- 1 - ! " #$# ! % &$!!! # ' % &$!$! (! ) !"#"$%& ' $( ')(%((* "#"%" $ * " !"#% Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * " + , ")&%"( "#"% " "' & * !"#$'% - + , & )"%%%( ' !"%%% $ + , # !"%%%$ - 3 - * !"#% " * * . "#"%' *+, !"#"%' & *+, * "#'$ # * * !"#"% ( *+, % * !"#"% % * - 4 - "#"'% * !"# ' * !"&&'% $ * !"#"%' *+, " * *+, "' !"#"%' *+, !"#$% - + + ,/ '0$/ * * - 5 - * #/ / $/ ''%' "&(%0' , '' ''& '%% '"%('%( .)) * %(%#'%' '%&'%' .) '%&'%' * 12 3* 3* * - 6 - + 3* , 45675859:65:;:;<94=8>559?;@5AB=@@;9C;9DE58:;<9 :45F=@;A;:G<? 995HE75)I4;B4;8:459<:;?;B=:;<9A=:5A '"%('%( 6=885A >G :45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 =79=:=K= :=:5 AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 7;>E9=@ =: 59C=@E7E L1 2M 75@=:;9C :< J=::578 :4=: 84=@@ 9<: >5 59:57:=;95A >G >59B458<? =:5@=C=F;=9A=@=>E7=C;5:;:;<9578 4=F5 =@8< B4=@@59C5A :45 <7A57 6=885A ;9 66@;B=:;<9 <'%&'%' =: 995HE75) I4575>G :45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@ >G =9 =AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 <7A57 4=A 6<8:5A :45 =66@;B=:;<98 >5?<75 <E7: =@@) =@<9C I;:4 66@;B=:;<9 <8'%&:<'%&#<?'%' 5:;:;<9578 4=F5 8<EC4: ?<7 ;88E=9B5 <? I7;: ;9 :45 9=:E75<?J=9A=JE8:<A;75B::457;>E9=@=:59C=@E7E:< :7=98?57 :45 66@;B=:;<9 <'%&'%' :< ;:8 =@=>E7=C; >59B4 ' : ;8 :45 B=85 J=A5 <E: <9 >54=@? <? :45 65:;:;<9578I4<=75=66@;B=9:8>5?<75:45=@=>E7=C;>59B4 - 7 - :4=: :45G =75 =CC7;5F5A >G :45 <7A57 I;:4A7=I;9C :45;7 =66@;B=:;<9 659A;9C >5?<75 :45 7;>E9=@ =: =@=>E7=C; >59B4=9AJ=K;9C;:<F57:<<E7: =@@)<?:457;9B;6=@ 59B4:<>5A5B;A5AI;:4<:457=66@;B=:;<98 $ =7;<E8 @5C=@ B<9:59:;<98 4=F5 >559 E7C5A ;9B@EA;9C :4=: :45 6<I57 <? A;8:7;>E:;<9 <? I<7K =J<9C8: :45 >59B458 ;8 <95 F58:5A I;:4 :45 <F579J59: =9A :45 7;>E9=@B=99<:59B7<=B4E6<98EB46<I57:4=:;8F58:5A 8<@5@GI;:4:45<F579J59::I=88E>J;::5A<9>54=@?<? :45 65:;:;<9578 :4=: :45 5??5B: <? :7=98?577;9C :45 J=::578 659A;9C >5?<75 =@=>E7=C; >59B4 :< 59C=@E7E >59B4 I;@@ 4=F5:455??5B:<?A5?5=:;9C:456E76<85<?8;:;9C<?>59B4 =: =@=>E7=C; =9A I<E@A >5 675NEA;B;=@ :< :45 ;9:5758: <? @;:;C=9:8 8EB4 =8 :45 65:;:;<9578 4575;9 : ;8 ?E7:457 B<9:59A5A:4=::459<:;?;B=:;<9;88E5A>G:454=;7J=9<? :45 =79=:=K= :=:5 AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 7;>E9=@ A=:5A '"%('%( ;8 ;9 B<9:7=F59:;<9 <? 