Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11335 (KAR)
SRI.CHANDERKANTH v. BASWARAJ AND ANR
MFA/201890/2017 · 2025-01-27
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11335 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11335 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"
$
#! #! !!%%&
' ( )
! "## $
%
&
# # ! '
((
! "#
$ # (')
%
( (
*$ % ( #
##
&
' !+'! * # , --'! &
&(
#
( !!!!! '. Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
## (
&
/&
&
# $# /&
&%
01234,56351,7839:53;4,<56389==39:>5?7,:@,12 123 =9:1>36 123 A9113: >6 19B35 <= 7,: 7>598 ;>6=,698 12,<?2>1>668913;7,:9;A>66>,5 ' 2>6 9==398 >6 ;>:3413; 9?9>561 123 C<;?A351 95;9D9:;;913;' !+'! *=9663;>5 , --'! @0 123 839:53; 35>,: >E>8 &<;?3 95; &( <:9; $23:3>59713::373::3;1,96F G7,:62,:1%
23 7941<98 A91:>H ,7 123 4963 >6 1291 ,5 ' '! 123=31>1>,53:D96=:,433;>5?1,
,:59E>889?3 ,52>6A,1,:40483@39:>5? , (*--95;919@,<1 !!! 9A 9 4:<>63: &33= @39:>5? , ' +- 49A3 7:,A ,==,6>13 ;>:341>,5 >5 :962 95; 53?8>?351 A9553:95;4,88>;3;D>12123A,1,:40483,7123=31>1>,53: 49<6>5?2>A1,7988;,D595;6<619>5?:>3E,<6>5C<:>361>6
- 3 -
4,5135;3; 1291 23 29; 6<773:3; 123 7:941<:3 ,7 123 :>?21 1>@>9 95; 7>@<89 95; 23 D96 62>713; 1, ;90?>:> A<81> 6=34>9810 2,6=>198 D23:3 23 <5;3:D351 ,=35 :3;<41>,5 >513:598 7>H91>,5 $(% ,7 123 @:,B35 @,536 3 D96 >5=91>3511>88!+ ''! $ ;906%
23=31>1>,53:489>A3;
129123D969
;:>E3:95;232966<773:3;;>69@>8>10 95; 23 A90 @3 9;3I<91380 4,A=356913; 7:,A 123 ,D53: 95;>56<:3:,71234:<>63:C33=
4963 49A3 1, @3 :3?>613:3; @0 9A9859?9:
=,8>43>5:>A3 <A@3:''*'! 95;9713:>5E361>?91>,5 429:?362331D9689>;9?9>561123;:>E3:,7:36=,5;351 , >3 33:35;:9 D2, =839;3; ?<>810 ,5 123 429:?3 62331 95;=9>;1237>53
36=,5;351 , 9==39:3; @37,:3 123
:>@<598 95; 7>83; D:>1135 61913A351 4,5135;>5? 1291 123 53?8>?3543D96,5123=9:1,7123=31>1>,53:95;123:3D96 5,6<4253?8>?3543,5123=9:1,7123;:>E3:,71234:<>63:
C33= 3 ;35>3; 123 I<951<A ,7 123 9A,<51 489>A3; @0 123=31>1>,53:9883?>5?1291>1>62>?2803H,:@>1951
- 4 -
>1D9661913;>5123D:>113561913A3511291123E32>483D96 @3>5?;:>E35@033:35;:9D2,D9629E>5?9E98>;;:>E>5? 8>43543 + 36=,5;351 ,'
56<:9543 ,A=950 4,5135;3; 1234:<>63: C33= 296 @335 7986380 >A=8>4913; >5 1234963@0123=31>1>,53:>5,:;3:1,A9B3<589D7<8?9>5 1 D96 4,5135;3; 1291 123 ( ;,36 5,1 ;>648,63 123 5<A@3:,7123E32>483,7:36=,5;351 , 95;>1D96,580 ;<:>5? 123 >5E361>?91>,5 @963; ,5 123 61913A351 ,7 ,53
