Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10841 (KAR)
DHONDIBA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/201281/2023 · 2025-01-16
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10841 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10841 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
! #$
" % &" ! $ '(')*+' ** &
!"
! #
!"
#
!"
$
%
&%
'%
%
!"
! (
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! ''
!"
$
' %
'! ' #! '
(
)!*!! ' #!* '
'
&
&
&'
'''
!# #*# *"( #'
'
(
+ &( &
+ &( &
,,-./0 1. 21 34 1 )!*!! 5/40346 7/819/ 2:/ 1-92 18 0032314;< 3=3< &-06/ &94 ;40 &'
-9;0 30;9 03.293,2 ;93.346 1-2 18 93>/ 1#!* 9/63.2/9/0 7? -9;0 1<3,/ 2;2314 30;9 03.293,2 819 2:/ 188/4,/. 5-43.:;7</ -40/9 /,2314 !# #*#*"9/;0@32:/,2314 #18;9/7/819/2:3. - 3 -
1-92-40/9/,2314#!189@32:;59;?/921A-;.: 2://4239/591,//0346.342:/.;30,;./;6;34.22:/>
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
@;. 3..-/0 21 2:/ ;,,-./0 ;40 7/346 ;6693/=/0 7? 2:/ .;>/2:/;,,-./05/232314/9.;9/7/819/2:3.1-92
# /;94/0,1-4./<8192:/5/232314/9..-7>32.2:;2 ;. 14 #*!* ;,,-./ 1 @;. 34 ,-.210? 34 93>/ 1*!* 9/63.2/9/0 7? -9;0 1<3,/ ;40 2:/9/819/ 32
3. ;55;9/42 2:;2 ; 8;<./ ;<</6;2314 :;. 7//4 >;0/ 34 2:/ 59/./42,;./:/51<3,/;82/934=/.236;2314:;=/83</0B C 834;<9/5192.2;23462:;241.-,:34,30/42:;02;E/45<;,/ 14#*!*;402:/.;309/5192;55/;9.217/,199/,234 =3/@ 18 2:/ 8;,2 2:;2 ;,,-./0 1 @;. 34 ,-.210? 34 93>/1*!*:/93;<1-92:;.41281<<1@/02:/ ,199/,2591,/0-9/7/819/2;E346,1643F;4,/182:/;<</6/0 188/4,/. 34 2:/ 59/./42 ,;./ ,,190346<? :/ 59;?. 21 ;<<1@2:/5/232314
/9 ,1429; </;94/0 36: 1-92
1=/94>/42 </;0/9 ;55/;9346 819 9/.5140/42 1 ;40 </;94/0 ,1-4./<;55/;93468199/.5140/421!:;=/1551./02:/ 5/232314 :/ </;94/0 36: 1-92
1=/94>/42 </;0/9 .-7>32. 2:;2 51<3,/ ;82/9 34=/.236;2314 :;=/ 83</0 B C 834;<
- 5 -
9/5192 ;40 2:/9/ 3. >;2/93;< 21 .:1@ 2:;2 ;,,-./0 1 @;.34,-.210?3493>/1*!*
" 4 2:/ 839.2 34819>;2314 0;2/0 2:/ #*!* 9/,/3=/0891>9/.5140/421!:/9/347?2:/51<3,/@:3,: :;09/.-<2/0349/63.29;231418'3493>/1#!* 32 3. .2;2/0 2:;2 14 #*!* ;2 ;71-2 * ;> ;,,-./0 1 ;7-./0 2:/ 839.2 34819>;42 7? -.346 83<2:? <;46-;6/;40,;-6:2:1<018:/9:;40;40293/0211-29;6/ :/9 >10/.2? ,,-./0 1.! ;40 @:1 @/9/ 59/./42 ;<146@32:;,,-./01791-6:2@110/4,<-7.891>2:/39 :1-./ ;40 ;,,-./0 1! ;<</6/0<? ;..;-<2/0 2:/ 839.2 34819>;42 @32: 2:/ .;>/ 14 :/9 </82 2:36: ;40 ,;-./0 34D-93/.