5B:;<9 #+, <? :45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 7;>E9=@8 B: =9A ;: ;8 8:=:5A :4=: :45 5H57B;85 <? 6<I57 E9A57 5B:;<9 #+', <? :45 - 8 - AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 7;>E9=@8 B: >G :45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@I<E@A=7;85<9@G;?:4575;8=9G=J>;CE;:G;9:45 A;8:7;>E:;<9 =8 75C=7A8 :< :45 <7A57 <? :45 <F579J59: E9A57 5B:;<9 #+, <? :45 B: BB<7A;9C@G ;: ;8 8:=:5A :4=::459<:;?;B=:;<9A=:5A'"%('%(;859B7<=B4J59:<? 6<I57<?:45<F579J59:E9A575B:;<9#+,<?:45 B: =7;<E8<:457B<9:59:;<984=F5>559E7C5A 98<?=7 =8 :45 J57;:8 <? :45 J=::57 ;8 B<9B5795A ;: ;8 8E>J;::5A :4=: :45 67<J<:;<9 @;8: I=8 5??5B:5A I;:4<E: B<98;A57;9C :45 <>N5B:;<98 J=A5 >G :45 65:;:;<9578 =9A =BB<7A;9C@G :45G 4=A =667<=B45A :45 7;>E9=@B4=@@59C;9C:45F=@;A;:G<?8EB467<J<:;<9@;8: " 586<9A59: < 4=F5 ?;@5A :45;7 A5:=;@5A 8:=:5J59:<?<>N5B:;<98=9A;:;8B<9:59A5A:4=::45<7A57 6=885A>G:454=;7J=9<?:457;>E9=@<9%"%#'%'=: 6=7=)( ;8 =9 <7A57 :4=: ;8 6=885A ;9 5H57B;85 <? 6<I57 E9A57 5B:;<9 '" <? :45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 7;>E9=@8 B: =9A 8EB4 <7A57 I=8 6=885A I4;@5 9<:;B;9C :4=: =66@;B=:;<98 I575 659A;9C >5?<75 :45 5@=C=F; >59B4 =8 I5@@ =9A - 9 - =BB<7A;9C@G <7A57 :4=: I=8 6=885A E9A57 6=7=)( JE8: >5 B<98:7E5A =8 <95 >5;9C 6=885A ;9 5H57B;85 <? 6<I57 E9A575B:;<9'"<?:45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F57;>E9=@8 B: : ;8 :< >5 9<:;B5A :4=: I;:4<E: 59:57;9C ;9:< A5:=;@5A?=B:8=9A@5C=@B<9:59:;<98E7C5A:45<9@G6<;9: ?<7 B<98;A57=:;<9 :4=: =7;858 >5?<75 :4;8 <E7: ;8 I45:457 :45 <7A57 6=885A <9 :45 =AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 8;A5 ;8 :45 <7A57 I4575;9 :45 =66@;B=:;<9 ?;@5A =9A 659A;9C >5?<75 :45 =@=>E7=C; >59B4 <? :45 7;>E9=@ <? :45 65:;:;<9578 I=8 I;:4A7=I9=9AJ=A5<F57:<<E7: =@@)<?:457;9B;6=@ 59B4 ;9 5H57B;85 <? 6<I57 E9A57 5B:;<9 '" <? :45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F57;>E9=@8 B:;8:<>58E8:=;95A & A5:=;@5A 657E8=@ <? :45 9<:5 8455: =: 995HE75)?;@5AI;:4:458:=:5J59:<?<>N5B:;<98I<E@A ;9A;B=:5:4=:;:I=8>7<EC4::<:459<:;B5<?:454=;7J=9 <?:457;>E9=@75C=7A;9C:45B@=7;?;B=:;<98<EC4:?