- 1 - ! ! "#" $%#!!&! # ! " '% !( !" ! # !" $# % & ' ( ((# # !" ! # (# #(( # # $# %#' Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ( ( !!) ( ( ! ( ( # # ' ### ( "! ( (( # !"* ( # ( # ( ( & &( ( !" ( (( # # # (( #( ' # + ( ## ( ( # (# ,+ # -& & %# -& &' #./0/012.34 53.6.713./804 193/ 02 /804 :30/ ;./0/012 4..<02=713/8.71>>1:02=3.>0.74 - 3 - !"#$%&'()* # +,)% "" " - -+. /0"1 % & /0"1 2 *" # % !1 % !"1 !13 ! * 1 % 4 5 16 ! .53?>.532.?@1924.>713/8.;53/0.4 .532.?@1924.>713/8.;./0/012.34496A0/4/85/ /8.3. 53. @.3/502 @12/35?0@/0124 02 /8. A5/.305>4 7192? 02 /8.@853=.48../70>.?02/8.;3.4.2/@54.819=802/8. 7034/ 02713A5/012 0/ 04 4/5/.? /85/ ?.@.54.? A<53 :81 :54 /8. 412 17 /8. ;./0/012.34 8.3.02 :54 ?30B02= ;. 59/130@<485: 6.5302= 3.=04/35/012 1)!! 12 /8. 5>>.=.? ?5/. 17 /8. 315? /35770@ 5@@0?.2/ /8. 3.C9040/012 =0B.2 6D /8. #1>0@. 96 24;.@/13 17 5?53 5E53 #1>0@. /5/0121>5;93@0/D5853548/35/5/.:19>?=1/1481: - 4 - /85//8.450?59/130@<48:?30B.26DA<5312*!" 85? A./ :0/8 52 5@@0?.2/ :0/8 5 @12/502.3 5/ 19?5> B0>>5=. 17 545B5<>5D52 /5>9<5 . 496A0/4 /85/ ;1>0@. 85B. 21/ ;31;.3>D 02B.4/0=5/.? /8. @54. 52? 85B. .3312.194>D 70>.? 52 565/.? @853=. 48../ 54 5=5024/ ?.@.54.? A<53 8. 7034/ 02713A5/012 04 5>41 496A0//.? 6D 5 8.5345D :0/2.44 :81 04 /8. @>14. 3.>5/0B. 17 ?.@.54.?2/8..B.2//8.;35D.34A5?.02/8.;./0/012 53. 21/ =352/.? ;./0/012.34 :81 53. /8. ;53.2/4 17 /8. ?.@.54.?:81:54/8.12>D41217/8.;./0/012.34:0>>6. ;9//1033.;5356>.853?480;@@13?02=>D8.;35D4/15>>1: /8.:30/;./0/012 #.3 @12/35 >.532.? 0=8 193/ 1B.32A.2/ #>.5?.3 854 1;;14.? /8. :30/ ;./0/012 8. 496A0/4 /85/ /8. A5/.305> 12 :80@8 3.>052@. 854 6..2 ;>5@.? 6D /8. ;./0/012.340421/3.>5/02=/1/8.02B.4/0=5/012?12.02/8. ;3.4.2/ @54. 8. 450? 3.C9040/012 04 =0B.2 6D /8. #1>0@. 9624;.@/13175?535E53#1>0@./5/0125853548/35 /5/.12/8.6540417/8.4/5/.A.2/A5?.6D/8.A1/8.3 - 5 - 17 /8. ?.@.54.? ?9302= /8. @1934. 17 02B.4/0=5/012 17 5 @54. 1 75354 ;3.4.2/ @54.04 @12@.32.? /8.3.04 5641>9/.>D 21 A5/.305> /1 481: /85/ 450? 59/130@<485: ?30B.26D?.@.54.?A<5385??548.?5=5024/52D1/8.3 B.80@>. @@13?02=>D 48. ;35D4 /1 ?04A044 /8. :30/ ;./0/012 8. 7034/ 02713A52/ 02 /8. ;3.4.2/ @54. 04 12. 1=.48 1 0F5D5<9A53 5802?35<53 :81 04 /8. @19402 631/8.317?.@.54.?A<532/8.7034/02713A5/012?5/.? *!" 8. 854 4/5/.? /85/ 5/ 5619/ ! 5A 12 *!" 8. 3.@.0B.? 5 ;812. @5>> 731A /8. A160>. ;812. 17 /8. ?.@.54.? A<53 52? :54 02713A.? /85/ A<53 :81 :54 ?30B02= ;. 59/130@<485: 6.5302= 3.=04/35/012 1)!! 