3E>;961291123E32>483D96>A=8>4913;7986380>5,:;3:1, 489>A1234,A=35691>,5
23:37,:3>1D964,5135;3;1291 123 79863 >A=8>491>,5 @3>5? E>6>@80 3E>;351 123 =31>1>,5 9?9>561:36=,5;351 ,' >6 8>9@83 1, @3 ;>6A>663;1 D96 9883?3;129197:9<;296@335=8903;@0123=31>1>,53:95; :36=,5;351 , 95; 123:37,:3 :36=,5;351 ,' >6 5,1 8>9@831,=901234,A=35691>,595;>1>6918>@3:101,19B3 988123;>773:35436<5;3:341>,5 *!,7123,1,:32>4836 41 $7,: 62,:1 F G% 123 9?3 ,44<=91>,5 95;123>54,A3,7123=31>1>,53:D96986,;35>3;
- 5 -
* 963; ,5 123 9@,E3 4,51351>,56 123
:>@<598 7:9A3;1237,88,D>5?>66<36
! !! ! " !#! $ %&&'(&)*+,!-
. -
$ . ! ! $ %'()*+
! /0- 1
-
/
/ - 2 /-3
23 =31>1>,53: D96 3H9A>53; 96 # 95;
H6# 1, #' D3:3 A9:B3; 36=,5;351 ,'56<:9543 ,A=9503H9A>53;>16,77>4>9896 95;123=,8>40D96
- 6 -
A9:B3; 96 H 713: 239:>5?
123 9:?<A3516 123 :>@<598 =:,433;3; 1, ;>6A>66 123 489>A =31>1>,5 ,5 123 ?:,<5;1291123E32>483296@3357986380>A=8>4913;@0123 =31>1>,53: - 3>5? 9??:>3E3; @0 123 69>; C<;?A351 123 =31>1>,53:>6@37,:312>6,<:1>59==398 ! 23
:>@<598:34,:;629E3@335634<:3;95;123 9:?<A3516,7839:53;4,<56389==39:>5?7,:1239==388951 95;:36=,5;351 ,'29E3@335239:; 39:53; 4,<5638 9==39:>5? 7,: 123 9==388951 D,<8;6<@A>112911233E>;3543,7# 4839:8062,D61291 236<619>53;>5C<:>36>5123944>;3511>6=,>513;,<11291 123 429:?3 62331 =9=3:6 =:,;<43; @37,:3 123
:>@<598 4839:8062,D12911235<A@3:,7123E32>483D961:943;,5 123 E3:0 53H1 ;90 ,7 123 944>;351 ,5 123 @96>6 ,7 123 61913A351 A9;3 @0,53 3E>;96 E35123 6=,1A929J9:
=:,;<43; 91 H# D2>42 D96 4,5;<413; ,5 ' '! >5;>4913; 123 E32>483 5<A@3: 95; 123:37,:3 79863 >A=8>491>,5 4,<8; 5,1 29E3 @335 <=238; @0 123
:>@<598
- 7 -
23:37,:3 123 1361>A,50 ,7 D2, 69>; 1291 123 E32>483296@3357986380>A=8>4913;4955,1@39443=13;95; 1236=,51953>10,71233E35164839:8062,D1291123E32>483 ,D53; @0 :36=,5;351 , D96 >5E,8E3; 1 >6 986, 6<@A>113;12913E3512,<?29==8>491>,57>83;<5;3:341>,5 *! ,7 123 41 D96 4,56>;3:3; 95; 9443=13; @0123 :>@<598 123 1361>A,50 ,7 4955,1 377341>E380 :3@<1 123 3E>;3543 ,7 # 4,<=83; D>12 123 429:?3 62331 =9=3:6
23:37,:3 23 6<@A>16 1291 ;>6A>6698 ,7 123 =31>1>,5>6=9135180>54,::341 ' >6 634,5; 6<@A>66>,5 >6 1291 123 I<951<A ,7 4,A=35691>,5 D96 4984<8913; >5 9 496<98 A9553: @0 123 :>@<598 95; 3E35 123 1,198>5? 91 123 4984<891>,56 9:3 D:,5?1>66<@A>113;1291123
