- 1 - !! " #$ % &$ ! # ''()*' )) & ! " # ! $ # % & !' ( !! !# (( !! ((! % ! Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ! ( ! ' ( ! " ( &! ( ' ' ) ( ! !! # ! ! ( (( " "$ "$ "* ( ! ) ( ! ( ( + ! ( ( !! &!' ! ( ' ( ( , ! ( ( ! ( (! !!+ ! ! - + & - + ' ../012340#5671819471:;<04/7:/3217 1.:<43"497 =<:;6>76?17:4@/60;:;113:<71 >74.112<3A0 <3 7<B1 4 71A<0:1712 8? :;1 6C68/76A< <:? 7<B1 4C<.1 :6:<43 6C68/76A< 947 :;1 49913.10 >/3<0;68C1 /3217 1.:<430 " "$ "$"*49 >132<3A819471:;14/7:490:22C &!'5(6C68/76A< - 3 - 1672:;1C1673124/301C947:;1>67:<10 # ( <3 7<B1 4 =60 71A<0:1712 8? 6C68/76A<<:?7<B1 4C<.1 :6:<436C68/76A< 947:;149913.10>/3<0;68C1/3217 1.:<430""$"$ "*49 6A6<30:636B63:; 13A6:<63294/74:;170 43:;1860<049:;19<70:<3947B6:<4326:12# 71.1<D12 974B 710>43213: 4 ;171<3 1<3A 6AA7<1D128?:;106B1:;1>1:<:<43170;171<3=;4671 6776?12606../012340#5<3:;1(671819471 :;<04/7: " 167312 4/301C 947 :;1 >1:<:<4317 0/8B<:0 :;6: 34 .4B>C6<3: =60 71.1<D12 974B 63? B1B817 49 :;1 4.<1:? 632 43C? 6: :;1 <30:63.1 49 :;1 31=C? 1C1.:12 42? 49 636A1B13: 6 96C01 .4B>C6<3: ;60 8113 C42A12 6A6<30: :;1 >1:<:<43170 1 9/7:;17 0/8B<:0 :;6: :;1 43,8C1 >6C4E6?/E:6 <3 ;<0 71>47: /3217 1.:<43 &#' 49 :;1 6736:6E6 4E6?/E:6 .: F"&9470;47:G.:49F",';600>1.<9<.6CC?2<71.:12 :;1 /:;47<:? .43.17312 :4 <3<:<6:1 6.:<43 6A6<30: :;1 - 4 - >1:<:<43170/3217:;1>74D<0<43049:;16736:6E64 >176:<D1 4.<1:<10 .: FF &947 0;47: G.: 49 FF,'>/70/63::4:;171>47:71.1<D12/3217 1.:<43 $"49:;106<2.:49FF;1/:;47<:?.43.17312 =<:;4/: .4B>C?<3A =<:; :;106<271.4BB1326:<43947 1H:76314/0 7160430 ;60 <3<:<6:12 :;1 <B>/A312 .7<B<36C>74.112<3A0..472<3AC?:;1>1:<:<43170>76? :46CC4=:;1>1:<:<43 17.43:76C167312<A;4/7:4D173B13: C16217 =;4 ;60 4>>4012 :;1 >1:<:<43 0/8B<:0 :;6: :;171 671 6CC1A6:<430 6A6<30: :;1 6../012 632 86012 430/.;6CC1A6:<436313@/<7?=60;1C2/3217 1.:<43 $" 49 :;1 .: 49 FF 6A6<30: :;1B 632 6 71>47: =;<.; <0 62D1701 :4 :;1 6../012 <0 9<C12 8? :;1 4B>1:13: /:;47<:? ;1719471 :;1 <B>/A312 .7<B<36C >74.112<3A0 <0 <3<:<6:12 6A6<30: :;1B 632 <3D10:<A6:<43 <3 :;1 06<2 .601 <0 31.10067? ..472<3AC?;1>76?0:42<0B<00:;1>1:<:<43 - 5 - $ 3 :;1 9<70: <3947B6:<43 26:12 # =;<.; <0 0/8B<::12 8? 710>43213: 4 ;171<3 <: <0 0:6:12 :;6: 947 :;1 >17<42 81:=113 $ :4 =;13 :;1 6../012 >170430 =171 499<.1 8167170 49 6736:6E6 :6:1 4D173B13: B>C4?110 4/0<3A 430:7/.:<43 4>176:<D1 4.<1:<10 & :2' 6C68/76A< :;1? ;62 6CC4::12 .17:6<3 0<:10 947 =;<.; :;171 =60 34 6>>74D6C 974B :;1 4B>1:13: /:;47<:? 6326C04;6204C2.17:6<30<:10:4:;1>170430=;4671 34: 4D173B13: 17D63:0 3 :;1 6947106<2 6CC1A6:<430 :;171 =60 63 13@/<7? ;1C2 6A6<30: :;1 6../012/3217 1.:<43$"49:;1.:49FF632:;1 13@/<7? 