Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 11292 (KAR)

SHANKARGOUDA v. M/S G N KAKHANDAKI AND ORS

WP/202158/2024 · 2025-02-07

S Sunil Dutt Yadav

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " # !$ $ % &'"""!$!( )& * !" # $ % & ! ' ( ' ) "! % "' ! ' ' ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ' "!% " ' ! ( ' ' ! " ' ' !" ' %' ) % ' ' ! ' % ' ) % ' "! ' % ' %' - 3 - ) % ' ' ! # $ "!)!) %)!")!!)!) )* (( + " & % ( ))( ( %% , - . ' % '' ( ( ).!.)!) / * (' )))! + ( % % (( " ( -- ( / %' -- ( ( ( ' % ' ( ' 0/ % ' ' 1' - 4 - ! $1' & 234 5637 897373:; 39 %:)!) )!) 34 <9. =3;>9< ?6:@ 729 A:@8B;3:; 5637 897373:; :)!")!!)!) B;<34<348:49<:?CD7234:6<96 ) 29 <9?9;<B;7 : 2B4 ?3=9< 7234 86949;7 5637 897373:;4993;E?:649773;EB43<9:?729:6<96B7;;9FG69. 52969CD 729 763B= :G67 2B4 B==:59< 729 '9@: <B79< !!))!) ?3=9< CD 729 8=B3;73??4 7: 729 9??9A7 72B7 B?796 <9?9;<B;7 : <39< 729 :7296 =9EB= 29364 :? <9?9;<B;7 :398=B3;73??:$&<9?9;<B;7:4"B;<52:B69 729=B44. 29364B69B=69B<D:;69A:6<B;<4B@9@BDC9 ;:79< " (:6 729 4B>9 :? A:;H9;39;A9 729 8B67394 B69 69?9669<7:B4896729366B;>C9?:69729763B=:G67 :)))! 5B4 ?3=9< CD '4 B>2B;<B>3 523A2 34 B 69E347969< 8B67;964238 ?36@ 6986949;79< CD 374 8B67;964 BEB3;47 2B;>B6E:G<B - 5 - 3<<B88BB;<72699:72964A=B3@3;E72969=39?:?8B443;E:? B <9A699 ?:6 8B67373:; B;< 498B6B79 8:449443:; :? 729 8=B3;73??4 2B=? 42B69 B=:;E 5372 <9?9;<B;7 :4) 7: CD AB6H3;E:G74GA286:8967DCD@9794B;<C:G;<4=B3;73??4 2B< B=4: 4:GE27 ?:6 8B443;E :? B <9A699 ?:6 896@B;9;7 3;IG;A73:;3;?BH:G6:?7298=B3;73??4BEB3;47729<9?9;<B;7 :69476B3;3;E23@?6:@<348:449443;E7298=B3;73??4?6:@ 4G37 86:8967D <94A63C9< 3; 8B6B.) :? 729 8=B3;7 9FA987 726:GE2B86:896<9A699?:68B67373:; 734729AB49:?729<9?9;<B;7472B7<G63;E729 89;<9;AD :? 729 86:A99<3;E4 <9?9;<B;7 : @7 GIB7B : 'B==3>B6IG; B>2B;<B>3 <39< B;< 429 5B4 ;:7 @B6639< ;:6 2B< B;D A23=<69; 8:; 296 <9B72 4GCI9A7 '9@: AB@9 7: C9 ?3=9< CD 729 8=B3;73??4 523A2 69B<4 B4 2969G;<96 J - 6 - !" #"$ $! % & ' !( ")) ")) & !(& % ' & * ;4:?B6B44GA2@9@:729<9?9;<B;7:2B< ?3=9<:CI9A73:;4B449673;E72B7:;=D=B44. 2936:?