- 1 - ! ""# $%&!& ' ( ! " # $ % & "! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - & '()* # $ % ) + *+**, &** & '- ./ 0 12 32454567289 1:;2 <1:==27>2? :7 68?28 ?:42? *+**,3:992?@A4128295?57>BB5<28:@6C86C84 5D:A:3C8:57 2B2827<2 6&** - 3 - 12 829367?274 E:9 :3365742? :9 : 5894 5;5956799594:7467(,,,:7?36942?:43245456728 6 46 E68F C7?28 3245456728 6" 16C>1 32454567289 1:?6@4:572?:@67?B86G412829367?27441:4159427C82 E6C=? @2 386;59567:==A C3 46 672 A2:8 829367?274 E:9 E68F57> <67457C6C9=A B86G !,,, 57 412 6BB5<2 6B 3245456728 6" 2 E:9 428G57:42? B86G 928;5<2 67 **)**67412>86C7?41:4121:??2G:7?2?:@85@2 6B 9****& B86G 672 G4 :==:EE: &6 C8:33: :FF:=:F546599C2:<12HC246E:8?9<6G3279:45673:A:@=2 46 128 12 3245456728 41282B682 <1:==27>2? 412 :B6829:5? 68?28 6B 428G57:4567 @2B682 4159 6C84 57 854 2454567 6,')'&** E15<1 E:9 ?593692? 6BB 67 *)*"**" ?582<457> 412 829367?274 46 922F 82?8299:= @2B682 412 :@6C86C84<<68?57>=A412829367?274B5=2?:32454567 @2B682 412 ?23:84G274 6B =:@6C8 46 <6795?28 54 :9 : 82B2827<2 6B : ?593C42 B68 :?DC?5<:4567 @A :@6C8 6C84 12 :442G349 :4 <67<5=5:4567 B:5=2? :7? 127<2 412 G:4428 E:9 =5942? @2B682 412 :@6C8 6C84 4 E:9 <67427?2? @2B682412:@6C86C8441:441268?286B428G57:4567E:9 - 4 - 945>G:45< :7? 76 386<2?C82 E:9 <6G3=52? @A <67?C<457> :727HC58A:>:5794412829367?2744E:9:=96<67427?2? 41:49C<182G6;:=E:9:7C7B:58=:@6C838:<45<2:7?41:4 412428G57:45676B928;5<26B412829367?274E:9E867>BC= :7? :8@548:8A 12 32454567289 274282? :332:8:7<2 @2B682 412:@6C86C84:7?<67427?2?41:4412829367?2741:? 57?C=>2? 57 : G59<67?C<4 :7? 41282B682 412 428G57:4567 E:9DC945B52?12:@6C86C8457428G96B:768?28?:42? (*+** 924 :95?2 412 428G57:4567 :7? ?582<42? 412 3245456728946825794:42412829367?2745746928;5<2 ! >>852;2? @A 412 9:5? 68?28 412 32454567289 B5=2?8542454567 6(,*!&*E15<1E:9:==6E2?:7? 412G:4428E:982G5442?@:<F46412:@6C86C84B68B8291 485:= B428 9C<1 82G:7? 412 32454567289 B5=2? E854427 94:42G274:?G54457>41:4412829367?274E:992=2<42?@A 3245456728 6 :7? 12 E:9 :3365742? 67 <6748:<4 @:959 57545:==A B68 : 32856? 6B 672 A2:8 :7? 41:4 412 <6748:<4 27?2?@A2BB=CI6B45G21282B68254E:9<67427?2?41:4 412829367?2741:?7685>1446<67457C257928;5<257;52E - 5 - 6B2<4567$66%$@@%6B4127?C9485:=593C429<44E:9 <67427?2? 41:4 412 <=:5G 6B 412 829367?274 41:4 41282 GC94 1:;2 @227 :7 27HC58A :9 328 412 :87:4:F: 5;5= 28;5<29 $=:995B5<:4567 67486= :7? 332:=% C=29 ,'+ $B6891684.:7? C=29,'+/%E:9764DC945B52?:9 412 829367?274 E:9 764 : >6;287G274 928;:74 :7? E:9 764 27454=2? 