- 1 - ! " #$! % #$!! $"" &'(&)"*+ ,&* +- $"" (, + - !"#$%$ &'"$ ( ) *+&%,+%$# +,+%$! - Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ,." $%. / &, 0 - *+&%,+%$# +,+%$!0 $ ,."$%. (,+ $ / + &'"$ ( ) *+&%,+%$# +$++%$& - &%+ /&,0 - *+&%,+%$# +$++%$&0 + ( & &%+ /&, / * - 3 - * 1 1 !$ *1 23 4543 256 78393883: 42363 57735;6 5<5=>64 423 ?@:<A3>4 75663: => B+$++%$& 5>: B+,+%$! :543:+&%,+%$#)C423;358>3: ::=4=B>5; 366=B>6 @:<3 2383=>594388393883:4B56D;358>3:366=B>6@:<3E9B862B84 =?5C57@85 F2383)C 423 ;358>3: 366=B>6 256 5GH@=443: 423 5773;;5>465GG@63: B6$ 4B & 9B8 423 B993>G36 7@>=625);3 @>:383G4=B>6,."I$%.&%+8FF=42&,B9 + 235)8=:<3:95G46B9423G563583569B;;BF6* 23A588=5<3)34F33>5GG@63:B$5>::3G3563:=>42=6 G563 A3385 58J33> F56 63GB>: A588=5<3 56 238 9=864 2@6)5>:25::=JB8G3:4=69@84238G563B942378B63G@4=B>4254 5GG@63: B$ F56 =;;I48354=>< :3G3563: A3385 38J33> )C 258566=>< 238 )B42 72C6=G5;;C 5>: A3>45;;C )C :3A5>:=>< AB>3C 98BA 238 9B8 2=6 )5: J=G36 > 42=6 )5GK<8B@>: B> $!%#+%$&54$,!7A4235GG@63:B$25:=>64=<543:2=6 6@)IB8:=>5436=35GG@63:B6+5>:&4BGBAA=4423A@8:38 - 4 - B92=6F=93A338558J33>GGB8:=><;C=>9@842385>G3B9423 =>64=<54=B> )C 5GG@63: B$ 5GG@63: B6+ 5>: & G5A3 B> 5 AB4B8 GCG;3 )3;B><=>< 4B 5GG@63: B$ 5>: 5665@;43: A3385 58J33>F2=;3623F56834@8>=><2BA398BA23845=;B8=><G;566 4=664543:42545GG@63:B+5665@;43:238F=42)563)5;;)54 B>423)5GK7B84=B>B9238235:5>: 5GG@63:B&F568=:=>< 423 AB4B8 GCG;3 @3 4B 423 5665@;4 623 93;; B> 423 8B5: 5>: 4238359438 6@GG@A)3: 4B 423 =>?@8=36 4 =6 423 G563 B9 423 78B63G@4=B>425459438423=>G=:3>45GG@63:B$G5;;3:/$ F2B=64236B>B9:3G3563:A33858J33>5>:=>9B8A3:2=A 42542=6AB4238F565665@;43:)C6BA3)B:C5>:623F56;C=>< B>4238B5:>6@G2=>9B8A54=B>/$8@623:4B42367B45>: 62=943: 238 4B 2B67=45; => 5> A)@;5>G3 2BF3J38 623 6@GG@A)3: 4B 423 =>?@8=36 238359438 23 ;B:<3: 5 GBA7;5=>4 5<5=>642=6954238=35GG@63:B$B>6@67=G=B>56738L$ & >4236483><42B965=:GBA7;5=>4423GBA7;5=>5>4I B;=G383<=64383:5G5635<5=>645GG@63:B$5>:4FBB42386=> 8=A3 B",+%$& :543: $!%#+%$& 9B8 423 B993>G36 7@>=625);3 @>:38 3G4=B>6 ,."I $%. &%+ 835: F=42 3G4=B> &, B9 238359438 423 >J364=<54=B> 99=G38 GB>:@G43: =>J364=<54=B>5>:83GB8:3:42364543A3>4B9/!F2BF56423 - 5 - GBIFB8K38B9423:3G3563:A338558J33>5>:F565;B><F=42 238544234=A3B9=>G=:3>46B5;6B42364543A3>4B9/'5> 3C3F=4>366 4B 423 =>G=:3>4 @)63H@3>4;C 5GG@63: F383 5883643:5>:)563:B>423=8JB;@>458C64543A3>4423F357B>6 @63:=>423GBAA=66=B>B9423G8=A383GBJ383:54423=8=>645>G3 @>:38 A525M58 L$# @)63H@3>4;C 59438 83GB8:=>< 423 64543A3>4 B9 423 A5438=5; F=4>36636 6B 5;6B B)45=>=>< 423 :BG@A3>46 98BA 423 GB>G38>3: 5@42B8=4C /$$ ;5=: 423 G258<362334)39B83423GBAA=445;B@84 , 9438 GBAA=445; B9 423 G563 )39B83 423 366=B>6 B@84423;358>3:366=B>6@:<3985A3:423G258<365<5=>64 4235GG@63:9B842359B83A3>4=B>3:B993>G365>:835:BJ38423 65A3 4B 423 5GG@63: 23 65A3 F56 :3>=3: )C 423 5GG@63: 5>:423CG;5=A3:4B)348=3: ! > B8:38 4B 78BJ3 423 G258<36 ;3J3;;3: 5<5=>64 423 5GG@63: )39B83 423 366=B>6 B@84 423 78B63G@4=B> => 4B45; 3L5A=>3:$$F=4>3663656/$4B/$$5>:<B4A58K3:+# :BG@A3>4656L6$4B+#6B5;6B<B4=:3>4=9=3:$$A5438=5; B)?3G4656$4B$$ - 6 - # B64566366A3>4B9B85;5>::BG@A3>458C3J=:3>G3 423 ;358>3: 366=B>6 @:<3 5GH@=443: 423 5GG@63: 9B8 423 G258<36;3J3;;3:5<5=>64423A=>423GBAAB>?@:<A3>475663: =>B+$++%$&5>:B+,+%$!2365=:?@:<A3>4=6 G25;;3><3:)C4234543=>4236357735;6=38=A=>5; 7735; B+%%$'.+%$# 5<5=>64 423 ?@:<A3>4 75663: => B+$++%$&5>:8=A=>5;7735;B+%%$#,+%$#5<5=>64 423?@:<A3>475663:=>B+,+%$! ' /3 25J3 2358: 8= =::5;=>< 54=; ;358>3: ::=4=B>5; 4543 @);=G 8B63G@4B8 9B8 423 5773;;5>44543 6B 5;6B 8= 5<5;= ;358>3: GB@>63; 9B8 423 8367B>:3>465GG@63: " 8= =::5;=>< 54=; ;358>3: ::; FB@;: GB>43>: 4254 423 ?@:<A3>4 @>:38 42363 57735;6 6@99386 98BA 738J386=4C5>:=;;3<5;=4C6=>G3423;358>3:366=B>6@:<395=;3: 4B57783G=5434233J=:3>G3B>83GB8:=>58=<24738673G4=J35>: 5GH@=443:4235GG@63:=>67=43B978B63G@4=B>7;5G=><6@99=G=3>4 3J=:3>G34B78BJ3423G258<36;3J3;;3:5<5=>644235GG@63:3 FB@;:9@842386@)A=4425442378B63G@4=B>25678BJ3:4235G4B9 5GG@63: )C 7;5G=>< 423 3J=:3>G3 B9 3C3F=4>36636 =3 /! - 7 - 5>:/'23634FBF=4>3663625J3G543<B8=G5;;C64543:5)B@4 423 =>G=:3>4 GBAA=443: )C 423 5GG@63: @84238 /$ )3=>< 423 6B> B9 :3G3563: ;B:<3: 423 GBA7;5=>4 6BB> 59438 423 =>G=:3>4 )C A3>4=B>=>< 423 >5A3 B9 2=6 954238 =3 5GG@63: B$ 5>: B4238 4FB 7386B>6 23 GB>43>46 B9 L$ G;358;C GB88B)B85436 4B 423 B85; 4364=AB>C B9 /$ 23 78B63G@4=B> 5;6B7;5G3:4233J=:3>G3B9/#423)8B4238B9:3G3563:> 6@G2 G=8G@A645>G3 423 ;358>3: 366=B>6 @:<3 F=42B@4 78B738;C57783G=54=><4233J=:3>G3B942363A5438=5;F=4>36636 )C 83;C=>< B> 6@8A=636 5>: GB>?3G4@83 5GH@=443: 423 5GG@63: 9B8423G258<36;3J3;;3:5<5=>64423AGGB8:=><;C23785C64B 63456=:3423=A7@<>3:?@:<A3>475663:)C423366=B>6B@84 )C5;;BF=><423634FB57735;65>:5;6B4BGB>J=G44235GG@63: 9B8423G258<36;3J3;;3:5<5=>64423A . 