Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 112152 (PNJ)
M/S VARUN FABS LTD. v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
CWP/5956/2009 · 2025-12-24
Amarinder Singh Grewal, Jagmohan Bansal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 112152 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 112152 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#"$%&'('
)*' ' #+,-*
""$*.#/ #0$1$.#/
!"#$ ##"
%% &' ()) * !"+# ##" ,)
-% ' ()) + !".# ##" '&/)%
-% %%' ()) ! !".$ ##"
, &' ()) 0 !!# ##0
'), -% ,, %%)
12)%3 2,1)) . $!"++ ##4 /')%5
-% ,, %%)
12)% 6 4 $.0.# ##4 /')%5 , -% ,, %%)
12)% 6
" $"4.0 ##4 /')%5
-% ,, %%)
12)% 6 $# *.+ ##0 2/)
-%
-% ,, %%)
12)% 6 $$ *.!* ##0 7
-% ' -% ,, %%)
12)% 6 $ *0!0 ##0 /& 89 69' -% ,, %%)
12)% 6 $* +$$ ##0
)/):)
-% ,, PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
&') %%)
12)% 6 $+ $.!!4 ##0 )'89 )9%% -% ,, %%)
12)% 6 $! *!"! ##0 ;; ;/% 6 ' -% ,, 6
2% 342' )2 )4 342' )2)4
< 2=)%3'&)>/ )/2%))%3'&) (/
)%>9/3'&)
(/
2?)3?',2%>/ >))3'&) (
2)1/?%3)92%>/ :2))%3'&) ?5)/),)3'&)) 7,)/?)2),3'&) (
@@@ 2 )45'. 4/
$
&,,2)'%'/&)3>/ /&(1/3/),)/18(18/&,,
/ )5 ( 1'8 ) &'&3 ()& ) 1> (,
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
*
//29/)2&%0.( /2()599)()+$$##4 >/18
12)%/),))% *
/)'),,)8)9)9/ 12 ( 89 ( 98 &%/ ( , /) %) ! 8) ,)2()&2998&%/>/)9998&%/:1>51) )&)892&(898()1&2>(/ ()1&>/,)8,)81,)2()&2(98()1&
/?', ()18>)8(
-%,,&3$"0*A(/B$"0*&CD%' &)%%-%)-%,)&/8,)2()&2)&!( /&)&/)99&
/?',/)(),
-%,, AD2%3$".!A(/B$".!2%CD + $""" ### ((&)% (
-% ,, & (( 2 &%29 >/ > 9)9 / &9 ( 98()1&
/>)'*,)&)%%)#0#*### >/18&>),)(/8)$""! "03$""0 ".)$"". "4 /(%%8,)&
/( 1(/2/29/)&)>/&/>)( ')*$$###
/)))< !"#$%
&#&&!%$!'$&($ !)&
"($!*&$+%$%& , -&'$ + $' & %$ $($ & & + ($(. -&+($($$'+&%$$& ($ $ & + ($ ($ ) & &$+ % $% $ % & . ,* PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
+
()(/)$+&($$'+$.$&$'& %($'%'%$(*$'&$
0($$'%%$)!*
1211344 )
121&5.! ) ! / = &3
-% ,, ' % ) #0#!##*)5/)/,,1(/)&)(% 2))8&
/(%
1(/2 ))%9)()%>/&/>)(')!$$##* >/&/))< 3$
$' !"#$%'$&($ 6( 1)& "$! ! 6$#. 1)$!'$($3$ 74#01$"#$%+&51)& 3)"#$%8$($3$3$
9 %$! '$ & ($ %/$+!) & '%&!#.*#!,!$&($: #+$'&,$#&/!,*$'!((!)& .() . $ 9 %$! '$ & ($ & $ $,4%$ $ & %$ )) ,* & ! %$! '$ & ($ % %& ((! '!+&+/'$.$*
:#+$'&,$#&($. +&+ +& !,* $ & ($ $ '! ((! )&.().$+&+/'$.