46 412 38642<4567 6B 412 :7? C=29 ,'+12:@6C86C84:B428<6795?2857>412<6742745679 B8:G2?412B6==6E57>599C29 " 12829367?274E:92I:G572?:7?12G:8F2? ?6<CG274912324545672892I:G572?E54729929579C33684 6B549<6742745679:7?G:8F2?B2E?6<CG274912:@6C8 6C84 :B428 <6795?2857> 412 G:4285:= 67 82<68? 12=? 41:4 412829367?274E:9:3365742?67<6748:<4@:959:9:5894 5;5956799594:74@A3245456728 657428G96B:768?28 - 6 - ?:42?(,,,4:=9612=?41:4412:336574G2746B412 829367?274 E:9 2I427?2? B68 672 G682 A2:8 :7? 41282:B428 B68 :764128 A2:8 4 :=96 12=? 41:4 412 829367?274E:9412748:79B2882?463245456728 6!E1282 829367?274 1:? 2I2<C42? : @67? :7? :>822? 46 412 <67?545679 :44:<12? 46 159 :336574G274 4 7645<2? 412 <=:5G 6B 412 32454567289 41:4 412 32454567289 1:? 82928;2? 41258 85>14 46 82G6;2 412 829367?274 B86G E68F 5B 54 E:9 B6C7?41:4159928;5<29E:97649:459B:<468A68549928;5<29 E282 764 82HC582? 4 :=96 B6C7? 41:4 412 2G3=6AG274 6B 412829367?274E:98272E2?B68:32856?6B672A2:8;5?2 68?28 !*** E15<1 41282:B428 E:9 8272E2? 67 (***E15<1E:946<6G246:727?@A,** 6E2;284123245456728E:982G6;2?B86G928;5<2:9328 41268?28?:42?"*)**:7?41282G6;:=E:9@:92?67 412:==2>:456741:4121:??2G:7?2?@85@26B 9****& 46?8:E:<12HC257B:;6C86B672G4:==:EE:82>:8?57> :<HC59545676B128=:7?12:@6C86C8441282B68212=? 41:441232454567289E282@6C7?46<67?C<4:92G@=:7<26B :7 57HC58A @2B682 428G57:457> 412 928;5<29 6B 412 - 7 - 829367?274:7?957<241:4G:7?:468A82HC582G274E:9764 <6G3=52?5412=?41:441268?28428G57:457>412928;5<296B 412 829367?274 E:9 764 =2>:= :7? 41282B682 :==6E2? 412 82B2827<2 :7? ?582<42? 412 32454567289 46 825794:42 412 928;5<296B412829367?274:=67>E541<67457C54A6B928;5<2 :7? <6792HC2745:= @272B549 E541 '- @:<F E:>29 257> :>>852;2? @A 412 9:5? :E:8? 412 32454567289 :82 @2B682 41596C84 ' 12 =2:872? <6C792= B68 32454567289 <67427?2? 41:4 412 829367?274 E:9 :3365742? 67 <6748:<4C:= @:959 :7?159:336574G274E:98272E2?B86GA2:846A2:859 :336574G274<:G246:727?67,**241282B682 <67427?2? 41:4 5B 412 829367?274 E:9 764 82G6;2? B86G 928;5<2@A2BB=CI6B45G2159928;5<2E6C=?1:;2<6G246 :7 27? 46 ,* :7? 41282B682 412 :@6C8 6C84 <6GG5442? :7 28868 57 ?582<457> 825794:42G274 E541 <67457C54A6B928;5<2 ) ! =2:872? <6C792= B68 412 829367?274 9C@G5442?41:4412599C2@2B682412:@6C86C84E:9412 - 8 - 945>G:45<428G57:45676B412829367?274B86G928;5<22 9C@G5442?41:4 412 :@6C8 6C841:9 ?2:=4E541412599C2 :7? 1:9 12=? 41:4 57 G:44289 6B 428G57:4567 @:92? 67 :7 :==2>:4567 :7 27HC58A 1:9 46 @2 <67?C<42? @A 412 32454567289 2 41282B682 <67427?2? 41:4 412 HC294567 E124128412428G6B412829367?274<:G246@2:727?67 ,** ?5? 