:>@<59812,<?26191361291 123 =31>1>,53: >6 351>183; 7,: 123 4,A=35691>,5 ,7 6!!!<5;3:123239;,7A3;>4983H=35636>57941 >1>61234,A=35691>,54984<8913;<5;3:123239;,78,66,7 7<1<:3>54,A3,5944,<51,7;>69@>8>103=,>516,<11291 123
:>@<598 79>86 1, 9D9:; 950 4,A=35691>,5 <5;3: 123
- 8 -
239; ,7 8,66 ,7 9A35>1>36 >5 8>73 95; 96 6<42 123 351>:3 4984<891>,5 ,7 123 4,A=35691>,5 >6 1,19880 >54,::341 95;
D>12,<19==8>491>,5,7950A>5;@0123
:>@<598 #3: 4,51:9 839:53; 4,<5638 9==39:>5? 7,:
:36=,5;351 ,'56<:9543 ,A=950 6<@A>16 1291 123 >5E361>?91>,5 =9=3:6 D,<8; 4839:80 62,D 1291 123 7<:123:
61913A351,71234,A=89>5951D96:34,:;3;9713: ;906 ,7123>54>;35195;123:37,:31234,548<6>,56:39423;@0 1235E361>?91>5?77>43:>57>8>5?123429:?3623319?9>561 33:35;:9 >6 ;,<@17<8 3 986, =,>516 ,<1 1291 123 69>;
3E>;96D2,61913;9@,<1123E32>4835<A@3:@37,:3123 5E361>?91>5?77>43:>6986,9:3891>E3,7123=31>1>,53:95;
123:37,:3 23 62,<8; 29E3 @335 3H9A>53; @37,:3 123 :>@<598>5,:;3:1,=:,E3123429:?362331>163871>6986, =,>513; ,<1 1291 123
:>@<598 296 :>?2180 4,A3 1, 123 4,548<6>,5 9@,<1 123 79863 >A=8>491>,5 ,7 123 E32>483 95;
123:37,:3 123 ,:;3: ,7;>6A>6698 ,7 123 =31>1>,5 533; 5,1 @3>513:73:3;D>12
- 9 -
1>61:>1389D1291123=31>1>,53:D2,4,A361, 123
:>@<598 >6 @<:;353; D>12 =:,E>5?
123 944>;351 95;
>5E,8E3A351 ,7 123 E32>483 580 9713: 6<42 3E>;3543 >6 839; @0 123 =31>1>,53: 123 ,5<6 62>716 <=,5 123 :36=,5;35156<:9543,A=9501,:3@<112369A35123 4963 ,5 295;123 =31>1>,53: D2,6<773:3; 123 >5C<:0 D96 9;A>113;1,1232,6=>198
234,A=89>51D968,;?3;96=3:
H#' D23:3 123 =31>1>,53: A351>,53; 1291 D235 123 944>;351 1,,B =8943 2>6 :3891>E36 9:<1>:9, ,55983 95; 9?5912,5598329;6335>195;123029;62>713;2>A1, 123 2,6=>198
23 4,A=89>51 986, A351>,56 1291 9713: 123 C33=2>11>5?2>6E32>483123C33=;:>E3:6=3;9D907:,A123 6=,1 D>12,<1 61,==>5? 123 E32>483
23 4,A=89>51 D96 :34,:;3; ,5 123 ;913 ,7 123 >54>;351 >16387 D2>83 123 =31>1>,53:D96>51232,6=>19895;123:37,:3>1>64839:1291 1234,A=89>514955,1@39883?3;,77>41>1>,<68059::91>5?123 >54>;351
23 ( >6 6=,51953,<6 95; 123:37,:3 123 6=,51953>10A9B36>1:38>9@83
- 10 -
23 6=,1 A929J9: D2>42 >6 =:,;<43; 91 H# D,<8;62,D1291>1D964,5;<413;,5' '! @31D335 !!95;-!!9AE>;35180123>5E,8E3A351,7123&33= @39:>5? , ' +- >6 A351>,53; >5 123 6=,1 A929J9: 23:37,:3 D235 123 6=,1 A929J9: D96 4,5;<413; 123 5E361>?91>5? 77>43: 29; 4,A3 1, B5,D 9@,<1 123 E32>483 5<A@3: D2>42 4955,1 @3 ;>6=<13; @0 12356<:9543,A=950
