Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11150 (KAR)
NAMDEV AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/200926/2024 · 2025-02-03
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11150 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11150 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!""
#$% & '% "
$ (
)(*+,)( ++ '
!"!#
$ !! !"!#
#
%
#
!"!#
&
&
!"!#
! #! !"!#
$ #'
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"!#
(
$
! !"!#
)*
+ * $*
* ** + !"!'
$
"
$+ * $++
!"!'&
) *
*+,
$ +
* + !"+
'#&" + * * + * '&' #' +
** * + ++*
&-"!'&!'##$#& +*
#&+*-
+
&(#'# + ++ *
&-" !'& !' ## $ #& + *
- 3 -
#&+*-
+ * * + .'('#$ * +++
,
++
/ + +
+
*+
$
0
$
*0
$
112345 63 76 " 89 6&(#'# :49589;
<4=6>4 7?4 62>7 6= 5587869@A +
@A@<2>@;8 @>8389;
627 6= >8B4 6#' >4;8374>45 <C
@A@<2>@;8 87C $6B49 *6A814 7@7869
@A@<2>@;8 =6> 7?4 6==49143 :2983?@<A42954> 4178693&-" !'&!'##>4@5D87? 417869#&6=*@>4<4=6>47?8362>72954> 417869&" 6=>*D87?@:>@C4>76E2@3?7?44978>4:>6144589;389 7?4@=6>43@851@34@3@;@89377?4B
4@>5A4@>945162934A=6>7?4:@>7843
- 4 -
# 4@>945162934A=6>7?4:47878694>332<B8737?@7 @=74> 7?4 B@>>8@;4 6= @112345 6 @95 ?83 D8=4>43:695497 6 7?4C D4>4 37@C89; 34:@>@74AC @7 *294 ?4>4@=74> >43:695497 6 ?@3 >472>945 76 ?4> :@>4973/ ?6234 @95 ?@3 <449 37@C89; 7?4>4 112345 6?23<@95?@589878@745:>6144589;32954> 417869-6= 7?48952@>>8@;417-!!@;@8937>43:6954976@95 7?43@B4?@3<449541>445D87?@=89589;7?@7>43:695497 6D8=4 ?@5 D87?5>@D9 =>6B 7?4 16B:@9C 6= ?4> ?23<@95 D87?627 F@A85 >4@3693 C B@G89; =@A34 @95 6B98<23 @AA4;@78693 7?4 :47878694>3 D?6 @>4 >4A@78F43 6= @112345 6 @>4 @>>@8;945 @3 @112345 89 7?4 :>43497 1@34116>589;AC?4:>@C376@AA6D7?4:4787869 & *4> 1697>@ A4@>945 8;? 62>7 6F4>9B497 *A4@54>@::4@>89;=6>>43:6954976@95A4@>945162934A @::4@>89;=6>>43:6954976?@F46::63457?4:4787869 ?4 A4@>945 =6> >43:695497 6 32<B873 7?@7 7?4 @AA4;@78693@>4B@54@;@8937@AA7?4@112345:4>3693897?4
- 5 -
8B:2;945 1>8B89@A :>6144589;3 116>589;AC 7?4C :>@C 76 583B8337?4:4787869 ! @>>8@;4 6= @1123456 @95>43:6954976 ?4>489 D@3 :4>=6>B45 69 ('&' @95 @=74> 7?4 B@>>8@;4 @112345 6 @95 ?83 D8=4 D4>4 37@C89; 89 @ >49745 :>4B8343 @7 *294 +>6B 7?4 D45A61G @ <6C 1?8A5 D@3 <6>9 76 7?4 162:A4 69 (''' 9 7?4 =8>37 89=6>B@7869 87 83 @AA4;45 7?@7 @=74> >43:695497 6D8=4 ?@5;8F49<8>7?767?41?8A53?4D@39677@G49<@1G<C?4> ?23<@95 AA4;@7869 89 7?4 =8>37 89=6>B@7869 83 7?@7 69 '&'7?4@112345:4>36931@B4767?4?62346=7?4 :@>4973 6= >43:695497 6 @95 ?@5 E2@>>4A45 D87?
