Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11464 (KAR)
BALAJI S/O SRIRANG NALBALE v. THE STATE THROUGH BHALKI RURAL POLICE STATION,
CRL.A/200207/2022 · 2025-01-22
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11464 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11464 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$! %
#$!! $"" &'&(")*
&)
+
! "
#
$
$
%
$ &
$ '(
! #
"
&
$()!# &
&
*"
$"
+
$
& $" ''
'',
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" & &
$"
%
$
" -
" $
$$
-
" $
!$
! -
" $
#
./011234567.289:;/872<388=02</0</>2872<3?3/:07 7.2 @=<?A2:7 9B 89:;/87/9: 3:< 9><2> 9B 02:72:82 <372< '' 13002< /: 9'', 56 7.2 <<4 /07>/87 3:< 200/9:0 =<?2 /<3> !.2>2/:3B72> >2B2>>2< 79 30 7.2 -423>:2<200/9:0=<?2-#C.2>2567.2423>:2<200/9:0=<?2 89:;/872< 7.2 3112443:7388=02< B9> 7.2 9BB2:820 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9:0 DE 3:< (' 9B 3:< 02:72:82< ./A 79 =:<2>?9/A142/A1>/09:A2:7B9>312>/9<9B9:2623>3:<79 1363B/:29B 0'''E/:<2B3=479B136A2:79BB/:2.20.344 =:<2>?90/A142/A1>/09:A2:7B9>312>/9<9B9:2A9:7.B9>7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: DE 9B &=>7.2> 7.2 388=02< /0 02:72:82< 79 =:<2>?9 /A1>/09:A2:7 B9> 4/B2 !>2A/:<2>4/B29B7.2388=02<#B9>7.29BB2:821=:/0.3542=:<2> 287/9: (' 9B 3:< 0.344 136 3 B/:2 9B 0''' 7 /0
- 3 -
B=>7.2></>2872<7.370=5073:7/;202:72:82013002<3?3/:077.2 388=02<0.344>=:89:8=>>2:746
.235>/<?2<B38709B7.283023>230B9449C0 .2<282302<E"=F73G.3?/>37//:7.2/:073:78302C30 7.2C/B29B388=02<7.2/>A3>>/3?2C300942A:/H2<0/IA9:7.0 1>/9> 79 ''D' /2 7.2 <372 9B /:8/<2:7 B72> 7.2/> A3>>/3?2 7.2 3112443:7388=02< 1.60/83446 3:< A2:73446 35=02<.2>C9A9:7.0/:797.2A3>>/3?27.2388=02<073>72< 89:0=A/:?3489.943:<3003=472<./0C/B2B9>:9>2309:?3/:07 7./0538F<>919:''D'37359=7')''1A7.2388=02< >27=>:2< .9A2 /:25>/372< 3:< ;2>53446 35=02< 7.2 <282302< %.2: 0.2 89:B>9:72< .2> .=053:< 9: ./0 >2?=43> 3489.94 89:0=A17/9: 3:< B=>7.2> 89:;262< 7.37 0.2 C9=4< J=/7 .2> 0.3>29BB/:3:8/34300/073:8279./A300.2B9=:</7</BB/8=4779 >=:7.2B3A/462:>3?2<567./07.2388=02<9:823?3/:35=02< 3:< 7.>2372:2< 79 F/44 .2> &9449C/:? 7.2 >9C 7.2 388=02< 19=>2<F2>902:23:<027.2>3543H2C/7.7.23/<9B38./A:26 43A1%.2:0.28>/2<B9>.241.2>A97.2>E/:E43C %83A2 79 .2> >208=2 7 7.37 7/A2 7.2 388=02< B42< 7.2 0197 =502J=2:746 7.2 <282302<E"=F73 72421.9:2< .2> 5>97.2>E/:E 43C %) 3:< </;=4?2< 79 ./A 359=7 7.2 /:8/<2:7
- 4 -
AA2</37246 %)>=0.2<797.201973:<3<A/772<.2>797.2 .901/734/:3:3A5=43:82889></:?460.2C303<A/772<303:
/:137/2:7 /: 9;2>:A2:7 901/734 .34F/ 3:< C30 7>2372< 56 9879>E %' :7.203A2<36/29:''D'5302<9:
"2</89E2?34 302 7.2 E %( 9B 7.2 >2019:<2:7E 94/82 1>9822<2< 79 7.2 9;2>:A2:7 901/734 3:< >289><2< 7.2 07372A2:7 9B 7.2 /:@=>2< "=F73 : 7.2 07>2:?7. 9B 7.2 03/< 07372A2:7 .2 >2?/072>2< 3 8302 3?3/:07 7.2 388=02< B9> 7.2 9BB2:820 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9:0 DE 3:< (') 9B /: >/A29D('<372<''D'=502J=2:7463B72>7C9 <3607.2/:@=>2<"=F73C30>2498372<7937=>"3.3>30.7>3B9> ./?.2>7>237A2:73:<C.2>20.20=>;/;2<B9>359=7<3603:< 7.2: 0=88=A52< 79 7.2 /:@=>/20 9: 'D' 889></:?46 5302< 9: 7.2 <237. >219>7 9B 7.2 <282302< "=F73 %( 0=5A/772< 3 >2J=/0/7/9: 52B9>2 7.2 @=>/0</87/9:34 "3?/07>372 79 /:;9F2 287/9: (' 9B 3:< 3889></:?46 12>A/00/9: C30 3889><2< 56 7.2 423>:2< "3?/07>372 79 /:;9F2 287/9: (' 9B /:>/A29D('.2>23B72>7.2:;207/?37/:? BB/82> 89:<=872< 7.2 /:;207/?37/9: 56 <>3C/:?
