- 1 - !"! # $" % &" ! $ '()*+,() +- & ! " #$ % ! & $ $ & $ $ !'' ! " #$ & ! & % Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ( & & ! () ' ( & && $ ( ( '' '( ' ( ' * * * ( (** & & & & & + ,$ + # ,$ + % --./01 2! 34 5360 2() ' ( 5073/80501 9: ;25<=.5 2>3-0 8<8324 <1735 ?25 8;0 2??04-0/ =.43/;<9>0 .4105 0-8324/ ( ( '' '( ' ( ' * * * ( <41 (** 2? 3/ 90?250 8;3/ 2.58 .4105 0-8324 ( 2? 5 @38; < =5<:05 82 A.</; 8;0 048350 =52-001347/ 34 8;0 /<31 -</0 @;3-; 3/ =041347 90?250 8;0 2.58 2? 3B3> .170 <41 & #54% ;25<=.5 <1735 13/853-8 - 3 - 0<51 >0<5401 -2.4/0> ?25 8;0 =083832405 >0<5401 37; 2.58 2B0546048 >0<105 ?25 50/=241048 2! <41 >0<5401 -2.4/0> ?25 50/=241048 2 0<5401 -2.4/0> ?25 8;0 =083832405 /.9638/ 8;<8 ?35/8 34?256<8324 3/ /.9638801 9: 8;0 008;<1;3=<83 2? 8;0 .88 2? @;3-; 8;0 =083832405 @</ 008;<1;3=<83 ?25 8;0 =05321 ?526 '! 82 '!* >>07<8324/ 6<10 34 8;0 ?35/8 34?256<8324 <50 9</0>0// <41 428 0B04 < /347>0 ><1: 10B2800 2? 8;0 .88 ;</ 6<10 <4: -26=><348 425 1.5347 8;0 -2.5/0 2? 34B0/837<8324 8;0 34B0/837<8324 2??3-05 ;</ 50-25101 8;0 /8<806048 2? <4: B3-836 ><1: 0 /.9638/ 8;<8 ?25 0C85<402./ 50</24/ 8;0 36=.7401 -53634<> =52-001347/ ;</ 9004 34383<801 --251347>: ;0 =5<:/ 82 <>>2@ 8;0 =0838324 ( 05 -2485< >0<5401 37; 2.58 2B0546048 >0<105 ;</ 2==2/01 =0838324 0 /.9638/ 8;<8 4B0/837<8324 ??3-05 ;</ -2>>0-801 -058<34 6<8053<> 1.5347 8;0 -2.5/0 2? 34B0/837<8324 @;3-; @2.>1 =536< ?<-30 /;2@ 8;<8 =083832405 ;</ 63/<==52=53<801 8;0 =52=058: 2? 8;0 - 4 - .88 0 ;2@0B05 ?<35>: /.9638/ 8;<8 4B0/837<8324 ??3-05 ;</ 428 50-25101 8;0 /8<806048 2? <4: 240 2? 8;0 <>>0701 ><1: 10B2800/ @38; @;26 8;0 =083832405 <>>0701>: ;</ 63/90;<B01 05./<> 2? 8;0 ?35/8 34?256<8324 @;3-; @</ /.9638801 24 '' ' ( 9: 50/=241048 2 @;2 3/ 8;0 =50/048 008;<1;3=<83 2? 8;0 .88 D42@4 </ ;53 31:D<4B< 35<E ;358;<5. @2.>1 72 82 /;2@ 8;<8 8;0 =083832405 ;05034 @</ 8;0 <8;<1;3=<83 2? 8;0 /<31 34/838.8324 ?25 8;0 =05321 ?526 '! 82 '!* ;0 <>>07<8324 <7<34/8 8;0 =083832405 3/ 8;<8 @;04 ;0 @</ 8;0 <8;<1;3=<83 2? 8;0 34/838.8324 ;0 ;<1 63/90;<B01 @38; 8;0 ?06<>0 10B2800/ 2? 8;0 .88 <41 <>/2 8;50<80401 8;06 @38; 1350 -24/0A.04-0/ 34 8;0 0B048 8;0: 50B0<>01 ;3/ <-8/ 8 3/ <>>0701 8;<8 ;0 ;<1 ?25-01 8;0 10B2800/ 2? 