236,<:43,7E32>4835<A@3:495 @37,<5;7:,A12361913A351,7 3E>;96D2>42>6=9:1,7 123429:?3623311>6=3:1>53511,5,131291D2>8312369>;
3E>;96D96D98B>5?,5
,:599A98 9?9::,9;1,?,1, 2>6 9?:>4<81<:98 895;6 9 4:<>63: &33= @39:>5? , '
+-29;?,531,D9:;69A98 9?9:913:2349A3 1, B5,D 9@,<1 123 944>;351 D2>42 29; ,44<::3; 1, 123 =31>1>,53: 7:,A 2>6 79123: @E>,<680 123 79123: ,7
3E>;96@3>5?9:3891>E3,7123=31>1>,53:96A351>,53;>5 1234,A=89>5129;986,>57,:A3;9@,<1123944>;3511,123 69>;
3E>;96
23:37,:3 >1 4955,1 @3 69>; 1291 3E>;96 @3>5?123:3891>E3,7123=31>1>,53:2>63E>;354329;@335 4,,B3;<=(<:123:2>661913A351986,62,D12915,,123:
- 11 -
E32>48329;=9663;,5123:,9;9112911>A395;123:37,:3 2329;A351>,53;123E32>4835<A@3:@37,:31235E361>5? 77>43:
+
23 :3=,:1 D2>42 >6 91 H#+ 62,D6 1291 123:3 D3:3 5, ;9A9?36 7,<5; ,5@,12 123 E32>4836 1 >6 5,1 366351>98 1291 3E3:0 E32>483 D2>42 A3316 D>12 95 944>;3512961,6<773:;9A9?3
23:37,:31239:?<A351,7 123 839:53; 4,<5638 7,: :36=,5;351 ,' 1291 @,12 123 E32>483636=34>9880123A,1,:40483,7123=31>1>,53:62,<8; 29E36<773:3;;9A9?34955,1@39443=13;
*
23 9@,E3 79416 D2>42 9:3 @,:53 ,<1 ,7 123 :34,:;6D,<8;62,D1291123=31>1>,53:296;>6429:?3;2>6 @<:;35 @0 3619@8>62>5? 1291 9713: 12,:,<?2 >5E361>?91>,5 1235E361>?91>5?77>43:29;4,A31,1234,548<6>,51291 123 E32>483 ,D53; @0 :36=,5;351 , 95; ;:>E35 @0 33:35;:929;49<63;123944>;3511>6986,=3:1>53511, 5,1312911231361>A,50,7 >65,1@963;,512379416 9E9>89@83 ,5 :34,:; 6906 >5 2>6 977>;9E>1 1291 123 5E361>?91>5? 77>43: 49A3 1, B5,D 9@,<1 123 E32>483
- 12 -
5<A@3: >5E,8E3; >5 123 944>;351 ,580 9713: ;906 @E>,<680 123 E32>483 5<A@3: D96 ;>648,63; @0 123 4,A=89>5951 1, 123 5E361>?91>5?
77>43: 9713: ;906 D235 23 49A3 1, B5,D 9@,<1 123 61913A351 A9;3 @0
3E>;96 5 7941 123 5E361>?91>5? 77>43: 29; 4,A3 1, B5,D 9@,<1 123 E32>483 5<A@3: ,5 123 E3:0 53H1 ;90 ,7 123 944>;351 D2>42 >6 4913?,:>49880 61913; >5 123 6=,1 A929J9: 91 H# 3543 =:>A9 794>3 123 1361>A,50 ,7 >6 5,1 4,::341 95; >1 ,E3:8,,B6 123 3E>;3543 83; @0 123 =31>1>,53: 36=,5;351 ,' 296 5,1 3H9A>53; 123 5E361>?91>5? 77>43: >5 ,:;3: 1, 3619@8>62 1291 123 >5E361>?91>,54,5;<413;@02>A>6D:,5?95;>54,::3415 1291 E>3D ,7 123 A9113: 123 4,548<6>,56 :39423; @0 123 :>@<5989:3=3:E3:6395;12304955,1@39443=13;
