Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10796 (KAR)
YOGESH S/O MALEPPA PATTAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200091/2019 · 2025-02-04
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10796 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10796 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%
"#$$ #!! &'(&)!*+&* +, #!! +
,
!!"" #
"
$ $ %! &' !!()"
#
&
"* + ,&
& (-% &
".-( $ &
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
& &
,
$
!! )"/ )/)-)".&
&& (-- % &
)"(( &
+
,
(/
$ &'
#
"
&
& !!")-
$ (
!!""
#
&
"* + ,&
& (-% &
".-( $ &
&)/)-)". & $
!! )"/
- 3 -
&
&& (--!)/
& / &
& &
& & "))))) 0 &
&
&
&& (--
& / &
&
&
$
1$
1$$
$
#
1$$
2343 5663574 89 :23 ;<=>?;:3@ 5;;A43@ <4" 5=@ ?4 @?B3;:3@ 5C5?=4: :23 DA@CE3=: <F ;<=>?;:?<= 5=@ <B@3B <F 43=:3=;3 @5:3@ )/)-)". 65443@ ?= 63;?57 543
<!! )"/89:23735B=3@@@7344?<=4$A@C35758AB5C?
23B3?=5F:3B B3F3BB3@ :< 54 :23 G735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 H23B389 :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 ;<=>?;:3@ :23 5663775=:4 5;;A43@ <4" 5=@ 5=@ 43=:3=;3@ 5;;A43@ <" :<A=@3BC<B?C<B<A4?E6B?4<=E3=:F<B7?F35=@:<6595F?=3<F 4"))))) 0F<B:23<FF3=;36A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=(--<F 5=@3;:?<=/<F:23
;:5=@?=@3F5A7::<659F?=3 23 42577 A=@3BC< 4?E673 ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B 5 63B?<@ <F :H< 935B4&AB:23B5;;A43@<"?443=:3=;3@:<A=@3BC<B?C<B<A4
- 4 -
?E6B?4<=E3=:F<B:H<935B45=@:<6595F?=3<F4!))) 0F<B :23<FF3=;36A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=!)/<F5=@?=@3F5A7:
<F F?=3 23 42577 A=@3BC< ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B 5 63B?<@ <F 4?I E<=:24 &AB:23B 5;;A43@ < ?4 43=:3=;3@ :< A=@3BC< B?C<B<A4 ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B 7?F3 5=@ :< 659 5 F?=3 <F 4"))))) 0F<B:23<FF3=;36A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=(--<F 5=@3;:?<=%<F:23
;:5=@?=@3F5A7::<659F?=3 23 42577 A=@3BC< 4?E673 ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B 5 63B?<@ <F :H< 935B4&AB:23B5;;A43@<?443=:3=;3@:<A=@3BC<B?C<B<A4 ?E6B?4<=E3=:F<B<=3935B5=@:<6595F?=3<F4"))) 0F<B :23<FF3=;36A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=((<F5=@?=@3F5A7:
<F F?=3 23 42577 A=@3BC< ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B 5 63B?<@ <F :2B33 E<=:24 &AB:23B ?: ?4 @?B3;:3@ :25: 577 :23 4A84:5=:?>3 43=:3=;3442577BA=;<=;ABB3=:79
