- 1 - !! " !# # $ %&""'" (& " # % ))*+,) ""++ ( !"### $ % !"###$ & &' !"### ( ) * Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! + !'!#$ $ !'%# ( ) + + $* + '$ + ,* + #'$#$& $#$& !!% $#$& + + ++ $# + + &$$#$& + !!% $#$& + - + + ++ %%)* %%).* + "$# + + + + ,,* + + / + + + + 0 - 3 - ! ) 0* 11234. 53$ 65 784 94:584 6;,3 5286 2<.48 416,5< '$ 5: 8 =,6; 7 >87?48 65 @273; 6;4 4<6,84 >85144.,<A3 ,< 5!!% $#$& >4<.,<A 94:584 6;4 5286 5: ..,6,5<7B ,C,B 2.A4 7<. + ,D7?7>287 78,3,<A5265:8,E45 $#$&84A,36484.9?,D7?7>287 8,E4 5B,14 676,5< ,D7?7>287 :58 6;4 5::4<343 >2<,3;79B4 2<.48 416,5< %%)1* 7<. %%).* 5: <:58E76,5< 41;<5B5A?16$###):583;56F16/*7<.416,5<3" 7<.$#5: $ 478.B478<4.152<34B:586;4>786,43 & + =73 ,<,6,7BB? 84A,36484. 7A7,<36 7GE, 7<H7<=7., 7<. 6;4 >46,6,5<483 ;484,< :58 6;4 5::4<143 >2<,3;79B4 2<.48 416,5<3 7<. $# 5: 9? ,D7?7>287 8,E4 5B,14 676,5< ,D7?7>287 5< 6;4 973,3 5: 6;4 :,836 ,<:58E76,5< .764. #'$#$& 8414,C4. :85E 843>5<.4<6 5$ ;484,< ;4 >5B,14 7:648 ,<C436,A76,5<;7C4:,B4.1;78A4 3;446 7A7,<36 6;4 711234. - 4 - <7E4. ,< 6;4 + :58 6;4 5::4<143 >2<,3;79B4 2<.48 416,5<3 7<. $# 84. =,6; 416,5< & 5: ;4 8,7B 5286 9? 58.48 .764. &$$#$& ;73 67H4< 15A<,I7<14 :58 6;4 5::4<143 >2<,3;79B4 2<.48 416,5<3 %%)1*7<.%%).*5:6;4167<.416,5<3"7<.$# 5: 7<. ;73 ,3324. 32EE5<3 65 6;4 711234. 4,<A 7AA8,4C4.9?6;437E4711234.53$6578494:5846;,3 5286 478<4.152<34B:586;4>46,6,5<483329E,636;76 1;78A4 3;446 ;73 944< :,B4. ,< 6;4 >8434<6 1734 5<B? :58 6;45::4<143>2<,3;79B42<.48416,5<37<.$#847. =,6; 416,5< & 5: ;4 8,7B 5286 =,6;526 >85>48 7>>B,176,5< 5: ,63 E,<. ;73 67H4< 15A<,I7<14 5: 6;4 5::4<143 :58 =;,1; 1;78A4 3;446 ,3 <56 :,B4. =,6;526 733,A<,<A7<?84735<34329E,636;766;484,37935B264B? <5 E7648,7B 65 >85341264 6;4 >46,6,5<483 :58 6;4 7BB4A4. 5::4<143 < 6;4 7934<14 5: <4143378? E7648,7B ,< 6;4 1;78A4 3;446 15<6,<276,5< 5: 6;4 ,E>2A<4. 18,E,<7B >85144.,<A3 73 7A7,<36 6;4 >46,6,5<483 ;484,< =52B. - 5 - 7E52<665792345:>8514335:B7=1158.,<AB?;4>87?3 657BB5=6;4>46,6,5< ! 48 15<687 B478<4. ,A; 5286 5C48<E4<6 B47.48 7>>478,<A :58 843>5<.4<6 5 7<. B478<4. 152<34B7>>478,<A:58843>5<.4<65$;7C45>>534.6;4 >46,6,5< ;4? 329E,6 6;76 6;4 >5B,14 7:648 .467,B4. ,<C436,A76,5< ;7C4 :,B4. 1;78A4 3;446 7A7,<36 7BB 6;4 711234. <7E4. ,< 6;4 + ;484 ,3 8415C48? 5: E5<4? :85E6;4>46,6,5<483;484,<=;,1;=52B.