,,-./0 1 ;..;-<2/0 2:/ 839.2 34819>;42 @32:
2:/ @110/4 ,<-7 14 2:/ 936:2 2:36: 18 2:/ 34D-9/0 ;40 ,;-./0 34D-93/. :/ ;,,-./0 5/9.14. ;<.1 ,93>34;<<? 3423>30;2/0 2:/ 839.2 34819>;42 ;40 </82 2:/ 5<;,/ 18 2:/ 34,30/42
- 6 -
H 90/9 .://2 34 93>/ 1*!* @:3,: 3. 5910-,/0 7? 2:/ </;94/0 ,1-4./< 819 2:/ 5/232314/9 ;<146 @32: 2:3. ,93>34;< 5/232314 @1-<0 61 21 .:1@ 2:;2 34 2:/ .;30 ,;./ ;,,-./0 1 ;4>;42: @;. ;99/.2/0 14 *!*;405910-,/07/819/2:/,1-9218D-93.03,2314;< ;63.29;2/4*!*:/@;.;6;345910-,/07/819/ 2:/ </;94/0 ;63.29;2/ ;40 14 2:/ .;30 0;2/ :/ @;. 9/>;40/0 21 D-03,3;< ,-.210? ;40 2:/ >;22/9 @;. ;0D1-94/021!*!*42:/*!*51<3,/:;0 83</0;9/A-3.32314.//E34651<3,/,-.210?182:/;,,-./0819 342/9916;2314;402:/.;>/@;.;<<1@/0;4051<3,/,-.210? 18;,,-./0;4>;42:@;.69;42/0819;0;?:/9/819/32
3. ;55;9/42 2:;2 ;,,-./0 1 ;4>;42: @:1 @;. ;99/.2/0 14 *!* 34 93>/ 1*!* @;. 34 ,-.210? ;40 2:/9/819/ 32 ,;4412 7/ 7/<3/=/0 2:;2 14 #*!*:/@;.59/./42;<146@32:2:/;,,-./01. I ! ;. ;<</6/0 34 2:/ 839.2 34819>;2314 .-7>322/0 34 2:/ 59/./42,;./ ,,-./013.2:/8;2:/918;,,-./01 ;40 ;,,-./0 1! 3. 2:/ 7912:/9 18 ;,,-./0 1 :/ 51<3,/;82/9 34=/.236;2314 34 2:/ 59/./42 ,;./ :;=/ 83</0;
- 7 -
B C 834;< 9/5192 .2;2346 2:;2 41 .-,: 34,30/42 :;0 2;E/4 5<;,/ ;. ;<</6/0 34 2:/ 839.2 34819>;2314 .-7>322/0 34 2:/ 59/./42,;./14.30/93462:/8;,23493>/1*!* ;,,-./0 1 @;. 34 ,-.210? ;. 14 2:/ ;<</6/0 0;2/ 18 34,30/42 34 2:/ 59/./42 ,;./ 2:/ 51<3,/ 83</0 ; B C 834;< 9/5192 34 2:/ 59/./42 ,;./ ;55/;9. 21 7/ ,199/,2 =/4 12:/9@3./ 2:/ </;94/0 ;63.29;2/ :;. 412 81<<1@/0 2:/ ,199/,2 591,/0-9/ 34 2:/ 59/./42 ,;./ 7/819/ 2;E346 ,1643F;4,/ 18 2:/ ;<</6/0 188/4,/. :/ </;94/0 ;63.29;2/:;=3469/D/,2/02:/B C834;<9/519283</0342:/ 59/./42 ,;./ 1-6:2 21 :;=/ 591,//0/0 21 9/,190 2:/ .@194 .2;2/>/42 18 ;40 2:/9/;82/9 2;E/4 ,1643F;4,/ 18 2:/ ;<</6/0 188/4,/. 34 2:/ 59/./42 ,;./ 1@/=/9 @32:1-2 /=/4 9/,190346 2:/ .@194 .2;2/>/42182:/ ,1643F;4,/182:/ ;<</6/0188/4,/.3.2;E/4;40.->>14.:;.7//43..-/021 2:/> :/ .;30 591,/0-9/ 81<<1@/0 7? 2:/ </;94/0 ;63.29;2/3.41234;,,190;4,/@32:<;@
- 8 -
14.30/93462:/;819/.;30;.5/,2.182:/>;22/9 ;>1815343142:;22:/59;?/9>;0/7?2:/5/232314/9.34 2:/ 59/./42 5/232314 4//0. 21 7/ 69;42/0 ,,190346<? 591,//0215;..2:/81<<1@346
; 93>34;</2323143.;<<1@/0 7 :/ /4239/ 591,//0346. 34 1 )!*!! 5/40346 7/819/ 2:/ 1-92 18
0032314;< 3=3< &-06/ &94 ;40 &' -9;0 30;9 03.293,2 ;93.346 1-2 18 93>/ 1#!* 9/63.2/9/07?
-9;01<3,/2;2314 30;903.293,2819 2:/188/4,/.5-43.:;7</-40/9/,2314 !# #*# *"9/;0@32:/,2314 #183.A-;.:/0;6;34.2 2:/5/232314/9.:/9/34 , 4 =3/@ 18 03.51.;< 18 >;34 5/232314 5/40346;55<3,;231438;4?.2;40.03.51./0188
,+
' % &" !*
"
3.21<1! %