A3.3H3>0 4/F2 0197 13:8.3:3A3 3:< 02/H2< " 3:< " 3:< 3409 89:<=872< /:J=207 13:8.3:3A3 9: 7.2 89>102 9B 7.2 <282302< :
- 5 -
>289></:?7.207372A2:79B7.2C/7:200208.3>?20.227C3043/< 52B9>27.289AA/77349=>7B9>7.23B9>2A2:7/9:2<9BB2:820
( B72> 89AA/7734 9B 7.2 8302 52B9>2 7.2 200/9:0 9=>77.2423>:2<200/9:0=<?2B>3A2<8.3>?203?3/:077.2 388=02< B9> 7.2 03/< 9BB2:820 3:< 7.2 03A2 C30 >23< 9;2> ;2>537/A 79 7.2 388=02< C./8. .2 <2:/2< 3:< 843/A2< 79 52 7>/2<
: 9><2> 79 1>9;2 7.2 8.3>?20 42;2442< 3?3/:07 7.2 388=02< 7.2 >9028=7/9: 2I3A/:2< /: 79734 C/7:20020 30 %79 %A3>F2<,<98=A2:7030
I0 79 ,3:< /<2:7/B/2<A372>/3495@287030" 79"
&9449C/:? 7.2 89A1427/9: 9B 1>9028=7/9: 2;/<2:82 7.2423>:2<200/9:0=<?2>23<9;2>7.2/:8>/A/:37/:?19>7/9:
9B 7.2 A372>/34 C/7:20020 79 7.2 388=02< 30 07/1=4372< =:<2> 287/9:((9B> C./8.C30<2:/2<56 7.2388=02<.2 <2B2:82 9B 7.2 388=02< /0 9B 79734 <2:/34 3:< 7.37 9B B3402 /A14/837/9:9C2;2>.2:2/7.2>2I3A/:2<3:6C/7:2009:./0 52.34B:9>?97A3>F2<3:6<98=A2:700=119>7/:?./08302
, &9449C/:?7.2300200A2:79B9>343:<<98=A2:73>6 2;/<2:82 14382< 52B9>2 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 7.2 423>:2<
- 6 -
200/9:0=<?289:;/872<7.23112443:7388=02<B9>7.28.3>?20 42;2442< 3?3/:07 ./A 3:< 02:72:82< ./A 30 07372< 0=1>3 .2 03/<@=<?A2:79B89:;/87/9:3:<9><2>9B02:72:82/08.3442:?2< /:7./0311234
) %2 .3;2 .23>< 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 >/ />/0. " 37/4 B9> 3112443:7 3:< 7.2 423>:2< <</7/9:34 7372 =54/8 >9028=79>>//<<34/:? 37/4B9>7.2>2019:<2:7E7372%2 .3;2340912>=02<7.2>289><0A3<23;3/4354252B9>2=0
.2 1>/A3>6 89:72:7/9: 9B 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 B9> 7.2 3112443:7 /0 7.37 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 2>>2< C./42 89:;/87/:? 7.2 388=02< B9> 7.2 8.3>?20 42;2442< 3?3/:07 ./A C/7.9=7 311>28/37/:? 7.2 2;/<2:82 /: >/?.7 12>01287/;2 2 B=>7.2> 89:72:<2< 7.37 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 89:;/872< 7.2388=02<0942465302<9:
I /27.21=>19>72<07372A2:7 ?/;2: 56 7.2 <282302< 52B9>2 %(E 37 7.2 .901/734 9C2;2> 7.2>2 3>2 :9 0=8. 2;/<2:820 B9>7.89A/:? 9: >289>< 7.377.2/:@=>2<C30/:3B/789:</7/9:79A3F20=8.07372A2:7 52B9>2 %( .2 3=7.9> 9B 7.2 03/< 07372A2:7 /2 %( B3/42< 79 9573/: 7.2 B/7:200 82>7/B/8372 B>9A 7.2 <=76 9879> 52B9>2 >289></:? 7.2 03/< 07372A2:7 2:82 3889></:? 79 7.2 423>:2<89=:024A=8.2;/<2:7/3>6;34=283::975237738.2<79
- 7 -
I 2B=>7.2>89:72:<2<7.37 %7.2262C/7:200797.2 /:8/<2:779734467=>:2<.907/42797.21>9028=7/9:8302.9=?. 7.2 1>9028=7/9: >24/2< 9: 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B % 79 % 3A9:? 7.2A % 3:< 3>2 7.2 .23>036 C/7:20020 79 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 8302 889></:? 79 7.2A 7.26 423>:7 359=7 7.2 /:8/<2:7 7.>9=?. %) C.9 3<A/772< 7.2 /:@=>2< 79 7.2 .901/734 9C2;2> 3889></:? 79 %) .2 >238.2< 7.2 0197 3B72>7.2/:8/<2:73:<0./B72<7.2/:@=>2<797.2.901/734563:
3A5=43:82 : 0=8.
8/>8=A073:820 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 7.202 C/7:200203>2/:0=BB/8/2:7791>9;27.28.3>?2042;2442<3?3/:07 7.2388=02<
D .2 423>:2< 89=:024 B=>7.2> 89:72:<2< 7.37 7.2>2 3>2 02>/9=0 </08>213:8/20 /: 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B % 79 % 359=7 7.2 A2:734 3:< 1.60/834 .3>300A2:7 A272< 9=7 56 7.2 388=02<797.2<282302<52B9>27.2/:8/<2:7&=>7.2>/:
I E 89A143/:7 /7 C30 2:=A2>372< 7.37 7.2 388=02< 19=>2< F2>902:2 9: 7.2 <282302< C./8. C30 079>2< /: 3 597742 9C2;2> 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 02/H2< 3 14307/8 83: B>9A 7.2 0197 3:< 7.2 03A2 C30 02:7 B9> & 7./0 0=>B3820 <9=57 /: 7.2 ?2:20/09B7.28>/A2.2423>:2<89=:02434090=5A/772<7.37 7.2>2019:<2:7E 94/82B3/42<79A3F23:63772A1779>289><7.2
- 8 -
07372A2:79B7.2;/87/A/:@=>2</:7.2.901/734C.2>20.2C30 3<A/772<B9>./?.2>7>237A2:73737=>B9>312>/9<9B<360 /2 7/44 .2> <237. 9: 'D' : 0=8. 8/>8=A073:820 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 8302 /0 =:>24/3542 3:< =:524/2;3542 2 3409 89:72:<2<7.377.2423>:2<200/9:0=<?22>>2<5602:72:8/:? 7.2388=02<B9>>2A/:<2>9B./04/B27.2>2567.2200/9:09=>7 7>3;2>02< 5269:< 7.2/> @=>/0</87/9: /: 2I2>8/0/:? 19C2> C./42 >2:<2>/:? 7.2 @=<?A2:7 30 7./0 19C2> /0 :97 ;2072< C/7. 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 30 43/< <9C: 56 7.2 9:K542 12I 9=>7 /:
1300/:? 0=8. 3: 9><2> 889></:?46 .2 1>360 79 3449C 7.2 311234560277/:?30/<27.2/A1=?:2<@=<?A2:7
' 472>:37/;246 .2 89:72:<2< 7.37 2;2: 9:
89:0/<2>/:? 7.2 2:7/>2 2;/<2:82 9: >289>< 7./0 8302 0J=3>246 B3440 C/7./: 7.2 3A5/7 9B
I8217/9: 79 287/9: ('' 9B C./8. /0 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: (' 3>7E 9> 9B 30 7.2 2:7/>2 /:8/<2:7 988=>>2< 37 7.2 01=> 9B A9A2:7 C.2: 7.2 388=02< 4907 024BE89:7>94 =19: ?>3;2 3:< 0=<<2: 1>9;9837/9: B9449C/:?7.2>9C527C22:./A3:<7.2<282302<95=77>200 ./03>?=A2:70.2>24/2<9:7.2B9449C/:?@=<?A2:70
!"!!# $%&
- 9 -
'(
)*' % % +,"!"!!-
! . / 0
(
12,12 3!"!!# $%& '(
)*' % % + !"2!"!,-
, 0% 4
5(
",,326# $%& '(
)*' % % +",",21-
. / 78&
11!""!#$%&'(
)9' %%+"13"3!""1-
0 :
' ' / ; $%&
)9' % % +"23"3221-
5( 4< / 0 $%&
)9' % %
3!"!- +
"3"!3!"! 3!"!-
1 ; =
(
/ : %'= =% $%&
)9' % % +>
" 3" 321-
6 0
&
/ :
%&
7 =$%&)9')&
%
;8> ;'%& =
!""",,
!"!,
!!3"3!"!-
2 + /
0%%&
! 3!"-="!!!" '(
)*'?%
" &
/ :
4 : 5
",3!"!, =
! "!"!,'()*'?%-
- 10 -
&
0%8 . @ - 16,"3! = !6"!!"!!'()*'?%-
! 4% ; )(
3!"!
