Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11443 (KAR)
SANJEEV KUMAR @ SANJU v. P.PALANIAPPAN AND ORS
MFA/202493/2018 · 2025-01-16
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11443 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11443 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#"$
%# #
&
! " #
$%
"$
"&" #
"
'( ) ** +
)% ) !"
&%" #
$ "$)
"
" ## ")!& "
)!& "
! ! #
" )#
%
" ," "
-
) #"
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.28 18:03:37 - 0800
- 2 -
" ) . !) && !#!" #
$ "$)
" !"
# " !" )
" &
")."
# "
" !%
) " #
% */."
#
! #
" )! -# %
"
"
! %" -
)
"
# " )#
/ +
)% )!! " " 0
!%%! %" " 0 (
& ! ! / ! ! " %#
! % ! # # & /
)% ! #
" ) " * )%
!# ! ! " # " ! %" # & ! $
$ !1) ! - 3 -
# $!1) ! !2345623472589:7;263<<234=7>?94@A23<<26637@ 375 @A2 6234725 89:7;26; 3<<234=7> ?94 42;<97527@ 9; 3757;:437829B<37=2;
A=; 3<<236 34=;2; 9:@ 9? C:5>B27@ 375 3D345 53@25/<3;;25=79*97@A2?=62 9? @A2 9:4@ 9? @A2 4=78=<36 27=94 =E=6 :5>2 375 " )=534" ?94 ;A94@ F 4=G:736H )2=7> 3>>4=2E25 GI @A2 ;3=5 C:5>B27@3753D345"@A2<2@=@=9724=;G2?942@A=;9:4@
A238@:36B3@4=J9?@A283;2=;3;G269D$
3 2@=@=9724D3;D94K=7>3;3 4=E24976944I9) ) /.. :7524 42;<97527@ 9 7 " 3@ 3G9:@ / <B" DA27 A2 D3; 97 5:@I <498225=7> ?49B !I5243G35@93BG3;34=7#:C343@"7234 362;2>397=E34=7 )225 =;@4=8@"36944IG234=7>9 .#83B2?49B @A29<<9;=@2;=52=73A=>A;<22537572>6=>27@B37724375 GI89B=7>97@A2D497>;=52"=@53;A253>3=7;@@A26944I9? - 4 -
@A2<2@=@=9724 A2<2@=@=9724;:;@3=725=7C:4=2;@9G9@A@A2 62>;"84:;A=7C:4I@962?@A:B24:;"62?@62>375@A24=>A@69D24 6=BG 375 @A2 4=>A@ 69D24 6=BG D3; 3B<:@3@25 97 @A2 ;<9@ =@;26?!2D3;;A=?@25@9#9E247B27@!9;<=@36")225"DA242 A2 @99K @423@B27@ @=66 * 375 @A2423?@24 A2 @99K @423@B27@ =7 E34=9:; 9@A24 A9;<=@36; @9@366I ?94 3 <24=95 9? 53I; 3; =7<3@=27@ !2 A35 ;<27@ A:>2 3B9:7@ ?94 @423@B27@83;2D3;36;942>=;@2425=784=B29 9? 2K7994 96=82 @3@=97 375 :6@=B3@26I =@ D3; ?9:75 @A3@ @A2 54=E24; 9? G9@A @A2 6944=2; D242 72>6=>27@=7 54=E=7> @A2 E2A=862 A2<2@=@=9724D3;354=E242347=7>B97@A6I;3634I 9? ;" D=@A 3 53=6I G3@3 9? 375 GI E=4@:2 9? 3B<:@3@=97 9? A=; 4=>A@ 62>" A2 A3; ;:??2425 3 <24B3727@ 5=;3G=6=@I 375 @A242?942" A2 <43I25 ?94 37 352L:3@2 89B<27;3@=97 ?49B @A2 9D724 375 @A2 =7;:424 9? @A2 9??275=7>6944I
A2 42;<97527@ 9 =; 9D724 9? @A2 9??275=7> 6944I 375 42;<97527@ 9 =; @A2 6944I 9D724 54=E27 GI @A2 <2@=@=9724 375 @A2I 42B3=725 2J<34@2 G2?942 @A2 4=G:736
A2 42;<97527@ 9; 375 " DA9 342 @A2 =7;:424; 9? G9@A
- 5 -
@A2E2A=862;3<<23425375?=625@A2D4=@@27;@3@2B27@ A2I 527=25@A2<2@=@=973E24B27@;42>345=7>@A23>2"988:<3@=97 375 =789B2 375 36;9 @A2 B37724 9? 988:442782 9?
