Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10964 (KAR)
ZEESHAN ALI v. HEAD OF DIVISIONAL RETAIL SALES AND ANR
WP/201789/2024 · 2025-02-10
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10964 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10964 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""#
$%&!&
'% !(
! "# $ #%
&
% # % #
' (
! )
%
$
& # $
% & % !!%#
# '(('
"# $ *%
&
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
#
!!' !!+
# ,
((+!(! % )* #
#
% *
## '-+'---
!(!(!% ) # #
& # ##
# %
# % ) #% ## #
* #
#
.*
*
/0 1023234506 /78 9/7::05;0< 2/0 60=092345 4> /38 711:3972345>467::42?0524>710264:0@?4@2:023564@1 9720;46AB3<094??@53972345<720<((+!(! ! /0 1023234506 945205<8 2/72 /0 8@C?3220< 75 711:3972345800D35;7::42?0524>710264:0@?4@2:027;73582 7 5423>3972345 388@0< CA 2/0 608145<0528 35B3235;
711:39723458 >64? 0:3;3C:0 1068458 >46 7::42?052 4> 7 <07:068/31 E32/35 ! ?8 >64? 6 ?C0<D76 369:0 @:0102 24E76<8 78271@6 45 2720 3;/E7A /0
- 3 -
1023234506E7880:0920<352/0<67E4>:42845('!!(! 94??@53972345 E78 7<<60880< 24 2/0 1023234506 45 2/0 87?0 <7A 60F@3635; /3? 24 60?32 7 8@? 4> 8.((((
45:35024E76<82/0353237:809@632A<01483275<@1:47<2/0 80:>7220820<<49@?05284>2/0>4::4E35;
! "# $
%
&
' $ &
&
# (
) * &++
#
# ) )+ +
$ ,#
) -)
& &
$ % ) ) $+
-)
. (((
! # ) +
((( )
/ )
0 1 1) -) ) )+
+ )
+ $)/ ! 2 &
)+ ) /
$ 34
/
+
5&#&67 8
- 4 -
/0 608145<0528 2/0607>206 7<<60880< 7542/06 0?73: <720< !!(!!(! 7;735 78D35; >46 2/0 >4::4E35; <49@?0528
! " 1 1) -) ) )+
+ )
+ $ ) / ! , &
)+ ) /
$ .4
/
+ 8
/0A35>46?0<2/010232345062/72/38711:3972345 E4@:< C0 60=0920< 3> /0 >73:0< 24 @1:47< 2/0 7C4B0 <49@?052835902/01023234506<3<542@1:47<2/07C4B0 <49@?05282/0608145<052860=0920<2/0711:39723454>2/0 1023234506B3<00?73:<720<!(!(! /01023234506E78 7:84 35>46?0< 24 ?7D0 7 60160805272345 3> /0 /7< 75A ;630B7590 60;76<35; 2/0 60=092345 4> /38 711:3972345 9946<35;:A 2/0 1023234506 8@C?3220< 7 60160805272345 <720<53:800D35;60<60887:4>/38;630B759075<60F@0820< 2/0 608145<0528 24 7::42 2/0 10264:0@? <07:068/31 4E0B06 2/0 60160805272345 E78 60=0920< 35 206?8 4> 7
- 5 -
601:A<720<((+!(! /01023234506382/060>460C0>460 2/384@62800D35;>467E632352/0572@604>906234676324 F@78/ 2/0 94??@53972345 <720< ((+!(! 75< 60B4D0 2/0 46<06 4> 60=092345 C07635; 60>060590 5@?C06 '-+'--- <720< !(!(! 75< 24 <36092 608145<0528 24 94583<06 2/0 711:3972345 8@C?3220< CA 2/0 1023234506 75< 164B3<0 75 411462@532A 24 60923>A 2/0 4C=0923458 9459065867380<
07650<94@580:>462/010232345068@C?3282/72 ?75A4>2/0<49@?052897::0<>46CA2/0608145<0528E060 35 >792 >@6538/0< 0 8@C?328 2/72 2/4@;/ 2/0 1023234506 E78 97::0<@145 24164<@90 <49@?052835206?8 4>2/0 0?73: <720< ('!!(!