= "6!"! '()*'?%-
,
A7-
,23!"!=""!!"!!')*' ?%-
13!"
;8- = !,",!"! '( )*' )&
%;8>&%%
2B=7/:? 7.2 359;2 0=5A/00/9:0 9B 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 B9> 7.2 3112443:7 >/ /<<34/:? 37/4 7.2 423>:2< <<4 0=5A/772< 7.37 7.2 @=<?A2:7 <920 :97 0=BB2> B>9A 12>;2>0/76 9> /442?34/76 0/:82 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 .30 89:;/872< 7.2 388=02< 3B72> A27/8=49=046 2I3A/:/:? 7.2 2;/<2:823;3/43542 9:>289></:3C244E>2309:2<@=<?A2:72 3409 89:72:<2< 7.37 7.2 1>9028=7/9: .30 14382< 0=BB/8/2:7 A372>/34 79 1>9;2 7.2 8.3>?20 42;2442< 3?3/:07 7.2 388=02< I /0 7.2 89A143/:7 ?/;2: 56 7.2 <282302< .2>024B /: 7.2 .901/734099:3B72>7.2/:8/<2:752B9>2 %(.289:72:709B I 8423>4689>>959>372C/7.7.22;/<2:829B %79 %
"9>29;2> 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B %) C.9 /0 7.2 5>97.2>E/:E43C 9B 7.2<282302<8423>46>2;23407.373B72>7.2/:8/<2:77.2/:@=>2<
- 11 -
83442<./A3:< /:B9>A2<7.377.2388=02<.3<027.2>3543H2 AA2</37246 .2 >=0.2< 79 7.2 0197 C.2>2 0.2 :3>>372< 7.2 /:8/<2:7 79 ./A 3:< .2 3<A/772< .2> 79 7.2 9;2>:A2:7 901/73437.34F/.2>23B72>.2>07372A2:7C30>289><2<56 %(2;2>7.242007.213>2:709B7.2<282302< %3:< %, .3;2 8423>46 <21902< 7.37 7.2 388=02< 3B72> A3>>6/:? 7.2/> <3=?.72>E"=F73 .3>3002< .2> 597. 1.60/83446 3:< A2:73446561438/:?A9:273>6<2A3:<052B9>2.2>79?>37/B6./0 ;/820 889></:? 79 7.2 423>:2< <<4 7.2 /:@=>2< .3< 0=>;/;2< B9> 3 12>/9< 9B <360 3B72> >289></:? 9B
I : 0=8.8/>8=A073:82/783::975203/<7.377.2/:@=>2<C30:97/:
3B/789:</7/9:79?/;207372A2:73012>
I 289:72:<2< 7.37 7.2 A/:9> 89:7>3</87/9:0 /: 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B A372>/34 C/7:20020<9:97?9797.2>9979B7.21>9028=7/9:83022:82 3889></:? 79 ./A 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 .30 >/?.746 89:;/872<7.2388=02<3:<3889></:?46.21>36079</0A/007.2 311234
3;/:?.23><7.2423>:2<89=:024B9>7.2>201287/;2 13>7/20 09 3409 .3;/:? 12>=02< 7.2 2:7/>2 2;/<2:82 3:< 7.2 <98=A2:70 14382< 52B9>2 =0 7.2 19/:70 7.37 3>/02 B9> 9=> 89:0/<2>37/9:3>2
- 12 -
B7
.%& % %(&(C
7
$%& .% ==&
==% = %
' % = ,"! 26+CD
( :7.2/:073:783023452/77.21>9028=7/9:2I3A/:2< C/7:20020791>9;27.28.3>?2042;2442<3?3/:077.2388=02< /7 /0 >2<=:<3:7 79 <24;2 /:79 7.2 :/776 ?>/776 9B /:</;/<=34 2;/<2:82 9B 344 C/7:20020 /7 /0 0=BB/8/2:7 79 311>28/372 7.2 2;/<2:829BA372>/34C/7:20020
: 9><2> 79 1>9;2 7.2 .9A/8/<34 <237. 9B 7.2 <282302< "=F73 /: 7./0 8302 7.2 1>9028=7/9: .30 >24/2< 9:
I ( 7.2 1907A9>72A >219>7 C./8. C30 A3>F2< /: 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 7.2 :;207/?37/:? BB/82> C/7. 89:02:7 9B 7.2 <2B2:82&=>7.2>7.21>9028=7/9:3409>24/2<9:7.22;/<2:829B %'E9879> C.9 /:/7/3446 7>2372< 7.2 /:@=>2< 3:< 7.2 8302 0.227/2
I , :12>=0349B
I (7.21907A9>72A>219>7 7.2 83=02 9B <237.
