Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10887 (KAR)
SMT. SEEMABAI AND ORS v. SMT. SHIVAKANTAMMA AND ORS
WP/202379/2022 · 2025-01-30
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10887 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10887 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" "
&% ' ( )&% '
(
! ! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
"
# $ %
&
'
()&
("*
('( " &
("*
! (***
"
(*
(*
#
$ %
- 3 -
'
+
*) *
&
)
"* ** , (
)
! ! "
# $ %
- 4 -
&
()&
("*
('( " ()&
("*
! ('( " ()&
("*
"
('( " ()&
("*
('( " ()&
("*
#
$ %
'
+
!**) *
&
"* ** , (
- 5 -
- . /
01234253678142925372:;<=7>290<3142?21616<723> 57:142925372:;<=7>290<314232>?<7:271>142@=2>16<7 A421423142>21A<A361?21616<7>=7:23316;92 '<0142 <7>161=16<7 <0 7:65 532 B56715675C92 58567>1 142 6B?=872:<3:23536>2>0<3;<7>6:23516<7
42?21616<723>67142>21A<?21616<7>;956B2:1< C2 142 92859 4263> <0 :2;25>2: 5635D A4692 142 32>?<7:271>59><;956B2:1<C2142928594263><0142>56:
5635D 42 >56: 5635D 45: 0692:
<"* ** 0<3 :2;953516<7 1< :2;9532 1451 142 :<;=B271 :512:
* **'A5>7<1C67:678=?<746B57:1<32>13567142 :2027:571 67 142 >=61 03<B 5962751678 142 >=61 ?3<?231E 67;2142>56:5635D:62:6712>1512:=3678142;<=3>2<0142 >=61 142 ?21616<723> 5> A299 5> 32>?<7:271> 0692: 5??96;516<7> 1< ;<B2 <7 32;<3: 5> 46> 92859
- 6 -
32?32>271516F2> 42 3659 <=31 429: 57 27@=63E =7:23 3:23,,=92<0<:2<06F693<;2:=3257:429:1451 142?21616<723>5327<1142928594263>57:14232>?<7:271> A232 142 92859 4263> <0 :2;25>2: 5635D 42 ?21616<723> 45F2 ;45992782: 142 50<32>56: <3:23> 67 142>2 1A< A361 ?21616<7> 7 142 B257A4692 142 32>?<7:271> A4< A232 C3<=841<732;<3:67142>=610692:5B2B<1<A614:35A142 >=6157:5;;<3:6789E142>=61A5>:6>B6>>2:5>A614:35A7 <7!**) * !
42 925372: ;<=7>29 0<3 142 32>?<7:271> ;<7127: 1451 142 32B2:E 5F5695C92 1< 142 ?21616<723> A5> 1< 0692 57 5??259 =7:23 3:23 , =92 $G% <0 <:2 <0 6F69 3<;2:=32 $% C=1 142 925372: ;<=7>29 0<3 142 ?21616<723>;<7127:2:14513:23,=92$G%<0C2 <79EA427575??96;516<7=7:233:23,,=92<0 6> 32D2;12: <A2F23 67 142 ?32>271 ;5>2 142 <=31 45> :2123B672:142>151=><0142?21616<723>=7:233:23,, =92<0
- 7 -
" 45F2;<7>6:232:142>=CB6>>6<7<0142925372: ;<=7>290<3142?21616<723>57:142925372:;<=7>290<3142 32>?<7:271>
?23=>59<03:23,=92$G%<0>4<A> 1451575??2596>B56715675C9258567>157<3:23?5>>2:<7 57 5??96;516<7 0692: =7:23 3:23 ,, =92 <0 <A2F23 67 142 67>1571 ;5>2 142 3659 <=31 45> ;<7>6:232:1425??96;516<7>672H23;6>2<061>?<A23=7:23 3:23 ,, =92 <0 4232 6> 7< ?3<F6>6<7 0<3 57 5??259=7:233:23,=92<058567>157<3:23 ?5>>2: =7:23 3:23 ,, =92 <0 42320<32 142 ?21616<723> A232 C<=7: 1< 0692 5 32F6>6<7 ?21616<7 =7:23 2;16<7<05>142@=2>16<7A421423142E532142 92859 32?32>271516F2> <3 7<1 5> :2;6:2: =7:23 142 6B?=872: <3:23 5B<=712: 1< 5 ;5>2 :2;6:2: 57: 60 142 32F6>6<7 ?21616<7 A232 1< C2 429: 67 05F<=3 <0 142 ?21616<723> 1427 1451 @=2>16<7 ;<=9: C2 067599E :6>?<>2: <00
- 8 -
) 7 F62A <0 142 D=:8B271 <0 142 <7.C92 ?2H <=31 67 142 ;5>2 <0 F> 61 6> 7<1 5??3<?36512 0<3 146> <=31 1< 2H5B672 142 6B?=872: <3:23 67 ?3<;22:678> =7:23316;92 '<0142<7>161=16<7<07:6557:142320<32 142286>13E6>:632;12:1<327=BC23142>2?21616<7>5>;6F69 32F6>6<7?21616<7>57:?95;2142>21A<A361?21616<7>C20<32 1425??3<?36512<=31 ' <3>1516>16;59?=3?<>2>142>21A<A361?21616<7> 532132512:5>;9<>2:
25372: ;<=7>29 0<3 142 ?21616<723> 6> :632;12: 1<B5G25??3<?36512;<332;16<7>67142A361?21616<7>><5> 1< C3678 61 67 9672 A614 142 0<3B ?32>;36C2: 0<3 069678 32F6>6<7=7:23
2;16<7<0 *(
&"'
"
6>1<
9<"
1 AIR 2015 SC 3269