Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11136 (KAR)
LINGANNA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/201076/2023 · 2025-02-03
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11136 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11136 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#$%!!&! '% ! "
$ ()(*+,(!!++ ,' $ ()(*+,(!!++
, '
! "
#
$ ! #
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% & %
"
' % & %
# !&! ! (
) *! %+
( ! !,#
! $#
! ( ,#
)
*! %
- %
%+
( . ## #* #+ ! $ #
#" ' ! - 3 -
%
,
'
! ( ,'
! ( ,'
"
! ( ,'
/
! ( ,'
! ! ( ,'
"
! ( ,'
- 4 -
$
! ( ,'
! ( ,'
) *! %
%+
,' * ! !!+
! ! ( ,'
)
*! %
- %+
(
%% '$ # ! $
# #" '
- 5 -
0! %
*0! % +
123##$" # 45 64278 9: ;<7 =>>?578 4@ 3 # A7@84@B 976317 ;<7 3?1; 36 4C42 ?8B7 =@8
=@C4
=4><?1 45;14>;
=1454@B 3?; 36 14D7 3 # 17B45;7178 9: 3;E=2 324>7 ;=;43@
=4><?1 631 3667@>75 A?@45<=927 ?@871 7>;43@5
$ #
#"=@8'36<76415;4@631D=@;4@ 14D73 #45;<7D3;<7136=>>?5783=@8;<7 3;<71=>>?578=17=226=D42:D7D9715
14D4@=2A7;4;43@3#" #45642789:;<7 =>>?5784@3'$ #A7@84@B976317;<73?1;36 4C42 ?8B7 =@8
=@C4
=4><?1 45;14>;
=1454@B 3?; 3614D73 #17B45;71789: 3;E=2324>7 ;=;43@ =4><?1
=>>?578 3,4@B=@@= 4@ 14D7 3 # 45 ;<76415;4@631D=@;4@;<7A1757@;>=57=@8;<7C4>;4D5 4@ 14D73 #=17;<7=>>?5784@14D73 #
- 6 -
7=1@78 >3?@572 =AA7=14@B 631 ;<7 A14C=;7 A=1;475F34@;2:5?9D4;;<=;;<7845A?;797;E77@;<7A=1;475 E<3=17=22D7D971536=6=D42:<=5977@=D4>=92:57;;278 =@8 4@ C47E 36 ;<7 57;;27D7@; E<4>< <=5 977@ =114C78 97;E77@ ;<7 6=D42: D7D9715 E4;<3?; ;<717 974@B =@:
>371>43@31?@8?74@62?7@>7
;<7:4@;7@8;3B4C7=G?47;?5 ;3;<7845A?;7=@8;<7176317A1=:;<=;;<7A1=:71D=874@ ;<757;E3A7;4;43@5D=:97=223E78
<7 A=1;475 <=C7 64278 =@ =AA24>=;43@ 4@ ;<757 ;E3D=;;715976317;<453?1;?@871 7>;43@'17=8E4;< 36 ! # =23@B E4;< ;<7 =6648=C4; 36 4@B=@@= E<345=>>?57834@14D73 #=@8;<7=6648=C4;
36<45D3;<71=1=5=DD=
E<345;<76415;4@631D=@;4@;<7 5=48>=57E4;<=A1=:71;3A71D4;;<7A=1;475;3>3DA3?@8 ;<7><=1B75<77;783667@>75=@8=253;3B1=@;;<7A1=:71 D=874@;<7A7;4;43@
7=1@78 4B< 3?1; 3C71@D7@; 27=871 <=5 913?B<; ;3 ;<7 @3;4>7 36 ;<45 3?1; ;<=; =22 ;<7 3667@>75 D7@;43@784@;<7><=1B75<77;=17@3;>3DA3?@8=927
- 7 -
" <7 =AA24>=;43@ 64278 9: ;<7 A=1;475 577H4@B A71D45543@ ;3 >3DA3?@8 ;<7 ><=1B7 5<77;78 3667@>75
45 ;=H7@3@17>318<75=D7455?AA31;789:;<7=6648=C4;36 =>>?5783=@8;<76415;4@631D=@; $ @ A=1=B1=A< 35 ;3 36 ;<7 =6648=C4;5
4; 45 5;=;78<=563223E5-
! "
#
$$%!&'!($$%)*+&'!
$ ,
( ,-.$ - /
- 8 -
0
/
1
2
2
/
* 3
2
I
<7845A?;797;E77@;<7A=1;475<=5977@@3E =D4>=92:57;;278<7A=1;475=17=22>2357172=;4C75=@84@ C47E 36 ;<7 57;;27D7@;
E<4>< <=5 977@ =114C78 97;E77@ ;<7DE<4><455=48;397C32?@;=1:E4;<3?;;<717974@B=@:
>371>43@31?@8?74@62?7@>7
;<7:4@;7@8;3A?;=@7@8;3 ;<7 A7@84@B >14D4@=2 >=575 <3?B<
;<7 ><=1B7 5<77;
3667@>75 =17 @3; >3DA3?@8=927
4@ C47E 36 ;<7 2=E 2=48 83E@ 9: ;<7 3@J927 ?A17D7 3?1; 4@ ;<7 >=57 36
C5 !1 E<7174@ 4;4539571C78;<=;@3;E4;<5;=@84@B;<724D4;=;43@5A13C4878
1 # @24@7
- 9 -
?@871 7>;43@#361
;<453?1;4@7K71>457364;5 A3E71 ?@871 7>;43@ 36 1
>=@ G?=5< ;<7 >14D4@=2 A13>7784@B5 17B45;7178 7C7@ 631 @3@ >3DA3?@8=927 3667@>75
;=H4@B 4@;3 >3@54871=;43@ ;<7 @=;?17 36 57;;27D7@; =@8 ;<7 B1=C4;: 36 ;<7 3667@>75 4@C32C784@;<75=48>=575 ' @871 ;<7 >41>?D5;=@>75
=D 36 ;<7 3A4@43@ ;<=; ;<7 A1=:71 D=87 9: ;<7 A7;4;43@715 4@ ;<757 ;E3 A7;4;43@5 @7785 ;3 97 B1=@;78 >>3184@B2:
A=55 ;<7 63223E4@B-
*4+ <714D4@=2A7;4;43@5=17
"
*44+ <7 7@;417 A13>7784@B5 4@ 3 # A7@84@B 976317 ;<7 3?1; 36 4C42 ?8B7 =@8 =@C4
=4><?1 45;14>;
=1454@B 3?; 36 14D7 3 # 17B45;7178 9: 3;E=2 324>7 ;=;43@ =4><?1
6313667@>75A?@45<=927?@871 7>;43@5 $
#
#"=@8'36=@84@ 3'$ #A7@84@B976317;<73?1;364C42
- 10 -
?8B7=@8
=@C4
=4><?145;14>;
=1454@B3?;
36 14D7 3 # 17B45;7178 9: 3;E=2 324>7 ;=;43@
=4><?1
631 3667@>75 A?@45<=927 ?@871 7>;43@5
$
#
#" 17=8 E4;< ' 36
=17 <7179: #$! =5 =B=4@5;;<7A7;4;43@7154@;<757;E3A7;4;43@5
!-,
(!&! '% ! "+ %
45;3 23