>8,E7:71,43;5= 6;4,<C5BC4E4<65:6;434>46,6,5<483,<6;47BB4A4.18,E4 < 6;4 1;78A4 3;446 ,6 ,3 3>41,:,17BB? 7BB4A4. 6;76 6;434 711234. 7B5<A =,6; 711234. 5 ;7. ,<.214. 6;4 :,836 ,<:58E7<6 65 >786 =,6; 7< 7E52<6 5: 3$###### )2>4436=4<6?B7H;3*7<.6;4847:6486;4?;7C41;4764. ;,E5=4C486;4?:7,8B?329E,66;766;458.485:67H,<A 15A<,I7<14 9? 6;4 8,7B 5286 ,3 .4:416,C4 1158.,<AB? 6;4?>87?65.,3E,336;4>46,6,5< % 48237B5:6;4E7648,7B5<6;484158.=52B.A5 653;5=6;765<6;4E48,635:6;41734,617<<569437,. - 6 - 6;76 6;484 ,3 7935B264B? <5 E7648,7B 65 >85341264 6;4 >46,6,5<483 :58 6;4 1;78A4 3;4464. 5::4<143 3 8,A;6B? 15<64<.4. 9? B478<4. 152<34B 7>>478,<A :58 6;4 843>5<.4<63,<6;41;78A43;446,6,33>41,:,17BB?7BB4A4. 6;76 6;4 >46,6,5<483 ;484,< 7B5<A =,6; 711234. 5 ;7. ,<.214. 843>5<.4<6 5$ 65 >786 =,6; 7< 7E52<6 5: 3$###### )2>443 6=4<6? B7H;3* =,6; 7 >85E,34 65 >7?;,E732E5:3185849B71HE5<4?7<.6;4847:648 ;7. 1;4764. ;,E 28,<A 6;4 152834 5: ,<C436,A76,5< 14867,< 7E52<63 ;7C4 944< 34,I4. :85E 7BB 6;4 711234. >4835<39?6;4>5B,14=;,1;=52B.>8,E7:71,43;5=6;4,8 ,<C5BC4E4<6 ,< 6;4 1734 5< ;7<. <.48 6;4 1,812E367<143,617<<569437,.6;766;484,37935B264B?<5 E7648,7B737A7,<366;4>46,6,5<4836594>85341264.:586;4 1;78A43;4464.5::4<143 <6;4>8434<61734+=73,<,6,7BB?84A,36484. :586;45::4<143>2<,3;79B42<.48416,5<37<.$#5: :648,<C436,A76,5<6;4>5B,14;7C4:,B4.1;78A43;446 7A7,<36 6;4 711234. >4835<3 :58 6;4 5::4<143 >2<,3;79B4 - 7 - 2<.48416,5<37<.$#847.=,6;416,5<&5: ;48,7B5286;5=4C48,<,6358.48.764.&$$#$&;73 59348C4. 6;76 6;4 1;78A4 3;446 ;73 944< :,B4. ,< 6;4 >8434<6 1734 :58 6;4 5::4<143 >2<,3;79B4 2<.48 416,5<3 %%)1*7<.%%).*5:6;4167<.416,5<3"7<.$# 5: 7<. 71158.,<AB? ;73 67H4< 15A<,I7<14 :58 6;4 7:58437,. 5::4<143 ;4 8,7B 5286 ;73 .,84164. 6;4 4A,368?6584A,3648718,E,<7B17347A7,<366;4711234.:58 6;47:58437,.5::4<3437<.71158.,<AB?,3324.32EE5<365 6;4E;484:584,6,37>>784<66;766;48,7B5286;73<56 7>>B,4. ,63 E,<. 65 6;4 1;78A4 3;446 94:584 67H,<A 15A<,I7<145:6;41;78A43;4464.5::4<143 ' <.48 6;4 1,812E367<143 6;4 58.48 >7334. 9? 6;48,7B5286.764.&$$#$&67H,<A15A<,I7<145:6;4 7BB4A4. 1;78A4 3;4464. 5::4<143 17<<56 94 32367,<4. 1158.,<AB?:5BB5=,<A58.48,3>7334. 8,E,<7B>46,6,5<,3>786B?7BB5=4. - 8 - ;4 58.48 .764. &$$#$& >7334. 9? 6;4 8,7B 528667H,<A15A<,I7<145:6;41;78A43;4464.5::4<143,3 @273;4. 7<. 6;4 E76648 ,3 84E,664. 65 6;4 8,7B 5286 65 >85144.:286;48,<71158.7<14=,6;B7= "-, )"'" (& " #+ &! ,365B5$