Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10915 (KAR)

SMT.MAHADEVI W/O GURAPPA GULAGOND v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200092/2019 · 2025-01-25

S Vishwajith Shetty

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" # $ "%% &'(&)%*+(&** $ ! " # $ %&& & %% &!' ( & ) " #$ Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % *') #($ % % !!'(!+ , # $ ! (! % %% *#$#-$#.$ % , !) % % % %% % / " # / $ 01 2334.15 67 813629 2.1 # $ : (! 6. ;1<:-1=06.:4-=67=06.288129<69154751-13=6:7*')#($ :< - 2..26967> =01 ?45>@17= 275 :-51- :< 3:7A63=6:7 275.17=173152=15!!'(!+82..15;B=01:4-=:< 556=6:729 6.=-63= 275 1..6:7. 45>1 6?2B284-2 #<:- .0:-=C-629:4-=D$ ( 12-5912-7153:47.19<:-=0182-=61. * 01 28819927= 01-167 E2. 302->1 .011=15 <:- =01 :<<1731.8476.02;914751-13=6:7!):<27513=6:7 *#$#-$#.$ :< =01 30154915 2.=1. 275 30154915 -6;1. - 3 - #-1A17=6:7 :< =-:36=61.$ 3= ++ #<:- .0:-= / #$ 3=/$ ;B =01 B :< 2.2A272 2>1E256 :9631 =2=6:7 6?2B284-256.=-63=0128819927=2<=1-28812-67> ;1<:-1=01-629:4-=84-.427==:.1-A631:<.4@@:7.:7 01-0253926@15=:;1=-615275=01-1<:-1=018-:.134=6:7 67:-51-=:.4;.=27=62=16=.302->1.2>267.==0128819927= 2334.15 025 1F2@6715 7671 302->1 .011= E6=71..1. 2. =: + 275 .1A17 5:34@17=. E1-1 @2-G15 2. F. =: ' 01-12<=1- =01 .=2=1@17= :< =01 28819927= 2334.15 4751- 13=6:7 ** :< - E2. -13:-515 ;B =01 -629 :4-= :E1A1- 7: 51<1731 1A651731 E2. 915:7 ;1029< :< =0128819927= 7:- E2. 27B 5:34@17=>:=@2-G1567.488:-=:<=0151<1731 ) 01 -629 :4-= 2<=1- 012-67> =01 2->4@17=. 255-1..15:7;:=0.651.A651=016@84>715?45>@17=275 :-51- 3:7A63=15 =01 28819927= <:- =01 :<<1731 8476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7 *#$#-$#.$ :< #$ 3= 275 13=6:7 !) :< %:- =01 :<<1731 8476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7 *#$#-$#.$ :< #$ 3= =01 28819927= E2. - 4 - .17=17315=:4751->:.6@8916@8-6.:7@17=<:-281-6:5:< :71 B12- 275 82B 2 <671 :< .(!! 275 67 51<249= =: 4751->:.6@8916@8-6.:7@17=<:-281-6:5:<=E:@:7=0. %:-=01:<<17318476.02;914751-13=6:7!):<=01 28819927=E2..17=17315=:4751->:.6@8916@8-6.:7@17= <:-281-6:5:<.6F@:7=0.27582B<671:<.(!! 275 6751<249==:4751->:.6@8916@8-6.:7@17=<:-281-6:5:< :71 @:7=0 167> 2>>-61A15;B =01?45>@17= 275 :-51- :<3:7A63=6:7275.17=173182..15;B=01-629:4-==01 28819927=6.;1<:-1=06.:4-= 12-715 3:47.19 <:- =01 28819927= 02A67> -16=1-2=15 =01 >-:475. 4->15 67 =01 288129 @1@:-2754@ .4;@6=. =02= =01 -629 :4-= 02. 7:= 8-:81-9B 288-1362=15 =01 @2=1-629 :-29 275 5:34@17=2-B 1A651731 2A2692;91 :7 -13:-5 275 =01-1;B 02. 1--15 67 3:7A63=67> =01 28819927= <:- =01 2991>15 :<<1731. 1 .4;@6=. =02= 1A17 6< =01 2991>2=6:7. 6. 8-1.4@15 =: ;1 =-41 =01 2991>15 :<<1731 8476.02;91 4751- =01 8-:A6.6:7. :< =01 #$ 3= 5:1.7:=>1=2==-23=15.6731=01-16.7:@2=1-629=:.0:E - 5 - =02=28819927=02567.49=15:-2;4.15=01<6-.=67<:-@27=67 284;963A61E1233:-567>9B8-2B.=:299:E=01288129 1- 3:7=-2 912-715 6>0 :4-= :A1-7@17= 91251- 02.:88:.15=018-2B1-@25167=0128812901.4;@6=. =02= 6< =01 1A651731 :< ) 275 6. 