71>47: 0:6:10 :;6: :;1 6CC1A6:<430 671 :7/1 /70/63: :4 :;1 71>47: /3217 1.:<43 $" 49 .: 49 FF :;1 43,8C1 >6C4E6?:; ;60 <00/12 6 71.4BB1326:<43 /3217 1.:<43 &#' :4 :6E1 6.:<43 6A6<30: :;1 6../012 632 6..472<3AC? :;1 >4C<.1 .4B>C<63:=60C42A12 - 6 - * ;171>47:49:;1>6C4E6?:;/3217 1.:<43 &#' 49 :;1 .: 26:12 $ <0 >742/.12 6C43A =<:; :;1 >1:<:<43 ;1 06<2 71>47: 0:6:10 :;6: <30><:149:;171>47:71.1<D12/3217 1.:<43$"49:;1 .: 49 FF 6A6<30: :;1 6../012 >170430 34 6.:<43 ;60 8113 :6E13 6A6<30: :;1B 60 >74D<212 /3217 :;1 >74D<0<4349:;1.:49FF632:;17194711H17.<0<3A >4=170 /3217 1.:<43 &#' 49 :;1 .: 49 F" :;1 4B>1:13: /:;47<:? <0 81<3A 2<71.:12 :4 :6E1 6.:<43 6A6<30: :;1 6../012 >170430 60 >74D<212 /3217 :;1 >74D<0<430 49 .: 632 :;17169:17 0/8B<: 6 71>47: 60 >74D<212 /3217 1.:<43 &"' 49 :;1 .: 49 F" <3:<B6:<3A :;1 499<.1 49 :;1 >6C4E6?:;6 684/: :;1 6.:<43 :6E13 47 >74>4012 :4 81 :6E13 43 :;1 71.4BB1326:<43B621/3217 1.:<43&#'49:;1.: 49F" ;4/A; :;1 >6C4E6?/E:;6 ;60 >60012 :;1 71.4BB1326:<43472170/3217 1.:<43&#'49:;1.: 49F"43$<:01C9<:6>>1670:;6:346.:<43 - 7 - 60 >74D<212 /3217 :;1 >74D<0<43 49 .: 49 FF =60 :6E13 8? :;1 4B>1:13: /:;47<:? 632 43 :;1 4:;17 ;632 <3 :;1 ?167 :;1 <B>/A312 .7<B<36C >74.112<3A0;608113<3<:<6:120:6:<3A:;6:>/70/63::4 :;1 71.4BB1326:<430 71.1<D12 974B :;1 43,8C1 >6C4E6?/:6:;1.7<B<36C.4B>C6<3:;6081139<C12 F ;171.4BB1326:<438?:;1>6C4E6?/E:;6 /3217 1.:<43 &#' 49 :;1 .: 49 F" <0 :4 :6E1 6.:<43 6A6<30: :;1 .43.17312 60 6A6<30: =;4B :;1 71>47:<09<C12/3217 1.:<43$"49:;1.:49FF60 >74D<212/3217:;1>74D<0<43049:;1.:49FF632 :;1 71.4BB1326:<43 <0 34: :4 <3<:<6:1 .7<B<36C >7401./:<43 6A6<30: :;1B 4=1D17 947 :;1 7160430 810:E34=3:4:;14B>1:13:/:;47<:?:;1?;6D134: :6E1363?6.:<436A6<30::;1>170430606A6<30:=;4B :;171>47:/3217 1.:<43$"49:;1.:49FF<09<C12 60>74D<212/3217:;1.:49FF 601243:;19<70:<3947B6:<4334=71.1<D12 974B710>43213:4<B>/A312.7<B<36C>74.112<3A0 - 8 - ;60 8113 <3<:<6:12 947 49913.10 >/3<0;68C1 /3217 1.:<430 " "$ "$ 632 "* 49 ;1 71>47: /3217 1.:<43$"49:;1.:716206094CC4=0 ! " # $% "&'(() 6012 43 :;1 06<2 71>47: :;1 <B>/A312 .7<B<36C>74.112<3A0;6081<3A<3<:<6:124=1D17:;1 9<32<3A0 <3 :;1 06<2 71>47: 671 34: 0/99<.<13: :4 >7401./:1 :;1 >1:<:<43170 947 :;1 6CC1A12 49913.10 32<0>/:12C? 34 .4B>C6<3: ;60 8113 71.1<D12 974B 63? 431 49 :;1 B1B8170 49 :;1 4.<1:? 6CC1A<3A :;6: :;1? ;6D1 8113 .;16:12 8? :;1 6../012 =;4 671 :;1 >60:499<.1816717049:;1 4.<1:? - 9 - 1.:<43 $F 49 :;1 .: 49 FF >74D<210 947 6.:<43 :4 81 <3<:<6:12 6A6<30: :;1 >170430 =;4 ;6D1 0/991712 :;1 71>47: /3217 1.:<43 $" 49 :;1 .: ;1 /:;47<:? <0 .43.17312 <30:162 49 :6E<3A 6.:<43 60 >74D<212 /3217 1.:<43 $F 49 .: 49 FF 947 :;1 7160430 810: E34=3 :4 :;1B ;6D1 <3<:<6:12 :;1 <B>/A312 .7<B<36C >74.112<3A0 =;<.; .6334: 81 0/0:6<312..472<3AC?:;194CC4=<3A47217 # ;1 >1:<:<43 <0 6CC4=12 13:<71 >74.112<3A0 <3 7<B1 4 71A<0:1712 8? :;1 6C68/76A< <:? 7<B1 4C<.1 :6:<43 6C68/76A< 947 :;1 49913.10 >/3<0;68C1 /3217 1.:<430 " "$ "$ "* 49 >132<3A 819471 :;1 4/7: 49 0: 22C &!'5 (6C68/76A<<0;1718?@/60;126A6<30: :;1>1:<:<43170;171<3 +* ' % &$ !) $ <0:4 C4F