@A2 388=527@375897@27525@A3@@A25=;3G=6=@I897@27525GI@A2 <2@=@=9724 =; A=>A6I 2J94G=@37@" =B3>=734I 375 :7@273G62 =7 63D @ D3; 897@27525 @A3@ @A242 D3; A23597 8966=;=97 G2@D227 @A2 @D9 6944=2;" @A242?942" @A2 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782GI@A2<2@=@=9724B3I36;9G2897;=52425GI@A2
4=G:736 A2 42;<97527@ 9 ?=625 355=@=9736 D4=@@27 ;@3@2B27@375897@27525@A3@@A2388=527@988:44255:2@9 @A2 72>6=>2782 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724" 3; @A2 8A34>2;A22@ D3;
?=625 3>3=7;@ G9@A @A2 54=E24; 7 @A2 G3;=; 9? ;:8A 897@27@=97;"@A2 4=G:736?43B25?9669D=7>=;;:2;$
!"#$"%#&&
' () *
+# *
,
-) .#&$-/#0
1
)
2
- 6 -
1
2 3 4 3
1
2
$&&1(5/ 2 6
1 2%71 2 . 8 / 29
*
A2 <2@=@=9724 D3; 2J3B=725 3; & 375 @D9 D=@72;;2; D242 2J3B=725 97 A=; G2A36? 3; &; 375 J; @9 / D242 B34K25 A2 42;<97527@ 9 2J3B=725 & 375
J; 375 D242 B34K25 A2 42;<97527@ 9 2J3B=725 & 375
J; 375 D242 B34K25?@24A234=7>G9@A@A2<34@=2;"@A2 4=G:73683B2@9 89786:;=97@A3@@A254=E24;9?G9@A@A26944=2;A35897@4=G:@25 2L:366I 375 A265 @A3@ @A2 =789B2 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724 3@ ;" <24 B97@A 375 @A2 5=;3G=6=@I G2=7> 3@ M" 3D34525389B<27;3@=97:75245=??2427@A235;3;G269D$
- 7 -
9D345;69;;9??:@:42=789B2 ;""
9D345;<3=7375;:??24=7> ;/*"
9D345;69;;9?=789B2?94 B97@A; ;""
9D345;B25=836G=66; ;" *
9D345;897E2I37828A34>2; ;" . 9D345;?995(2J@43 79:4=;AB27@ ;*" /
9D345;3@@27537@H;8A34>2; ;"
9D345;5=;?=>:42B27@ ;*"
9D345;@A289;@9?3=<:4 34@=?=8=366=BG ;""
9@36 ;""
. :2@9@A2?=J=7>9?*M72>6=>278297@A2<34@ 9?3<<26637@<2@=@=9724"@A23D3453B9:7@=; ;"**"*/
/ )2=7> 3>>4=2E25 GI @A2 ;3=5 C:5>B27@" @A2 <2@=@=97243<<4938A25@A=;9:4@=73<<236
; G2?942" 976I @A2 =7;:424; 9? G9@A @A2 6944=2;
A3E2 3<<23425 G2?942 @A=; 9:4@ 36;9 A2 34>:B27@; GI 623472589:7;263<<234=7>?94@A2<2@=@=9724375@A26234725 89:7;263<<234=7>?9442;<97527@9;375342A2345
A2 6234725 89:7;26 3<<234=7> ?94 @A2 <2@=@=9724 B3=76I897@27525@A3@"=@A289B<27;3@=973D34525GI@A2
4=G:736=;97@A269D24;=52375@A2<2@=@=9724G2=7>354=E24
- 8 -