2358B?@C3@F5;:4<F:23;5435B354A=@3B
"0>?;:?E ?= :2?4 ;543 7<@C3@ 5 ;<E675?=: 83F<B3 :23 B346<=@3=:0<7?;3 5773C?=C :25: :23 5;;A43@ <" H54 H<BJ?=C 54 5 294?;57 @A;5:?<= =4:BA;:<B ?= 545>342H5B5 ?C23B B?E5B9 ;2<<7 5=@ 574< <H=3@ 5 4:5:?<=5B9 4:<B3 5: 5D5D 5BJ3: H23B3 :23 5;;A43@ < FB3KA3=:79 >?4?:3@ 23= :23 >?;:?E0"H544:A@9?=C?="):2CB5@35:3:25=9;2<<7:23
- 5 -
5;;A43@<"?@3=:?F?3@2?E5=@25@5;<=>3B45:?<=4:5:?=C23 25@ :A:<B3@ 2?E F<77<H?=C H2?;2 23 ?=>?:3@ :23 >?;:?E :< 2?4 4:<B3 = :23 E<=:2 <F $A=3 )"/ H23= " >?4?:3@ :23 5;;A43@ <",4 4:<B3 23 ?=>?:3@ 2?E :< 5;;<E65=9 2?E :< 9@3B585@F<B6AB;254?=C<FE5:3B?574;;<B@?=C79:2398<:2 73F: F<B 9@3B585@ 3CAE 5L5B 5=@ 6AB;2543@ 4:5:?<=3B?34 F<77<H?=C :23?B 6AB;2543 :239 B3:AB=3@ :< :23 7<@C3 25@ :23?B E3574 5=@ :239 425B3@ :23 83@ 54 :239 4736: : =?C2: :23 5;;A43@ <" 3I6B3443@ 2?4 @34?B3 :< 25>3 ;5B=57 ?=:3B;<AB43 H?:2 " 5=@ :23B389 5::3E6:3@ :< @?4B<83 >?;:?E0" 2<H3>3B " B34?4:3@ 4A;2 5@>5=;34 5=@ H57J3@ <A: <F :23 B<<E 5:3B A6<= 2?4 B3:AB= :< :23 B<<E :23 5;;A43@ <" ;<=:?=A3@H?:24A;25@>5=;3423F<77<H?=C=?C2:<=;35C5?= :23 5;;A43@ <" 5::3E6:3@ :< 25>3 6294?;57 ?=:?E5;9 H?:2
" 5=@ :23B389 F<B;?879 @?4B<83@ 2?E 5=@ 25@ ;5B=57 ?=:3B;<AB43 &AB:23B :23 5;;A43@ <" :2B35:3=3@ :23 >?;:?E =<: :< @?>A7C3 :23 45E3 H?:2 5=98<@9 A843KA3=:79 5F:3B 5 75643 <F <=3 E<=:2 H23= " >?4?:3@ :23 5;;A43@ <",4 4:<B3 23 <=;3 5C5?= :<<J " :< 2?4 2<A43 5=@ 5: 58<A:
")) =<<= @?4B<83@ " 5=@ 25@ ;5B=57 ?=:3B;<AB43 H?:2 2?E A: <F F35B :23 >?;:?E @?@ =<: @?>A7C3 :23 45E3 :< 5=98<@9 5:3B ?= :23 E<=:2 <F ACA4: )"/ <= :23 @59 <F
- 6 -
=@363=@3=;3 F<77<H?=C :23 F75C 2<?4:?=C 5: :23 524?7@5B,4 <FF?;35:58<A:).()5EH23=">?4?:3@5;;A43@<",4 4:<B3:235;;A43@<5=@<:23BFB?3=@4<F5;;A43@<"H2< H3B36B343=:5::234:<B3@3;?@3@:<H5:;25E<>?35:AJ:5 235:B3 5758AB5C?
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
" :< 4E<J3 ;?C5B3::3 5=@ :23B35F:3B 5445A7:3@ 5=@ :2B35:3=3@2?E459?=C23J=3HH25::235;;A43@<"@?@:< 2?E 5: 9@3B585@ 5=@ ?= 2?4 2<A43 5=@ :23B389 F<B;3@ :23 >?;:?E:< 25>3;5B=57?=:3B;<AB43H?:2 2?E?=;3:235;;A43@
- 7 -
<574<:2B35:3=3@2?E:<=<:@?4;7<43:2345E3:<5=98<@9
"B3E5?=3@4?73=:F:3B:H<@594:23>?;:?EH54A=5873:< 3?:23B35:<BAB?=5:344A;223B3>3573@:2345?@?=;?@3=::< 2?465B3=:45=@7<@C3@5;<E675?=:83F<B3"(5463BI"
