Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10842 (KAR)
JAGANNATH S/O MUTTANNA v. NAGARAJ S/O VISHWANATH HUGAR AND ANR
MFA/201943/2022 · 2025-01-08
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10842 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10842 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$
"
" %%&'
( )
*
! !! "
"# $!! %""&& '
&
"
"
("# %
)
!"
# #'
*
"
! ! " )) &""
#
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"# $
%"!! &) *
& +***'
) )! +%' )
&! !! )
) ****"! &! )"
! "
!"& ** *
! ) )! !&
,"! " % ,"! '
-./01-./2-034526-1.77-./829:4/;<-.77-11.2;.20 ;<-1-./2-034526-1.77-./829:4//-67420-2;4*
* <86 .77-.1 86 :81-0 => ;<- 7-;8;842-/ 82 & 4** * =-829 .99/8-?-0 => ;<- @509A-2; .20 .B./0 0.;-0 **** 7.66-0 => ;<- 008;842.1 -284/ 8?81 509- .20 "80./ %:4/ 6<4/; C/8=52.1D' 6--E829 -2<.23-A-2;4:34A7-26.;842
- 3 -
<-:.3;5.1A.;/8F4:;<-3.6-86.6=-14B
.' <81-;<-.77-11.2; 7-;8;842-/B.6/80829<86 A4;4/3>31- 42 +*# :/4A .22.0.A=- <4BE ;4B./06.5=.0.;"80./2-./-</5;.085A.24;<-/ A4;4/3>31- =-./829 4# # 3.A- :/4A 477468;- 08/-3;842 82 /.6< .20 2-9189-2; A.22-/ .20 3.56-0;<-.3380-2;=>341180829B8;<;<-?-<831-4:;<- 7-;8;842-/6./-651;7-;8;842-/656;.82-082@5/8-6.20 8AA-08.;-1> <- B.6 6<8:;-0 ;4 ;<- <4678;.1 B<-/- <- <.0520-/942-65/9-/8-6=>.0A8;;82982;4;<-<4678;.1 .6 827.;8-2; :/4A +*# ;4 #+*# -23- 7-;8;842-/ 31.8A6 34A7-26.;842 42 .33452; 4: ;<- 82@5/8-6 656;.82-0 => <8A .6 .9.826; ;<- 4B2-/ .20 8265/-/4:;<-4::-20829A4;4/3>31-
='
2 8665.23- 4: 24;83- ;<- 4B2-/ 4: ;<- 4::-20829 ?-<831- /-A.82-0 -F7./;- =5; ;<- 265/.23- 4A7.2> 342;-6;-0 ;<- A.;;-/ => 342;-20829 ;<.; ;<- 34A7-26.;842 31.8A-0 86 <89<1> -F4/=8;.2; 528A.982./> .20 52;-2.=1- .20 ;<.; ;<-
- 4 -
2-9189-23- B.6 42 ;<- 7./; 4: ;<- 7-;8;842-/ <8A6-1:
;<-/-:4/- ;<- 265/.23- 4A7.2> 86 24; 18.=1- ;4 7.> ;<-34A7-26.;842
3' <-/8=52.142;<-=.6864:;<-342;-2;8426 4: =4;< ;<- 7./;8-6 :/.A-0 .77/47/8.;- 8665-6 -;8;842-/ B.6 -F.A82-0 .6 .20 ;<- -083.1
::83-/ B<4 .66-66-0 ;<- 086.=818;> B.6 -F.A82-0 .6 * F6 ;4 B-/- A./E-0 82 -?80-23- -67420-2; 4* -F.A82-0 8;6 ::83-/ .6 .20 F6.20*B-/-A./E-0:;-/<-./829=4;<680-6 .20.:;-/.77/-38.;829-?80-23-42/-34/0;<-/8=52.1 <.6 .B./0-0 ;<- 34A7-26.;842 520-/ 08::-/-2; <-.06 .6=-14B
!4664::5;5/-8234A- * * .82.2065::-/829
-083.1F7-26-6 +#
!466 4: 8234A- 05/829 1.80577-/840 *
)440 .20 245/86<A-2;
342?->.23- G .;;-20.2; 3<./9-6
!4664::5;5/-.A-28;>
!