$* $%# .&$ '$ %$#* $' ; , $ )&($'$($$';+/'$.$*
12 15&& )
12<.6( ) 0
/ ( ))% 1(
-% %%) 12)%3 2,1) A( / B
12)%CD >/&/ &), 1 , ' PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
! )+$$##4 . )2%(/21,/) >)9)9/12(&9(()1&),)2()&2( ()1&3/23&!($"0*&>))%&)1%2%$#(/ $".! 2%3 ,) &2% 1 ) >/ 8) >/) 2 & )( , /) / 8)
/ ' (&) ) #$#0##. -, )%% -% ) -% ,)&/8 ,)2()&2 ) (, / %'8 ( &
/& %( >) )% >($#!#$0 4
%$ %) &2% ( 21, /) 21,23/23(%,)&12 2%$#>))%&)1%
/,)>))22%4>/ %,) /) 1 &1
/ >) 9)9 / 12 ( &9 ( ()1& >/&/ 9)% ) ( ,)2()&2 ( (/ 2& ( ( B,)2()&2C ) ' 2 )% E-&&3$"++)>/)%E-&
)((&3$"4!)%&)1% &%')1%2$"0*&
/>)%)1%)8&/ &(89
"
/)'/)%)&2%(/))2/ &>//)1%))&
$#
/ /)%' & 2 & ! ( $"0*& >/&/2&)1%><
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
0
= -& &!! , !# %$!!% % '$ & (($$'&"%*$';%$!!;!$!! ;! .%&* .'% : %& $ ;%)$(%#!$.&!6$#. .*,*$'%$&>''%!6?';
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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
. "*.'%))#,*.. & %$ .* ((! $ & -,! %$ %$ B'$%%!!$$.$'%$$'&.C $$
/ )() & >) >( #$#$$".! / &%%&'9%8(,-%2 29 $".! ### ) ()& /) 1 ), 18 /),)3
-% ,,&,,2&))$.$$###
/>52 ###)2&,)8&
/ (//)((,)2()&2)')%E-& &3$"++)>//) ()%E-&
)((&3$"4!/2% 1 )% ( ,9 %)1%8 2 & !
( $"0* & E- B.'%D /) 1 ( 2 & A(D ( )% E-&&)&))< E'.'%%!*($%=
%! $ %!!* $ & %$.(!$ $' .'%($%@
+&%&(%'!$$*)$$&1%$ $&($$'&1%&!$&!F;% -'' "% $' .$) $ .'% & +$ .'% &!! , %$ %%$)!* &!!%!$$!*($+&$.(!$*&!,$ &($%$$.'%$';%,!)$$,!$ *($+&$))&($%$$.'%$ &$+%%$C $
,/2)%()1'F2&3'/)& ( - B,)2()&2C 2 )% E-& & '8 > &%2'8&>/&/&)%)&%%)8/&,%( ,)2()&22&
/)&/2%)-)%E-&& PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
4
>/ ,)8 )&' ) &%) 1 B,)2()&2C 9 )&593 )&593 %)1%%93 %)1%%9 & /)' 1 &%) ) & ),29,)2()&2
-%2&()%%2/)7)9!# 0+ ( )% E-&
)((&
/ ) &,, ( /) 7)9(,!#0+)/)(2//)9>/) 7)9!)%>/&3!+,),)(1)!!)&8%&)%%/ &/)/)93&/))'/) 3& (21%93893931%)&/93,&G93>93,2% (%93 &)1%9),2,)2()&2 (/)7)90$60 %)1%%93 %)1%%9 ( &) )&59 (, 12%5 )&5 )% )&5 )( )8/), / 2& ,)5)1% ),2 ,)2()&2
/ /) &%%&'%8 &%) /) 893 ,&G93 1%)&/93 21%93 >93 9 ( 8) ()1& ),2 ,)2()&2 ,%)%83 )((-9 1)3 %)1%%9 %)1%%93 )&59 (, 12%5 )&5 )% )&5 ( 9), ),2 ,)2()&2 $*
,/((B,)2()&2C2)%E-&& ) >/ /) ( )% E-&
)(( &3 ' /) ((,)2()&2(%'8()%E-&28'8>E'8 ,)%% & >/&/ &)% )&%%)8 ,)2()&2 ( 2& ),2 ,)2()&2 $"0* &3 / ( ( B.'%D3/>'3/)1'/)&>2%1%' ,)2()&2(-%E-B;!D/)1(2& A9D>/&/))< E-;!C . * ',% $ %!$& $ * $ ). $ PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
"
*$&%!.+&$!!*$($'G%$$$ +$$! $ !/ $ # '%!
