:;8 8 01 1:6>0884A 8/28 8/4 =>>0110=94; /21 9=8 A01<:114A2978/09?26=:88/4<=984981=D
G29A<=984981 =D8/4</2;?41/448
/4 34;:125 =D 8/4 ;4<=;A1 =D 8/4 =>>0110=94;
C=:5A1/=C8/28098/4<=>35209867348080=94;'28
G >4980=94A 8/28 8/4 A4<4214A /0@H:>2; C21 8/4 108809? =9 8/48;=5547 /4<=>352098C21D054A=929A0801 :9A4; 8/4 10?928:;4 =D ' 9 8/4 <;=114G2>09280=9 =D '0801450<084A67;413=9A498=8/282D84;;42A09?8/4 <=984981=D
G/4/2A3:8/0110?928:;4
:614F:49857=9 0823342;18/288/4 9@4180?2809?DD0<4;/2A;4<=;A4AD:;8/4;18284>498=D' 2134;
G!214A=98/4120AD:;8/4;18284>498</2;?4 1/448<2>48=64D054A2134;
GC/4;4090801>4980=94A 8/28 8/4 A4<4214A/0@H:>2; C21 108809? =9 8/4 49?094 67 8/410A4=D8/4A;0@4;29A/4D455A=C929A1:182094A09B:;041 ;41:5809?09/01A428/801;454@2988=9=848/28098/4<;=11 4G2>09280=9 =D 8/4 ' /4 /21 A4904A 8/28 /4 /2A ?0@49
- 7 -
297 D:;8/4; 18284>498 8= 8/4 9@4180?2809? DD0<4;
/4;4D=;4 09 8/4 <;=114G2>09280=9 ' /2@09? A4904A /01 D:;8/4; 18284>498 8/4;4 01 >284;025 8= 1/=C 8/28 8/4 9@4180?2809?DD0<4;019=8B:180D04A09;45709?=98/4D:;8/4;
18284>498 =D '
G<438 8/414 3=50<4 3234;1 9= =8/4;
A=<:>4981 2;4 2@2052654 64D=;4 8/01=:;8 8=1/=C 8/288/4 A4<4214AC21108809?=98/449?094678/410A4=D8/4A;0@4;
/4
G29A8/4</2;?41/448182848/288/4A4<4214AC21 108809? =9 8/4 49?094 /2@4 6449 A4904A 67 ' 08 01 9=8 H9=C9/=C8/49@4180?2809?DD0<4;<2>48=8/4<=9<5:10=9 8/28/4C212108809?=98/449?094
/4 84180>=97 =D 8/4 ' C/= 01 29 =DD0<025 =D 8/491:;29<4=>3297352<41;45029<4=98/43=50<43234;1 =957 4 A=41 9=8 /2@4 297 D0;18 /29A 09D=;>280=9 21 8= C/48/4; 8/4 A4<4214A C21 108809? =9 8/4 8;2<8=; =; =9 8/4 8;=5547 9A4; 8/414 <0;<:>1829<41 4@49 8/=:?/ 8/4 =>>0110=94;A= 9=8A01<:112978/09?26=:88/4
G29A 8/4 </2;?41/448 8/4 <=9<5:10=91 =D 8/4 =>>0110=94;
<299=8 64 D2:584A C08/ /4 =>>0110=94; C21 B:180D04A 09 /=5A09?8/288/4A4<4214AC218;2@4509?098/48;=5547=D8/4
- 8 -
8;2<8=;6:89=8=98/449?094=D8/48;2<8=;98/28@04C=D 8/4 >2884; 8/4 233425 01 64;4D8 =D 297 >4;081 /4;4D=;4 8/4 12>4 01 502654 8= 64 A01>0114A 29A 08 01 2<<=;A09?57 A01>0114A
A &
$ ' $
! 018=%5=%-
%