9?3A23EI>995;E2A=862"A3;;:??242535=;3G=6=@I9?M == A2 4=G:73624425=7A965=7>@A3@@A242D3;897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782 97 @A2 <34@ 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724 === A2 4=G:736 ?3=625 @9 79@2 @A3@ @A2 <2@=@=9724 G2=7> 3 54=E24 9? 3 A23EI >995; E2A=862" A35 @A2 2347=7> 83<38=@I 375 A=; =789B2 3@ ;"<24B97@AD=@A9:@897;=524=7>?:@:42<49;<28@; D3;79@C:;@375<49<24
63G943@=7>97@A23G9E2897@27@=97"@A26234725 89:7;26 3<<234=7> ?94 @A2 <2@=@=9724 897@27525 @A3@ @A2 3B<:@3@=979?@A24=>A@62>9?@A2<2@=@=9724G269DK722A3; 42;:6@25=7M5=;3G=6=@I375@A2 4=G:736?3=625@9897;=524 @A2;3B2@@A23>29?*I234;"@A2<2@=@=972483779@?=75 3 72D 3E983@=97 @9 8344I 97 A=; 6=?2 375 @A242?942" @A2 89786:;=97;4238A25GI@A2 4=G:7363G9:@@A25=;3G=6=@I342 =7894428@ !2 ?:4@A24 897@27525 @A3@ @A2 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782A3;79@G227<49<246I3;;2;;25GI@A2 4=G:736 !2 897@275; @A3@ @A2 @2;@=B97I 9?
@A2 & 3; D266 3; @A2 &" :72L:=E98366I ;A9D; @A3@ @A2 72>6=>2782 D3; 97 @A2 <34@9?@A29??275=7>E2A=862375=@2449729:;6IG26=2E25@A2 96=823<24;@9A965@A3@@A242D3;897@4=G:@94I72>6=>2782
- 9 -
=7 2L:36 <49<94@=97 GI @A2 <2@=@=9724 A2 96=82 3<24;
862346I ;A9D @A3@ @A2 =7E2;@=>3@=97 D3; 5972 3?@24 @A2 E2A=862;D24242B9E25?49B@A2;<9@@93E9=5@A2@43??=8C3B" A2782" @A2 ;<9@ B373>24 89:65 79@ A3E2 G227 G26=2E25 GI @A2 4=G:736 A242?942" A2 ;:GB=@; @A3@ @A2 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>278289:6579@A3E2G2273@@4=G:@25@9@A2<2@=@=9724=7 37ID3I 2>345=7>A=;@A=45897@27@=97"A2;:GB=@;@A3@@A2 =789B29?@A2<2@=@=97243@"<24B97@AD3;C:;@375 <49<24 3; A2 G2=7> 3 54=E24 9? A23EI >995; E2A=862" @A2
4=G:736 24425 =7 425:8=7> @A2 =789B2 ?49B ;" @9 ;"
! " 6234725 89:7;26 3<<234=7> ?94 42;<97527@9D9:65;:GB=@@A3@@A2<2@=@=9724G2=7>3>25 *I234;"A3;;:??2425@A25=;3G=6=@I3@/M3;<24 98@94H; 2E=52782"@A2 4=G:736@A9:>A;A9:65A3E2@3K27@A2;3B23@ /M" G:@ 27A37825 @A2 ;3B2 @9 M !2782" A2 ;:GB=@; @A3@79?3:6@837G2?9:75=7@A289786:;=979?@A2 4=G:736=7 @A=;42>345@=;;:GB=@@25@A3@@A2<2@=@=9724837E24ID266 2K2 9:@ A=; 6=E26=A995 GI 42;94@=7> @9 9@A24 <2@@I G:;=72;;