8= 5<5;= ;358>3: GB@>63; 9B8 423 8367B>:3>465GG@63: FB@;: 6@)A=4 4254 423 ;358>3: 366=B>6 @:<3 59438 A34=G@;B@6;C 3L5A=>=>< 423 3J=:3>G3 B> 83GB8: 75663: 5 F3;; 8356B>3: ?@:<A3>4 F2=G2 :B36 >B4 G5;; 9B8 5>C =>4389383>G3 GGB8:=>< 4B 2=A /! 3C3F=4>366 4B 423 =>G=:3>47584=5;;C4@8>3:2B64=;35>:623F56@>5);34B=:3>4=9C 423 5665=;5>46 @84238 423 3J=:3>G3 B9 /' B>3 AB83 - 8 - 3C3F=4>366 5;6B 6@99386 98BA 63J383 =>9=8A=4=36 =6 64543A3>4 F5683GB8:3:)C423GBA7;5=>5>4IB;=G359438&:5C698BA423 :543B9=>G=:3>4B5;6BB>738@65;B92=63J=:3>G3=4GB@;:)3 356=;CGB>G;@:3:425423=65G25>G3F=4>3664B42378B63G@4=B> 23 65=: 5673G4 F56 42B8B@<2;C 3L5A=>3: )C 423 ;358>3: 366=B>6 @:<3 23 ;358>3: GB@>63; FB@;: 9@84238 GB>43>: 4254 A@G2 3J=:3>4=58C J5;@3 G5>>B4 )3 5445G23: 4B 423 3J=:3>G3B9/$5>:/#6=>G3423C583235865CF=4>36636 4B423=>G=:3>4@8423842=6)3=><42357735;65<5=>645GH@=445; ?@:<A3>456738423;5F;5=::BF>)C423B>E);373LB@84 =>G543>5B9?@:<A3>464235773;;543B@84A@64633F234238 423 J=3F 45K3> )C 423 366=B>6 GB@84 F2=;3 5GH@=44=>< 5> 5GG@63:8356B>5);C45K3>B>423)56=6B93J=:3>G3B>83GB8: >42=6G563423J=3F45K3>)C423366=B>6B@84=67B66=);3 J=3F 56 6@G2 =>4389383>G3 =6 >B4 G5;;3: 9B8 GGB8:=><;C 23 785C64B:=6A=6642357735; $% 5J=><2358:423;358>3:GB@>63;9B842383673G4=J3 7584=366B5;6B25J=><738@63:4233>4=833J=:3>G3B>83GB8: 423B>;C7B=>44254FB@;:58=639B8B@8GB>6=:3854=B>=6* - 9 - $$ /3 25J3 G5839@;;C 738@63: 423 3>4=83 3J=:3>G3 B> 83GB8: > B8:38 4B 3645);=62 423 G258<36 ;3J3;;3: 5<5=>64 423 5GG@63:42378B63G@4=B>2563L5A=>3:$$F=4>36636)39B83423 366=B>6 B@84 > B8:38 4B 78BJ3 423 2BA=G=:5; :3542 B9 423 :3G3563: A3385 58J33> 423 78B63G@4=B> 783:BA=>5>4;C 83;=3:B>4233J=:3>G3B9/.I8 5A36254=;F2BGB>:@G43: 423 5@4B76C B> 423 GB8763 B9 423 :3G3563: 5>: =66@3: 423 7B64AB843A837B8456738L+%>738@65;B9L+%/. 256B7=>3:4254423:3542=6:@34BDGBA5565836@;4B9=>?@8=36 6@645=>3: B> 235:E @84238 423 78B63G@4=B> 5;6B 83;=3: B> =>H@36475>G25>5A5GB>:@G43:B>423GB8763B9423:3G3563: )C /$$ 56 738 L, 6 GB@;: )3 633> 98BA L, 423 >J364=<54=B> 99=G38 /, B)638J3: 56 A5>C 56 >=>3 =>?@8=36 B>423GB8763B9423:3G3563:@84238/!423F=4>366F2B F56 => 423 GBA75>C B9 423 :3G3563: 54 423 4=A3 B9 =>G=:3>4 64543: => 238 3J=:3>G3 4254 6BA3 @>K>BF> 7386B>6 5665@;43: 423 :3G3563: 5>: :@3 4B 423 65A3 423 :3G3563: 93;; B> 423 8B5: 5>: 6@645=>3: =>?@8=36 B> 238 235: 5>: 4238359438 6@GG@A)3: 4B 423 =>?