- 1 - !" ! #$ " % &" ! $ '()*+( *, & !" ! #$ ! % & ' ( ( Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )! % & ( ## (' ( * ( ( )! )")")* + # ( *,!)* & )* ( ' - ( (( *.!!)*)" !* ( ( / # # & / # #' 001234 52 65 * 78 5*,!)* 938478: ;3<5=3 6>3 51=6 5< # ( ?@?;1=?:7 ?=7278: 516 5< =7A3 5)*=3:7263=34;B?@?;1=?:7 5A385@703 6?6758 ?@?;1=?:7 <5= 6>3 5<<38032 91872>?;@3 1843= - 3 - 3067582*.!!)*)"=3?4C76>306758!*5< ?=3;3<5=36>7251=61843=306758*5<=C76>? 9=?B3= 65 D1?2> 6>3 3867=3 9=5033478:2 78 6>3 ?<5=32?74 0=7A78?@0?23?2?:?78266>3A 3?=4@3?=834051823@<5=6>39?=6732 ! ( 78 =7A3 5)* C?2 =3:7263=34 ;B ?@?;1=?:7 5A38 5@703 6?6758 ?@?;1=?:7 <5= 6>3 ?<5=32?745<<38032?:?7826>?8E?=?8456>3=2586>3;?272 5< 6>3 <7=26 78<5=A?6758 4?634 "))* =3037F34 <=5A =329584386 5 C>5 72 6>3 C7<3 5< ?001234 5 G >?8E?=>3936767583=2>3=378C>5?=36>3A56>3=?84 27263=25<?001234 5?=3?==?B34?2?001234 5265* 78 6>3 ( 8F3267:?6758 5< 6>3 0?23 72 05A9@3634 ?84 0>?=:3 2>336 >?2 ;338 <7@34 ?:?7826 <51= 93=2582 >3 936767583=2 ?=3 ?==?7:834 ?2 ?001234 52 65 * 78 6>3 0>?=:3 2>336 >3 =7?@ 51=6 ?<63= 6?E78: 05:87H?803 5< 6>3 0>?=:3 2>33634 5<<38032 >?2 722134 21AA582 65 6>3 ?001234 378: ?::=73F34 ;B 6>3 2?A3 936767583=2 ?=3 ;3<5=36>7251=6 - 4 - * 3?=834051823@<5=6>3936767583=221;A7626>?6 936767583=2?=36>3A56>3=?8427263=25<?001234 5?84 6>3B?=3?@@26?B78:239?=?63@B321;A7626>?6<?@23?84 5A87;12 ?@@3:?67582 >?F3 ;338 A?43 ?:?7826 6>3 936767583=2 58@B 65 >?=?22 ?84 3A;?==?22 6>3A 3 ?@25 21;A7626>?68529307<70?@@3:?67582?=3A?43?:?78266>3 936767583=2 C>70> C51@4 ?66=?06 6>3 ?@@3:34 5<<38032 ?2 ?:?78266>3A3803>39=?B265?@@5C6>393676758 3= 0586=? @3?=834 7:> 51=6 5F3=8A386 @3?43= ?993?=78: <5= =329584386 5 ?84 @3?=834 051823@?993?=78:<5==329584386 5>?F359952346>3 93676758 >3B 21;A76 6>?6 ?<63= 05A9@3678: 6>3 78F3267:?6758 0>?=:3 2>336 >?2 ;338 ?@=3?4B <7@34 ?84 6>3=3<5=3 76 72 856 ? <76 0?23 <5= 3I3=07278: 6>3 95C3=2 1843= 306758 * 5< = 005=478:@B 6>3B 9=?B 65 472A7226>393676758 " 3=12?@5<6>3?F3=A3862A?43786>3(C51@4 =3F3?@6>?66>3A?==7?:35<?001234 5C76>=329584386 5 C?2 25@3A87H34 58 ) ?84 ?<63= 6>3 - 5 - A?==7?:3 ?001234 5 ?84 >72 C7<3 C3=3 =327478: 65:36>3=?6B43=?;?486>3<7=2678<5=A?6758?@@3:?6758 5< ?22?1@6 58 6>3<7=26 78<5=A?86 78 >3= 9?=3862+ >5123 ?6 >766?91= 78 ?@?;1=?:7 72 58@B ?2 ?:?7826 ?001234 5 C>572>3=>12;?84>3=3?=38529307<70?@@3:?67582?2 ?:?7826 ?001234 52 65 * 78 6>3 <7=26 78<5=A?6758 ?84 58@B5A87;12?