<7>G:45 >59B4<?7;>E9=@=:=@=>E7=C;=9A:45<>857F=:;<98J=A5 ;9 :45 <7A57 <? '%&'%' I=8 =@8< A5:=;@5A ;9 :45 9<:5 - 10 - 8455:EB4<7A57<?:457;>E9=@A=:5A'%&'%'75=A8 =84575E9A57 ! "# $ %"& '$( $ $ ' !! )' *$ +* ! % ,- '$ . ! ' !$ $ -$/ $ 0% $*( ' *1 $- '$ ' ! %#2 ' 3$ $ )' ),$* '$ 4 1 ' $*$ $ 5$ 3 +* ! ' $*$ ,- '$ ' *$-( ' .$ 61$,$7$$$/$ ( *1 ' ' $*$ '$. *$- .$ 61$,$7$$$/$ )' $*$ $ -$$$,* ,! ' ,' -*$*1 $ $$' ' 8*$($. 8' 9' ' $*$ '$. , $ ,1 ' 8*$($. 8' ! . ! ' $,. $ ,- $1 / *$!$ !- ' 6:,* - 11 - +'$-$ $ '' ' 8' '$.( 4 $ ' $*$ - ($ $* ',1 0 ** 0 $ ! '$( 5$ +* ! ' $*$ !* ,4 3$- $/ " ' -$ ;< # :;8>GF;7:E5<?:4;8<7A57:4=::457;>E9=@=: :45 =@=>E7=C; >59B4 4=A 9<:;B5A :4=: =66@;B=:;<98 4=F5 >559 59:57:=;95A >G :45 5@=C=F; >59B4 ;9 66@;B=:;<9 <8%#&0%##'%'=9A:=K;9C9<:5<?:458=J5;: I=8 ?<E9A 95B588=7G :< 855K B@=7;?;B=:;<9 ?7<J :45 4=;7J=9=8:<I45:457:45=@=>E7=C;>59B4I=84=F;9C NE7;8A;B:;<9:<59:57:=;9:45675859:=66@;B=:;<9459<:5 8455: ?E7:457 I<E@A ;9A;B=:5 :4=: :45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@4=8:=K599<:5<?8EB4<>857F=:;<9J=A5>G:45 =@=>E7=C;>59B4=9A4=8=@8<:=K599<:5<?659A59BG<? =66@;B=:;<98>5?<75:455@=C=F;>59B4=8I5@@=8657:45 9<:58455: ?:579<:;B;9C:458=J5:454=;7J=9<?:45 - 12 - 7;>E9=@ ?;9=@@G <7A578 ?<7 6<8:;9C 66@;B=:;<9 <'%'%' >5?<75 <E7: =@@ < : JE8: >5 9<:;B5A :4=: 66@;B=:;<9 <'%'%' I=8 B<995B:5A I;:4 66@;B=:;<9 <8'%&)'%&#'%' : JE8: >5 9<:;B5A :4=: =8 <>857F5A =><F5 :45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@ I=8 =667=;85A <? :45 <>857F=:;<98 J=A5 >G :45 7;>E9=@ =: =@=>E7=C; >59B4 75C=7A;9C J=::578 =@75=AG 659A;9C>5?<75:455@=C=F;>59B4 ( ?:4=:I575:<>58<:45<7A576=885A>G:45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@ ;8 <95 E9A57 5B:;<9 '" <? :45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F57;>E9=@8 B:=9A:4=:;84<I:45<7A57;8:< >5 B<98:7E5A;8=@8<:458E>J;88;<9J=A5 >G B<E985@?<7 4=;7J=9<?:457;>E9=@:;88E>J;::5A:4=::4<EC49< 865B;?;B 67<F;8;<9 ?<7 5H57B;85 <? 