Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 11321 (KAR)

KORVA GOVINDA v. K.MALLESHI AND ORS

MFA/201837/2017 · 2025-01-21

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # ! ! $ !"# ! $ %& ' (() * +# ++' ' !, ! ' $ %& ' (() '## !, !+ &$ ' ("(() '--) $ ' (() ' + ' ' LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.23 00:52:33 - 0800 - 2 - . ""- , '# +( * +# , '##' # / & $ ' ' ' ' # $ ' # ' , $ ) ( +# ' , ' ' ' - )) $ ' "0 " $ ' 0 ' ' # , $ ' ! ! '1+ , ,' ! !'1+ , ,' '2345 6234725 89:7;26 4< +3=: ' 2>3?:553 3@@234<7? A94 >B2 3@@26637>@2><><9724 375 6234725 89:7;26 4< 37C:73>B 3663DD3 B2>>D 3@@234<7? A94 42;@97527> 97;:437829E@37D B<; 3@@236 <; =D >B2 @2><><9724 <7 9( 3;;3<6<7? >B2 C:5?E27> 375 3F345 53>25 - 3 - )@3;;25=D>B255<><9736<;>4<8>3752;;<97; ,:5?2 375 3<8B:4 A94 ;B94> G 4<=:736H ;22I<7? 27B3782E27>9A89E@27;3><97 B2A38>9A>B283;2<;>B3> FB<6242>:47<7?A49E :479963A>24:76935<7?B:;IA49E>B2944D=234<7?9 ("(()B2E2>F<>B37388<527>3>3=9:>!3E 97 5:2>9>B272?6<?27>54<J<7?=D>B254<J249A>B2 ;3<5 944D B2 @2><><9724 A<625 863<E @2><><97 =2A942 >B2 4<=:736 FB<8BF3;9@@9;25=D42;@97527>97;:43782 9E@37D 897>275<7? >B3> >B2 89E@27;3><97 863<E25 <; B<?B6D 2K94=<>37> <E3?<734D 375 :7>273=62 375 >B2 3?2 <789E2375988:@3><979A>B2@2><><9724F3;36;9527<25> F3; 36;9 897>27525 >B3> >B2 >24E; 375 8975<><97; 9A >B2 @96<8DF242J<963>25=D>B254<J243759F7249A>B2J2B<862 ) B2 4<=:736 A43E25 3@@49@4<3>2 <;;:2; 375 >B2 E3>>24 F3; B2345 3A>24 86:==<7? >B2 ;3E2 F<>B 9" A>24 @24:;36 9A >B2 2J<52782 355:825 97 428945 375 B234<7? =9>B >B2 @34><2; >B2 4<=:736 3F34525 89E@27;3><979A ; - )):7524A9669F<7?B235;! - 4 - 9F345;@3<7375;:AA24<7? ; 9;;9AA:>:422347<7? ; " 94 E25<836 2K@27;2; =3;25 9725<836+<663752J<52782 ;( )) ) 9F345; 3>>2753782 8B34?2 & @28<36 995 & 5<2> & 36;9 437;@94>3><97B34?2; ; ; - )) ( +2<7? 3??4<2J25 =D >B2 L:37>:E 9A 89E@27;3><97 >B2 @2><><9724 <; =2A942 >B<; 9:4> <7 >B<; 3@@236 " 234725 89:7;26 3@@234<7? A94 >B2 3@@26637> F9:65 ;:=E<> >B3> >B9:?B >B2 3@@26637>@2><><9724 B35 ;:;>3<725 A438>:42 9A ><=<3 375 A<=:63 >B2 4<=:736 A3<625 >9 3;;2;;>B289E@27;3><97:7524>B2B235;69;;9A3E27<><2; <7 6<A2 375 69;; 9A 2347<7? 5:4<7? >B2 63<5 :@ @24<95 > <; 897>27525>B3>>B2@2><><9724=2<7?3996<2B3;;:AA2425>B2 5<;3=<6<>D 9A 0 3; ;>3>25 =D $ 375 >B242A942 >B2 5<;3=<6<>D3;;2;;25=D>B2 4<=:736<;97>B269F24;<52 - 5 - 6234725 89:7;26 3@@234<7? A94 42;@97527> 9 M 7;:43782 9E@37D ;:=E<>; >B3> >B2 4<=:736B3;897;<52425>B2@BD;<8365<;3=<6<>D9A0>9>B2 6<E= FB<8BF9:6542;:6><7A:78><97365<;3=<6<>D9A0 375 >B242A942 >B242 <; 79 7225 A94 37D 27B3782E27> 9A >B2 89E@27;3><97'2A:4>B24897>275;>B3>>B2L:37>:E9A>B2 89E@27;3><973F34525=D>B2 4<=:736<;352L:3>2375>B242 <;797225A94<75:6?2782=D>B<;9:4> '3J<7? 