Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10873 (KAR)

THE BRANCH MANAGER v. TARABAI AND ORS

MFA/202366/2018 · 2025-01-28

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " ! ! ## $% ##& ##&' !( !(()%* $ % ! ! ! !! "! !"#$% &##!! ' ( LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.10 10:44:13 - 0800 - 2 - !! ## !" $ %% ! )#$% &# '#)* )( ) )! '( ) #! # # !! ##! ) + # ! ! ) ) #!## # ) % $ , % $ , *( !! ##! # ## ) ) )# &$ % ! )# ! &##!! '( - 3 - ! ! ! ! # ! # !! "! !"#$% % !! ## !" $ %% '#!) ) ""##$ $-+%( &# ' ). * #* #)%( ) )! '( ) #!## + # ! ! ) #! # # !! ##!#) - 4 - &'$ % ! )# ! &##!! '( ! ! !! !" #$% !! ## !" $ %% '#!) ) ""##$ $-+%( &# '#)* $$#( ) )! '( ) #!## + # ! ! ) #! # # - !! ##!#) - 5 - $( % !! ## !" $ %% & '#( ) + - #. # ! #$ ! ! %! !! "! !"#$% % ! )#$% &# ' ) * )%( - 6 - ))! !) )!## + # /!!! ) #! # # 0 !##!!!! # # ($( % !! ## !" $ %% & '#( ! ! !! !"# ! )#$% &# ')( - 7 - ))! !) )!## +# /!!! ) #! # # - 0 ! ##!! !!# ) ) !! ) ##! ) ))! ! 1! ! '# 1! ( 2343 5663574 58943 :;< := <23 >:??:@ A;BC?3@< 5@B 5D58B4 B5<3B + 65443B 9@ :4 5@B- EF<237358@3BBB9<9:@57 3@9:8 9G97 ;BC3 5@B :??9449:@38 =:8 ?67:F334 :?63@45<9:@9A5F56;85'23839@5=<3883=3883B<:54H<23 :??9449:@38/ =:8 42:8<( 39@C 5CC893G3B EF <23 459B >:??:@ A;BC?3@< <23 63<9<9:@384 9@ : - 8 - 25G3 =973B ) :% * 346:@B3@< :$ @4;85@>3 :?65@F 254 =973B ) : 5@B 8346:@B3@< :$:D@38 254 =973B ) 8:E : - 9?97587F E39@C 5CC893G3B EF <23 459B A;BC?3@< <23 @4;85@>3 :?65@F 9@ :- 254 =973B ) :+ 5@B <23 :D@38 254 =973B )8:E:- - ):8<2345I3:=>:@G3@93@>3<23658<934D:;7B E383=3883B<:54638<239885@I9@CE3=:83<2389E;@57 23 =5><;57 ?5<89J := <23 >543 9@ 42:8< 94 54 E37:D 23 63<9<9:@384 9@ : 583 <23 B363@B3@<4 := :@3 42:I 25G5@ D2: B93B 9@ <23 5>>9B3@< 23 63<9<9:@38 $ ;?58 9@ :- 94 <23 9@A;83B D2: 94 <23 >735@38 :=<23 G329>73 9@G:7G3B 9@ <23459B5>>9B3@< 23B3>3543B 42:I 25G5@ 5@B <23 9@A;83B$;?58 D383 D:8I9@C 54 B89G38 5@B >735@38 9@ ?9@9 <96638 7:88F - 9 - E3589@C:$ $-+%D29>294:D@3BEF8346:@B3@< :$:<9757 @ + D23@ <23 459B 7:88F 7:5B3B D9<24<:@34D5468:>33B9@C=8:?5458D5B5<:;89;?9@ :5 5@ 42:I !5F75@B 8;>I E3589@C : $+ 0$- >5?3 =8:? :66:49<3 B983><9:@ 5@B >:779B3B D9<2 <23 ?9@9 <96638 7:88F @ <23 459B 5>>9B3@< 42:I 25G5@ B93B :@ <2346:<5@B;?5825G9@C4;==383B9@A;8934D54429=<3B <:<232:469<575<:55@B<23835=<3823<::I<835<?3@<5< 38;B9 :469<57 5C57I:< 2383=:83 <23 B363@B5@<4 := 42:I25G5@5@B<239@A;83B;?58=973B>759?63<9<9:@4 5C59@4< <23 :D@38 5@B 9@4;838 := <23 <96638 7:88F E3589@C :$ $-+% 433I9@C >:?63@45<9:@ ;@B38 <23 68:G949:@4:=<23?67:F33/4:?63@45<9:@><-'=:8 42:8<H/( @ 438G9>3 := @:<9>3 <23 :D@38 5@B 9@4;838 := <23 ?9@9 <96638 7:88F 5663583B 5@B =973B <2398 D89<<3@ 4<5<3?3@<423:D@385B?9<<3B<25<<23B3>3543B42:I 25G5@ 5@B 9@A;83B ;?58 D383 3?67:F334 ;@B38 29? E;< B3@93B <23 K;5@<;? := <23 45758F >759?3B EF <23 - 10 - 63<9<9:@384 3 >:@<3@B3B <25< <23 B3>3543B 5@B <23 9@A;83BD383E39@C659B545758F:=4 $638?:@<2 5@B<23G329>7325BG579B9@4;85@>3<239@4;83894795E73<: 65F<23>:?63@45<9:@ % 23 @4;85@>3 :?65@F D2: D54 5885F3B 54 8346:@B3@< : E3=:83 <23 :??9449:@38 5B?9<<3B <23 >:G385C3 := <23 6:79>F E;< 9< D54 >:@<3@B3B <25< B89G38 42:I25G5@D54@:<25G9@CG579BB89G9@C79>3@>35@B<23 :@3 =;8@9423B EF 8346:@B3@< :$:D@38 5@B <23 63<9<9:@384 93 E3589@C : $$ 94 5 =5I3 :@3 @ =5>< <23 459B B89G9@C 79>3@>3 E37:@C4 <: :@3 D56@97I83658<=8:?<2343>:@<3@<9:@4>38<59@:<238 C8:;@B4D383574:85943BEF9< 23 7358@3B :??9449:@38 =85?3B 5668:6895<3 944;34* >7;EE3B E:<2 <23 63<9<9:@4 5@B 83>:8B3B >:??:@ 3G9B3@>3 #3<9<9:@38 : 9@ : D54 3J5?9@3B54# 5@B04#<:#-D383?58I3B9@<2398 3G9B3@>3 23 63<9<9:@38 9@ - D54 3J5?9@3B 54# 5@BJ4#<:#+D383?58I3B9@2943G9B3@>3 - 11 - 346:@B3@<:D543J5?9@3B54 5@B5@:==9>957:= 8346:@B3@< : D54 3J5?9@3B 54 J4 <: + D383?58I3B:@<2398E3257= + =<38 23589@C E:<2 <23 49B34 7358@3B :??9449:@38 237B <25< <23 63<9<9:@384 9@ : >759?9@C >:?63@45<9:@ =:8 <23 B35<2 := 42:I 25G5@ 583 3@<9<73B =:8 5 >:?63@45<9:@ := % $EF2:7B9@C<23?:@<27FD5C34:=<23B3>3543B 5< 4 $* <23 63<9<9:@38 9@ :- 94 3@<9<73B=:85>:?63@45<9:@:=4% $239@4;85@>3 >:?65@F D54 45BB73B <: 65F <23 >:?63@45<9:@ 5?:;@< E;< <23 9@<3834< D54 :8B383B <: E3 659B EF <23 :D@38 := <23G329>73 39@C 5CC893G3B EF <23 5E:G3 =9@B9@C4 <23 68343@<5663574583=973B - @ ) :4 5@B + >:??:@ 4;E4<5@<957 K;34<9:@ := 75D 254 E33@ =85?3B 54 E37:D - 12 - !" @ ) 8:E :4 - 5@B - - >:??:@ 4;E4<5@<957 K;34<9:@ := 75D 254 E33@=85?3B54E37:D 23<238 <23 :??9449:@38 94 A;4<9=93B 9@ =54<3@9@C<239@<3834<6:8<9:@:=<23795E979<F:@ <23:D@38:=<23G329>73L @ ) :% @: 4;E4<5@<957 K;34<9:@ := 75D D:;7B 58943 =:8 >:@49B385<9:@ 23 63<9<9:@384583>:@<3@B9@C<25<<23D5C34:=<23B3>3543B >:@49B383BEF<23:??9449:@385<4 $638?:@<2 94 @:< 68:638 < 94 D:8<2 <: @:<3 <25< <23 @:<9=9>5<9:@ 944;3BEF<233@<857:G38@?3@<;@B383><9:@ '(:= <23 >< B3>75834 <23 D5C34 <: E3 4 $ 638 ?:@<2@5>5<3@5:=B3>949:@4<294:;8<54D37754<23 - 13 - G589:;4:<238 9C2:;8<425G3237B<25<9@<235E43@>3:= 5@F >:C3@< 3G9B3@>3 <23 D5C34 @:<9=93B EF <23 3@<857 :G38@?3@<583<:E35>>36<3B@<23>543:@25@B574: <23 5B?9<<3B D5C34 EF <23 :D@38 := <23 G329>73 D2: 94 3?67:F38 94 4 $ 638 ?:@<2 2383=:83 5 K;34<9:@ := =5>< 25G9@C B3<38?9@3B EF <23 :??9449:@38 94 @:< 5G5975E73<:E3K;34<9:@3BE3=:83<294:;8<44;>2<23 5663579@):% =973BEF<2363<9<9:@3849@ : 94E383=<:=5@F?389<45@B94795E73<:E3 B94?9443B :=5854<234;E4<5@<957K;34<9:@:=75D85943B 9@ <235663574 =973B EF <23@4;85@>3 :?65@F 93 94 >:@>38@3B 9< 94@3>34458F<:@:<3<25<<23@4;85@>3:?65@F>:@<3@B4 <25<<23B89G9@C79>3@>3:=B3>3543B42:I25G5@D54 5 =5I3 :@3 < 94 @3>34458F <: @:<3 <25< <23 83C94<85<9:@ >38<9=9>5<3 := <23 G329>73 B89G3@ EF B3>3543B 42:I 25G5@ :D@3B EF 8346:@B3@< : 5@B 9@4;83B EF 8346:@B3@< : 94 68:B;>3B 5< J < 42:D4 <23 - 14 - ;@75B3@D39C2<:=<23G329>73<:E3C42383=:83 <2383K;983B79>3@>3<:B89G3<23459BG329>73D545@! 797>3@>3 23 A;BC?3@< := <23 63J :;8< 9@ <23 >543 := !"# $% &' ($) *+, -%*%& 75F4B:D@<25<<238394@:@3>3449<F:=:E<59@9@C 579>@3>3=:8<85@46:8<G329>739@>543<23;@75B3@D39C2< :=<23G329>73947344<25@+%C4 638;457 := J D29>2 94 68:B;>3B EF <23 :D@38 := <23 G329>73 42:D4 <25< B3>3543B 42:I 25G5@ 25B G579B B89G9@C 79>3@>3 E3589@C : %- 5@B 9< D54 G579B <: B89G3 5 <85@46:8< G329>73 =8:? % <: % 2383=:83 <23 459B B89G9@C 79>3@>3 D54 4;==9>93@< =:8 <23 6;86:43 := >:?6795@>3 := <38?45@B>:@B9<9:@4:=<236:79>F<?5FE3<8;3<25<<23 63<9<9:@384 25B @:< =;8@9423B <23 459B 79>3@>3 <: <23 @4;85@>3:?65@F< ?5F 574:E3 <8;3<25<<23B89G9@C 79>3@>368:B;>3B5<J4<5@B9@C9@<23@5?3:=42:I 25G5@D549@=:8?3BEF;?E59<:E35=5I3:@354 1 +'( - 15 - 638<23B:>;?3@<468:B;>3BEF<23@4;85@>3:?65@F5< J45@B+EG9:;47F<2343B:>;?3@<442:D<25<<23 79>3@>3E3589@C: <:E39@<23@5?3:= :@3 D56@97 I83 @B38 <2343 >98>;?4<5@>34 9< 94 9??5<38957 D23<238 <23 B89G9@C 79>3@>3 68:B;>3B EF <23 63<9<9:@384 D54 <8;3 :8 =5I3 J =;77F >:G383B <23 83K;983?3@< := <23 6:79>F 5@B <2383=:83 <2383 >5@@:< E3 5@FC8:;@B:=>:77;49:@:=<23:D@38:=<23G329>735@B<23 63<9<9:@384<94@:<@3>34458F<:3@<389@<:<23B94>;449:@ 5E:;<<23=5I3B89G9@C79>3@>354J 254C835<38G57;3 <25@ J4 5@B + D29>2 583 @:< 68:G3B 54 83K;983B ;@B3875D2945463><94683>9437F:E438G3BEF<237358@3B :??9449:@38 9@ 6585 := <23 9?6;C@3B A;BC?3@< :@43K;3@<7F <23 4;E4<5@<957 K;34<9:@ := 75D 85943B 9@ <23435663574945@4D383B9@<235==98?5<9G3 3C58B9@C<234;E4<5@<957K;34<9:@:=75D85943B 9@ $ . / // >:@>38@9@C <23 9@<3834< 94 >:@>38@3B <23 63J :;8< 9@ <D: := 9<4 A;BC?3@< 254 >7589=93B <23 ?5<<38 23 63J - 16 - :;8< 9@ (( 0 - 1 2( 02( (3 254 237B 54 E37:D 45 # $ % & $ '() ) * +,-. '( %/0 1 222 +,-." 3333333333 / 2 4 5 1 +67 8 9 & 2 '(%- - 17 - 2 5 6 7 $,# 0% (%:'-;;<(=1-;;> $ 5 ? +,-. 5 5 ? 2 1 2 - 18 - 5 @ 33333333333333 5 1 +7 ? * A ? 8 9 2 ? 2 - 19 - & 4 8 9 ? 5 ? & ? ? 5 # 2 5 33333333333 B 2 - 20 - 5 5 # 2 C % !5<38 9@ <23 B3>949:@ := 8- 01( 1 (- (0 9 <23 63J :;8< 25B <23:>>549:@<:>7589=F<2368:6:49<9:@759B54E37:D CD2@ 2 9# :'-;;<(=1+,->9% E: '+,,7(D1+> 2 8 9 +,DD' 89"($ +,F 2:+,.D' / 2 0(> 4 :> 5 3 '-( + - 21 - 1 +67 8 9 & F 2 : > F " 5 %G @4 2:'-;;<( = 1 -;;> 2 5 * 89 & @ 2 9 # :'-;;<( = 1 +,-> 5 2 C 2383=:83 D23@ <23 ?5<<38 4<::B B94<9@C;9423B <23 795E979<F <: 65F <23 9@<3834< D:;7B E3 C:G38@3BEF<23<38?45@B>:@B9<9:@49@<236:79>F@<23 >543:@325@B<236:79>F5<JD:;7B42:D<25<9<945 ?:<:8 G329>73 6:79>F 5@B <2383 94 @: 4;>2 >75;43 D29>2 D:;7B 5E4:7G3 <23 @4;85@>3 :?65@F =8:? 65F9@C <23 - 22 - 9@<3834< :@ <23 >:?63@45<9:@ 5?:;@< 2383=:83 <23 >8:44:EA3><9:@4=973BEF<23:D@38:=<23G329>73B3438G3 <:E3577:D3B5@B23>5@@:<E345BB73BD9<2<239@<3834< >>:8B9@C7F<234;E4<5@<957K;34<9:@:=75D85943B9@<2343 >8:44:EA3><9:@4945@4D383B9@<23@3C5<9G32:7B9@C<25< <23 @4;85@>3 :?65@F 94 795E73 <: 65F <23 9@<3834< 6:8<9:@574: + @<23834;7<6544<23=:77:D9@C '9( ) :% =973B EF <23 63<9<9:@384 5@B ) :4 5@B + =973B EF <23 @4;85@>3 :?65@F 583 2383EF %*% '99( ) 8:E :4 - 5@B - - 583 '' ! :@43K;3@<7F <23 @4;85@>3 :?65@F 94 237B 795E73 <: 65F <23 9@<3834< 6:8<9:@574:5@B<:<25<3J<3@<<23A;BC?3@<:= <23:??9449:@384<5@B4?:B9=93B - 23 - '999( 235?:;@<B36:49<3BE3=:83<294:;8<9=5@F 94 :8B383B <: E3 <85@4?9<<3B <: <23 :??9449:@38 B $ ) ! * ! ! !94<:7:%