- 5 -
"-829 .99/8-?-0 => ;<- 6.80 @509A-2; ;<- 7-;8;842-/86=-:4/-;<8645/;82;<86.77-.1
2 ;<- .77-.1 =-829 .0A8;;-0 ;<- /8.1 45/; -34/06 <.?- =--2 6-35/-0 ;<- 24;83- ;4 /-67420-2; 4 0867-26-0 B8;< .20 /-67420-2; 4* <.6 .77-./-0 ;</459< 8;634526-1
!-./2-0 34526-1 .77-./829 :4/ ;<- .77-11.2; B451065=A8;;<.;.;;<-;8A-4:.3380-2;;<-7-;8;842-/B.6 .9-0.=45;>-./6B4/E829.6.44E.20<-65::-/-0;<- :/.3;5/- 4: =81.;-/.1 7./8-;.1 =42- :/.3;5/- 4: 1-:; ;-A74/.1 :/.3;5/- 4: 1-:; A.6;480 =42- :/.3;5/- 4: 1-:; 31.?831- .20 :/.3;5/- 4: /89<; ;8=8.1 3420>1- <- 6.80 82@5/8-6 <.?- /-651;-082086.=818;>;4;<--F;-2;4:*H.64782-0=>;<- * .20 ;<-/-:4/- 8; 86 342;-20-0 ;<.; ;<- :523;842.1 086.=818;>.66-66-0=>;<-/8=52.1.;H86.=>6A.11>14B .2024;7/47-/-:5/;<-/342;-206;<.;;<-34A7-26.;842 .B./0-0 520-/ ;<- 4;<-/ <-.06 86 .164 42 ;<- 14B-/ 680- <-23-6--E6-2<.23-A-2;4:;<-34A7-26.;842
- 6 -
+
1-./2-0 34526-1 .77-./829 :4/ /-67420-2;4*B451065=A8;;<.;;<-086.=818;>.66-66-0=> ;<-*=-829*H;<- 4:;<-6.A-<.6=--2;.E-2=> ;<-/8=52.1 H.2024:.51;3.2=-:452082/-67-3;4: ;<-6.A-<-:5/;<-/65=A8;;<.;;<-.77-11.2;;<459<<.0 342;-20-0 ;<.; <- B.6 B4/E829 .6 . 44E 42 6.1./> 4:
7-/ A42;< <.0 24; 7/4053-0 .2> 0435A-2; 82 65774/; 4: ;<- 6.A- <-/-:4/- 6<- 65=A8;6 ;<.; ;<- 24;842.1 8234A- 342680-/-0 => ;<- /8=52.1 86 7/47-/ .20 34//-3;
#
2 7-/56.1 4: ;<- /8.1 45/; -34/06 8; .77-./6 ;<.;;<-7-;8;842-/<.0656;.82-082@5/8-6;4<86<-.0.6B-11 .6 :/.3;5/- ;4 ;<- ;8=8. 4: ;<- /89<; 1-9 2 :.3; * .66-66-0;<-086.=818;>82/-67-3;4:;<-/89<;14B-/18A=.20 82<8647828428;B.6;4;<--F;-2;4:*H;867-/;82-2;;4 24;-;<.;;<-7-;8;842-/B.6B4/E829.6.44E82;<-<46;-1 B<-/-;<-2.;5/-4:;<-B4/E/-I58/-6;<-A.25.118:;8294:
;<- <-.?> 5;-26816 <86 0-:828;-1> /-I58/-6 . 7<>683.1 -F-/;842 .20 ;<-/-:4/- ;<- .66-66A-2; 4: ;<- :523;842.1 086.=818;>=>;<-/8=52.1.77-./6;4=-6189<;1>42;<-14B-/
- 7 -
680-2;<-342680-/-04782842;<-086.=818;>4:*HB4510 =-7/47-/.2034//-3;
<- 9580-182-6 8665-0 => ;<- ./2.;.E. ;.;- !-9.1 -/?83-6 5;<4/8;> 82 /-67-3; 4: 6-;;1-A-2; 4: ;<- 08675;-6=-:4/-;<-!4E0.1.;7/-63/8=-;<-24;842.18234A- 4:
:4/ ;<- >-./ *# 2 5A7;--2 25A=-/ 4: 0-3868426 ;<86 45/; <.6 <-10 ;<.; ;<- 9580-182-6 8665-0 => !./-<-10;4=-.33-7;.=1-42;<-9/4520;<.;;<->./- 82 9-2-/.1 342:4/A8;> B8;< ;<- A828A5A B.9-6 :8F-0 520-/ ;<-828A5A.9-63;<-/-:4/-;<-24;842.18234A-4:
;<-7-;8;842-/86.33-7;-0.6
7-/A42;<<56;<- 14664::5;5/-8234A-863.1351.;-0.6+ F*FF *H ;<.; -I5.16 ;4 # * => .047;829 . A51;8718-/ 4: CD:4/;<-.77-11.2;=-829.9-0>-./6
426-I5-2;1> ;<- 1466 4:8234A- 05/829;<- 1.80 577-/840863.1351.;-0.6+FA42;<6;<.;-I5.16;4 *
- 8 -
<- /8=52.1 <.6 .B./0-0 . 65A 4:
;4B./06 7.82 .20 65::-/829 .20 342680-/829 ;<- 25A=-/ 4:
:/.3;5/-6 65::-/-0 => ;<- .77-11.2; 8; B4510 =- @56; .20 7/47-/;4.B./0.65A4:520-/;<86<-.0
* <- /8=52.1 <.6 342680-/-0 <.6 ;<- 1466 4:
.A-28;8-6.; ;<-6.A-/-I58/-6;4=--2<.23-0;4 <- 34A7-26.;842 .B./0-0 520-/ /-A.82829 <-.06 04-6 24; /-I58/- .2> 82;-/:-/-23- -23- ;<- .77-11.2;86-2;8;1-0:4/;4;.134A7-26.;8424:* .6 .9.826;**+ # .B./0-0=>;<-/8=52.1.6=-14B
1 4 -.0 B./0=>;<- /8=52.1 B./0=> ;<8645/;
!466 4: :5;5/- 8234A-
* # * * .82.2065::-/829
-083.1F7-26-6 +# +#
!466 4: 8234A- 05/8291.80577-/840
* *
)440 .20 245/86<A-2; 342?->.23- G .;;-20.2;3<./9-6
- 9 -
!466 4: :5;5/- .A-28;>
!
<-/-B811=--2<.23-A-2;4:#+
;867-/;82-2;;424;-;<.;;<-/8=52.1<.6:8F-0 ;<- 342;/8=5;4/> 2-9189-23- 42 ;<- 7./; 4: ;<- 7-;8;842-/ .; H;<-6.A-0424;/-I58/-.2>82;-/:-/-23-=>;<8645/;
<-/-:4/- ;<- .77-11.2; 86 -2;8;1-0 :4/ H 4: ;<- ;4;.1 34A7-26.;842.A452;.60-;-/A82-0.=4?-
)4/;<-.:4/-6.80/-.6426;<-.77-.10-6-/?-0 ;4=-.114B-0827./;-23-;<-:4114B829
%8' <-.77-.186.114B-0827./;
%88' <-.77-11.2;86-2;8;1-0:4/.65A4:* 826;-.04:
%888' <- /-6; 4: ;<- ;-/A6 .20 34208;8426 /-9./0829 342;/8=5;4/> 2-9189-23- 42 ;<- 7./; 4: ;<- 7-;8;842-/
- 10 -
.77-11.2; 0-7468; 086=5/6-A-2; .20 -;3 4/0-/-0 => ;<- /8=52.1/-A.8252.1;-/-0
%8?' <- *20 /-67420-2; J 265/.23- 4A7.2> 86 08/-3;-0 ;4 0-7468; H 4: ;<- ;4;.1 34A7-26.;842 .A452;
.1429 B8;< 82;-/-6; .; ;<- /.;- 4: H 7-/ .225A :/4A ;<- 0.;-4:7-;8;842;8110.;-4:0-7468;
%?' <--2<.23-034A7-26.;842.A452;864/0-/-0;4 =-/-1-.6-082:.?45/4:;<-.77-11.2;
0 '
" )
"
" !86;414+