<9A9B49< <9?9;<B;7 : A:G=< C9 C6:GE27 :; 69A:6< 7 5B4B=4: 489A3?3AB==D BH9669< 3; 729 4B3< :CI9A73:;4 7: 729 @9@: 72B77296934B69?969;A97:<9?9;<B;7:729434796:? 729<9A9B49<B;<8=B3;73??:$&A=B3@3;E729@49=H947: C9=B44. 2936452:B694:GE277:C9C6:GE27:;69A:6< 7 5B4 489A3?3AB==D A:;79;<9< 72B7 =B44. B;< =B44. 29364 AB;;:7 C9 C6:GE27 :; 69A:6< 43@G=7B;9:G4=D AA:6<3;E=D <9?9;<B;7 : 4:GE27 ?:6 69I9A73:; :? 729 @9@: 734B=4:7:C9;:73A9<72B7729<9?9;<B;7: 2B<?3=9<B<97B3=9<@9@:B7;;9FG69. 7:7299??9A772B7 - 7 - 72:GE2:G672B<7B>9;;:79:?<9B72:?<9?9;<B;7:37 2B<;:7<9A3<9<B47:52:B69729=9EB=6986949;7B73H94:? <9?9;<B;7 : 7 5B4 489A3?3AB==D B449679< 72B7 :G67 :GE27;:77:2BH97B>9;;:79:?@9@:B;<896@3779<729 8=B3;73??47:B@9;<729ABG49.737=9B;<:6<96:?)!")!) 5B469KG369<7:C9>9873;BC9DB;A9 :7294B3<@9@::CI9A73:;45969?3=9<CD729 8=B3;73??4:;"!!")!)7:7299??9A772B7529;B?9@B=9 <39<3;7947B79729;296=9EB=29364B69729=9EB=29364:?296 ?B7296398=B3;73??:$&<9?9;<B;7:"B;<<9?9;<B;7 :52:B69B=69B<D:;69A:6<B;<BAA:6<3;E=D499>4?:6 <34@344B=:?729@9@:?3=9<CD<9?9;<B;7: L 29:G67B?79629B63;EC:7243<942B48B449< B;:6<96:;729@9@:<B79<)!)!)B;<B==:59<729 @9@: <B79< !!))!) ?3=9< CD 729 8=B3;73??4 29 4B3< :6<96 <97B3=4 72B7 3; 796@4 :? 9A73:; $)&$B& :? 3;<G GAA9443:;A7L$?:642:670729A7/&52969B?9@B=9 3;<G<39452:2B43;296379<72986:8967D?6:@296?B7296 :6 @:7296 3; 729 BC49;A9 :? B;D 4:; :6 <BGE2796 4B@9 - 8 - 5:G=<<9H:=H9:;72929364:?296?B7296B;<;:73;796@4 :?9A73:;$&:?729A7 ! 7 34 729 A:;79;73:; :? A:G;49= ?:6 <9?9;<B;7 : 52: 2B4 ?3=9< 729 86949;7 5637 897373:; 72B7 529; <9?9;<B;7:<39<729@:7296<9?9;<B;7:"3;796@4 :? 9A73:; $& :? 729 A7 5:G=< C9 =B44. 2936 52: 5:G=<3;296377:7299FA=G43:;:?729:72964 734?G67296 4GC@3779< 72B7 9A73:; $)&$B& :? 729 A7 ;: <:GC7 86:H3<94 72B7 86:8967D :? 729 ?9@B=9 52: <39< 3;7947B79 @BD<9H:=H9<G8:;72929364:?729?B72963669489A73H9:? :6<96 :? 4GAA9443:; G;<96 9A73:; $& :? 729 A7 2:59H96?:64GA29H9;7GB=37D72969@G47C9B?3;<3;E72B7 72986:8967D72B734<9H:=H9:;729?9@B=9C9=:;E47:729 ?B7296 7 34 ?G67296 4GC@3779< 72B7 729 H96D 4G37 ?:6 8B67373:; 34 ?3=9< CD 729 8B67;964238 ?36@ '4 B>2B;<B>3 523A2 B 69E347969< ?36@ B;< 729 8=B3;7 BH96@9;74 B69 A=9B6 72B7 729 ?36@ A=B3@4 3;796947 3; 729 4B3< 86:8967D A=B3@3;E 2B=? 