Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11459 (KAR)
RAMA S/O TIMMANNA GUBBEWAD @ GOLLAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200209/2022 · 2025-01-08
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11459 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11459 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#
!"
" $%&'$( )*'+$) ,
! "# #
"# # #
! "
$%
"
%&&'&$
&$'&(
"
"
)
"
"
"
"
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" "
#
"
#!
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
.+753-0 ?+36/,, +/(1/>5:/?*5=3*/-449,/8.9:.5:3/802=-8/*+, /A3:-<98+4+-0 456>/,,+56 -0,5 39:6/8 *5,3+0/ "9:3*/: - 6 - ,E -68 H ?*5 -:/ 3*/ 4+:49=,3-63+-0 ?+36/,,/, -68 :/0-3+7/, 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 -0,5 39:6/8 *5,3+0/ 35 3*/ .:5,/493+56 4-,/ /7/:3*/0/,, 3*/ .:5,/493+56 -88+3+56-002 >-+0/8 35 .:57/ 53*/: 4+:49=,3-64/, 0+C/ :/457/:2 5> =-3/:+-0 51</43 ?*+4* ?-, ,-+8 35 *-7/ 1//6 9,/8 >5: 45==+,,+56 5> 3*/ 4:+=/ , ,94* -445:8+6; 35 3*/ 0/-:6/8 4596,/0 .:5,/493+56 *-, 35 .:57/ +3, 4-,/ 1/2568 :/-,56-10/ 85913 12 .0-4+6; 45;/63 /7+8/64/ 5?/7/: +6 3*/ +6,3-63 4-,/ 3*/:/ +, 65 ,94* :/0+-10/ /7+8/64/ .0-4/8 12 3*/ .:5,/493+56 35 .:57/ +3I, 4563/63+56/64/*/.:-2,35-005?3*/-../-012,/33+6; -,+8/ 3*/ +=.9;6/8 <98;=/63 5> 4567+43+56 -68 5:8/: 5> ,/63/64/ E 3*/ 0/-:6/8 88+3+56-0 3-3/ 910+4 :5,/4935: >5: 3*/ :/,.568/63@3-3/ 4563/68/8 3*-3 <98;=/63968/:3*+,-../-06/+3*/:,9>>/:,>:5=./:7/:,+32 65: +00/;-0+32 -, 3*/ 0/-:6/8 /,,+56, 98;/ *-, =/3+49059,02/A-=+6/83*//7+8/64/56:/45:8-68.-,,/8 - ?/00 :/-,56/8 <98;=/63 ?*+4* 85/, 653 4-00 >5: -62 +63/:>/:/64/ 445:8+6; 35 3*/ 0/-:6/8 88+3+56-0 3-3/ - 7 - 910+4:5,/4935:8/4/-,/8+,656/53*/:3*-63*/?+>/5> 3*/ -449,/8 -68 3*/2 153* ?/:/ :/,+8+6; +6 - :/63/8 :/,+8/64/-3500-:6+-3+68-;+,,94*3*/569,+,56 3*/ -449,/8 35 .0-4/ 1/>5:/ 3*+, 459:3 3*/ 4-9,/ 5> 8/4/-,/8I,8/-3* H 445:8+6;35*+=123*//7+8/64/5>,&$ 35H.:5,/493+56*-,,944/,,>9002.:57/83*-33*/-449,/8 -68 8/4/-,/8 ?/:/ :/,+8+6; 35;/3*/: -68 56 3*/ 8-3/ 5> +64+8/633*/-449,/8?-,7/:2=94*.:/,/63+63*/*59,/ ;-+6,3 3*+, 1-4C8:5. ,*5908 3*/ -449,/8 >-+0 35 .:57+8/ :/-,56-10/ /A.0-6-3+56 >5: 3*/ 4-9,/ 5> 8/-3* 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 968/: ,94* 4+:49=,3-64/, 12 +675C+6; /43+56 &'( 5> 3*/ 68+-6 7+8/64/ 43 3*/ 59:3 4-6 8:-?