81-4.156=6.A1-B3912-=02=8-:.134=6:702.@251:4=2 32.1<:-=01302->1.011=15:<<1731.2>267.==0128819927= A651731 :< 275 ) 6. 3:--:;:-2=15 E6=0 =01 1A651731 :< 275 E0: 2-1 6751817517= E6=71..1.0128819927=02.2;4.1567=018-1.1731 :< 275 275 =01-1<:-1 =01 :<<1731 8476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7 *#$#-$#.$ :< #$ 3= 3912-9B >1=. 2==-23=15 2>267.= =01 28819927= 01 -629 :4-= 02A67> 288-1362=15=06.2.813=:<=01@2==1-02.-6>0=9B3:7A63=15 =01 28819927= <:- =01 302->1 .011=15 :<<1731. 33:-567>9B.018-2B.=:56.@6..=01288129 ' 018-:.134=6:767.488:-=:<6=.32.102.1F2@6715 7671 302->1 .011= E6=71..1. 2. =: + 7 =01 8-1.17=32.16.=01<6-.=67<:-@27=275)6.=01 - 6 - E6<1:<(275*2-1=0182730E6=71..1.=: =01 .8:= @202H2- 275 2-1 .265 =: ;1 =01 6751817517= E6=71..1. 67 E0:.1 8-1.1731 28819927= 2991>159B 2;4.15 275 ) -1<1--67> =: =016- 32.=1 '6.=01:9631<<631-E0:025676=6299B-1>6.=1-15=01 %2756.=01184=B481-67=17517=:<:9631E0: 025 3:@891=15 =01 67A1.=6>2=6:7 275 <6915 302->1 .011= + 6. =01 80:=:>-2801- F 6. =01 3:8B :< =01 3:@89267= 275 F2 6. =01 .6>72=4-1 :< ' 67 =01 3:@89267= F(6.=0180:=:>-280:<=01.8:=275 F* 6. =01 .8:= 82730272@2 F*2 275 F*; 2-1 =01 .6>72=4-1. :< 82730 E6=71..1. 61 ( 275 * 275 F*36.=01.6>72=4-1:<E0:6.=017A1.=6>2=67> <<631-67=018-1.17=32.1 F)6.=01%275 F)26. =01.6>72=4-1:<'E0:025-1>6.=1-15=01% F 6. =01 32.=1 31-=6<632=1 :< 275 F 6. =01 .G1=30 @28 F'6.=01:-51-<-:@=01481-67=17517=:<:9631 56-13=67>=:67A1.=6>2=1=0132.1 - 7 - 275 ) 02A1 .=2=15=02= 2;:4=2 B12-8-6:- =: =01 52=1 :< 6736517= =016- 32==91 E1-1 >-2H67> 67 =01 2>-6349=4-29 <6195 ;19:7>67> =: =01 28819927= 67 E0630 .01 025 >-:E7 @26H1 3-:8 01-1<:-1 28819927= 2991>159B 2;4.15275)-1<1--67>=:=016-32.=101-12<=1- 28819927=2991>159B32@1712-=016-0:4.1275:7312>267 2;4.15=01@-1<1--67>=:=016-32.=12752==02==6@1=016- 716>0;:-. 67=1-A1715 %:- =01 84-8:.1 :< 2==-23=67> =01 :<<1731.8476.02;914751-13=6:7*#$#-$#.$:<=01 #$ 3= ++ =01 67.49= :- 2;4.1 ;B =01 2334.15 -1<1--67> =: =01 32.=1 :< =01 A63=6@ E0: ;19:7>. =: .3015491532.=1:-.30154915=-6;1.0:495;16727B89231 E6=067=0184;963A61E275 2-1.265=:;1=01 6751817517= E6=71..1. 67 E0:.1 8-1.1731 28819927= 025 2991>159B2;4.15275)712-=016-0:4.1-1<1--67> =:=016-32.=1 + 02..=2=15=02=01E2.6706.0:4.1E017=01 6736517= 67 I41.=6:7 025 =2G17 89231 712- =01 0:4.1 :< 275 ) 1 :A1-012-5 =01 82-=61. <6>0=67> 275 - 8 - =01-1<:-1 01 025 >:71 =: =01 .8:= 1 012-5 28819927= 2;4.67>-1<1--67>=:06.32.=14-67>=013:4-.1:< 3-:..1F2@672=6:7=06.E6=71..02..=2=15=02=06.0:4.1 6.2=256.=2731<-:@=010:4.1:<;4=015:1.7:= G7:E=011F23=56.=2731102..=2=15=02==0156.=2731 ;1=E117=010:4.1:<27506.0:4.1327;13:A1-15 67!@674=1.;BE29G ! 02. .=2=15 =02= 06. 0:4.1 6. 25?2317= =: =01 0:4.1 :< 275 1A17 =06. E6=71.. 54-67> =01 3-:.. 1F2@672=6:702..=2=15=02=6=E:495=2G12;:4=!=: @674=1.=:-1230=010:4.1:<<-:@06.0:4.1%-:@ =01 1A651731 :< 275 6= 6. 