@@3:?67582?=3<5184?:?78266>3A(1=6>3= 26?63A3865<6>3<7=2678<5=A?86C?2=305=434;B6>395@703 58 "))* ?84 3F38 78 6>3 2?74 26?63A386 6>3 <7=26 78<5=A?86>?226?6346>?6?<63=6>3A?==7?:32>3?84>3= >12;?84C3=3=327478:239?=?63@B?6B43=?;?4>3>?2 26?634 6>?6 58 )))* 2>3 >?4 =361=834 65 >3= 9?=3862+>5123?6>766?91=?84586>32?744?63?6?;516 ")) 9A ?001234 5 ?2E34 >3= 65 :7F3 >7A 47F5=03 ?84 >?4 @3<6 >3= 78 >3= 9?=3862 >5123 ?84 =361=834 65 B43=?;?4>3>?226?6346>?621;23D1386@B6>3=3C?2? 9?80>?B?6>3@4?842>3C?22386;?0E65B43=?;?4?@58: C76>>3=>12;?84 - 6 - , 672>3=29307<700?236>?6>3=>12;?84C?2856 6?E78: 0?=3 5< >3= 3F38 6>3=3?<63= 78 B43=?;?4 ?84 6>3=3<5=32>3>?4=361=83465>3=9?=3862+>5123?84>?4 ?99=5?0>346>395@703>3=3<5=376723F743866>?6?<63= 6>3?@@3:34780743866>?6>?46?E389@?0358)))*78 6>3 9?=3862 >5123 5< 6>3 <7=26 78<5=A?86 6>3 A?663= C?2 2366@3478?9?80>?B?6?84<7=2678<5=A?86>?4=361=83465 B43=?;?4 ?84 2>3 C?2 26?B78: ?@58: C76> >3= >12;?84 >3 ?@@3:?6758 78 6>3 <7=26 78<5=A?6758 72 6>?6 3F38 6>3=3?<63= >3= >12;?84 C?2 856 6?E78: 0?=3 5< >3= ?84 6>3=3<5=3 2>3 >?4 ?99=5?0>34 6>3 95@703 >3=3 72 85 ?@@3:?6758 C>?6253F3= ?:?7826 6>3 936767583=2 >3=378 6>?6 6>3B>?405A365B43=?;?4?84>?4?;12345=?22?1@634 6>3<7=2678<5=A?86>3=37285?8B210>?@@3:?6758A?43 ?:?7826 6>3A 6>?6 6>3B >?F3 05AA76634 ?8B 210> ?06 ?6 B43=?;?4 ?<63= 6>3 <7=26 78<5=A?86 >?4 J57834 >3= >12;?84 91=21?86 65 9?80>?B?6 >3@4 C>70> C51@4 9=7A? <?073?66=?066>30>?=:32>336345<<38032?:?78266>3A - 7 - >3 A?63=7?@ 58 =305=4 C51@4 :5 65 2>5C 6>?6 ?001234 5726>3A56>3=5<?001234 5?84?001234 52!?84*?=3A?==73427263=25<?001234 5?846>3B ?=3 ?@@ =327478: 239?=?63@B ?@58: C76> 6>37= <?A7@B A3A;3=2 B A?E78: 5A87;12 ?@@3:?67582 ?:?7826 6>3 =3@?67F32 5< ?001234 5 6>3B ?=3 ?@@ 251:>6 65 ;3 ?==?7:834?2?001234786>37A91:8340=7A78?@0?23C>70> 0?8856 ;3 93=A76634 8 6>3 3F386 7A91:834 0=7A78?@ 9=5033478:2 72 ?@@5C34 65 05867813 ?2 ?:?7826 6>3 936767583=26>32?A3C51@4?A5186265?;1235<9=50322 5<@?C843=6>307=01A26?80327672J126?84830322?=B 65 D1?2> 6>3 2?A3 005=478:@B <5@@5C78: 5=43= 72 9?2234 >30=7A78?@9367675872?@@5C34 >33867=39=5033478:278 5*,!)*938478: ;3<5=3 6>3 51=6 5< # ( ?@?;1=?:7 ?=7278: 516 5< =7A3 5)*=3:7263=34;B?@?;1=?:7 5A385@703 6?6758 ?@?;1=?:7 <5= 6>3 5<<38032 91872>?;@3 1843= - 8 - 3067582*.!!)*)"=3?4C76>306758!*5< ?2?:?7826936767583=226?84D1?2>34 -+ ( % &" !* " =6 726 5@ 5!,