764 :8592 B68 <6795?28:4567 @2B682 412 :@6C86C841C912<67427?941:44125G3C>72?:E:8? 3:992? @A 412 :@6C8 6C84 59 DC94 :7? 386328 :7? ?629 764 E:88:74 57428B2827<2 2 :=96 <67427?9 41:4 412 767 8272E:= 6B 412 428G 6B 928;5<2 6B 412 829367?274 :=96 :G6C749 46 945>G:45< 428G57:4567 7 9C33684 6B 4159 <6742745671282=52?C367412DC?>G2746B32I6C8457 412 <:92 6B ;9 + 1:;2 <6795?282? 412 9C@G5995679 6B 412 =2:872?<6C792=B6841232454567289:7?412=2:872?<6C792= B68412829367?274 1 2024 INSC 620 - 9 - ( 12B:<441:4412829367?274E:92G3=6A2?@A 412324545672895976457?593C42416C>167<6748:<4@:959 1232454567289:82C7?6C@42?=A:757?C948A57;52E6B412 DC?>G274 6B 32I 6C84 57 <:92 6B ;9 1282B682412C7=:EBC= 82G6;:= 6B :7 2G3=6A22 67 412 @:959 6B :==2>2? G59<67?C<4 E6C=? B:== B6C= 6B 412 386;595679 6B 412 7?C9485:= 593C429 <4 82=:457> 46 428G57:4567 127 412 2G3=6A28 38636929 46 428G57:42 : E68FG:7 68 :7 2G3=6A22 67 :==2>2? G59<67?C<4 E15<1 1:9 92856C9 8:G5B5<:45679 96 B:8 :9 412 2G3=6A22 68 412 E68FG:7 59 <67<2872?412:==2>:45671:946@29CBB5<5274=A294:@=5912? @2B682 4:F57> : 92856C9 9423 9C<1 :9 428G57:4567 B86G 928;5<21596C84<:77645>7682412B:<441:4428G57:4567 6B 928;5<2 @:92? 67 945>G: E6C=? ?2385;2 64128 2G3=6AG274 633684C754529 46 9C<1 :7 2G3=6A22 68 : E68FG:7 1282B682 412 2G3=6A22 @2B682 3:9957> :7A 68?28 6B 428G57:4567 916C=? @2 ?6C@=A 9C82 41:4 412 :==2>:4567G:?2:>:57944122G3=6A221:996G29C@94:7<2 2 AIR 2006 SC 355 - 10 - :7?5768?2846@29:459B52?:@6C44129:G2:727HC58A59: GC94 159 59 :=96 412 <679454C4567:= G:7?:42 C7?28 845<=2 ! 6B 412 679454C4567 6B 7?5: 1282B682 412 B57?57> 6B 412 :@6C8 6C84 41:4 412 829367?274 E:9 C7=:EBC==A 428G57:42? B86G 928;5<2 <:7764 @2 428G2? 5G38632868C7DC947412<6748:8A412:@6C86C841:9 825794:42?412=:E?2<=:82?@A4126C84B86G45G24645G2 :7? 41282 59 76 28868 <6GG5442? @A 412 :@6C8 6C84 57 ?582<457> 412 825794:42G274 6B 412 928;5<2 6B 412 829367?274 796B:8 :9 412 <674274567 6B 412 829367?274 41:47678272E:=6B412428G6B928;5<26B412829367?274 41:4 ?5? 764 82:==A :8592 B68 <6795?28:4567 @2B682 412 :@6C86C841268?28?59<67457C57>412928;5<296B412 829367?2745976467412>86C7?41:4159928;5<21:?<6G2 46:727?@A2BB=CI6B45G2B41:4@2412<:9241596C84 <:7764<6795?28412HC294567C8>2?@A412=2:872?<6C792= B68 412 829367?274 41:4 412 ?59<67457C:4567 6B 928;5<2 6B 412 829367?274 E6C=? :=96 :G6C74 46 : 945>G:45< 428G57:4567 1:4 59 =2B4 6327 46 @2 <6795?282? 57 :7 :3386385:42386<22?57> - 11 - , 7 ;52E 6B :@6;2 4159 E854 32454567 =:<F9 G2854 :7?59 !)* '&( & & !(