Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 110197 (PNJ)
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. EX L NAIK GURDEV SINGH AND ANOTHER
CWP/34967/2024 · 2025-01-14
Sudeepti Sharma, Sureshwar Thakur
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 110197 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 110197 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"!#$!% &'
#&(&)!% &'
*
+' ,- + . .. /
,- +. . . .+ !" #$%&'(%
& )*
+ ,,,, .. /
0
- ***
%. &*
*
+ )%&%!)*
%
)*
%
/012/1/- 3
+-4& % %
! *
5
%
$
(
%5 ((
&.*
!*
(5%$)
-)*
%) % 5! .%%55. 1)2(13 1)45#(&% / -6
$!10-1-727%)% )*
%5*%.%(*%
)$
'(
.*
))
()$8--1-770 *
%)
&
-.%
+
55 9/-1:/111 %.%(*%
*
)$8-1:/1-1
-1! % DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%--%!)
'(
*
(
)*
'(
&*
(
* % 5! ); # << =*
% % 5! .% %
>81?)5)
& !*
5
%
$
(%5 % 8 *
% 5! 5
$
(5%$ )
- .% 6
(
!*
9$
*!&**
*%*
% % 5!.%
*
% % 5
%%'%
! )$5%! '( @ -)5
&
)
*
5
%
$ (
%5((
&.*
!*
(%%(*%55
*
%) %
6
(
*
%&
(%$
%55. '
% /012/1/-*
%'
%)*
%
%(
*
%)
! " ! ### $# %#& $ #
'
'
()*
+!## #, : 5%
'
)$*
%)
%
%% *
3%4& !*
5
%
$
(
%5((
&* +)%*%)5
*
%%*
%. )
*9 &!#!&)!"
267" (#2 DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
0 A
)
(
$%B
%
))
('
%6(% *
. & %
)5%%(
)
$.*
* *
)%55$
)%! %
'+C+'%!$
$
)*
)
( 5& *
55
*
%$!&
%*
%5 %
&*
($
5
&%%$
$
)*
($ %% )
(
% 5*$
&%*
*
%$
$%
(
&! * %
&*
5$
*
(
(% 5 *
(
%5
(% 5
($
%%'% % % 5
$5%! '(
&*%(D
&)$&*
(5 )**
6$
!*
E 5
9&(%
5 %
& *
5
'% %%%* ) *
% '
( %
%( *
%)
&-# . ' ' /0 12
'
' '
3'
& !
# 4'
' '
5
6' ' 7
$-+&8
93))16 ' $:"2# 12
' '
'
#)
'4'
'
''#;6'(6'$<12=# 12 '
12
'
3
DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
#
'
# 16'-2# 12)
'
'
'' ' # ;6'$<12=# 12)
'>
'>
#;$<12=# 12)
'
9
'
?@4' #;$<12=A
12) ?@ '
3))8B'?1? 7
2 & & C 85
0 B 7 8 '
:+ -#
" # D
4'
'
# 2 ('
%34)*
% '
%(
(5
& **
5! (5%
&*%.*
%% 5! ($
%5 %!$
$
)*
($ %%
)
(
% 5*$
&%.*(* *
)/1 ?'
&*
& ** %! (* % 5 $
$
D
'%5
)$*
$!& ! * D
%
*
))% 5! F *
5
&*
%$
)% 5! %! $
$
)*
($ %%
)
(
% 5*$
&.*
($
%5 DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
* .*%% 5!%D%$)/1?$
& $
%'
5! D
%
(5%% )$ *
#
(%5 A%& %*
(%5! (*%*
%%%
% 5! % % 5 ($%%'%
!$5%! '(
*
%
(5%%
($ 6
!*
5
6''7
$-+&8 93))16 ' $:"2# 7 *
$
&***
%
$% '+C+'*
*!(%5%$
%5*
%5*)%!$
$
)* )
(
% 5*$
((
&
(%55!.*
%*
%
)* ($
55
&*
(% *
($ .*%! %
#
'
&***
*
%5%)* $& *% .*
%! % *
& * (( D
5!& *
! *
% *%
)
%34 )%! %
&%*
$
%
D
5)* '(
% % $
$
) *
)
(
% 5*$ $
%'
5!&*
)'*
.$
D%
) 3%4'+C+'*
((
&
*
$5! &% (%
&*
%
$%+(*%
&*
&*
(5%$% ($
5
(
'
% 5! #
'
&%55*
)%( % (($%(
%
% *
)
'(
! * ((
&%
(5
5!(G
&*)
(5%.*
*
* )%! %
'+C+'*
((
&%
D
5D% ) $5%! '(
%H *
%$
%%'%
! % % 5
$5%!
'( DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-1 A
*%%$%!&*
($
%5
)*%)* (5
34*%! *
(%
%5)% 5! * ((
& 5!" %4*
$
)%((
%(
)*
((
$5%! '(
&$
($
(
!*
#
(%5 A% '+%+' *
.* %
%
.*(* *. '
&
($
((5
! *$ )
($
5 4 ! )*
% *
)& $%! %5 D
5! ($
((5
!*
#
(%5A%& %
)$
) $5%! '( % % 5
$5%! '(
&%*
*
%$
% (
%5
% -- *
&)*
$
(%5*5*%*
%
(5 *%'
(
$
(%5
%$%)*
(( $%
&**
($
5
'(
&*
&* %$
.55
$
*%'
%
'(
&! * %3%4&*
#
(%5A%
D
%
*
%) ((5 -/ #
'
&%5
(5%
%&*%$%%! )*
#
(%5A%)55.*
5
5%.9*%
+ )*
I
#
(%53#5%! 4&/11/JI5
$
" %5(5
I -8 *
)
&*%
. $
.*
*
$) *
% '
(5
&.*
*
%*
$
)
5$
)* DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*
$!&*%)
%
5$%!$
(%5
%$% $%
'+%+'**
%5*&*%
(%$
(
% $
%
*$ %H .*
*
$
(%$ %
*%*
%
%
.%%$%%
#
'
& %5
D
$
&)$*
)%(%*%&.*
*
* %(%%5
+
*
)*
%
&%H* *
)&*
&**
55$
)* %B 5%(
& '+%+' *
%('
! *$ ) $5%! '(
&.*
!&*9$%!((5
*%*
) *
%
%*
.%%
D
5)*
'(
*
$! %%(*.%% % 5
(%$
%%'%
!* $5%! '( -@ %&%5
D
%*
)$* (&.*
*
*
#
(%5A%&%55!(
$%B
% %5
('
%
(
%5(*
(B&%(5%5!%
%* %'
)*
%
&**
$5!$
) %
)$
(%5 (*D
& * '
5 *
5(B (*%
( (
(& .*
)$&%*
*
%
(%$
(
#
'
&)*
% $5!$
)%5
5%5!&*
!$%! ($
((5
D% *
)&*
D
*
%
5$
%B 5%(
&%*
.%(
%5 . ) $5%! '(
% % 5
($%%'% ! )$%(
)$5%! '(
9%5!&)*
%
$5!