= :23 4:B3=C:2 <F I"0;<E675?=: "(0 B3C?4:3B3@ 5= &5C5?=4::235;;A43@?=B?E3<- )"/@5:3@())"/ F<B:23<FF3=;346A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=4((!)%!)/(-- B H3;:?<=(%<F5=@3;:?<=4%5=@/<F:23
;: A843KA3=::<B3C?4:B5:?<=<F5=&0"(;<=@A;:3@FAB:23B ?=>34:?C5:?<=89566B323=@?=C:235;;A43@5=@5F:3BB3;<B@?=C :23?B ><7A=:5B9 4:5:3E3=: B3;<>3B3@ :23 E<:<B8?J3 A43@ F<B ;<EE?44?<= <F ;B?E3 89 @B5H?=C 46<: 65=;25=5E50I- B373>5=: E525L5B4 5=@ B3;<B@3@ :23 4:5:3E3=:4 <F <:23B H?:=34434 " 75?@ :23 ;25BC3 4233: 83F<B3 :23 344?<=4 <AB:F<B:235F<B3E3=:?<=3@<FF3=;34
(
= :5J?=C ;<C=?L5=;3 <F :23 <FF3=;345=@ 43;AB?=C :23 6B343=;3 <F :23 5;;A43@ :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 FB5E3@ :23 ;25BC34 5C5?=4: :23 5;;A43@ F<B :23 <FF3=;34 6A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=4((!)%!)/(--B H3;:?<=(% <F3;:?<=4%5=@/<F:23
;:2345E3H54B35@ <>3B>3B85:?E:<:235;;A43@<H3>3B:235;;A43@@3=?3@:23 ;25BC345=@;75?E3@:<83:B?3@
- 8 -
% = <B@3B :< 6B<>3 :23 ;25BC34 73>3773@ 5C5?=4: :23 5;;A43@ :23 6B<43;A:?<= ;<773;:?>379 3I5E?=3@ "( H?:=34434 83F<B3 :23 344?<=4 <AB: 54 " :< "( E5BJ3@ @<;AE3=:4 54 I4" :< 5=@ ?@3=:?F?3@ E5:3B?57 <8D3;:4 54 4"5=@
! = ;<E673:?<= <F :23 6B<43;A:?<= 3>?@3=;3 :23 735B=3@344?<=4$A@C3B35@<>3B:23?=;B?E?=5:?=C3>?@3=;3<F :23 E5:3B?57 H?:=34434 :< :23 5;;A43@ 54 4:?6A75:3@ A=@3B 3;:?<=("(<FB<H3>3B:235;;A43@@3=?3@:2345E3 23 @3F3=;3 <F :23 5;;A43@ ?4 <=3 <F :<:57 @3=?57 5=@ :25: <F F5743?E67?;5:?<=<H3>3B:235;;A43@=3?:23B3I5E?=3@5=9 H?:=34434=<BE5BJ3@5=9@<;AE3=:4<=:23?B83257F
/
= 544344E3=: <F :23 <B57 5=@ @<;AE3=:5B9 3>?@3=;3 675;3@ 83F<B3 :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 ;<=>?;:3@ :23 5663775=:4 5;;A43@ F<B :23 ;25BC34 73>373@ 5C5?=4: :23E 5=@43=:3=;3@:23E544:5:3@
- 23>57?@?:95=@73C57?:9<F:23DA@CE3=:65443@89 :23735B=3@344?<=4$A@C3?4;5773@0?=F<B4;BA:?=9898<:2:23 5;;A43@ 89 H59 <F F?7?=C 4365B5:3 5663574 <B3 65B:?;A75B79 :23 5;;A43@ <" <C342 F?73@ B?E?=57 66357
- 9 -
<)))." )". 5=@ :23 5;;A43@ < 25B5=58545>5 F?73@ B?E?=5766357<))"! )". 3 25>3 235B@ :23 735B=3@ ;<A=437 B? 5=@J?42<B3 <<8 F<B :23 5663775=: ?= B7<))"! )". :23735B=3@;<A=437B?525=:342345?F<B:235663775=:?= B7<)))." )". :23 735B=3@ @@?:?<=57 :5:3 A87?;
B<43;A:<B B? ?@@57?=C 5:?7 F<B :23 B346<=@3=: <" ?= 8<:2:2356635745=@B?77AB+B?5=;2575=:<42? F<BB346<=@3=:<?=8<:2:235663574
.