- 10 -
2@8"375@A242?942"@A23;;2;;B27@9?@A25=;3G=6=@I=;<49<24 375894428@
2>345=7> @A2 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782" =@ =; ;:GB=@@25GI@A289:7;26?9442;<97527@9@A3@@A296=82 3<24; G2=7> 9:@ 89B2 9? =7E2;@=>3@=97 GI 3 @3@:@94I :@A94=@I" 83779@ G2 G4:;A25 3;=52 @ =; ;:GB=@@25 @A3@ DA27@A273B29?@A2&=;79@;A9D7=7@A28A34>2;A22@ 3; 37 2I2D=@72;; 375 3; 3 623724 9? @A2 6944I 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724" A=;
@2;@=B97I 83779@ G2 3882<@25 3; 37 2I2D=@72;; @ =; ;:GB=@@25 @A3@ @A242 D242 9@A24 2I2D=@72;;2;3E3=63G62375@A2<2@=@=9724A3;79@2J3B=725 37I9?@A2B"@A242?942"@A2E24I?38@@A3@&D3;36;937 2I2D=@72;;=;79@89449G943@25GI37I9@A242E=527823753;
;:8A" A=; 2E=52782 =; :7G26=2E3G62 A242?942" A2 ;L:3426I 426=2;97@A296=823<24;@9897@275@A3@@A242D3;2L:36 897@4=G:@94I72>6=>2782GIG9@A@A254=E24;!2;:GB=@;@A3@ @A2<9@3A3C34862346I52<=8@;@A3@@A2388=527@A3<<2725 3@@A2827@249?@A24935375@A242?942"@A242=;797282;;=@I 9? =75:6>2782 GI @A=; 9:4@ 3;@6I" A2 ;:GB=@@25 @A3@ @A2 =789B29?@A2<2@=@=9724A3;79@G227<49E25GI2J3B=7=7>
- 11 -
42;<97527@ 9 @ =; ;:GB=@@25 @A3@ 42;<97527@ 9 ;A9:65A3E289B2G2?942@A29:4@@9;3I3G9:@@A2;3634I <3=5GIA=B@9@A2<2@=@=9724 A242?942"=7@A23G;27829? 37I3882<@3G622E=52782"@A2 4=G:736A3;4=>A@6I897;=52425 @A2=789B29?@A2<2@=@=97243@ ;"<24B97@A
A2 6234725 89:7;26 3<<234=7> ?94 42;<97527@ 9" DA9 3<<234; ?94 @A2 7;:424 9? @A2 E2A=862 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724 A3; ;:<<94@25 @A2 E24;=97 9? @A2 6234725 89:7;26 ?9442;<97527@9
<24:;369?@A289B<63=7@;A9D;@A3@@A2 D3; 42>=;@242597@A2G3;=;9?89B<63=7@?=625GI2K799496=82 @3@=97GE=9:;6I"A2D3;79@372I2D=@72;;375@A242?942" @A2 3E24B27@; =7 @A2 89B<63=7@ 342 79@ 9? B:8A E36:2 !9D2E24"@A2<9@3A3C34"DA=8A=;<495:8253@
J;375 @A2 @437;63@25 E24;=97 3@
J3 D9:65 ;A9D; @A3@ @A2 <2@=@=9724=7A=;6944ID3;>9=7>@9D345;)225?49B963<:4 375 @A2 9??275=7> E2A=862 9D725 GI 42;<97527@ 9 375 =7;:425GI42;<97527@9D3;>9=7>@9D345;963<:4 A=; 598:B27@;A9D;@A3@@A2388=527@A35988:44253@@A2827@24
- 12 -
9?