02 5 3548 52? 2.=>0=.2/ A522.385?>14/@12/31>17/8.45A.52?5453.49>//8. B.80@>.85?/93/>.?52?02/8.315?/35770@5@@0?.2/A<53 85? 4977.3.? =30.B194 02F930.4 52? 8. 854 5?A0//.? 02 1B.32A.2/ 14;0/5> 545B5<5>D52 / 04 02 /804 65@<=3192? 020/05>>D ( :54 3.=04/.3.? 713 /8. 177.2@.4 - 6 - ;9204856>. 92?.3 .@/0124 !"* 52? 17 # 5=5024/ A<53 / 5;;.534 /85/ 4964.C9.2/>D A<53 :81 :54 5?A0//.?02/8.1B.32A.2/14;0/5>5/545B5<5>D52:54 4807/.?/15;30B5/.814;0/5>5/1>5;93@0/D025853548/35 /5/.6D804A1/8.352?5 @54.:543.=04/.3.?02 1!" 6D 5?53 5E53 #1>0@. /5/012 1>5;93 @0/D 5853548/35 /5/. 52? 654.? 12 /8. 4/5/.A.2/ A5?. 6D /8.A1/8.317/8.B0@/0A?9302=/8.@1934.1702B.4/0=5/012 02/8. @54.0/5;;.534/85/#1>0@.9624;.@/1385? =0B.2 5 3.C9040/012 /1 /8. 814;0/5> 59/8130/0.4 5/ 1>5;93 4..<02=/8..G5@/3.5412713/8.?.5/817A<53G@.;/ /8. 5713.450? 3.C9040/012 /8.3. 04 21 1/8.3 A5/.305> /1 481: /85/ 450? 59/130@<485: ?30B.2 6D ?.@.54.? A<53 85??548.?5=5024/52D1/8.3B.80@>.12*!" ) 8. 4/5/.A.2/ 17 /8. ;./0/012.34 :54 3.@13?.? 6D /8. 2B.4/0=5/02= 770@.3 02 /8. ;3.4.2/ @54. 92?.3 .@/012 ) 17 3# 52? ;./0/012.34 85B. 21/ 4/5/.? 6.713. /8. 2B.4/0=5/02= 770@.3 /85/ A<53 :54 21/ /8. ?30B.317/8.450?59/130@<485:12/8.?5/.17/8.5@@0?.2/ - 7 - 213 /8.D 85B. 4/5/.? /85/ 59/130@<485: 17 A<53 85? ?548.? 5=5024/ 52D 1/8.3 B.80@>. 12 *!" 8. 5@@0?.2/0417/8.D.53!"52?.B.202/804;./0/012/8. ;53/0@9>534 17 /8. @12/502.3 :80@8 5>>.=.?>D 85? ?548.? 5=5024/ /8. 59/130@<485: 17 A<53 04 21/ A.2/012.? 8.3.713. 21 ;93;14. :19>? 6. 4.3B.? 02 ?03.@/02= 52D 793/8.3 02B.4/0=5/012 02 /8. @54. 7 /8. ;./0/012.34 :.3. 5==30.B.?:0/8/8.@853=.48../70>.?02/8.;3.4.2/@54. /8.D 19=8/ /1 85B. 70>.? 5 ;30B5/. @1A;>502/ 6.713. /8. F9304?0@/0125> 193/ 6.713. :80@8 /8. @853=. 48../ :54 70>.? 5B02= 750>.? /1 5B50> /8. .770@5@0194 3.A.?D 5B50>56>. /1 /8.A 92?.3 >5: /8.D 85B. 5;;315@8.? /804 @193/ 52? 85B. 419=8/ 713 5 793/8.3 02B.4/0=5/012 02 /8. A5//.3 02@. /8. @853=. 48../ A5/.305> 02 /8. ;3.4.2/ @54.@12@>940B.>D;31B./85/?.@.54.?A<53:54?30B02= /8.;.59/130@<485:6.5302=3.=04/35/012 1)!! 52?/8.5@@0?.2/02C9.4/01285?/5<.2;>5@.57/.38.85? >14/ @12/31> 17 /8. B.80@>. 5A 17 /8. 1;02012 /85/ 21 ;93;14.:19>?6.4.3B.?0213?.302=793/8.302B.4/0=5/012 02 /8. A5//.3 57/.3 >5;4. 17 A13. /852 4.B.2 D.534731A - 8 - /8.?5/.17/8.5@@0?.2/ 2?.3/8.@03@9A4/52@.45A 17 /8. 1;02012 /85/ ;./0/012 04 >056>. /1 6. ?04A044.? @@13?02=>D71>>1:02=13?.304;544.? 30/;./0/0124/52?4?04A044.? !)* '!&! # ! "( # 04/ 1> 1 #