C30 07372< 30 L0217/82A/8 0.98F <=2 79 5=>:M :12>=0349B
I E,7.283020.22714382<56 %E' 3409A2:7/9:07.377.2<282302<0=073/:2<5=>:/:@=>/20359=7 (N 13>7 B>9A 7.202 A372>/340 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 3409 >24/2<
- 13 -
9: 7.2 /:J=207 13:8.3:3A3 <>3C: 9: 7.2 89>102 9B 7.2 <282302< 30 12>
I 56 % 7.2 :;207/?37/:? BB/82> %)/07.2C/7:200B9>7.203A297. %)3:< %.3;2 /<2:7/B/2< 7.2 5=>: /:@=>/20 9: 7.2 89>102 9B 7.2 <282302< 2;2>7.24200 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 3409 14382<
I 7.2 8302 0.227 9B <282302< A3/:73/:2< 56 7.2 .901/734 37 37=> :
12>=034 9B
I B=>7.2> >2;2342< 7.37 7.2 <282302< C30 7>2372<B9>5=>:/:@=>/20B9>312>/9<9B<3603:<7.2>23B72> 0.2 0=88=A52< : 0=8. 8/>8=A073:820 C2 3>2 9B 7.2 89:0/<2>2<;/2C7.377.21>9028=7/9:.301>9;2<7.2.9A/8/<34 <237. 9 89::287 7.2 388=02< B9> 7.2 .9A/8/<34 <237. 9B 7.2 <282302< 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 1>2<9A/:3:746 >24/2< 9:
I E 7.2 07372A2:7 A3<2 56 7.2 <282302< 099: 3B72> 7.2 /:8/<2:7 /29:''D'52B9>2 %(/:7.29;2>:A2:7901/734 37 .34F/ : 83>2B=4 12>=034 9B
I 7.2 <282302< 07372< 7.37B9449C/:?.2>C2<</:?C/7.7.2388=02<0.2423>:77.377.2 388=02<C303:3<</87C.989:0=A2<4/J=9>9:2;2>6<36530/0 3:<1/8F2<>9CC/7..2><2A3:</:?A9:26 :''D'37 359=7 )'' 1A .2 83A2 79 7.2 .9=02 /:25>/372< 3:< 7.2>23B72>.3<3>9CC/7..2>3:<;2>5344635=02<.2>%.2:
- 14 -
0.23<;/02<./A:9779/:<=4?2/:0=8.38709=79B7.254=2.2 ?>3552<3F2>902:259774219=>2</79:.2>3:<027.2>3543H2 C/:?797./00.20=073/:2<5=>:/:@=>/20 %.2>A97.2>E/:E 43C C30 3: 262EC/7:200 79 7.2 /:8/<2:7 372> 7.2 <282302< /:B9>A2< %)E.2>5>97.2>E/:E43C9;2>31.9:28344359=77.2 /:8/<2:7 /: 7=>: .2 ;/0/72< 7.2 .9=02 3:< 3<A/772< .2> 79 3 9;2>:A2:7 901/734 .9=?. 7.2 03/< 07372A2:7 9B 7.2 <282302<C30>289><2<56 %(C/7.9=79573/:/:?7.2B/7:200 82>7/B/8372 B>9A 7.2 <=76 9879> :2;2>7.24200 %( .30 <21902<7.370.2C30;2>6A=8.89:08/9=03:</:34=8/<07372 9B A/:< C./42 :3>>37/:? 7.2 /:8/<2:7 &=>7.2> /7 89=4< 52 ?37.2>2< B>9A 7.2 >289><0 7.37 7.2 <282302< .3< 0=073/:2< (N5=>:/:@=>/203:<7.370.2C3089:08/9=07/012>7/:2:779 A2:7/9:7.377.22;/<2:829B %(>2;23407.37.29573/:2< 7.212>A/00/9:B>9A7.2<=769879>79>289><
I
, &=>7.2>7.289:72:709B
I E8423>4689>>959>3720 C/7. 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B %E) C.9 3<A/772< 7.2 /:@=>2< 79 7.2 .901/734889></:?79./A/AA2</372463B72>7.2/:8/<2:7.2 ;/0/72< 7.2 .9=02 3:< 7.2 /:@=>2< /:B9>A2< ./A 359=7 7.2 387 12>127>372< 56 7.2 388=02< .2 :3>>37/9: 9B /:8/<2:7 56 7.2 /:@=>2< 79 %) 3:< %0 , 3:< C.9 .3;2 ;/0/72< 7.2
- 15 -
.901/734 9: 7.2 03A2 :/?.7 37 359=7 '' 3A 8423>46 89>>959>3720C/7.7.289:72:709B
I %0,3:<.3;2 8372?9>/83446<21902</:7.2/>2;/<2:827.37/:7.2.901/7347.2 <282302< /:B9>A2< 7.2A 359=7 7.2 .3>300A2:7 A272< 9=7 56 7.2 388=02< 3:< 3409 359=7 7.2 /:8/<2:7 9: ''D' &=>7.2> 3889></:? 79 7.2A 7.2 /:@=>2< C30 ;2>6 A=8.