6<I57 ;8 6<;9:5A <E: =8 >5;9C:7=B5A:<=6=7:;BE@=785B:;<9;9:45675859:B=85;: JE8: >5 B<98:7E5A :4=: :45 <7A57 <? :45 7;>E9=@ B<98<@;A=:;9C:45=66@;B=:;<98:<:457;9B;6=@59B4;8<95 :4=: B<E@A >5 :7=B5A :< 5B:;<9 '" <? :45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 7;>E9=@8 B: 459 6<I57 ;8 =F=;@=>@5 :4<EC4 ;: ;8 9<: - 13 - 8:;6E@=:5A E9A57 I4;B4 8:=:E:<7G 67<F;8;<9 8EB4 6<I57 ;8 >5;9C5H57B;85A;?;:B<E@A>5:7=B5A:<=B57:=;98:=:E:<7G 67<F;8;<98EB45H57B;85<?6<I57;8:<>5E645@A % 9 :45 675859: B=85 I;:4<E: 59:57;9C ;9:< :45 <:457B<9:59:;<98:=K;9C9<:5:4=:J=::578I575659A;9C >5?<75 :45 5@=C=F; >59B4 =8 I5@@ ;9 @;C4: <? I4;B4 :45 7;>E9=@ =: =@=>E7=C; >59B4 4=A 7=;85A = DE57G ?<7 B@=7;?;B=:;<9 >5?<75 :45 4=;7J=9 B<98<@;A=:;9C 8EB4 =66@;B=:;<98>GJ=K;9C<F57=@@=66@;B=:;<98:<:457;9B;6=@ 59B4 <E7: 4=@@) ;9B@EA;9C =8 75C=7A8 :4<85 J=::578 659A;9C >5?<75 :45 5@=C=F; >59B4 9<:;B;9C :4=: :45 8E>N5B:J=::57I=8;A59:;B=@JE8:>5B<98:7E5A8:7;B:@G:< >5=9<7A57;95H57B;85<?6<I57E9A575B:;<9'"<?:45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F57;>E9=@8 B:45 65H<E7:;9:45B=85 <? 4=8E645@A 5H57B;8;9C<?6<I57E9A575B:;<9'"<?:45 AJ;9;8:7=:;F5 7;>E9=@8 B: 4<EC4 85F57=@ B<9:59:;<98 4=F5 >559 7=;85A;9B@EA;9C:4=::45B=85;9 => 3++ - 14 - 4=8 >559 75?5775A :< = @=7C57 >59B4 ;: JE8:>59<:;B5A:4=::45DE58:;<9<?75?5759B5=665=78:< >5<9:45J=;9:=;9=>;@;:G<?=I7;:65:;:;<9>5?<75:45<E7: =9AI4;B4DE58:;<94=8>5597=;85A=9A9<:=875C=7A8:< =9=865B:<?5H57B;8;9C<?6<I57E9A575B:;<9'">G:45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@ 5 955A 9<: 59:57 ;9:< =9G <:457 B<9:59:;<98 7=;85A ;9B@EA;9C F=@;A;:G <? :45 9<:;?;B=:;<9B4=@@59C5A>G:4565:;:;<9578:;8:4585::@5A 6<8;:;<9<?@=II459=J=::57B<E@A>5A;86<85A<?I;:4<E: 59:57;9C;9:<:45F=@;A;:G<?=9<:;?;B=:;<9:45<E7:<EC4: :<=F<;A59:57;9C;9:<:45F=@;A;:G<?:459<:;?;B=:;<9=9A=8 7;C4:@G6<;9:5A<E:;9:45675859:B=85:45B<9:7<F578GB=9 >5 758<@F5A 8<@5@G <9 6<I57 <? :45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@E9A575B:;<9'" =F;9C 45@A :4=: :45 4=;7J=9 <? :45 7;>E9=@ 4=85H57B;85A6<I57E9A575B:;<9'"<?:457;>E9=@8 B: :<I;:4A7=I:45=66@;B=:;<98>5?<75:455@=C=F;>59B4=8 I5@@ =8 =@=>E7=C; >59B4 =9A J=K;9C :4<85 =66@;B=:;<98 <F57 :< :45 67;9B;6=@ >59B4 :< =F<;A 6=88;9C <? A;F57C59: - 15 - =9AB<9?@;B:;9C<7A5789<<BB=8;<9=7;858:<59:57;9:<:45 F=@;A;:G<?:459<:;?;B=:;<9=9A:58:;9C:458=J5=875C=7A8 :45 @5C=@ B<9:59:;<98 7=;85A 75C=7A;9C 5B:;<9 # <? :45 B: BB<7A;9C@G:4565:;:;<9;875N5B:5A !*+ (!! # ') $ !*+ ($! ) $ ;8: <@ <'& )