2882-17= =02==016- 0:4.16.7:=.6=42=15A1-B39:.1=:=010:4.1:<275 ).:=02==01B3:49502A1:A1-012-5=0128819927=275 <6>0=67>E6=01230:=01-:7( !+(!'01-1<:-1 6= 3277:= ;1 .265 =02= 8-:.134=6:7 02. 8-:A15 6=. 32.1 ;1B:75 -12.:72;91 5:4;= =02= =01 28819927= 025 67.49=15 :- 2;4.15 275 ) -1<1--67> =: =016- 32.=1 67 27B 89231E6=067284;963A61E - 9 - (275*E0:2-1=0182730E6=71..1.=:=01 .8:= @202H2- 02A1 7:= .488:-=15 =01 32.1 :< =01 8-:.134=6:727554-67>=016-3-:..1F2@672=6:7=01B02A1 .=2=15=02=8:96310257:=.4@@:715=01@712-=01.8:= :<3-6@1275=01B0257:=.6>715:7=01.8:=@202H2-2= =01.8:=:<3-6@1 ( = 02. 3:@1 :7 -13:-5 =02= 28819927= ;19:7>. =: 276>2-:@@476=B275), ;19:7> =:.3015491532.=13:@@476=B=02.29.:3:@1:7-13:-5 =02= =01-1 E2. 27 12-961- 56.84=1 ;1=E117 =01 276>2- :@@476=B 275 =01 301549152.=1 :@@476=B -192=67> =: @;15G2- 6-391 275 =01-1 E2. 2 3-6@6729 32.1 -1>6.=1-15 12-961- E0630 E2. 817567> 3:7.651-2=6:7 1 =02=2.6=@2B=01<23=-1@267.=02=67=018-1.17=32.1 =01 8-:.134=6:7 02. <26915 =: 8-:A1 6=. 32.1 ;1B:75 -12.:72;915:4;==02==0128819927=0252;4.15:-67.49=15 275 ) -1<1--67> =: =016- 32.=1 67 2 89231 E6=067 =01 84;963 A61E 275 =01-1<:-1 2@ :< :8676:7 =02= =01 - 10 - -629:4-=E2.7:=?4.=6<615673:7A63=67>=0128819927=<:- :<<17318476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7 *#$#-$#.$ :< =01 #$3=++ * %:- =01 84-8:.1 :< 67A:G67> =01 :<<1731 8476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7 !) :< =01 8-:.134=6:7 6. -1I46-15 =: 8-:A1 =02= =01 28819927= 2334.15 025 67.49=15 =01 A63=6@ E6=02767=17==:8-:A:G1;-1230:<812310128819927= 2991>159B 025 2;4.15 275 ) <:-=01-12.:7=02= =016-32==91025.=-2B1567=:01-8-:81-=B275E1-1<:475 >-2H67>01-1<:-16=3277:=;1.265=02==0128819927=025 67.49=15 , ) E6=0 67=17= =: 8-:A:G1 ;-1230 :< 81231 %:- =01 84-8:.1 :< 2==-23=67> =01 :<<1731 8476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7 !) :< 6= 6. 7:= .4<<63617= =02= =01 2334.15 025 67.49=15 =01 A63=6@ ;4= .430 67.49= @4.= ;1 .4<<63617= 17:4>0 =: >6A1 8-:A:32=6:7 =: =01 81-.:767.49=15275.4308-:A:32=6:7E:495324.127:=01- =:;-12G=0184;96381231:-=:3:@@6=27B:=01-:<<1731 01-1 6. 7: .430 1A651731 2A2692;91 :7 -13:-5 E0630 E:495.2=6.<B=017131..2-B67>-15617=..:2.=:8476.0=01 - 11 - 28819927= 2334.15 <:- =01 :<<1731 8476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7!):< ) 751- =01 36-34@.=2731. 2@ :< =01 :8676:7 =02= =01 -629 :4-= E2. 7:= ?4.=6<615 67 3:7A63=67> =01 28819927= 2334.15 <:- =01 :<<17.1. 8476.02;91 4751- 13=6:7.*#$#-$#.$:< #$3=27513=6:7!):< 33:-567>9B=01<:99:E67> 2$ 013-6@67292881296.299:E15J ;$ 01 ?45>@17= 275 :-51- :< 3:7A63=6:7 275 .17=1731 82..15 67 813629 2.1 # $ :! (! 82..15 ;B =01 :4-= :< 556=6:729 6.=-63= 275 1..6:7. 45>1 6?2B284-26.01-1;B.1=2.651 3$ 01 28819927= 2334.15 6. 23I46==15 :< =01 302->1.011=15:<<1731. - 12 - 5$ 269 ;:75. 6< 27B 1F134=15 ;B =01 28819927= 2334.15 .=275. 327319915 275 <671 2@:47= 6< 27B 518:.6=15 ;B =01 28819927= .0299;1-1<47515=:01- ,+ &# $ * 6.=:9:*)