Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 111850 (PNJ)
INDERJIT SINGH v. PSEB AND ANR
RSA/1191/1994 · 2025-11-03
Vikas Bahl
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 111850 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 111850 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#"$%&''( $)*+""$,- ''''..//$ 0*#1# 1$+2
/!*"!"3*)$)$-* '''''#.$)$# 4% 56
4'
0 76
8888 0 769'6 7
!"#$% & #
! &&'&$$(
)
"* +$,-.# ((/(',$$' )
)
)
" )
*
0
*)
" #
!# &('%$$(
)
"* NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
" ( 1
) )2
3)4
#2
!". *5 6 && &(-'/-$%$78
6) '%$%$ ) ' !" . * 5 9.* :
$;9
" <$;
=:>
*
0
*
(',$$'
*) )
?)
- )! )
" 0
*"
)
) (',$$')0
"
@
) *)
)
) *
,9
:$; )0
0
*
, A
#
&'$$$& ) NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
&
/ # 0
*)
"
,9
:$; )
0
* )0
"A
# A#
" #" )
)
)
* )
)"*BC"# <
= !)*
*
"* ) 4
6
66
; 3" )
'%$%$9.6&: 9.6 :)(',$$'-
)
)
)" ? "
,9
:$; )
) )
*)
*"
* NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
)
)
))
) -
)"
*! *? "
)
)
"*BC"#
" )
)
)* ! *
) -
!*? "# )*
! ) )
)
*,9
: $;
? ! )
"*
* )
-! *? "
*
)
"
"*#3 -
)
)
"
*$$'-
)
"* 4
6
% 3
"
)
) ,9
:$;
NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
( ? "
**) 0
*)0
"
)! *? "
! # )#
)
)
"
6
$ A
#
"2)
") ) ' A "
0
) ) )
" :--*#.., ;$$1/"$!*<$#;"- 11* ! ;1/) <1$ <"$* .$/3 * <+* .$/3 "$ !!*)$! ;"- ,1/"$ ( - = ,1/"$##../"!2/-"< -"##1$! #-; !1# $"! )) '>'>
?' * *)* ))&'('
?'@
"" $!#-#").$/3"#-/)2<+*.$/39 -$9 ;--* " ;# "$!1<2$ 1.$ - *#.$)$ ).*<$ -A !$)1!) *,1/* "$B1"*3 "$ !!*)$!;"--,1/"$#>$) -= NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
C ,1/"$#@
""" :--*-+1),<$# -*"/1*#;//# - #..//1**.*A*##-,1/"$#;-"!- -A2$D$"$!$#")*"$*$-*/A$ ,1/"$#@ A
? "
* ))
) 0
*) A
*0
)
) )
)
)"! *
*A$;
*
"
*
! *
,&'',
")
!"#
$% #
# & ! !
"# !"'( #$%&'(%)*$( )* %$+ )*
! + )* %
" ! "
" %$"
%$ &" ! , &" % &%
+
+
,-. ,- +,/ #)0&'(%)*$$( +
,-. ,- +, $%
!(%
" % # $ %
! " NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
= %! " $
$% $%
-" $% # $%
%
$$ %! " + )* $%
!(%
"# #
%# %
" & &
! ! " !( %
"# #
%# ! % $%#
$ $ % %
% ! % ! " $%
" " $%
#
% + )* % !$
" ! + )* ! ! % % & .$%
$$ ! "! $ , + )-* ! ! % %
" & .$%
$$ ! "! $ ,
"
) ) )
)
"
* ! " &3) *"
)
"
"
!) )
)
) (',$$')
,$; )
)
")
!"#
$%
# # & ! ! "# !"'( NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
> /01 2134025 )* %$+ )*
! + )* %
" ! "
" %$"
%$ &" ! , &" % &%
+
+
,-.1 /36 2134025 + ,
-,. ,
"
,
-. ,-. ,, 2 .,
" ,
+,
,- .1 )* $%
! %
"# #
%# %
" & &
! ! " ! %
"# #
%# ! % $%
$ $ %
%
% ! % ! " $%
"
" $%
#
% + )* % !$
" ! + )* ! ! % % & .$%
$$ ! "! $ , + )-* ! ! % %
" & .$%
$$ ! "!
$ ,
"
)) ," 9
:$;
) *
"
* ))
) -)
*!* ( A
"BC" NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
#
A) )"
)
) )
"
*$$'
ABC" # )
-)" !*),9
:) ,9:!"#
9
: $;'?) )
*" 0
*)
" )"
. "
) 2
*) ! )! )" )*)!* ) 0
*
*
6 6
)
0
*"
* *)
)*" *"
? " BC"#2 )6 NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
0
*
)
"*
#
)! B
#)
A ! ") 7 (
!"#
$% # # & ! ! ! "# !"' #$%&'(%)*$( )* 8$+ )*
! + )* %
" ! "
" %$"
%$ &" ! ! &" % &%
+
+
,-.1 #)0&'(%)*$$( + ,
-3,. ,
"
,
+--. ,-. ,, 2 .,
" ,
+,
,- .1 )* $%
!(%
"# #
% %
" & &
! ! ! " ! %
"# #
% ! % $%#
$ $ %
%
% ! %
! ! " $%
" "
$%
#
%+ )* % !$
" !+ )* ! ! % % & .$%
$$ ! "! $ !+ )-* ! ! % %
" & .$%
$$ ! "! $ !9 NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
--- --- --- :
$ % !$ &" %" !% # ! " $% !(% &" % $" $
$ % %
"9 %! $
& % $ !(%
" !$
" 4
,
,
,,-/5, -- , +, + ' +'/ 0 $ $& ; ,%
+/ "//0
")//0/# < ;
,%# % ! .$ # =
%! %$!$ %# &" %
! %$ )* $ $ :
$>& 8 5% $ 0 $ $ %$ )*
$ & $%
!