23735B=3@;<A=437F<B:23B3463;:?>35663775=:?= 8<:2 :23 5663574 >323E3=:79 5BCA3@ :25: :23 DA@CE3=:
;25773=C3@ A=@3B :2343 5663574 4AFF3B4 FB<E 63B>3B4?:9 5=@ ?773C57?:9 54 :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 CB<4479 F5?73@ :< 566B3;?5:3 :23 3>?@3=;3 <= B3;<B@ ?= B?C2: 63B463;:?>3 5=@ 65443@ :23 ?E6AC=3@ DA@CE3=: 8543@ <= 4ABE?434 5=@ ;<=DA=;:AB3239FAB:23B4A8E?::3@:25::236B<43;A:?<=F5?73@ :< 6B<>3 :23 5C3 <F >?;:?E " 89 =3?:23B 675;?=C ;B3@?873 @<;AE3=:=<B895::3E6:?=C:<;<=@A;:5@?<7<C93I5E?=5:?<= 5=@<44?F?;5:?<=:34:<F>?;:?E:<@3:3BE?=32?45C3:25:23H54 5 E?=<B 5: :23 :?E3 <F ?=;?@3=: 23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 4<7379 B37?3@ <= I"-05C3 ;3B:?F?;5:3 ?44A3@ 89 ""035@
- 10 -
54:3B ?= ;<=>?;:?=C :23 5;;A43@ A=@3B :23 6B<>?4?<=4 <F :23
;:239FAB:23B;<=:3=@3@:25::23B3?45=?=<B@?=5:3 @3759<F@594?=7<@C?=C:23;<E675?=:5F:3B:23754:5773C3@ ?=;?@3=:<H3>3B5;;<B@?=C:<":23?=;?@3=:H5445?@:< 25>3<;;ABB3@<=)")/)"/5=@:23;<E675?=:H547<@C3@<= ())"/?=4A;2;?B;AE4:5=;34:23>3B4?<=<F";5==<: 83837?3>3@239574<;<=:3=@3@:25:%0A=;73<F>?;:?E5 6B5;:?;?=C 5@><;5:3 H54 5;:?>3 ?= 7<;57 6<7?:?;4 5=@ :25: :23B3 H54 ?770H?77 83:H33= :23E 6B?<B :< :23 ?=;?@3=: 54 4A;2 23 F574379?E67?;5:3@ :23435;;A43@?=:23?=;?@3=:239FAB:23B 4A8E?::3@ :25: <= 63BA457 <F 3>?@3=;3 <F :23 <;:<B0. :23B3 H3B3 =< 4A;2 ?=DAB?34 <B 4?C=4 <F ;5B=57 ?=:3B;<AB43 F<B:2;<E?=C ?= :23 B36<B: 54 63B I"( 5=@ . @?@ =<:
@36<43:<:25:3FF3;: &AB:23B :233>?@3=;3<F0F5:23B<F >?;:?E5=@4(5=@%:23;7<43B375:?>34<F:23>?;:?E;5==<: 83:5J3=?=:<;<=4?@3B5:?<=54:2395B3:2365B:?45=H?:=34434 :<:23?=;?@3=:?:2:23434A8E?44?<=4:2396B59:<577<H:23 56635745=@:<43:054?@3:23?E6AC=3@DA@CE3=:65443@89:23 344?<=4<AB:
") 3FA:?=C :23 58<>3 4A8E?44?<=4 E5@3 89 :23 735B=3@ ;<A=437 F<B :23 5663775=:4 :23 735B=3@ @@?:?<=57 ;<=:3=@3@ :25: :23 DA@CE3=: ;25773=C3@ ?= :2343 5663574
- 11 -
=3?:23B 4AFF3B4 FB<E 63B>3B4?:9 =<B ?773C57?:9 5=@ =< 3I;36:?<= ;5=83:5J3=FB<E:23DA@CE3=:65443@89:23344?<=4<AB:
F<B :23 B354<=4 544?C=3@ 89 :23 344?<=4 <AB: A=@3B 5 H3770 B354<=3@ DA@CE3=: 3 ;<=:3=@3@ :25: :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 3758<B5:379 566B3;?5:3@ :23 3>?@3=;3 <F "0>?;:?E
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