8;0 .88 82 />00= @38; ;36 <41 <>/2 ./01 82 /041 29/-040 +;<8/== 60//<70/ 82 8;06 ;3/ 2.58 B310 25105 1<801 !! ' ( ;<1 -<>>01 .=24 8;0 >0<5401 8<80 .9>3- 52/0-.825 82 B053?: - 5 - <41 /.9638 <92.8 8;0 34B0/837<8324 1240 34 8;0 =50/048 -</0 <?805 8;0 & @</ 5073/80501 ;0 >0<5401 37; 2.58 2B0546048 >0<105 @;2 ;</ =521.-01 8;0 34B0/837<8324 50=258 <>247 @38; <4 <==>3-<8324 ?3>01 9: ;36 ?25 B<-<8347 8;0 3480536 25105 75<4801 9: 8;3/ 2.58 ;</ ?<35>: /.9638801 90?250 8;3/ 2.58 8;<8 4B0/837<8347 ??3-05 ;</ 428 50-25101 8;0 /8<806048 2? <4: 240 2? 8;0 <>>0701 ?06<>0 10B2800/ @38; @;26 8;0 =083832405 <>>0701>: ;<1 63/90;<B01 25 @;26 ;0 ;<1 -53634<>>: 3483631<801 ) 05./<> 2? 8;0 ?35/8 34?256<8324 @2.>1 72 82 /;2@ 8;<8 8;050 3/ 42 /=0-3?3- <>>07<8324 </ <7<34/8 8;0 =083832405 ;05034 <92.8 <4: 63/<==52=53<8324 2? 8;0 =52=058: 2? 8;0 .88 <41 24>: 26439./ <>>07<8324 3/ 6<10 82 8;0 <?250/<31 0??0-8 ;0 =534-3=<> <>>07<8324 <7<34/8 8;0 =083832405 34 8;0 ?35/8 34?256<8324 3/ <92.8 2.85<7347 8;0 6210/8: 2? ?06<>0 10B2800/ <41 <>/2 /8<>D347 8;06 8 3/ ?.58;05 <>>0701 8;<8 ;0 ;<1 /048 29/-040 +;<8/== 60//<70/ 82 8;0 ?06<>0 10B2800/ <41 <>/2 ;<1 -53634<>>: 3483631<801 8;06 <41 -<>>01 .=24 8;06 82 />00= @38; ;36 - 6 - 8 3/ 428 8;0 -</0 2? 8;0 ?35/8 34?256<48 8;<8 ;0 ;<1 50-03B01 <4: @538804 -26=><348 34 8;3/ 507<51 ?526 <4: 240 2? 8;0 ?06<>0 10B2800/ 425 8;0 4B0/837<8347 ??3-05 ;</ 50-25101 8;0 /8<806048 2? <4: 240 2? 8;0 ?06<>0 10B2800/ 2? 8;0 .88 1.5347 8;0 -2.5/0 2? 34B0/837<8324 2? 8;0 -</0 4105 8;0 -35-.6/8<4-0/ <6 2? 8;0 2=34324 8;<8 3? 8;0 36=.7401 -53634<> =52-001347/ 3/ <>>2@01 82 90 -24834.01 8;0 /<60 @2.>1 428 24>: -<./0 /0532./ ;<51/;3= <41 069<55<//6048 82 8;0 =083832405 9.8 38 <>/2 @2.>1 <62.48 82 <9./0 2? =52-0// 2? ><@ 4105 8;0 -35-.6/8<4-0/ 82 /0-.50 8;0 041/ 2? E./83-0 38 3/ 40-0//<5: 82 A.</; 8;0 048350 -53634<> =52-001347/ --251347>: ?2>>2@347 25105 3/ =<//01 ;0 -53634<> =0838324 3/ <>>2@01 ;0 048350 =52-001347/ 34 5360 2() ' ( 5073/80501 9: ;25<=.5 2>3-0 8<8324 <1735 ?25 8;0 2??04-0/ =.43/;<9>0 .4105 0-8324/ ( ( '' - 7 - '( ' ( ' * * * ( <41 (** 2? =041347 90?250 8;0 2.58 2? 3B3> .170 <41 & #54% ;25<=.5 <1735 13/853-8 </ <7<34/8 8;0 =083832405 <--./01 2! /8<41/ A.</;01 4 B30@ 2? 13/=2/<> 2? 6<34 =0838324 =041347 <==>3-<8324 3? <4: /8<41/ 13/=2/01 2?? ., ) % &" !+ " 3/8 2 ! > 2