79 7.2A 7.2 /:@=>2< C30 ;2>6 A=8. 89:08/9=0 37 7.2 7/A2 "9>29;2> % 79 % .3;2 3409 <21902< 7.37 2;2> 0/:82 7.2 <282302< C30 A3>>/2< 79 7.2 388=02<7.2388=02<.3>3002<.2>1.60/834463:<A2:7344656 <2A3:</:?A9:26
) 7/0;2.2A2:7463>?=2<567.2423>:2<89=:024B9> 7.2 3112443:7 7.37 7.2 1>9028=7/9: .30 B3/42< 79 14382 3:6 A372>/34 2;/<2:82 79 207354/0. 7.37 7.2 ;/87/A C30 /: 3 4=8/< 07372 79 ?/;2 07372A2:7 30 12>
I 3:< 3409 79 A3F2 9>34 07372A2:70 52B9>2 % 79 % : 12>=034 9B 2;/<2:82 9B %( 7.2 08>/52 9B
I /7 >2;2340 7.37 7.2 /:@=>2< C30 89:08/9=0 37 7.2 7/A2 9B <2190/:? .2> 07372A2:7 3:< .2 3409 799F 12>A/00/9: B>9A 7.2 9879> 79 >289>< 0=8. 07372A2:7 <A/772<46 7.2 <282302< .3< 0=88=A52< 79 7.2 /:@=>/20 3B72> '<360B>9A7.2<3729B/:8/<2:7:0=8.8/>8=A073:8207.2>2
- 16 -
/0 :9 >2309: 79 <9=57 7.2 8>2</5/4/76 9B 7.2 <282302<K0 07372A2:73:<3409.2>9>3407372A2:7079 %079
%2 3>2 3C3>2 9B 7.2 190/7/9: 9B 43C 7.37 /B 89:;/87/9: /0 5302< 9: <6/:? <2843>37/9: 9B 7.2 <282302< 7.2 03A2.307952311>28/372<C/7.<=283>2.2@=</8/347.29>6 >2?3></:? 7.2 38821735/4/76 9B 3 <6/:? <2843>37/9: /0 7.37 0=8. <2843>37/9: /0 A3<2 /: 2I7>2A/76 C.2: 7.2 13>76 /0 37 7.2 A9=7.9B<237.C.2>22;2>6.9129B7./0C9>4</0C3:/:?3:< C.2:2;2>6A97/;279B3402.99</00/42:82<7.2A3:/0/:<=82< 56 7.2 A907 19C2>B=4 89:0/<2>37/9: 79 0123F 7>=7. 349:2 97C/7.073:</:?7.203A2?>23783=7/9:A=07522I2>8/02</: 89:0/<2>/:?3:<3<<=8/:?C2/?.73?2790=8.<2843>37/9:0.2 9:K542 12I 9=>7 /: 7.2 8302 9B
.24</:13>3?>31.9(30=:<2>
B:
.%=
(&&=='( (&=
%=
= ?(><
( <
(
< &> < (
=> %= '(
<% = 8 (
% <
&
> &=%%'?==& <&
' &
= = ==%
?= ( ==%= <
=
(=
%
:
%<
=
!""!-1"
- 17 -
'> < ==
=( +
E% =?
< =
==%
< = ?>
=%
(& =
%'%=
% % ==
=% %
% == :
=%>
<
<( ' &%
= <%
%&& %= & :
=% % %
=
=< %( ' ( (>
>
=% (<
=< =8
(&=8 %
=
% <
(<
= < ==% 8
=> =<>=' =
==
= => (& = ==' (& = = ' <& ( E%
=%= <
'( <'(&
<<%= = + =>
<> %=
( '
% %= <& '( 8 & = = = 7
=>
=( = & '%( =(>
%&
% %
=( %%=&>'=& '% :
E% <
(& = % =('&<
%= = '( & = %(
%= =& E%(> <
% <& ' =
%=
=( = ==%= =
- 18 -
=%=7
(E% <
=(&=%' = < 7
'(
( &
= < 8 <
%?'(
= = = ' = % =%%(
'%( %
%=='(
=( % =%
%( %
%%
=='' <D
D :12>=0349B7.2B/:</:?09B7.29:K54212I9=>7 /: 7.2 359;2 @=<?A2:7 3 82>7/B/837/9: 56 7.2 9879> C./42 >289></:? 7.2 07372A2:7 9B /:@=>2< /0 2002:7/3446 3 >=42 9B 83=7/9:3:<7.2>2B9>27.2;94=:73>63:<7>=7.B=4</0190/7/9:9B 7.2<2843>37/9:83:52207354/0.2<97.2>C/02"9>29;2>7.2>2 /0 :9 0=8. .3>< 3:< B307 >=42 7.37 C./42 >289></:? 7.2 <2843>37/9: 9B 2/7.2> 7.2 <282302< 9> /:@=>2< 7.2 03/< 07372A2:7A=0752>289><2<567.2"3?/07>3729>3.0/4<3>3:< 7.29879>A=07521>202:7377.377/A2:7.283029:.3:< 30 07372< % 7.2 07372A2:7 9B 7.2 /:@=>2< C30 >289><2< 099:3B72>7.2/:8/<2:73:<7.2>2/0:90=8.8.3:829B7=79>/:? 7.2/:@=>2<563:69B7.2C/7:200209>567.2 94/822:827.2 3012877.37.30795259>:2/:A/:</0C.27.2>7.2/:@=>2<C30 89:08/9=0377.27/A29BA3F/:?0=8.3<2843>37/9:
- 19 -
' :7.283029:.3:<9:12>=0349B7.289:72:709B I 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B %( 3:< 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B % 79 % 3:<
I /2 7.2 8302 0.227 A3/:73/:2< 56 7.2 .901/7343=7.9>/7/207/447.2<237.9B7.2/:@=>2<C23>29B7.2 ;/2C7.377.2/:@=>2<C3089:08/9=03:</:34=8/<07372377.2 7/A29BA3F/:?7.2<2843>37/9:E
I
2;2>7.24200 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B % 79 % 3409 89>>959>372 C/7. 7.2 89:72:70 9B
I .9=?. 7.2 <2B2:82 8>900E2I3A/:2< 7.202C/7:200203742:?7.:97./:?C9>7.C./42 C30 24/8/72< B>9A 7.2A 79 </083>< 7.2/> 7207/A9:6
;2:
97.2>C/02 7.2 <2B2:82 .30 B3/42< 79 1=7 B9>7. 3:6 <2B2:82 79 1>9;2 7.2 >2309: B9> B3402 /A14/837/9: 9B 7.2 388=02< <A/772<46 7.2 /:8/<2:7 988=>>2< 37 7.2 A37>/A9:/34 .9=02 9B 7.2<282302<.2388=02<52/:?7.2.=053:</0<=7659=:<79 2I143/: 3:< 3<<=82 >2309:0 B9> 7.2 .9A/8/<34 <237.