@A2 4935 !9D2E24" =@ =; <24@=727@ @9 79@2 @A3@ @A2 9??275=7> E2A=862 G234=7> 9 .# =; 3 @27 DA22625 E2A=862 A2 E2A=862 54=E27 GI @A2 <2@=@=9724 =; 3 >995; 6944I 7 9@A24 D945;" =@ =; 86234 @A3@ @A2 9??275=7> E2A=8629D725GI42;<97527@9D3;3;<28=368344=3>2375 =@D3;A23E=24@A37@A2E2A=8629?@A2<2@=@=9724 A296=82 3<24;36;9;A9D@A3@@A2388=527@G2=7>3@@A2827@249?@A2 4935" @A2 <9@ 3A3C34 D3; <42<3425 3?@24 42B9E=7> @A2 E2A=862;?49B@A2;<9@ 9@A3@2J@27@"@A2<9@3A3C34A3; 3
A28A34>2;A22@<495:8253@
JN@437;63@25 89<I 3@
J;3O D9:65 ;A9D @A3@ @A2 54=E24; 9? G9@A E2A=862; D242 8A34>2;A22@25 ?94 72>6=>27@ 54=E=7> E=527@6I"@A254=E24;9?G9@AE2A=862;D242;@:8K:7524@A2 ;@224=7> DA226; 375 @A2 8623724; 9? G9@A E2A=862; A35 79@ ;:??2425 B:8A =7C:4I A2 3G9E2 8=48:B;@3782; ;A9D @A3@ @A2E2A=862;8966=525A235973@@A2827@249?@A24935"375 3;;:8A"72>6=>2782D3;3@@4=G:@25@9G9@A@A2E2A=862;
*
A2 <2@=@=9724" DA9 2J3B=725 3; & 375 @A2 2I2D=@72;; :7=6" DA9 2J3B=725 3; & ;3I @A3@ @A2 9??275=7> E2A=862 D3; 89B=7> ?49B 9<<9;=@2 5=428@=97 375
- 13 -
DA=62 9E24@3K=7> 379@A24 E2A=862" =@ 8966=525 3>3=7;@ @A2 E2A=8629?@A2<2@=@=9724 A=;;3I9?&;375@A9:>A79@ 527=25 ;<28=?=8366I =7 @A2 849;;2J3B=73@=97 GI @A2 6234725 89:7;263<<234=7>?9442;<97527@9"=@=;2E=527@@A3@@A2 @2;@=B97I9?&=;79@;:<<94@25GI37I96=823<24;@A3@ A2D3;36;937=7C:4259598:B27@;D24236;93E3=63G62@9 ;A9D@A3@A2D3;@A26237243@@A2@=B29?@A2388=527@ 9 @A3@2J@27@"@A2@2;@=B97I9?@A2&=;3882<@3G62
. 49B @A2 3G9E2" <49;<28@:; 9? @A2 @A=7>;" =@ =;
2E=527@ @A3@ @A242 D3; 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782 GI @A2 <2@=@=972436;9
/
A2 72J@ 3;<28@ D9:65 G2 @9 DA3@ 2J@27@ @A2 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782 =; 97;=524=7> @A2 ?38@ @A3@ @A2 E2A=862 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724 D3; 6=>A@24 @A37 @A3@ 9? @A2 9??275=7> E2A=862" @A2 54=E24 9? @A2 A23E=24 E2A=862 D9:65 A3E2 @9 G234 A=>A24 42;<97;=G=6=@I 375 3; ;:8A" A=;
72>6=>2782 D9:65 G2 A=>A24 7 @A2 =7E2;@=>3@=97 B352 GI @A2 96=82" @A2I 976I ?9:75 @A3@ G9@A @A2 54=E24; A35 897@4=G:@25" G:@ @A2 2J@27@ 9? 72>6=>2782 A3; @9 G2
- 14 -
3;824@3=725GI@A2 4=G:736@=;<24@=727@@979@2@A3@@A2 <24:;36 9? @A2 C:5>B27@ D9:65 ;A9D @A3@ @A2 4=G:736 A35 79@ G2;@9D25 =@; 3@@27@=97 97 @A2 73@:42 9? @A2 E2A=862;
A242?942" 897;=524=7> @A2 73@:42 9? @A2 E2A=862; =7E96E25" @A2 E2A=862 9D725 GI 42;<97527@ 9 375 =7;:425 GI 42;<97527@9"G2=7>3A23E=24972"@A272>6=>27829?=@;
54=E24 D9:65 G2 97 @A2 A=>A24 ;=52 7 @A2 897;=52425 9<=7=979?@A=;9:4@"=@D9:65G2C:;@3753<<49<4=3@2@9A965 @A3@@A2897@4=G:@94I72>6=>278297<34@9?@A2<2@=@=9724D3; M375@A3@9?@A29??275=7>E2A=862D3;/M
9B=7> @9 @A2 5=;3G=6=@I" @A2 <2@=@=9724 @A9:>A 897@27@25@A3@A2D3;3<49?2;;=973654=E249?3A23EI>995; E2A=862"A25=579@>9@B34KA=;54=E=7>6=827;2 A2428945; 9?@A2 4=G:736D9:65;A9D@A3@389<I9?@A254=E=7>6=827;2 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724" DA=8A D3; =;;:25 GI @A2 2K7994 96=82 @3@=97"=;3E3=63G62;<24@A=;598:B27@"@A253@29?G=4@A 9?