@8=36 > 6@G2 G=8G@A645>G3 => B@8 - 10 - GB>6=:383: J=3F 423 78B63G@4=B> 256 78BJ3: 423 2BA=G=:5; :3542B9423:3G3563:)3CB>:8356B>5);3:B@)4 $+ BF3J38 4B GB>>3G4 423 5GG@63: => 423 59B8365=: 2BA=G=:5; :3542 B9 423 :3G3563: 423 78B63G@4=B> 256 A5=>;C 83;=3:B>4233J=:3>G3B9/$=34236B>B9:3G3563:F2B ;B:<3:423GBA7;5=>456738L$4233J=:3>G3B9/#F2B =6423A5438>5;@>G;3B9/$6B5;6B4233J=:3>G3B9/6! 5>: ' 423 3C3F=4>36636 4B 423 =>G=:3>4 > 738@65; B9 423 3J=:3>G3 B9 /$ 5>: /# 423 65A3 :37=G46 4254 5GG@63: B$ F56 423 2@6)5>: B9 :3G3563: 5>: => 423 C358 +%$$ 23 :=JB8G3: 238 5>: 4238359438 23 F56 >B@8=62=>< =;;IF=;; 5<5=>64 423:3G3563:>423:543B9=>G=:3>45GGB8:=><4B/$23 F56=>9B8A3:)C5GG@63:B$428B@<2AB)=;372B>34254423 :3G3563: F56 5665@;43: 5>: F56 ;C=>< B> 423 8B5: > 4@8> /$ =>9B8A3: 423 65A3 4B /# F2B 8@623: 4B 423 67B4 5>:65F423=>?@83:2B@<2/#62=943:2384B4232B67=45; 623 6@GG@A)3: 4B 423 =>?@8=36 /# 5;6B :37B63: 4254 59438 423=>G=:3>423G5A34BK>BF5)B@4423=>G=:3>4428B@<2/$ >6@G2G=8G@A645>G34233J=:3>G3B9/6$5>:#2564B)3 483543: 56 235865C 3J=:3>G3 4B 423 =>G=:3>4 @84238 => 423 - 11 - G8B663L5A=>54=B>B9/#=4=6G;358;C64543:4254=>423C358 +%$$=463;94235GG@63:B$:=JB8G3:423:3G3563: $& 23 78B63G@4=B> 5;6B 83;=3: B> 423 3J=:3>G3 B9 /!5>:/'4233C3F=4>366364B423=>G=:3>4>738@65; B9 423 3J=:3>G3 B9 /! F2B F56 F=42 423 GBA75>C B9 :3G3563:B>423:543B9=>G=:3>4623256G543<B8=G5;;C64543: 42546BA3@>K>BF>7386B>65665@;43:423:3G3563:5>::@34B 423 65A3 623 6@645=>3: =>?@8=36 B> 238 235: 5>: 93;; B> 423 8B5:23835943862323;73:4B62=94423=>?@83:4B4232B67=45; F23836236@GG@A)3:4B423=>?@8=363>G3=4=6G;3584254623 F56@>5);34B=:3>4=9C4235665=;5>46B>42367B4B>423:543B9 =>G=:3>4 2B@<2 423 78B63G@4=B> 78B?3G43: /' 56 5> 3C3F=4>3664B423=>G=:3>4B>G5839@;738@65;B94233J=:3>G3B9 /'54423B@46342=664543A3>4F5683GB8:3:)C423B;=G3 59438 & :5C6 98BA 423 :543 B9 =>G=:3>4 =3 B> $"%#+%$& 2B@<22325664543:=>2=63J=:3>G342542325:F=4>3663:423 =>G=:3>4B95665@;4)C5GG@63:B+5>:&4B423:3G3563:F=42 .F2=;323F5678BG33:=><4B5443>:5F3::=><9@>G4=B>B> 5AB4B8GCG;32BF3J38=>423G8B663L5A=>54=B>2325664543: 4254 2=A63;9 5>: /+% F383 78BG33:=>< 4B 5443>: 423 A588=5<3 )C F5;K B> 4254 :5C 5>: F=4>3663: 423 =>G=:3>4 - 12 - 3J38423;3662364543:4254 23F56423G;B6398=3>:B9/# 5>:A342=A63J385;4=A3659438423=>G=:3>4>67=43B94254 2395=;3:4B=>9B8A4235G4GBAA=443:)C4235GG@63:3=42384B /#B84B423B;=G39B85738=B:B9&:5C6@8423842383=65 638=B@6:=6G8375>GC=>2=63J=:3>G3GBA7583:4B2=664543A3>4 83GB8:3:@>:383G4=B>$#$8>6@G2G=8G@A645>G3423 3J=:3>G3 B9 /' 5773586 4B )3 :B@)49@; => 83673G4 B9 2=6 78363>G3B>4236G3>3B9BGG@883>G3544234=A3B9=>G=:3>43 6@::3>;C 5773586 => 423 67B4 5>: 4238359438 :=65773586 9B8 5 738=B: B9 42833 :5C6 5>: 2=6 64543A3>4 F56 83GB8:3: 4238359438 2=6 J386=B> B9 /' 78BJ36 4254 23 =6 5 G25>G3 F=4>3664B423=>G=:3>466@G2B>G5839@;3L5A=>54=B>B9423 3J=:3>G3 B9 /6! 