Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 11054 (KAR)

GURANNA S/O SIDDANNA DESAI v. BASALINGAYYA SWAMY HIREMATH AND ANR

MFA/201545/2019 · 2025-01-21

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"! # " " $$% & ' ( ! "#" $ % & " ' (!)"* ! "#" '' + ! "#" $ % ' , ("#"# " & LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date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