.:/,9=.3+56968/:/43+56&&%5>3*/ 68+-67+8/64/43
/7/:3*/0/,, 53*/: ?+36/,,/, /A-=+6/8 12 3*/ .:5,/493+563*/>-=+02=/=1/:,+/,&$35H-0,5 8/.5,/83*-33*/-449,/8=+,3:/-3/83*/8/4/-,/85?+6; 35*+,,9,./43+6;*/:>+8/0+32-68-0,5?*/63*/8/4/-,/8 8/40+6/8=56/3-:28/=-68,123*/-449,/835;:-3+>2*+, 7+4/, 6 ,94* 4+:49=,3-64/ 3*/ .:5,/493+56 ,944/,,>9002
- 8 -
/,3-10+,*/8 3*/ ;9+03 5> 3*/ -449,/8 1/2568 :/-,56-10/ 85913 "9:3*/: 3*/ 67/,3+;-3+6; >>+4/: &E -0,5 8/.5,/8 ,+=+0-:02 / -0,5 4563/68/8 3*-3 3*/ 5:-0 3/,3+=562 5> & 4-3/;5:+4-002 45::515:-3/, ?+3* 3*/ =/8+4-0 /7+8/64/ 5> &B ,3-3+6; 3*-3 3*/ 8/-3* ?-, 4-9,/8 89/ 35 *5=+4+8-0 ,3:-6;90-3+56 12 ?-2 5> ,=53*/:+6; 6 ,94* 4+:49=,3-64/, 3*/ .:5,/493+56 *-, .:57/83*/;9+035>3*/-449,/81/2568:/-,56-10/85913 -68 3*/ 0/-:6/8 /,,+56, 98;/ :+;*302 4567+43/8 3*/ -449,/8>5:3*/4*-:;/,0/7/00/8-;-+6,3*+=445:8+6;02 */.:-2,358+,=+,,3*/-../-0 &' -7+6; */-:8 3*/ 0/-:6/8 4596,/0 >5: 3*/ :/,./43+7/.-:3+/,,5-0,5./:9,+6;3*//63+://7+8/64/56 :/45:8 +64098+6; 3*/ +=.9;6/8 <98;=/63 3*/ >5005?+6; .5+63,-:+,/>5:59:456,+8/:-3+56
!"#
- 9 -
&& 6 3*/ +6,3-63 4-,/ -01/+3 3*/ .:5,/493+56 /A-=+6/8 &E ?+36/,,/, 35 .:57/ 3*/ 4*-:;/, 0/7/00/8 -;-+6,33*/-449,/8+3+,:/8968-63358/07/+6353*/6+332 ;:+332 5> +68+7+89-0 /7+8/64/ 5> -00 ?+36/,,/, 6 5:8/: 35 .:57/ 3*/ *5=+4+8-0 8/-3* 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8@:+8/7+ 3*/ .:5,/493+56*-,.:+=-:+02:/0+/8563*//7+8/64/5>&B 3*/85435:?*54568943/83*/-935.,2563*/45:.,/5>3*/ 8/4/-,/8-68,91,/D9/6302+,,9/8.5,3=5:3/=:/.5:3-, ./:A&E-683*/+6D9/,3.-64*-6-=-4568943/8563*/ 45:.,/12&E 67/,3+;-3+6;>>+4/:-,./:A&'6 4-:/>90 ./:9,-0 5> 3*/ 4563/63, 5> A&E +/ .5,3 =5:3/=:/.5:385435:*-,5.+6/83*-3J3*/8/-3*?-,89/ 35 -,.*2A+- -, - :/,903 5> ,3:-6;90-3+56 12 0+;-39:/I
"9:3*/:*/,3-3/83*-30+;-39:/,-:/-63/=5:3/=+;-39:/ =-:C +, >5968 56 3*/ 6/4C 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8@:+8/7+ 5 ,91,3-63+-3/3*+,,%-68B3*/?+36/,,/,>5:+6D9/,3 .-64*-6-=- 8:-?6 56 3*/ 45:.,/ -, ./: A&' ,3-3/8 3*-3 -63/ =5:3/= 0+;-39:/ =-:C +, >5968 56 3*/ 6/4C 5> 3*/8/4/-,/8/64/-456<5+63:/-8+6;5>3*//7+8/64/5> &B3*/85435:-683*//7+8/64/5>,%B-68&E