2/060 E060 84?0 <389601759308 E/39/E06060923>37C:008@C?3282/722/01023234506?@82 /7B0C005;3B0571068457:/07635;C0>460164900<35;24 /4:< 2/72 2/0 <49@?0528 >@6538/0< CA 2/0 1023234506 <3< 542946608145<24/3857?0462/722/0:75<4>>060<CA2/0 1023234506<3<542946608145<242/00946<4>3;/28
- 6 -
' #06 45267 2/0 :07650< 94@580: >46 2/0 608145<0528 8@C?3220< 2/72 2/0 1023234506 E78 35>46?0< E0:: 35 23?0 24 164<@90 2/0 <49@?0528 75< 2/080 <49@?0528 E060 ?720637: >46 2/0 1@61480 4> 27D35; 2/0 388@04>7::42?0524>2/010264:0@?4@2:02242/01023234506 >46E76< 0 8@C?328 2/72 83590 2/060 E060 ;:7635; <389601759308 35 2/0 <49@?0528 164<@90< CA 2/0 1023234506 2/0 1023234506 E78 7;735 35>46?0< 45 !!(!!(! 24 60923>A 2/0 <0>0928 4E0B06 83590 2/0 1023234506 <3< 542 27D0 75A 82018 35 2/72 60;76< 2/0 608145<0528E060>4690<2460=0922/0711:3972345>3:0<CA 2/0 1023234506 0 8@C?328 7::42?052 4>10264:<07:068/318 38 23?0 8058323B0 75< <0105<8 @145 C@835088 >46?@:78 0B4:B0< CA 2/0 608145<0528 >64? 23?0 24 23?0 0 2/060>460 945205<8 2/72 2/0 711:3972345 4> 2/0 1023234506 E78 C4@5< 24 C0 60=0920< 45 2/0 ;64@5< 4> <0:7A 35 164<@935; 2/0 <49@?0528 0 7:84 945205<8 2/72 2/0 608145<0528 /7B0 24 792 79946<35; 24 2/0 6@:08 75< 60;@:723458>67?0<CA2/0?E/39/38711:397C:0#75 5<37
- 7 -
75<540G9012345975C0?7<03584>76782/0102323450638 94590650<
+ /7B0 94583<060< 2/0 8@C?3883458 4> 2/0 :07650<94@580:>462/0102323450675<2/0:07650<94@580: >462/0608145<0528
/05 2/38 4@62 F@0630< 2/0 608145<0528 E/02/06 2/0 10264:0@? <07:068/31 38 7::4220< 24 75A450 0:80 CA 2/0 608145<0528 E32/35 ! ?8 >64? 6 ?C0<D76 369:0 @:0102 24E76<8 78271@6 45 2720 3;/E7A :07650< 94@580: 8@C?3220< 2/72 /0 /78 54 35826@923458E/02/0675A7::42?05238?7<0
- 7B35; 60;76< 24 2/0 >792 2/72 2/0 1023234506 4E50< 7 176239@:76 13090 4> :75< E/39/ E78 8@327C:0 >46 2/0 0827C:38/?052 4> 10264:0@? 4@2:02 75< 83590 2/0 608145<0528 7:84 >0:2 2/722/01023234506H8 :75< 38 8@327C:0 >462/01641480<10264:0@?4@2:022/0608145<0528C0>460 60=09235;2/0711:39723454>2/01023234506?@82/7B0;3B05 76078457C:0411462@532A4>C035;/076< >2/060E7875A
- 8 -
<389601759A352/0<49@?0528>@6538/0<CA2/01023234506 2/0608145<0528?@82/7B0/0:<71068457:?00235;8478 24 8462 4@2 2/0 <3>>0605908 672/06 2/75 0G109235; 2/0 102323450624;3B07601:A2/64@;/750?73: 5?7220684> 2/38572@6032387:E7A83<07:>462/0608145<052824?002 @1 2/0 711:39752 84 78 24 8462 4@2 75A <389601759308 5 2/72 B30E 4> 2/0 ?72206 2/4@;/ 2/0 711:3972345 4> 2/0 1023234506 38 60=0920< 75 411462@532A <0806B08 24 C0 ;67520< 24 2/0 1023234506 3> 2/0 10264:0@? 4@2:02 38 542 7::4220<2475A4500:8023::<720
( 5B30E4>7C4B02/38E6321023234538 F@78/35; 2/0 46<06 <720< !(!(! 17880< CA 2/0 608145<052860=09235;2/0711:39723454>2/01023234506 > 2/010264:0@?<07:068/31385427::4220<2475A4500:80CA 2/0 608145<0528 E32/35 ! D?8 >64?
6 ?C0<D76 369:0 @:0102 24E76<8 78271@6 45 2720 3;/E7A 2/0 608145<0528760<360920<24/4:<71068457:?00235;E32/ 2/0102323450675<84624@22/0<3896017593083>75A352/0 <49@?0528164<@90<CA2/01023234506
- 9 -
546<0624/782052/016490882/0102323450638 <360920< 24 ?002 2/0 608145<052 4 45 !+(!!(! 72 (( 7? E32/ 7:: 2/0 60F@360< <49@?0528 2 38 ?7<0 9:0762/723>2/0608145<05243854287238>30<E32/2/0 <49@?0528462/00G1:7572345>@6538/0<CA2/01023234506 2/0608145<0528 8/7:: 164900< 24 1788 71164163720 46<068 24 032/06 ;3B0 >@62/06 23?0 24 164<@90 2/0 60F@360< <49@?0528462460=0922/0711:39723454>2/01023234506
!)*
'&( &
* 3824:4(