@A2 <2@=@=9724 =; .// 375 A2 D3; 3:@A94=P25 @9 54=E2A23EI<3;;27>24E2A=862375@A2G35>27:BG24=;36;9 B27@=9725 =7 @A2 ;3B2 A242?942" @A242 83779@ G2 37I 59:G@=7@A2;3I9?@A2<2@=@=9724@A3@A2D3;3<49?2;;=9736
- 15 -
54=E24 97 3 A23EI >995; E2A=862 A:;" @A2 3B<:@3@=97 9? @A24=>A@62>9?@A2<2@=@=97243;2E=527825?49B@A2B25=836 428945; 3@
J; @9 375 D9:65 2;@3G6=;A @A3@ @A242D3;3B<:@3@=979?@A24=>A@62>
E27@A2<A9@9>43<A 9?@A2<2@=@=9724<495:8253@
JD9:65;A9D@A2;3B2
A:;"=@=;2E=527@@A3@GI69;=7>@A24=>A@62>"@A2<2@=@=9724 83779@ 54=E2 3 A23EI >995;E2A=862 !2 A3; G227 5=;3G625 ?49BG2=7>3<49?2;;=973654=E24
E=527@6I"3@@A23>29?* I234;"A2A35@9;A=?@A=;3E983@=97@9;9B2@A=7>26;2"DA=8A D9:6552?=7=@26I37=B<9;;=G62@3;K
@=;D94@A@979@2"=7342827@C:5>B27@"=7@A2 83;29? "=7
" 528=525 97" @A2 <2J 9:4@ A3; A265 @A3@ 69;; 9? 972 2I2 9? 3 =3B975 :@@24 D9:65 42;:6@=73M5=;3G=6=@I A242?942"@3K=7>86:2?49B@A2 ;3=5C:5>B27@"3B<:@3@=979?@A24=>A@62>9?@A2<2@=@=9724 A3; 52?=7=@26I 42;:6@25 =7 M 5=;3G=6=@I A2 ?:78@=9736 5=;3G=6=@I 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724 D3; 79@ 4=>A@6I 528=525 GI @A2
4=G:736 7 @A3@ E=2D 9? @A2 B3@@24" @A2 5=;3G=6=@I =; 897;=524253@M
- 16 -
:1 3; @A2 =789B2 9? @A2 <2@=@=9724 =; 897824725"@A2 4=G:736=7@A23G;27829?37I9@A24B3@24=36 97 428945" 3882<@25 @A3@ A2 D3; 3 <49?2;;=9736 54=E24 375 A265A=;=789B2@9G2 ;"<24B97@A A242?942"79 ?3:6@ 837 G2 ?9:75 =7 42;<28@ 9? @A2 3;;2;;B27@ 9? @A2 =789B29?@A2<2@=@=9724
A2
4=G:736 A3E=7> 89786:525 3G9:@ @A2 5=;3G=6=@I" @A2 =789B2 375 @A2 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782" @A2 69;; 9? ?:@:42 =789B2 =; @9 G2 8368:63@25
E=527@6I" DA27 @A25=;3G=6=@I=;@9@A22J@27@9?M"?:@:42<49;<28@;36;9 7225@9G2897;=52425!2782"GI355=7>M@9@A2=789B2
"" @A2 2??28@=E2 B:6@=<6=8375 D9:65 89B2 @9
"@=;D94@A@979@2@A3@@A2 4=G:736A3;@3K27@A2 B:6@=<6=243@F*H):@3;79@25;:<43"@A254=E=7>6=827;29? @A2<2@=@=9724"DA=8A42B3=725:7B34K25";A9D;A=;53@29? G=4@A3;.// A2;3B23>2=;36;9B27@=9725=7@A2 B25=836 428945; 36;9 A242?942" A2 D3; 3>25 * I234; 3@ @A2@=B29?388=527@ A:;"@A23<<49<4=3@2B:6@=<6=24D9:65 G2.88945=7>6I"@A269;;9??:@:42=789B2=;428368:63@25 3; ;"JJ.@A3@2L:36; ;.""