(*D
%*
%
)%
5$
%B5%(
&* !* #
(%5A%((
&5
%%((5&*%*
%
%* DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
8 $%(
(
)%! %
& ! *
%$%
% * *
5$
)%! 5*
%$!&%'!% )(
5%5!*
D
%('
(H
*
)& *
(
)
)$5%! '(
& .5%%55! 5
%%. 55((5 !*
#
(%5A%&*%%(' (%$
(
)$ %
))
('
(%%5
( (
( .*
!*
.5
%5)% 5! -:
. '
&.*
%
%'&*9
D %(*
(
)*
&%
(%$
(
!* 5
%
$
(%5 %*
%
%&*
%
!* (%
55%
%*! %(
*
%) ; ) E'& <B ///1?# F2# '7G
'
?5
#G
' #
6?@
#)7G
' #
'
F() (G
#)
?F # G )
'
17<"H)B?& &
& +2# -0 %)*
(
'
%5*%%*
$
)* %
5$
%B5%(
%*
(%$
$%
$ )*
(5
3%4
(5%
!*
E 5
9(% 5
%
!*
#
(%5 DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
A%&*%$
%
.*(**. '
&) * &
($
5
*
$!&$%B
5$%! ) & *
(5%% ) 5%. 6$
3%4 *% *
!*
%
$*%*
()*
%
% .%%
D
5)
)
'(
&
D
)%'% 5! . '+%+'*
***
%
$ % 5
*
5
%
'
(
*
%
$ (%$
(% *
. '
& *
% (%
'
( %((*%'+%+'*
&%*
)(
5! *
%
$& %%55!%5(%% !%5*
#
(%5A%&
%
5)*
%') %*& **
$5!$
) * %
) 5(B (*% ( (%%5 (
(
(*D
34& .*
! $%! (%$ %'
5
*%*
)*
%
*
%$! 5& (%$
(
)$%
(
%5
()%$5!*!#
'
& *
!.%%5
D
%
*
$
(%5&*% *
%
)%. 55)$
%%*
.%%(
%5
% %
(%$
*
%%'%
! (%$
% % 5
$5%! '( -2 . '
&%
%)3%4&(5
*%*% (
%
! )$ %
% *%' (
*
3%4
%
5!&(
'
( *
$3%4*%
5
!*
&*
!&* 9(%
'
.
*%
*
)*
$
(%5 %&%
%(
3%49(5!&*
!(
(
(% DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%
*
%55)$
%&
*
!* )*
%
(%
%
%
D
5)%
(
%5
( )%$5!*!9%5!&
D
(5%
%
)$ )$5%! '(
%&
D
(5% % % 5
($%%'%
! )$5%! '( !* -F #
'
&**%
*
*%*
%
34 ((
.*5
'(
(%$
)$
!*
)
(
5 %*
%
%(
%
%& (
*
$%%
* 5
'%
5%&.*(*$%B
*
)*
%
34% %(
%
%&
%)*
D
5*%%(*&E %
)$ *
) $5%! '(
(%$ %%'%
! )*
$5%! '(
(
D
(
&* 5%(B)*
%
$%%
*
5%&
(%* 9((5
&*%
'
)*
)*
%
%
34 *
*((
%
%(
%
%&*
!&*
% %
(5%
($
%%'%
! % % 5
)$5%! '( -7 *
&(
$)*
6$
!* 9&(%
5
%
!">
# $ % &' .*
&%
(5%%$%
* &*%*
))))&%*
*%
($
. *
((
5%5!%5*
%
)
% 5
* (%$
'
*
) *
B D% * %
))
$%
*)%' DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
/1 '
*
. (
*
(5%% ) 5%. $% '
(3%4$%B
*
%
(5%%
%
5%)5%. $&*
!&*
5%)5%. $&%$%
'
( 3%4%5$%B
*
*
()
)'+%+'* )
(
5 ((
& & & %5
5
* ((
&*%%!$
B*
%)*
.$
% $%
*
&%*%&*
)55
($5
$
&%
5 *
&
('
)*
%&)%!&)
5%!%5%(* /- *
)
& *
% ) *
) ) *
% ))&
$)*
'
(3%4
!*
%5 ((
&%5
))
)$%!55
%5!%
D *
5
(#26!# 1#5(9!&2"
26! 3!1#&!% )(&"!3 # 26! :!2727&!#" 1&% 7&!#!&)!"
267" (#2 // *
5
%
(
5)*
$*%* 5
%
%5 *% )%5
*%$5! *
5
'% 5%& % *
%$
%
5!
%5(% 5
(%5(5% (%
)
5.*%
'%5
%* .*%
(*%
($5
)
$)
%
$
$ *
*
%
5%$%%
%!$
) * % 5! 5
$
%
'(
5
$
&% *%
)
%(* *
%%
%%
5!%
($5
)
('
( (
%! %*
%$ *
5
'%
5%%
%(
*
%) !&"7& !5(3127&" # #9;0
DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$"&# '4' 1' 2'
4'
$#, &%%#
'
'
9
'
#, !&"7& !5(3127&" # #9;0 8 <:#I
'4'
$#,
-28
' 6 '
7
6 /
9
6 '
#, /8 *
5
%
9
5)*
$*%* %5.*5
%55.*
3%4*%.5! * '3%4 !%B
5%-27)*
5% )*
$!&-70-5%*
%
5%-27
%( *
%) $:-#
'(
'
1
2' ' '
? '
'
DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&
& #
( '
.'