- 10 -
3*/ 67/,3+;-3+6;>>+4/:-056;?+3*3*/.5,3=5:3/=:/.5:3 5>85435:+/A&E-68+6D9/,3.-64*-6-=-A&'?/ -:/5>3*/456,+8/:/87+/?3*-3.:5,/493+56*-,.:57/83*/ *5=+4+8-0 8/-3* 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 1/2568 -00 :/-,56-10/ 85913 & 6 5:8/: 35 4566/43 3*/ -449,/8 >5: *5=+4+8-0 8/-3*5>3*/8/4/-,/8.:5,/493+56*-,:/0+/856/7+8/64/ 5> & +/ 3*/ ;:-68=53*/: 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 ?*5 *-, ,/33*/4:+=+6-00-?+635=53+5612058;+6;3*/45=.0-+63 3*-3+,A&6./:9,-05>A&45=.0-+63+3+,,3-3/8 3*-3 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 :+8/7+ ?-, =-::+/8 35 3*/ -449,/8 -3 -1593/+;*32/-:,.:+5:353*/8-3/5>+64+8/63*/:/->3/: 3*/2 153* ?/:/ :/,+8+6; +6 - 3+6 ,*/8 -3 500-: 6+ -3 +68-;+35?6 3+,,3-3/8+63*/45=.0-+633*-3:/0-3+56,*+. 1/3?//63*/-449,/8-688/4/-,/8?-,,3:-+6/8"9:3*/: ,*/ 7+,+3/8 3*/+: .0-4/ 5> :/,+8/64/ -68 -87+,/8 3*/ -449,/8 653 35 +6890;/ +6 ,94* -43+7+3+/, 5?/7/: 56 '&'('&B H */: ,56@+6@0-? +6>5:=/8 */: 3*-3 3*/ -449,/8*-8=9:8/:/83*/8/4/-,/812,3:-6;90-3+6;*/: */:/12 ,*/ -056; ?+3* &' -68 53*/: :/0-3+7/, 5>
- 11 -
&=-8/*-,3/353*/8/4/-,/8I,:/,+8/64/-68>5968 3*/45:.,/445:8+6;35&-33*/*59,/5>8/4/-,/8 9.56 +6D9+:+6; E +/ 56/ =3 96+3- 8+790;/8 3*/ :/-,56, >5: 3*/ +64+8/63 6 ./:9,-0 5> 3*/ /7+8/64/ 5> & ,*/ :/+3/:-3/8 3*/ -7/:=/63, 5> */: 45=.0-+63 -, ./: A& -68 -0,5 ,3-3/8 3*-3 ,*/ 4-=/ 35 C65?
-1593 3*/+64+8/63-68-449,/8?-,3*/./:./3:-35:5>3*/4:+=/ 3*:59;*H6./:9,-05>/7+8/64/5>H:+-=- 2-C58-?*5+,-0,53*/:/0-3+7/5>3*/8/4/-,/8@:+8/7+ ,3-3/83*-3*/?-,+6>5:=/8-15933*/+64+8/6312,5=/5> 3*/ :/,+8/63, 5> 3*/ ,-+8 450562 ?*/:/ 3*/ -449,/8 -68 8/4/-,/8 ?/:/ :/,+8+6; 5?/7/: 3*/ :/,.568/63@.50+4/ *-7/653=-8/-62/>>5:335/+3*/:35:/45:83*/,3-3/=/63 5> -62 5> 3*/ :/,+8/63, 5> 3*/ ,-+8 450562 65: /A-=+6/8 3*/=1/>5:/3*/ 59:3"9:3*/:E?*5+,656/53*/:
3*-6 3*/ ?+>/ 5> H -0,5 ,3-3/8 ,+=+0-:02 3*-3 =3 /00-??- ( +6>5:=/8 */: -1593 3*/ +64+8/63 63/:/,3+6;02 153* 3*/,/ ?+36/,,/, +/ ,E -68 H 1/+6; 3*/ 405,/ :/0-3+7/, 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 *-7/ .-:302 39:6/8*5,3+0/353*/.:5,/493+564-,/
- 12 -
& 5=+6;353*//7+8/64/5>(?*5-00/;/802 +6>5:=/8 3*/ +64+8/63 35 E 353-002 39:6/8 *5,3+0/ 35 3*/.:5,/493+564-,/-68,*/*-,8/6+/83*/,-+8-,./43+6 */:/7+8/64/*59;*3*/0/-:6/8.910+4.:5,/4935:4:5,, /A-=+6/8 */: -3 0/6;3* 653*+6; ?5:3*?*+0/ ?-, /0+4+3/8 >:5= */: 35 .:57/ */: ,3-3/=/63 1/>5:/ 3*/ .50+4/
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
- 13 -
-68 3*/ 4-9,/ >5: 3*/ 8/-3* 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 -, ./: 3*/ .:57+,+56,5>/43+56&'(5>3*/ 68+-67+8/64/43 &B / *-7/ 65 D9-::/0 56 3*/ ,-+8 .:/.5,+3+56 5> 0-?5?/7/:+3+,-0,5,/330/80-?123*+, 59:3-683*/ 56I10/./A 59:31/>5:/8+,4*-:;+6;,94*-19:8/612 3*/-449,/8.:+=-:+02+3+,3*/89325>3*/.:5,/493+5635 .:57/12.0-4+6;45;/63/7+8/64/3*-3-449,/8?-,+63*/ 45=.-62 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 56 3*-3 >-3/>90 6+;*3 -, 8+,49,,/8,9.:-6./:9,-05>3*//63+://7+8/64/5>3*/ =-3/:+-0?+36/,,/,3*/:/+,65,94*/7+8/64/>5:3*45=+6; 3*-33*/-449,/8?-,+63*/45=.-625>3*/8/4/-,/856 3*/>-3/>906+;*35:/57/:3*/-449,/8*-,,59;*3.0/-5> -6 456>+:=+6;3*-3*/?-,653-3+68-;+-68563*/ 8-3/ 5> +64+8/63 */ ?-, -3 - 8+>>/:/63 .0-4/ +/ +6 911/?-87+00-;/68/:,94*4+:49=,3-64/,3*/ 8932+, 4-,39.563*/.:5,/493+5635.:57/3*/-435>3*/-449,/8 12 :/02+6; 56 53*/: 4+:49=,3-64/, 8=+33/802 ?*/6 - 4-,/:/,3,564+:49=,3-63+-0/7+8/64/.:5,/493+56 *-,35 .:57//-4*4+:49=,3-64/?+3*5931:/-C+6;3*/4*-+6@0+6C
- 14 -
&( 6 3*/ +6,3-63 4-,/ /A4/.3 *5=+4+8-0 8/-3* 5> 3*/ 8/4/-,/8 12 ?-2 5> ,3:-6;90-3+56 656/ 5> 3*/ 53*/: 4+:49=,3-64/, -:/ .:57/8 12 3*/ .:5,/493+56 */ :/457/:2 5> ?/-.56 ?*+4* ,-+8 35 *-7/ 1//6 9,/8 >5:
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
:/.5:3/8 +6 */08+6.-:-;:-.*@$-,968/:
- 15 -
-&% " $ %& ' (() * ##
&
&
" &"& & # +,-##../ !0
1!