?4> @=74>54B@9589;56D>C783@AA4;457?@7@1123456?@5 @33@2A745 ?4> @95 67?4> @112345 :4>3693 89378;@745 ?8B 7 83 =2>7?4> @AA4;45 7?@7 @AA 7?4 @112345 :4>3693 A4=7 7?4 :A@14@=74>1>8B89@AAC8978B85@789;>43:6954976@95?4> =@B8ACB4B<4>3
4@>945 162934A =6> 7?4 :47878694>3 ?@3 :>652145H25;B497@95541>44:@3345896&!'&
- 6 -
D?81?D@3=8A45<C@1123456?23<@952954> 417869- 6=7?48952@>>8@;417-!!=6>>43787278696=169H2;@A >8;?73 9 7?4 3@85 :>6144589;3 @ =89589; ?@3 <449 >416>545<C7?4H2>835817869@A+@B8AC62>77?@7>43:695497 6D8=4 ?@5 A4=7 7?4 16B:@9C 6= ?4> ?23<@95 D87?627 F@A85>4@369397?4<@1G;>62956=7?43@85=89589;8=7?4 @AA4;@78693D?81?@>4B@54897?4=8>3789=6>B@7869=8A4589 7?4B697?6=:>8A'8331>27898I4587<416B4358==812A7 76<4A84F47?43@B49@5587869767?43@B4;494>@A@95 6B98<23 @AA4;@78693 @>4 =6295 @3 @;@8937 7?4 :47878694>3 ?4>489@95963:418=816F4>7 @173@>4B@54@;@89377?4B ( ?4 B@74>8@A 69 >416>5 D62A5 @A36 ;6 76 3?6D 7?@7 @=74> >43:695497 6 ?@5 A4=7 7?4 16B:@9C 6= ?4> ?23<@953?4?@57@G493?4A74>89?4>:@>4973/?6234@95 @112345 6?23<@95 ?@5 89878@745 :>6144589;3 @;@8937 ?4>2954> 417869-6=7?48952@>>8@;417-!!9 7?4 =8>37 89=6>B@7869 87 83 @AA4;45 7?@7 @AA 7?4 @112345 :4>36931@B4767?4?62346=:@>49736=>43:6954976 @95@<2345@95@33@2A745?4>
- 7 -
" ?4 690<A4 2:>4B4 62>7 89 7?4 1@34 6=
?@3?4A5@3=6AA6D3
! "#
$%&'
1 '-& ! - 8 -
(
)
$ *
(
)
+
(
(
, # #
- #
(
( ! - 9 -
. ! )
+
- +2>7?4>7?4690<A4 2:>4B462>7897?4@34 6=
@95 89 7?4 1@34 6=
?@3 6<34>F45 7?@7 89 7?4 @<34914 6= 3:418=81 @AA4;@78693 D?81? D62A5 @77>@17 7?4 6==49143 @9 @774B:7 76 8B:A81@74 7?4 94@> >4A@78F43 6= 7?4 ?23<@95 1@9967 <4 :4>B87745 ' ?83 62>7 89 7?4 1@34 6=
2 '-& ! 3 '-" &
- 10 -
?@3 ?4A5 7?@7 D?49 7?4 B@74>8@A 69 >416>5 D62A5 ;6 76 3?6D 7?@7 7?4 :47878694>3 D?6 @>4 1A634 >4A@78F43 6= ?23<@95 @>4 B@>>845 @95>438589; 34:@>@74AC @95D?497?416B:A@897A@1G33:418=81@AA4;@7869336@376 8B:A81@74 7?4 :47878694>3 =6> 7?4 6==49143 @AA4;45 @;@8937 7?4B 321? 1>8B89@A :>634127869 3?@AA 967 <4 @AA6D45 76 16978924
954> 7?4 18>12B37@9143 @B 6= 7?4 6:89869 7?@7 7?4 :>@C4> B@54 <C 7?4 :47878694>3 >4E28>43 76 <4 ;>@9745<CE2@3?89;7?48B:2;9451>8B89@A:>6144589;3@3 @;@89377?4B116>589;AC=6AA6D89;6>54>83:@3345
?41>8B89@A:478786983@AA6D45 ?44978>4:>6144589;3896&(#'#:49589;
<4=6>47?462>76=5587869@A+
@A@<2>@;8@>8389;
627 6= >8B4 6#' >4;8374>45 <C
@A@<2>@;8 87C $6B49 *6A814 7@7869
@A@<2>@;8 =6> 7?4 6==49143 :2983?@<A42954> 4178693&-" !'&!'##>4@5D87? 4 ''
-'
- 11 -
417869 #& 6= * @3 @;@8937 7?4 :47878694>3@112345 6376"37@953E2@3?45
5 ( & '% "+ %
8376 A6# *