(
# /@ *
%
%&
5
'%
)
% '
( !*
5
%
%5((
(%
8/@) /1-05
% 9 1#41"6 (3!#71 <" &7&
&%71
#"0 (
-11F/1-F& .*
% $5% D
.% )* )
*
%5((
&*%(&"&"&%)
"(( &)&"*&
""&"&
&+& %%&
"
"& ' &
""%&""&
,%"*&
"&
&)&%
-*
5
% %5((
%)
(
*
5
'%
5%
' *%
$)
5%-27)*
5%)* $!&-70-&
#*
&*
%5 %5
'
*%
'
# *
%'
( .% (*%55
!*
)%
)
*
E 5 $
9 %*
%$
.%*
5 !*
9'
( (%
5
% &7&
&%71
#" <" 9 #141"6 (3!#71& (
/2&/1/-&.*(*9'5
%53%! 78@0)/1/-4
(%$
%
*
5
'%%%%*&%(( *
%'
(%
%(
*
%) DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&#@$
9
.' $
' '& &$
F ' #.&., %
)&)"%*)
"&"&
"& &
&%"
"& %""& ) )% ' &
""%
"& & &
"""&
&)&&%&&
""&
,%"*&
"& ,& &"
'&
"
& *&
"# '
#, /: *
5
%
(
5)*
)*
$*% * 9
'(
&%$$$
'(
)-:! %.%
D
%* %
'(
&.*
%&
-*%
5! -1! %%--%!)
'(
.** 9.*
%)
&*
.% %
)*
)
'( /0 . '
&!
*
%
)*
%D%5)! )
'(
* 9 .5+
5
* &
($
%% 5
(
)*
($
)% 5! &*() *
'(
5
$
) 9
'(
%. 55 %)*
% 5! 5
$
*
%
*%&*** )*
'(
* 9&*
(
* %
D%5)! '(
&*
&***
.%
D ($5
*
D
)-:! %&%*
)*
($ 5
)
'(
. '
&.*
*
)* '* 9&*
%(D
%% 5!.*(**%
% %
)$
)$5%! '(
*
%$
% % 5 %%'%
!$5%! '(
&*
!*
%
%5$
)% % 5!&**
55)*
'* DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*
9&.*
%)
*
(%$
%
($
%
%!)* * 9
'(
&%*
.*
*
.%
D '%5
(*%
)$
'(
&%%5! *
%(% /2 ) & (
*
% '
$
$
& . 55
* &%*
%*
D
)D%5)! '(
&)*
!*
($
5
)*
%
'( (*&.*
*
'(
*
(%$
.* *
($
(*%
) $
'
$+(( 9%5!&.*
$
5!%(()% 5!3%4&%
(%$ %5
*$&*%&
'
5!*
*%
)* $5%! '(
& *% *
(%$
(5
($5
*
% D%5)! &%*
)**
! %
'(
&) *
'(
* 9
5%5!&*
% 5!)* ($5
*
D%5)! )
'(
*
9&*(%%*
.%!)*
($
. *
) )
'(
&*
(
'
)*
$)-1! %%--%!) '(
* 9&
%
5!$
5!*
$
*%* *%($5
*
%
-:! %)D%5)! '(
*
9 /F *
)
&
$)*
5%)5%.3%4 !*
E 5
9(%
5
%
$
$ /0
1%&0 - .%
5
)
'( 5
$
) 9
'(
)*
% 5! 5
$
*
)&% %5! !*
%5(( 7&13 #%!#
267" (#2 DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
/7 %)
$%*&*9)$
*
. %.*
'%% '
&*
%$
$ 81 *
$
&%%
!*
5
%
%5 ((
&$%%
%%))$ 8- )%5.*%55
%5(%34&)%! =.. />
=. .+> *
* 6!26!#
":!147&5?#!1"&!% ' !"? 6!26!# #!:#21@3! ' !"? DINESH 2025.01.15 23:37 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document