& 2)3#
&
& '& !4 5 ( & " # , -## 6 70
87
!4 5(
& &
& & *
'& * & & 9
- 16 -
$' # , -## .0
9. !4 5 (
:&
& & & '& * :
* &
9;
" & & ;
&E /64/+67+/?5>3*/,/330/8.:/4/8/6319:8/6 5> .:57+6; ,./4+-0 C65?0/8;/ 4-6653 1/ ,*+>3/8 56 3*/ -449,/8 =/:/02 56 3*/ 1-,+, 5> >-439= 5> .0-4/ 5> 5449::/64/960/,,.:5,/493+56*-,.:57/8+3,4-,/1/2568 -00:/-,56-10/85913-,,3-3/8,9.:- &H */ 56I10/ ./A 59:3 +6 3*/ 4-,/ 5> ! "# :/.5:3/8 +6 $
%% */08 3*-3 3*/ .:5,/493+56 *-, 35 .:57/ +3, 4-,/ 1/2568 :/-,56-10/85913-683*/:/+,-8+>>/:/64/1/3?//6.0-4/ 5>.:55>K=-21/L-68K=9,31/L 63*/4-,/56*-6856
- 17 -
4-:/>90 ./:9,-0 5> 3*/ /63+:/ /7+8/64/ 56 :/45:8 +3 45908 1/ ;-3*/:/8 3*-3 3*/ 0/-:6/8 /,,+56, 98;/ 4567+43/8 3*/-449,/8,50/02:/02+6;563*/-,./433*-33*/-449,/8 -68 8/4/-,/8 ?/:/ :/,+8+6; 35;/3*/: "9:3*/: -449,/8 >-+0/8 35 8+,4*-:;/ 3*/ 19:8/6 968/: /43+56 &'( 5> 3*/ 68+-67+8/64/435?/7/:-,./:3*/<98;=/63,3-3/8 ,9.:- ?/ -:/ 96-10/ 35 -44/.3 3*/ :/-,56+6; 5> 3*/ 0/-:6/8 /,,+56, 98;/ */ 56I10/ ./A 59:3 +6 3*/ 4-,/5>"&
'# ():/.5:3/8 +6
*-, =-8/ -6 51,/:7-3+56 +6 :/,./43 5> =5:-0 4567+43+56 3*-3 ?-68/:+6; 56 ,3:56; ,9,.+4+56+,653-65.3+56358/4+8/-4-,/123*//,,+56, 59:3-68*/08+6.-:-;:-.* 5$-,968/: 1+ & & & &
' &
3
&
" # &
<
- 18 -
=("< 7>/ # 4 / , 7>/ # ? !.@ ,-("<4.> 0
" A 3
# &
B & 8 9 8 9
&
;
' 6 3*/ +6,3-63 4-,/ -01/+3 3*/:/ +, ,*5:3 5> /7+8/64/ 35 .:57/ 3*/ 4*-:;/, 0/7/00/8 -;-+6,3 3*/ -449,/8 3*/ 0/-:6/8 /,,+56, 98;/ 4567+43/8 3*/ -449,/8-../00-63 1-,/8 56 ,9:=+,/ -68 456</439:/ 6 59:7+/?3*/,-+84567+43+565:8/:4-66531/,9,3-+6/8-68 +63/:>/:/64/ +, :/D9+:/8 +6 3*/ +=.9;6/8 <98;=/63 5> 4567+43+56-685:8/:5>,/63/64/445:8+6;02?/-6,?/: .5+63 5& +6 3*/ ->>+:=-3+7/ -68 .5+63 5 +6 3*/ 6/;-3+7/-68.:54//835.-,,3*/>5005?+6;
+ */ :+=+6-0../-0 5'''H'+,**+
- 19 -
++ */ <98;=/63 5> 4567+43+56 -68 5:8/: 5> ,/63/64/ 8-3/8%&&'&$.-,,/8+6 5&$'&(123*/ 88+3+56-0 /,,+56, 98;/ +<-2-.9:- +, ,/3 -,+8/
+++ */ -449,/8-../00-63 +, -4D9+33/8 >5: 3*/ 5>>/64/ .96+,*-10/ 968/: /43+56 ' 5> 3*/ 68+-6 /6-0 58/
+7 */ 9./:+63/68/63 5> -+0 93*5:+32 +, 8+:/43/8 35 :/0/-,/3*/-../00-63-449,/8>5:3*?+3*+>*/+,653 :/D9+:/8+6-6253*/:4-,/,
/;+,3:2 +, 8+:/43/8 35 45==96+4-3/ 3*+, 5:8/: 35 3*/-+093*5:+3+/,4564/:6/8
.*
$
#)
.*
$ )
# +,3 5&0 5B