9B 7.2 <282302< /: ./0 .9=02 0/:82 7.2 03/< 301287 /0 C/7./: ./0 F:9C42<?2 2I84=0/;246 30 07/1=4372< =:<2> 287/9: ', 9B 7.2 :</3:
;/<2:82 87 .9=4< 7.2 388=02< B3/4 79 300/?: 3:6 0=8.89.2>2:72I143:37/9:7.29=>783:1>20=A27.2388=02< 30 12>127>379> 30 12> 7.2 1>9;/0/9:0 07/1=4372< =:<2> 287/9:
9B7.2:</3:
;/<2:8287
- 20 -
: 7.2 /:073:7 8302 7.2 <2B2:82 9B 7.2 388=02< /0 7.377.2<282302<.3<3:2I7>3A3>/7343BB3/>C/7. %)C.9/0 :9:2 97.2> 7.3: .2> 5>97.2>E/:E43C %.2: 7.2 388=02< 89:B>9:72<C/7.7.2<282302<0.289AA/772<0=/8/<25619=>/:? F2>902:23:<0277/:?.2>024B3543H29C2;2>791>9;27.203/< <2B2:82 7.2 388=02< .30 :97 2I3A/:2< 3:6 C/7:200 2;2>7.24200 % 52/:? 7.2 C/B2 9B %) 8372?9>/83446 <2:/2< 0=8. 3442?37/9:0 56 7.2 388=02< : 12>=034 9B 7.2 2;/<2:829B %79 %C23>29B7.289:0/<2>2<;/2C7.37 7.2 <2B2:82 9B 7.2 388=02< /0 :97 1>953542 9:2 30 0=8. .2 B3/42< 79 2I143/: 7.2 8/>8=A073:820 9B 7.2 .9A/8/<34 <237. 9B 7.2<282302</:./0.9=029:7.2B372B=4<36
( 7/0340989:72:<2<567.2423>:2<89=:024B9>7.2 388=02<7.377.2262C/7:200 %7=>:2<.907/42<A/772<46 0.252/:?7.2A97.2>9B388=02<A/?.7.3;27=>:2<.907/4279 0./24<7.2388=02<B>9A7.29BB2:829C2;2>7.37/7024B/0:97 3 ?>9=:< 79 </083>< 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 97.2> A372>/34 C/7:20020 % 79 % &=>7.2> 7.2 A/:9> 89:7>3</87/9:0 /: 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B A372>/34 C/7:20020 <9 :97 ?9 79 7.2 >997 9B 7.2 1>9028=7/9:8302
- 21 -
.29:K54212I9=>7/:7.283029B
.30 .24< 7.37 7.2 A/:9> 89:7>3</87/9:0/:7.22;/<2:829BA372>/34C/7:20020/7024B/0:97 3?>9=:<79</083><7.2/>7207/A9:6&=>7.2>7.29:K54212I 9=>7 .24< 7.37 C./42 311>28/37/:? 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 3 C/7:200 7.2 311>938. A=07 52 79 300200 C.27.2> 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 3 C/7:200 >23< 30 3 C.942 31123>0 79 52 7>=7.B=4 :82 7.2 /A1>200/9:/0B9>A2</7/0:282003>6B9>7.289=>7792;34=372 7.22;/<2:823:<7.23442?2<</08>213:8/203:<7.2:79B/:<9=7 C.27.2>/7/03?3/:077.2?2:2>3472:9>9B7.21>9028=7/9:8302 B 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 262 C/7:200 /0 B9=:< 79 52 8>2</542 3:< 7>=07C9>7.6A/:9></08>213:8/20C./8.<9:973BB2877.289>29B 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 8302 83::97 52 A3<2 3 ?>9=:< 79 <9=57 7.2 7>=07C9>7./:2009B7.2C/7:200
&=>7.2>/7/0340989:72:<2<567.2423>:2<89=:024 B9>7.23112443:77.37 %79 %3>27.284902>2437/;209B 7.2 <282302< 7.26 3>2 7.2 13>7/03: C/7:20020 79 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 8302 30 0=8. 7.2/> 2;/<2:82 83::97 52 >24/2< 79 89:;/87 7.2 388=02< 9C2;2> 7.2 9:K542 12I 9=>7 /: 7.2
!!"2-6, 2
- 22 -
8302 9B
! (.24</:13>3?>31.9)30=:<2>
F"B+=
E%( E%(
<
G% & ! .%&> B < '& = &% %&
.= 3 ( 0=
= .= BD BD<(%.%= :
=B%%>%'%D &=D
, 012>7.2B/:</:?09B7.29:K54212I9=>7/:7.2 359;2 8302 /7 /0 8423> 7.37 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 7.2 A372>/34 C/7:2002083::9752</083><2<A2>2469:7.2?>9=:<7.377.26 3>2>2437/;209B7.2<282302<
) :0=8.8/>8=A073:8209:9;2>344>2E311>28/37/9:9B 7.22;/<2:823;3/435429:>289><C23>29B7.289:0/<2>2<;/2C 7.377.21>9028=7/9:.301>9;2<7.2388=02<307.212>127>379> 9B 7.2 8>/A2 3:< .2 /0 >2019:0/542 B9> 7.2 .9A/8/<34 <237. 9B 7.2<282302<
9A/:?797.23472>:37/;20=5A/00/9:567.2423>:2< 89=:024B9>7.23112443:77.377./08302B3440C/7./:7.23A5/79B I8217/9:E 79 287/9: ('' 9B 9: 83>2B=4 12>=034 9B 7.2
,!"!,@@<-!!
- 23 -
2;/<2:823;3/435429:>289></:84=</:? I 7.289A143/:7C30 49<?2< 56 7.2 <282302< .2>024B /7 89=4< 52 022: 7.37 7.2 388=02<52/:?7.2.=053:<C303.35/7=343489.94/83:<9:7.2 B372B=4<36.2>27=>:2<.9A237359=7)''1A/:25>/372<3:< 9=79B7.254=2.21/8F2<3>9C<2A3:</:?A9:267989:0=A2 A9>24/J=9>%.2:7.2<282302<3<;/02<./A79J=/7./0;/820O 2:>3?2<567.203A2.219=>2<F2>902:29:.2>3:<027.2> 3543H2 C/7. 7.2 3/< 9B 3 8./A:26 43A1 %./42 /:72>1>27/:?