,A>5? 1, 123 I<951<A ,7 4,A=35691>,5 >1 >6 3E>;3511291123=31>1>,53:12,<?2D96953A=8,033,7123 2965,1=:,;<43;95>,19,73E>;35431,3619@8>62 12369A3;A>113;8023D969;:>E3:,7123
95;
5,12>5? =:3E3513; 2>A 1, =:,;<43 9 6989:0 68>= 1, 62,D
- 13 -
129123D969;:>E3:
23:37,:3>14955,1@369>;129123>6 351>183; 7,: 8,66 ,7 >54,A3 ,5 944,<51 ,7 950 ;>69@>8>10 235123:3>65,3E>;35431,62,D129123296@3353>123: :3A,E3;7:,A12363:E>43,:2>66989:0296@335:3;<43; >1>65,1>5123A,<12,7123=31>1>,53:1,690129123296 6<773:3; ;>69@>8>10 95; 123:37,:3 2>6 >54,A3 296 @335 :3;<43;1A90@31:<3129123A9029E36<773:3;A>5,: ;>69@>8>10@<112912965,1:36<813;>595034,5,A>48,661, 2>A
23:37,:31239;A>66>@834,A=35691>,5>6,580<5;3: 123:3A9>5>5?239;6 -
23
:>@<598 12,<?2 619136 >5 =9:9 ,7 123 >A=<?53;C<;?A3511291=31>1>,53:>6351>183;7,:A3;>498 3H=35636 ,7 6!!! 123 7>?<:36 9::>E3; 91 96 ;>64<663;>5=9:9'D,<8;62,D1291>1D96,5944,<51,7 ;>69@>8>10
23:34,:;6:3E3981291123=31>1>,53:29;6=351 96<A,76'!!!!!1,D9:;6A3;>4983H=3563696=3:
A3;>498 @>886 91 H6# 1, #'+
23:37,:3 23 >6 351>183; 7,:12369A3<5;3:123239;,7A3;>4983H=35636
- 14 -
'! 23 ;>6429:?3 6<AA9:0 =:,;<43; 91 H#- 62,D612912329;6<773:3;7:941<:3,71>@>995;7>@<8995;
23 D96 >5=91>351 7,: 9@,<1 ;906
23:37,:3 123 =31>1>,53: >6 351>183; 7,: 9 6<A ,7 6!!!! <5;3: 123 239; ,7 =9>5 95; 6<773:>5?) 6 !!!! <5;3: 239; ,7 91135;9543 429:?36 7,,; 5,<:>62A351 95; 4,5E309543) 6'!!!!<5;3:123239;,78,66,79A35>1>36>58>7395;
9 6<A ,7 6 !!!! <5;3: 123 239; ,7 8,66 ,7 >54,A3 ;<:>5? 89>; <= =3:>,;
23 I<951<A ,7 4,A=35691>,56 4984<8913; @0 123
:>@<598 91 =9:9 62,D6 123 >59==8>491>,5 ,7 A>5; 1,D9:;6 123 4984<891>,5 95; 6<42 9==:,942@0123
:>@<59869:31,@362<553; ' 35431239==388951=31>1>,53:>6351>183;7,:9 1,1984,A=35691>,5,76'!!!!<5;3:;>773:351239;6 96@38,D #9>595;6<773:>5? 6!!!! 3;>4983H=35636 6'!!!!! 1135;951 429:?36 7,,; 5,<:>62A35195;4,5E309543 6 !!!! ,66,7>54,A3;<:>5?89>;<==3:>,; 6 !!!! ,66,79A35>1>36 6'!!!! *+, -. - 15 -
'' 5 123 :36<81 123 9==398 ;363:E36 1, @3 988,D3;35431237,88,D>5? $>% 239==398>6988,D3; $>>% 23 >A=<?53; C<;?A351 95; 9D9:; =9663; @0123
:>@<598>663196>;3 $>>>% 239==388951=31>1>,53:>6351>183;7,:91,198 4,A=35691>,5,76'!!!!1,?3123:D>12 >513:36191+.=97:,A123;913,7=31>1>,5 1>88>16:398>J91>,5 $>E% 36=,5;351 ,'56<:9543 ,A=950 >6 ;>:3413; 1, ;3=,6>1 123 351>:3 4,A=35691>,5 9A,<51D>12>59=3:>,;,73>?21D33B67:,A 123;913,712>6,:;3:
; &
#! ( #
>61 , 8 ,'