- 1 - !" ! #$ "% &" ! $ '(')*+('** & !! " #$ $ $ % ! ! ! ! & " #$ % Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !' !# % ! #(% ) ( ') * +', ' ! $ ! #% #&% #% ! !* # )% # % + & + ! $- - ! ( .-$(- # .-$(-% //0123 41 563 76 4+', 8263769 :2;4<2=>240<=4;<76/785?2674<7@7?563-57/>0< <2971=2<23 ;4< =>2 4;;26/2 80671>5:?2 0632< 2/=746 & 4; =>21126=75?4AA437=721/=+ #;4<1>4<=B=>2/= + C%5<2:2;4<2=>7140<=0632<2/=746'4;4324; <7A765? <4/230<2 D7=> 5 8<5E2< =4 F051> =>2 26=7<2 8<4/223769176=>25;4<21573/51251595761==>2A 25<3=>2?25<623/40612?;4<=>285<=721 - 3 - 8<7@5=2 /4A8?576= D51 ;7?23 :2;4<2 =>2 =<75? 40<= :E =>2 G0<7137/=7465? 9<7/0?=0<5? 6182/=4< 563 1171=56= 7<2/=4< 4; 9<7/0?=0<2 57/>0< D>2<276 =>2 82=7=7462<1>2<2765<25<<5E2351<21846326=41563 >25??295=746176=>2/4A8?576=5<2=>5=46', =>2/4A8?57656=>53@717=23=>2<2=57?1>484;=>2/4A856E H64D65114<4A5632?6=2<65=7465?7A7=2317=05=23 5= 6301=<75? <25 E32<5:53 453 57/>0< 563 >53;4063=>5==>21573<2=57?1>4837364=>5@2<2F0717=2 ?7/2612 51 8<4@7323 0632< =>2 8<4@717461 4; !2<=7?7I2< #64<9567/ <9567/ 4< 7J23% #46=<4?% <32< + 563 46=>25??295=7464;@74?5=7464;?5012#%#&%563#%4; =>25;4<2157346=<4? <32<>2/4A8?57656=>53767=75=23 /<7A765?8<4/223769151595761==>282=7=7462<1>2<276563 564=>2< >2 =<75? 40<= >5@769 =5H26 /4967I56/2 4; =>2 5??2923 4;;26/2 80671>5:?2 0632< 2/=746 & 4; =>2 /= + ;4<@74?5=7464;=>25;4<21573/?501214;=>246=<4? <32< >51 711023 10AA461 =4 =>2 5//0123 82<1461 563 :2769 599<72@23 :E =>2 15A2 =>2 82=7=7462<1 5<2 :2;4<2 =>7140<= - 4 - ' 25<623 /40612? ;4< =>2 82=7=7462<1 10:A7=1 =>5==>282=7=7462<1>5@2:2265<<5E23515//012341 563 76 =>27< /585/7=E 51 5659769 7<2/=4< 563 05?7=E 46=<4? ;;7/2<4;=>2/4A856E>282=7=7462<15<2:2769 >2?3@7/5<7401?E?75:?2;4<=>2/4A856E563=>2<2;4<2=>2 /4A856E71562/2115<E85<=E;4<=>2/<7A765?8<4/2237691 51 8<4@7323 0632< 2/=746 4; =>2 /= + //4<3769?E>28<5E1=45??4D=>282=7=746 2< /46=<5 ?25<623 4884123 =>2 82=7=746 56310:A7=1=>5==>256597697<2/=4<4;=>2/4A856E71 A532 51 5 85<=E 563 =>2<2;4<2 =>2<2 71 /4A8?756/2 4; 2/=7464;=>2/=+ , 2/=746 4; =>2 1126=75? 4AA437=721 /= + <2531510632< ! !! !! ! !! !! ! " - 5 - # $ !! !! % ! % ! & !! ! ' ( $ ) ! ! !!! ! !!!! ! *&! + , ! !- , ! , & <253769 4; =>2 5;4<21573 8<4@71746 4; ?5D A5H217=@2<E/?25<=>5=D>26=>24;;26/215<25??2923=4 >5@2:226/4AA7==23:E5/4A856E=>282<14676/>5<92 4; =>2 /4A856E 563 D51 <2184617:?2 ;4< =>2 15?21 4; =>2 /4A856E 51 D2?? 51 =>2 /4A856E 1>5?? :2 322A23 =4 :2 907?=E4;=>2/46=<5@26=7465631>5??:28<4/22323595761= 563 80671>23 5//4<3769?E >2<2;4<2 /4A856E 4; D>7/> =>25//01235<22A8?4E221D2<2<2F07<23=4:25<<5E2351 5//0123 76 =>2 7A809623 8<4/2237691 563 =>2 /4A8?576= - 6 - /5664= :2 8<4/22323 51 595761= =>2 5659769 7<2/=4< 7<2/=4<4<56E2A8?4E224;=>2/4A856E76=>25:126/2 4; =>2 4A856E :2769 A532 51 5 85<=E =4 =>2 /<7A765? 8<4/2237691 6 17A7?5< /7</0A1=56/21 =>71 40<= 76 <7A765? 2=7=746 4,,' 37184123 4; 46 ,' >51 F051>23 =>2 7A809623 /<7A765? 8<4/2237691 632< =>2 /7</0A1=56/21 5A 4; =>2 4876746 =>5=176/2=>2/4A856E>5164=:2265<<5E23515//0123 76=>28<2126=/512=>2/<7A765?8<4/2237691767=75=2392=1 @7=75=23;4<64=/4A8?E769=>2<2F07<2A26=4;2/=7464; =>2/=+ 26/2=>27A809623/<7A765?8<4/2237691 /5664=:2101=57623//4<3769?E8511=>2;4??4D769 #7% >2/<7A765?82=7=746715??4D23K #77% >2 26=7<2 8<4/223769 76 4+', 8263769 :2;4<2 =>2 <76/785? 2674< 7@7? -0392 563 - 40<= 57/>0< <2971=2<23 ;4< =>2 4;;26/2 80671>5:?2 0632< 2/=746 & 4; =>2 - 7 - 1126=75?4AA437=721/=+ 71F051>2351 595761==>282=7=7462<1>2<276 #777% 4D2@2<=>714<32<D7??64=/4A276=>2D5E4; =>2 <21846326=1 =5H769 5/=746 595761= =>2 82=7=7462<1765//4<356/2D7=>?5D ,+ '% &" !* " $ 71=4?4,