42B69 3; 729 86:8967D - 9 - AA:6<3;E=D 37 34 4GC@3779< 72B7 3? 37 34 729 AB49 :? 729 8=B3;73??4729@49=H9472B77298B67;9642382B42B=?42B693; 72986:8967D729;729KG9473:;B47:529729686:8967DAB; C9769B79<B4C9=:;E3;E7:729?B7296B;<29;A9<9H:=G73:; G;<969A73:;$)&$B&347:?=:57:729=9EB=29364:?729 ?B7296 34 B @B7796 7: C9 86:C9< CD B; 9;KG36D B4 A:;79@8=B79<G;<966<96))G=9:? ) 2:GE2@9@:4B69?3=9<B;<B4B=4::CI9A73:;4 B469?9669<7:3;729;B66B73:;:?729?BA74BC:H93734A=9B6 72B7729KG9473:;B47:52:34729=9EB=2936:?<9?9;<B;7 :34B@B779672B769KG36947:C9<9A3<9<B;<AB;;:7C9 <9A3<9<?6:@729@9@:B;<:CI9A73:;4?3=9<3;=3E27:?729 ;B7G69:?A:;79;73:;4:?<9?9;<B;7:B447B79<BC:H9 " ;=3E27:?729A:;79;73:;46B349<CDA:G;49=?:6 <9?9;<B;7:B4;:73A9<BC:H9375:G=<C9B886:863B79 7: 69=9EB79 729 8B67394 7: B; 9;KG36D B4 7: 729 =9EB= 2936 9;737=9< 7: A:@9 :; 69A:6< 3; 8=BA9 :? <9?9;<B;7 : GA2 <9796@3;B73:; B4 7: 52: B69 729 =9EB= 29364 :? <9?9;<B;7:347:C9@B<93;796@4:?G;<966<96)) - 10 - G=9:?7B>3;E;:79:?729A:;79;73:;4:?<9?9;<B;7 :72B77298=B3;73??4729@49=H94A=B3@2B=?42B693;729 86:8967DB;<BAA:6<3;E=D3?729=9EB=6986949;7B73H94:?729 ?B7296B69A=B3@3;E63E273742:G=<C9947BC=3429<72B7729 86:8967DC9=:;E47:729?B7296:?<9?9;<B;7: ;=3E27:?7294B3<<34AG443:;:6<96:;@9@: 34497B43<9B67394B6969=9EB79<7:9;KG36DG;<966<96 ))G=9:??:6729763B=:G677:<9796@3;9B47:52: B69 729 =9EB= 29364 :? <9?9;<B;7 : 29 @9@:4 B;< :CI9A73:;4?3=9<@BDC97298=9B<3;E472B7A:G=<C969=39< :; B7 729 73@9 :? 9;KG36D (G67296 C:72 43<94 B69 B7 =3C967D7:?3=9B<<373:;B=8=9B<3;E4523A25:G=<9;BC=9729 :G677:2BH9B?G==.?=9<E9<9;KG36DG;<966<96))G=9 :? 99<=944 7: 47B79 B <97B3=9< 9;KG36D 34 C93;E :6<969< B;< BAA:6<3;E=D 729 9;737=9@9;7 :? ?3;<3;E B4 7: =9EB= 29364 :? <9?9;<B;7 : 5:G=< 9;BC=9 729 :G67 7: <9A3<9<9H:=G73:;B;<<3H343:;294B3<9;KG36D347:C9 9;<9BH:G69<7:C9A:@8=979<B77299B6=3947 - 11 - (G67296 ;99<=944 7: 47B79 3; =3E27 :? 729 <34AG443:;72B72:=<3;EB;9;KG36DG;<966<96))G=9 :? 9F89<373:G4=D 729 3;7963@ :6<96 9B6=396 E6B;79< 47BD3;E72986:A99<3;E447B;<4HBAB79< AA:6<3;E=D7295637897373:;34<348:49<:?? "+, )""!$!(* '! 347:=:)"