9B 7.2<282302<
9A/:?797.23472>:37/;20=5A/00/9:567.2423>:2< 89=:024B9>7.23112443:77.377./08302B3440C/7./:7.23A5/79B I8217/9:E 79 287/9: ('' 9B 9: 83>2B=4 12>=034 9B 7.2
,!"!,@@<-!! - 23 -
2;/<2:823;3/435429:>289></:84=</:? I 7.289A143/:7C30 49<?2< 56 7.2 <282302< .2>024B /7 89=4< 52 022: 7.37 7.2 388=02<52/:?7.2.=053:<C303.35/7=343489.94/83:<9:7.2 B372B=4<36.2>27=>:2<.9A237359=7)''1A/:25>/372<3:< 9=79B7.254=2.21/8F2<3>9C<2A3:</:?A9:267989:0=A2 A9>24/J=9>%.2:7.2<282302<3<;/02<./A79J=/7./0;/820O 2:>3?2<567.203A2.219=>2<F2>902:29:.2>3:<027.2> 3543H2 C/7. 7.2 3/< 9B 3 8./A:26 43A1 %./42 /:72>1>27/:? I8217/9: 79 287/9: ('' 9B 7.2 9:-542 12I 9=>7 /: 7.2 8302 9B #$%&$$ '($$ & )$)* + ,--$)( .$->219>72</:/ ,, ,011.24</: 13>3?>31.90D'3:<(30=:<2> F2 )<> % > = < % H?= = ,"" +6 &< 8 7,-> (%& ' => =%E%(8 = >'(=< (>% 'E%< 8% % 7-> & '% > ( =<= = < 5 89 = = > < ?( '% = '( 4 76-> < &< 8 7,-> ;% 8 72-> ;% 0 % 8 7"-> = 5 8 : =% % - 24 - => % = < 2 H?= H?= = ,"" +2 H?= < %&%=> > < => =% < & = H?= < > ==% = % & %=>=% ( '(8 ==H?= < = = < % > % & % % E% = =%' = < % & 8 %% & =& =% %%% : H?H?= %= =< = (& == % " +& H?= = ,"";0 0 >" % =< = ' ?='8- = % & = ==%#'- =%'&#=- = % ' %# - > '( => % ' < =# - % 8 =%& =%= < =# - % =% < & = ( '( 8 == G & < = ( <=> ' ' %%%( ?=' %&=% % G% > % ' = < < %= < =;0 %-%===('I - 25 - B6 + ( ' = = B& %D =C '= '='<7 ' < = ==%= % =%> > <( > % =# > =%%> = '=8&% =( < = ==% '& + % =%( =&%&& < & =J + ' '(<(< =I =%= = => & & ==%= + =( = = < '= ==%<% = ( (< <= = =(< > < = ==% & = 8 %.'( 6 : + <> E%(> ( ' % I - : B& %D = < ' > '&& = =( ==%> = % < = ==% < =<%'8 =!-++>< &% ( > % = ==%=>=%&% = ==% '& = < G H?= - 26 - =,"" >6" ,- : '=8&% = '( % = = ( ' 8==& < %'E% = =% & % = =& = - : '< % ' =( = %= & = = < '( > < && = ==%D !: E%='(& %=E%== ==>%'=% ': <= &= < &< ==8 %H?==,"" +G> < < & = ==% & = = =(> % '
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
I8217/9:9C2;2>79 </08.3>?2 ./0 5=><2: 7.2 388=02< A36 >246 =19: 7.2 8302 9B 7.21>9028=7/9:3:<7.22;/<2:823<<=82<567.21>9028=7/9:/: 7.29=>7
(' 7 /0 /: 7./0 89:72I7 C2 C9=4< >2B2> 79 7.2 8302 9B 7.2 1>9028=7/9: : 7.2 8302 9: .3:< 30 </08=002< 0=1>3 56 12>=034 9B 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B %0 79 7.2 C/7:20020 52B9>2 C.9A7.2<282302<<21902<359=7/:8/<2:77.379:7.2B372B=4 <36 7.2 388=02< 83A2 79 .9=02 56 89:0=A/:? 3489.94 3:< 1/8F2<=1 3>9CC/7..2>%.2:0.2>20/072<./A 563<;/0/:?
./A 7.2 /:8/<2:7 83=02< 0=<<2:46 9: 3 01=> 9B A9A2:7 .2 388=02< :2/7.2> .3< /:72:7 :9> F:9C42<?2 79 A=><2> 7.2 <282302<.203A2/0?37.2>2<5612>=0349BA2</834>219>70 9B 7.2 /:@=>2< C.2>2 /7 /0 2:=A2>372< 7.37 7.2 /:@=>2< .3<
- 29 -
0=073/:2<(N9B5=>:/:@=>/203:<0.20=>;/;2<8944287/;246B9> 312>/9<9B'<360&/:34460.20=88=A52<<=2790217/82A/3 /: 7.2 9;2>:A2:7 901/734 :2 9B 7.2 >2309:0 89=4< 52 ?37.2>2<7.37438F9B1>912>A2</83483>2A/?.7.3;2>20=472< /: .2> <2A/02 :
0=8. 8/>8=A073:820 C2 .94< 7.37 3112443:7388=02< 12>127>372< 7.2 8>/A2 9=7 9B 7.2 54=2 =19:
0=<<2: 1>9;9837/9: 3:< 9C/:? 79 4900 9B 024BE89:7>94 9: 3:
3889=:7 9B L049C 5=>: >2387/9: B9449C2< 56 7.2 B/:34 3:< /AA2</372 1>9;9837/9:M 1146/:? 7.2 1>9;9837/9:
I8217/9:
C2 89:;2>7 7.2 89:;/87/9: 9B 3112443:7 B>9A 287/9: (' 79 287/9:(' 3>79B
( .2 9:-542 12I 9=>7 /: 7.2 8302 9B
$3 45344$ >219>72</: !D))#.24<7.37/:843=02!(#9B287/9:
('' /:0723< 9B 7.2 C9><0 L4/F246 79 83=02 <237.M 988=>>/:? /:
7.2 89>>2019:</:? 843=02 !5# 9B 287/9: DD 7.2 C9><0 L0=BB/8/2:7 /: 7.2 9></:3>6 89=>02 9B :37=>2M .3;2 522: =02< 5;/9=0467.2</07/:87/9:4/20527C22:359</46/:@=>64/F24679 83=02<237.3:<359</46/:@=>60=BB/8/2:7/:7.29></:3>689=>02 9B:37=>27983=02<237..2</07/:87/9:/0B/:25=7>2343:</B 9;2>499F2<A36>20=47/:A/083>>/3?29B@=07/82.2</BB2>2:82
- 30 -
527C22: 843=02 !5# 9B 287/9: DD 3:< 843=02 !(# 9B 287/9: (''/09:29B7.2<2?>2209B1>9535/4/769B<237.>20=47/:?B>9A 7.2 /:72:<2< 59</46 /:@=>6 9 1=7 /7 A9>2 5>93<46 /7 /0 7.2 <2?>22 9B 1>9535/4/76 9B <237. C./8. <272>A/:20 C.27.2> 3 8=413542 .9A/8/<2 /0 9B 7.2 ?>3;207 A2</=A 9> 7.2 49C207 <2?>22.2C9><L4/F246M/:843=02!5#9B287/9:DD89:;260 7.2 02:02 9B L1>953542M 30 </07/:?=/0.2< B>9A 3 A2>2 1900/5/4/76.2C9><0L59</46/:@=>60=BB/8/2:7/:7.29></:3>6 89=>029B:37=>27983=02<237.MA23:7.37<237.C/44527.2 LA907 1>953542M >20=47 9B 7.2 /:@=>6 .3;/:? >2?3>< 79 7.2 9></:3>689=>029B:37=>2
( 0 </08=002< 0=1>3 0/:82 7.2 <282302< .3< 0=073/:2< (N 5=>: /:@=>/20 3:< 0=>;/;2< B9> 3 12>/9< 9B ' <360 B9449C/:? 7.2 /:8/<2:7 3:< 7.37 .2> <237. C30 <=2 79 0217/82A/3 /:B2>2:82 89=4< 52 ?37.2>2< 7.37 7.2 <2?>22 9B 1>9535/4/769B<237.C3049C2073:<7.23879B7.2388=02<B3440 C/7./:7.23A5/79B
I8217/9:79287/9:(''9B C./8.