897;<52425 >B2 E3>24<36 3J3<63=62 97 428945 <><;2J<527>>B3>>B2@2><><9724B35;:;>3<725A438>:42 9A ><=<3 375 A<=:63 375 >B2 98>94 2K3E<725 3; $ B3; 3;;2;;25 >B2 @BD;<836 5<;3=<6<>D 9A >B2 @2><><9724 3> 0 >9 >B26<E= B2 4<=:736B3;3;;2;;25>B2A:78><97365<;3=<6<>D 3>0375897;<524<7?>B279><9736<789E29A>B2@2><><9724 3>) @24E97>BB3;3F34525>B289E@27;3><97><; @24><727> >9 79>2 >B3> >B2 4<=:736 A3<625 >9 3F345 37D 89E@27;3><97 :7524 >B2 B235 69;; 9A 3E27<><2; <7 6<A2 375 >B2 69;; 9A 2347<7? 5:4<7? >B2 63<5 :@ @24<95 =J<9:;6D >B2;2 >F9 B235; ;B9:65 B3J2 =227 897;<52425 =D >B2 4<=:736 - 6 - - B2 ?:<526<72; <;;:25 =D >B2 3473>3I3 >3>2 2?36 24J<82; :>B94<>D A94 ;2>>62E27> 9A >B2 5<;@:>2;=2A942>B29I5363>@42;84<=2>B279><9736<789E2 9A ; @24 E97>B A94 >B2 D234 7 :E@>227 7:E=249A528<;<97; >B<;9:4>B3;B265>B3>>B2?:<526<72; <;;:25 =D 342 B265 >9 =2 3882@>3=62 97 >B2 ?49:75 >B3>>B2D342<7?272436897A94E<>DF<>B>B2E<7<E:EF3?2; A<K25:7524>B2<7<E:E$3?2;8> B242A942 >B279><9736 <789E2 9A >B2 @2><><9724 <; 897;<52425 3; ; @24 E97>B B2 5<;3=<6<>D 9A 0 344<J25 3> =D >B2 4<=:736 3@@234;>9=2894428> ;<782<>B3;>3I27B36A9A>B25<;3=<6<>D 9A >B2 6<E= 3; >B2 A:78><9736 5<;3=<6<>D >B242A942 79 <7>24A242782<;42L:<425<742;@28>9A>B2;3E2 B242<;79 5<;@:>242?345<7?>B23?29A>B2@2><><9724'2782 >B269;; 9AA:>:42<789E2<;8368:63>253; ;"(KKK0 >B3> 2L:36; >9 ; " 97;2L:27>6D >B2 89E@27;3><97:7524>B2B23569;;9A<789E25:4<7?>B263<5 :@ @24<95 <; 8368:63>25 3; ;"( K >B3> 2L:36; >9 ;- ( - 7 - B2 4<=:736 B3;79> 3F3452537D 89E@27;3><97 :7524>B2B23569;;9A3E27<><2;<76<A2375>B242A942 3;:E 9A ;( <;3F34525:7524>B<;B235 B289E@27;3><97 3F34525 :7524 >B2 B235 @3<7 375 ;:AA24<7? <;97 >B2 69F24 ;<52375>B242A942 ;3E2<;27B37825>9 ;) B2 428945; 36;9 42J236 >B3> >B2 <E@637>; 342 >B242375;9E23E9:7><;42L:<425>942E9J2>B2;3E27 >B<;42?345>B242<;7225A94A:>:42E25<8362K@27;2; B2782 ; <; 3F34525 :7524 >B<; B235 FB<8B F9:65 79> 8344D37D<7>242;> 7 >B2 42;:6> >B2 @2><><9724 <; 27><>625 A94 >B2 E95<A<2589E@27;3><973;=269F! 6 9 '235; F345=D>B2 4<=:736 F345=D>B<; 9:4> 9F345; @3<7 375 ;:AA24<7? ; ;) 9;; 9A A:>:42 2347<7? ; " ; " 94 E25<836 2K@27;2; =3;25 97 25<836 +<66 375 2J<52782 ;( )) ;( )) - 8 - ) 9F345; 3>>2753782 8B34?2 & @28<36 995 & 5<2> & 36;9 437;@94>3><97 B34?2; ; ; ( 9;; 9A <789E2 5:4<7?63<5:@@24<95 <6 ;- ( ( 9;;E27<><2;<76<A2 <6 ;( " :>:42 25<836 K@27;2; <6 ; ; - )) ; )) B242F<66=227B3782E27>9A ; ( ( ) '2782 >B2A9669F<7?! < B23@@236<;3669F25<7@34> << B2 3@@26637>@2><><9724 <; 27><>625 A94 89E@27;3><97 9A ; ( ( <7 355<><97 >9 FB3> B3; =227 3F34525 =D >B2 4<=:736 F<>B <7>242;> 3> "0 @24 377:E A49E >B2 53>2 9A @2><><97 ><66 52@9;<> 2K86:5<7? <7>242;> A94 ; 3F34525 :7524 >B2 B235 GA:>:42 E25<8362K@27;2;H - 9 - <<< B2 42;> 9A >B2 >24E; 375 8975<><97; 42?345<7? 52@9;<>37542623;2 2>8 9452425=D>B2 4<=:736 42E3<7:736>2425 5 % ! & ! + <;>9!69!( !