- 17 -
A289B<27;3@=973D34525GI@A2 4=G:736:7524 @A2 42B3=7=7> A235; 592; 79@ 42L:=42 37I 42897;=5243@=97 @ =; 2E=527@ @A3@ @A2 4=G:736 A35 897;=52425 @A2 69;; 9? =789B25:4=7>63=5:<<24=95?943<24=959?B97@A; A2 25=836 )=66; D242 36;9 897;=52425 3; <24 @A2 38@:36;
97E2I3782 8A34>2; D242 897;=52425 3@ ;" 375 @9D345;5=;?=>:42B27@3;:B9? ;*"D3;3D34525GI @A2 4=G:736 9D345;@A289;@9?34@=?=8=366=BG"@A2 4=G:736 A3;3D345253;:B9? ;"" A:;"@A23<<26637@=; 27@=@625?94@A289B<27;3@=97=;G269D$
9D345;69;;9??:@:42=789B2 ;.""
9D345;<3=7375;:??24=7> ;/*"
9D345;69;;9?=789B2?94 B97@A; ;""
9D345;B25=836G=66; ;" *
9D345;897E2I37828A34>2; ;" . 9D345;?995(2J@43 79:4=;AB27@ ;*" /
9D345;3@@27537@H;8A34>2; ;"
9D345;5=;?=>:42B27@ ;*"
9D345;@A289;@9?34@=?=8=36 6=BG ;""
9@36 ;"*"
:@ 9? @A2 3G9E2 89B<27;3@=97 3B9:7@ 52@24B=725 GI @A=; 9:4@" @A2 897@4=G:@94I 72>6=>2782 9? - 18 -
M9?@A2<2@=@=9724A3;@9G2525:8@25 A242?942"3?@24 525:8@=7> M 9? 89B<27;3@=97 3B9:7@" =@ D9:65 89B2 @9 ;"" !2782" @A2 <2@=@=9724 =; 27@=@625 ?94 3 89B<27;3@=97 9?
;"" 3; 3>3=7;@ ;"**"*/" 3D34525GI@A2 4=G:736
7@A242;:6@"@A2<2@=@=9752;24E25@9G23669D25 =7<34@!2782"@A2?9669D=7>$
=
A2<2@=@=97=;3669D25=7<34@ ==
A2=B<:>725C:5>B27@3753D345<3;;25GI@A2
4=G:736 =; A242GI B95=?=25 A2 3<<26637@ =;
27@=@625?943;:B9? ;"**"/=7355=@=97@9 DA3@A3;G2273D34525GI@A2 4=G:736 ===
A2 42;<97527@ 9 ;A366 52<9;=@ @A2 ;3B2 D=@A=7N2=>A@OD22K;"3697>D=@A@A2=7@242;@3@ @A2 43@2 9? .M <24 377:B" ?49B @A2 53@2 9? <2@=@=97@=66=@;52<9;=@
- 19 -
=E
A2 42;@ 9? @A2 94524; <3;;25 GI @A2 4=G:736 42>345=7> @A2 ?=J25 52<9;=@" 2@8" 42B3=7 :736@2425
5 '# ( #
) =;@9$69$*
$