!/ $ $& ', %!',C $+
, / 2)% ( )1' F2 &3 ' /) -%,) ()1& &%/8) 9), )8 / )&% ,) >/%%8)(&>%%5)(&)%%5)&%2(1 / ) ( ' /) ,)2()&2 ( 8) &%/ 9), &%2 ,) )9 &)% & &) 2 ,)2()&28)3()1&39),3,)2)&%% (%)>/)(()/)2&)%%8)-9)2&)1 1>2%)2%&(&)%%8'2&/&
/ ),91>((B,)2()&2C(,)%E-&& )>/)%E-&
)((&%'8&& / )1& ( &(& ' $"0*&3 >) ,,1% 1> ( (, )% E-& & >/&/ ) & %'89 ) (( 8 ( 28 )% E-& &3 18 >)8 ( E
/ ' ( ):2, ( 28 ) ) )9)9)/281))-)9
/2&/' $"0* & 7) %9%)2 1> ( ( B,)2()&2C (, )% E-&&3 ,2 /)' &) ), ' / $"0*& $! /%892&!AD($"0*&>/&/ >)$".!&%83')9%8>)&' (, &9 2 (, $".! ###
/ ()& &1) 18 % ) $.$$### ( /),)3
-% ,, /)%(/)8(&2&)1%>< PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
$#
E1,
"((!%,!*$'-;!$..H
$($%$
:+$!!/$+*$/$$$#$ %$$&,$#,4%)&.)$'& -;! $.. &! 0!& $ & !* ,A!*)*$#$ $&(+&+,$)& $ *$ / $ & & ,$# ($,!. , $!#&!)$'$%)I(%! -;!:*)! -&'%.&,,!A$$'!#*$' %$$%)I+&!)!$($+!!#* $ ,$& & +* : ((!%,! #%#
"!&$)& & "% %. $ ;% $ )! ( & , %$!!% $# ($ $'
* &%,!&'%&$((!%,!$ (($%)
: & % & ,4% . +& 1& " +!! $' 8$ $' : " 1!/ #) :* ((&".#>.*,,* &-;!*$#$%*!)!%$.(!%$ +& ) $ & -;! $..H (%!!* '$ (($%).%&.*$'&. &$'..%!$.!!$.'%* #*.!!!/%$)*
-& $& $ & +& * (%& & +#(*&%%&)(!*#$%,*& * .'% & %$.($ .!! &#) () +#) ($%) (* & !#* $' ;% % $ * )* %!$& $' ($% %!$& & % .* , .!!&#)+#)($%)(*-;!$* +& (%& % $ )* $' ($% %!$& & %.*,!!&#)$!*+#)(*&%* +&(%&9/($+&!$$.%!$&;.( '$. -;! $ % , %&) $ ( ($%) % * !#! !* ( -%&%!!*($%$$.'%&*$$ PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
$$
./%!$&2*2;! &(%$&((!%,!*$'%$( ($%)$'-;!$..%$%+&%&& $ . ((!%,! '$ & ! * '& &.!*.($,!$%$#&%($%) ''(.*,)#).(!$*.$ $ ($(! $.$$!%&%&$+%+$)?$%$!!% & % ' + %$!!% +& +!! &(( $ & ($ ,+&($
: #+ $' & ,$# : $)!* '!! & <$ -;! $ %$ '#$,!* & ,4% . +&%& #!!* & .$ A $' & -;! $.. $ & ,! $ '$ $ %&)) & -;!
$..H$($%)I(%# $'&?$'&%$%
-&/)*$!$$/)'$+$&)'$.*$ +&/($!) J$'&'!!* 12 3#,&0# &.C $0
,/2)%()%3'/),,%( >)(//)&/2%1%'&9 2))/)9(,)2()&2(8))8,(&)/ )9(8)2((&&>)%'29&9!8)3 ,1% &' / &) &9 2 >/&/ ) 9'9 ,%8,(,!!#% $. /
-%,,4+/9/%!###* %'/)&/2%1%'&92 /2%1%')/)9(8)
/&&%2)>/)() ,92&)1%>< PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
$
E
"' ! %$ .$ ,$# & $..&%&'$!!$+)
-$%*$&..&"%'$
!.) & % , $!* $ & ;! * ' ,$# & ;! .%&*@
%)&((!.$'$'%'$. &;)K$K
+)&($+$';.($1%$ F ($($,$#@ , $' % &$! $ , % &$! %$$, K % $ %! & ;! * ,) %$. &$ & % (#+ , $ ;%! & *.'$;($
$$,!)!$($,.($($!$& 6$#. '$ ;.($ $' '$ & ( ($'$.(($+($%$$& !.!$1%$$'F;%"%C $4
/)%G9/()&/)2')1%%'8) &%%&&(,-%2'(&))#$#0##.-,)%% / -% 2 ) /)( )1%/ / & %( >( $#!#$0 / ()& &%%&'%8 ' /) ?', %( >) ' ( / /)&/2%1&/)9(,&92 $"
/,29&>2###)'%' $""! "4 ,) & > 2 18 $ 8) (, / '%' 2% $# ( / $".! 2% ' /) & /)%% 1 2 >/$8)2%$#))<
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$1!$$!1!##
$*
E 7%$#* $' % &$ !# $$!* !# & & % & , &$ !# &$)& #% $ $&+ $ +& $$!* '@ & .'% %&),! +& & % $ &$ !# $ $ +&$. ' & , $$!* . $ $% $' . '$. & $.. . +& $ * '$. & $+&%&&%&,(&!!(*&'%%* $&%.*,'&.$($&.;% +&.$&'$.&$'%($'%&$%C
/ >)5 ( )( & 2%3 / & > 1) 18 %,) #
/ '> ( & ( / 2 ( ))%1(%%)
12)% ,/2)%(3' /)
12)% /) ) ) )%%8 )59 )% /) 1 ,,&/)&)%%8)>/2&9()&2)%)%9)% $
In the wake of above discussions and findings, we are of the considered opinion that the instant petitions deserve to be )%%> ) )&&9%8)%%>,29)/18)
9)%&)AD3()83)%)(
.2 )4/
.2)4/
!,-*&5 0(/0"
//)59) H
//)1%
H PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.12.26 13:54 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document