5>: ' 423 3C3F=4>36636 4B 423 =>G=:3>4 423=83J=:3>G3G5>>B4)3)3;=3J3:565<B673;48@424B78BJ3423 G258<36 ;3J3;;3: 5<5=>64 423 5GG@63: J3> B4238F=63 423 ;358>3: 366=B>6 @:<3 F2=;3 57783G=54=>< 423 3J=:3>G3 B> 83GB8: => 423 =A7@<>3: ?@:<A3>4 B)638J3: 4254 GB>:@G4 B9 /'=3>B4A3>4=B>=><B9423=>G=:3>43=42384B/#B84B 423B;=G39B85738=B:B942833:5C6G8354365638=B@6:B@)4=> 2=6J386=B>LG37442363F=4>3663642378B63G@4=B>25695=;3: - 13 - 4B7;5G35>CB423883;=5);33J=:3>G34BGB>>3G44235GG@63:=> 4235;;3<3:G8=A3 $, 2378B63G@4=B>5;6B95=;3:4B3645);=6283GBJ38CB9 F357B>6F2=G265=:256)33>@63:9B8GBAA=66=B>B9G8=A3)C 78BJ=>< L, => 5GGB8:5>G3 F=42 ;5F F=42=> 423 5A)=4 B9 3G4=B>+'B9423>:=5>J=:3>G3G456738423;5F;5=::BF> )C 423 B>E);3 73L B@84 => 423 G563 B9 3>G3B>BJ385;;738@65;B94233>4=83 3J=:3>G3 B> 83GB8: 423 78B63G@4=B> 256 95=;3: 4B 7;5G3 6@99=G=3>4 3J=:3>G3 4B 78BJ3 423 <@=;4 B9 5GG@63: )3CB>: 8356B>5);3:B@)4 $! 2=6 )3=>< 5> 57735; 5<5=>64 423 5GH@=445; 423 B>E);373LB@84=>423G563B9 !"" # 6@AA58=M3:42378=>G=7;364B3L38G=63 423 7BF38 )C 423 5773;;543 B@84 4B =>4389383 => 423 B8:38 B9 366=B>6B@84=>7585<8572B.56@>:38* !" # ! "" " $%&%%'' "()**+ %(%&%,)-*$ - 14 - . " / " " ! # "" 0" 1 2 ! " 3"" " . 2 ! " " 4 " .! "" 0 " 0 5 " 0 "! " " 0 $# @84238 423 B>E);3 73L B@84 => 423 G563 B9 $%%&&" # '(F2=;39@84238 6@AA58=M=>< 423 78=>G=7;36 => :35;=>< F=42 423 57735; 5<5=>64 5GH@=445;=>7585<8572B,+23;:56@>:38* 6%4 1 ,(%&%6),-66 - 15 - "! . " " 7 8 ()1 9 ! : () : () 5 ! ! " " ! ": () 5 " "! " : () 5 2 ! : ()5 ! ! " $' 3>G3 B> G5839@; 738@65; B9 423 5)BJ3 ;5F ;5=: :BF> )C 423 B>E);3 73L B@84 5>: 423 3J=:3>G3 7;5G3: )C - 16 - 423 78B63G@4=B> => 423 =>645>4 G563 F3 583 B9 423 GB>6=:383: J=3F425442378B63G@4=B>25695=;3:4B7;5G36@99=G=3>43J=:3>G3 4B 78BJ3 423 G258<36 ;3J3;;3: 5<5=>64 423 5GG@63: )3CB>: 5;; 8356B>5);3 :B@)4 > 4254 J=3F B9 423 A54438 F3 :3G;=>3 4B =>4389383 => 423 =A7@<>3: ?@:<A3>4 75663: )C 423 366=B>6 B@84 GGB8:=><;C F3 5>6F38 423 7B=>4 85=63: 5)BJ3 => 423 >3<54=J35>:78BG33:4B75664239B;;BF=><* 23 8=A=>5; 7735;6 9=;3: )C 423 4543 583 "))" )3=><:3JB=:B9A38=46 .+ & %* ! .+ &! * ! / =64B*$;B*&! *