/01=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:(' 3>79B
(( 9C2;2> 7.2 02:72:82 /A1902< 56 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7B9>7.29BB2:821=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:DE9B /0 @=073:<1>912>B9>7.2>2309:0</08=002<%
- 31 -
( : 12>=034 9B 7.2 /A1=?:2< @=<?A2:7 13002< 56 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 89:;/872< 7.2 388=02< B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: (' 9B 3:< 02:72:82< ./A 79 =:<2>?9 4/B2 /A1>/09:A2:7 7/44 ./0 4307 5>237../002:72:82/A1902<567.2423>:2<200/9:0=<?2/0 :97 0=073/:3542 =:<2> 43C 30 12> 7.2 43C 43/< <9C: 56 7.2 9:K542 12I 9=>7 /: 7.2 8302 9B %
( &
6 .24< 7.37 3C3></:? 9B 0128/34 8372?9>6 02:72:82 /: 0=507/7=7/9: 9B <237. 02:72:82 7.37 /0 02:72:82 53>>/:? >2A/00/9: =:<2> > B9> 0128/B/2< 72>A 5269:< 623>0 9> 4/B2 /A1>/09:A2:7 53>>/:? >2A/00/9: B9> >207 9B 4/B2 /0 ;34/< 7 /0 843>/B/2< 7.37 .9C2;2> 19C2> =:<2> >7/8420 ) 3:< , C./8. /0 :97 7.2 03A2 30 7.2 0737=79>6 19C2> 9B >2A/00/9: /0 :97 3BB2872< C3>< 9B :9:E>2A/7734 0128/B/2< 02:72:82 9> 4/B2 /A1>/09:A2:7 53>>/:? >2A/00/9: B9> >207 9B 4/B2 .24< :97 ;/9437/;2 9B 0213>37/9: 9B 19C2>0 =8. 0128/3402:72:82C.2:/A1902<=:<2>0=5073:7/;21>9;/0/9:09B <920 :97 9;2>431 1>982<=>34 19C2> =:<2> > 9: 89:0/<2>/:?8>/A20/7=37/9:/::</3!13>7/8=43>46:2I=0527C22: .3><2:2<8>/A/:3403:</44E?9772:C2347.3:<:37=>29B.2/:9=0 8>/A20 9: 7.2 >/02# <2436 /: </019034 9B 83020 3:< 5343:8/:? !"-1
- 32 -
/:72>2079B;/87/A0C/7.7.9029B89:;/8700=8.0128/348372?9>6 02:72:82 5289A20 /:2;/73542 &=>7.2> /7 C30 .24< 7.37 0=8. 0128/348372?9>602:72:8283:9:4652/:;9F2<56/?.9=>70 9> =1>2A2 9=>7 3:< :97 56 200/9:07>/34 9=>70 : 0=8. 8/>8=A073:820 7.2 03/< 02:72:82 /A1902< 56 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7/0:970=073/:3542=:<2>43C
( &9> 7.2 B9>2?9/:? >2309:0 7.2 311234 13>746 0=8822<03:<C23:0C2>19/:79!/#/:7.2:2?37/;23:<19/:7 9!//# 13>746 /: 7.2 3BB/>A37/;2 3:< 1>9822< 79 1300 7.2 B9449C/:? / .2311234/0
75 // .2@=<?A2:79B89:;/87/9:3:<9><2>9:02:72:82 <372<''13002<567.2<</7/9:34/07>/87 3:<200/9:0=<?237/<3>/:9'',/0 A9</B/2< B>9A 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9:('9B 797.29BB2:821=:/0.3542=:<2> 287/9:(' 3>7E9B /// .2 388=02< /0 02:72:82< B9> 3 12>/9< C./8. .2 .3034>23<6=:<2>?9:2/2D623>0A9:7.0) <360 30 9: 7.2 <372 <</7/9:3446 .2 0.344 136 3 B/:2 9B 0'''''E P =1220 C9 3F. :46Q 52B9>27.2200/9:09=>7/:<2B3=479B136A2:79B
- 33 -
B/:2 .2 0.344 =:<2>?9 0/A142 /A1>/09:A2:7 B9> 3 12>/9< 9B 7C9 623>0 B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2>287/9:(' 3>7E9B /; .2 02:72:82 /A1902< 56 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 B9> 7.29BB2:821=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:DE9B /0F217/:7387 ; : <2190/7/:?
7.2 B/:2 3A9=:7 9> =:<2>?9/:? 7.2 <2B3=47 02:72:82 7.2 3112443:7388=02< 0.344 52 >242302</B.2/0:97>2J=/>2</:3:697.2>8302 ;/ B 7.2 B/:2 3A9=:7 /0 <2190/72< 56 7.2 3112443:7388=02< 52B9>2 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 7.2 423>:2<200/9:0=<?2/0</>2872<79/:7/A3727.2 03A2 79 % 3:< %, 7.2 13>2:70 9B 7.2 <282302< 3:< </05=>02 7.2 03A2 79 7.2A 2J=3446 9:<=2/<2:7/B/837/9:
,*
& %) ! ,*
&! ) ! % /07949(D