%
" &" % ! $
" !$
"
% $% $%
& % &
$ & % $%
$$ %! " 0 $% %
%! $ %$!$ %
0 % %! $ %$!$ % ! ! " $%
! %
" 3%%
" %$ )* $ %& % % % $& ? 8 $ 0
6$ !" &
% %$ ,$ % < &%< !#
$ " & # $ & % %$
$ 6
+,,,"
- ,
. . -"
,-" ,
,-
- , . + -. 2. / ,7, , - -/ ' + - NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
,
. . -. ,- . ,- + , 2,
7 . , ,/
,
." + /
- +
-,-
- '+ '1
-. -
-. 7 . / / ,
%., '8. ,, , ,
2
+.- '8' + .,/ , 7 ." 7 . . /$,,,,7 . ., + ,. -. "2-
,32-
" 2-
"7 . - '8'/ $ !" #
% &" .$ %#
% $% .$" &
$"
% .$ % % $
% &$ # + 7 . 7 ,,32-
,. - -! & % + %
&" .$" %# %" $
" ! .$" % ) 7 . , ,
. . ,
-,
, + '/ - , /
" , , ,
2
, ,,, '8 /&+ ." ,
. .7 . - . ,. ,
,, ,, . NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
& - 7 , - -
. 4
- ./0 % # # $ &
" ! "# %$
%" ! % $ >$%
$ & $% % !% %$ $+
- -., . 7 .,, -
,. / , .,/ -,6
+
.-
./)
, -
2
, 7 .'8'/ ,, . -,6
,
, ,-,
,/9 ,A)
)
"
!
)
)" )
-
0
A #
5
#
: -/ - / 6.9"; &*
<6===;
"
! )
!* )* 0
*
)
" )
A
! ")
.$
$ %
%$ &"
! NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
" $ .$"
7 ,. - -- ./$. ,- ,- +, -."
7 . -
-/
" -.+
" - / ? 9& 5$! 8 $ %
+/ " ; > ,-
,- + ,
- +
-)'--. ""7 .- - ./ 5 7 ." - ,-
,- +,",",/'8 ',.+ ,,,7 . - ,,
,- ,- + ,/ 0 $
$%! ? 9& $! 8 $ @$ 5 A )$*#
$ $ &, -
,- ,- +-." - , + -
7 ./ ,."
- -
7 .,-
+
, ./&
" - -
,
""3 / 8 .$"#
= >% &"
&
%
/?)" !*"
%$$; )
$$' NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
( !*") 0
*
*
"* 0
*
0
A
" )
"*
)0
" 0
%9,:9":$; )
"
"* *
*)
0 *
0
* " 9&:
A"00 0
*""
*) *
0
* $$; ; 7 0
*
*
!*
"
"
) )
*
"** 0
*")*)
+)
"
"
#)
*) 0
*
" )* )
A %$;
)
"
* $%'
") NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
C :)'3$,$-
'&(?@'(A&'$#& $%
#)0&'(%)*$( = )* 1
! " % %$ )* )-* $ -2,
7 ."-. -+
'
-+
/ )* $ $
"
"
$
" ! &" , # &" % #
$ .$ $
"
! "# -.
" 7
'
." 7
/ (2
$ $
"# .$" " % $&($ )B* )* $&($
)* .$ $
" & % $ % $ $
" )
*
.$" ! " $ $ $ #
. ,1
,
,
,,1
-
, , ," ,, 33
- + , , . -
, -.-.1
,-. ,
. -" ,, / ! . +, + -.,. ,,"-
,- . ,,
,,
.$ ! " $&!# $% ! !" & %# ! %
&
)* )* % ! %# NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
= $ $
" !" .$ $%
% % ! # %
%"
# $ $&( $ )*# .$ $
" $ # % % & ! &" ! " ! %# $ $
" %
% % < $% % !" < % ! $
)&* $ -, - . -."
.-. 7
,,-."
,
,. " 3 ;" 7
./ ,5
. 7
. ,,
7
. 7 . ,," -.". -.,
"4 B & ,B
,
,,/9 % A"* )
)
# ) (',$$' $ A0
+9
:9
:)"
") )
) !*
!*
"
%$ $;
) 0
"
)
)
*" NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
>
&' ! #) # ) ) # 2 ,9
:$;
) )
+
" 3
"")*
) (',$$'A )
""*" &!)
" (',$$'
"
" A ! #) #
*
* )
)
"
* A"
0
)+9
: ) & )" (',$$'
" && A0
)
" )
" 0
*A
) *$$'! #)
*$$( NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement
#)
*$$(
"
*$$ ABD"#
) 6
0
*A
#"
)
)"6
0
* &( *
) ! #)# (',$$'
"
A-
)"
0
"
0 76
A<2*&9(
< >-2
E F >"E F NARESH KUMAR 2025.11.06 17:24 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document/judgement