""035@54:3B5=@:23@<;AE3=:I"-05C3;3B:?F?;5:3<F :23>?;:?EH2?;2;735B793=AE3B5:34:25::23>?;:?EH54 5C3@ 837<H"/935B45::23:?E3<F?=;?@3=:3FAB:23B;<=:3=@3@ :25:4:<%0235B459H?:=34434:<:23?=;?@3=:83F<B3H2<E
- 12 -
:23>?;:?E=5BB5:3@:23?=;?@3=:F<77<H?=CH2?;2:2397<@C3@5 ;<E675?=:=4A;2;?B;AE4:5=;34:23B3?4=<B354<=:<@?4;5B@ :23 3>?@3=;3 <F :23 >?;:?E 5=@ :23 3>?@3=;3 <F 4 :< % ;;<B@?=C79 :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 254 @A79 566B3;?5:3@ :23 3>?@3=;3 <= B3;<B@ 5=@ ;<=>?;:3@ :23 5;;A43@ F<B :23 ;25BC3473>373@5C5?=4::23E5=@=<?=:3BF3B3=;3?4H5BB5=:3@ ?=:23?E6AC=3@DA@CE3=:;;<B@?=C79236B594:<@?4E?44:23 5663574
"" 23735B=3@;<A=437F<B:23B346<=@3=:<5@<6:4 :23 4A8E?44?<= E5@3 89 :23 735B=3@ @@7 F<B :23 B346<=@3=:0:5:3
" 5>?=C235B@:23735B=3@;<A=437F<B:23B3463;:?>3 65B:?34 5=@ <= 63BA457 <F :23 3=:?B3 3>?@3=;3 <= B3;<B@ ?=;7A@?=C :23 ?E6AC=3@ DA@CE3=: 65443@ 89 :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4$A@C3:236<?=:4:25:5B?43F<B<AB;<=4?@3B5:?<=5B3
!""#
$%&
'() &
(*)*
+
,
!""#
!,!
'()
-
(*)*
+
- 13 -
"( =<B@3B:<8B?=C2<E3:23CA?7:<F:235;;A43@:23 6B<43;A:?<=2546B3@<E?=5=:79B37?3@<=:233>?@3=;3<F"0 >?;:?E4:<%0:23F5:23B5=@;7<43B375:?>34<F":23 E3@?;573>?@3=;3<F.0<;:<B5=@""035@54:3BH2< ?44A3@:235C3;3B:?F?;5:3<F:23>?;:?E =;5B3FA75=5794?4<F 3>?@3=;3<F"23254;5:3C<B?;5779@36<43@:25:?=:23935B )"/:235;;A43@<"54J3@2?E:<>?4?:2?44:<B34:5:?=C:25:
23 :A:<B3@ 2?E ?= 2?4 %:2 5=@ !:2 CB5@3 23B35F:3B ?= :23 E<=:2 <F $A=3 )"/ 23 :<<J " :< 9@3B585@ A=@3B :23 6B3:3I: <F 6AB;254?=C E5:3B?574 F<B 2?4 4:<B3 F:3B 4A;2 6AB;2543:235;;A43@<"F<B;?87925@;5B=57?=:3B;<AB43H?:2
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
- 14 -
5=@5;;A43@<"0F5:23B<F:23>?;:?E5=@%0A=;73<F :23 >?;:?E 574< B3?:3B5:3@ :23 3>?@3=;3 <F 4" 5=@ ( = ;5B3FA73I5E?=5:?<=<F:233>?@3=;3<F4":<%5783?::23B3 ?4@3759?=7<@C?=C:23;<E675?=:2<H3>3B:23B3?4=<B354<= :<@?4;5B@:23?B3>?@3=;354F5B54:235;:<F;5B=57?=:3B;<AB43 ;<EE?::3@89:235;;A43@<="
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
- 15 -
4A;25A:23=:?;5:3@@<;AE3=:7?J38?B:2;3B:?F?;5:3675;3@89:23 6B<43;A:?<= ?= ?:4 3>?@3=;3 <B ?= :23 ;25BC3 4233: E5:3B?574 I;36: I"- 584<7A:379 =< <:23B ;B3@?873 @<;AE3=:4 H3B3 675;3@ 89 :23 6B<43;A:?<= :< 6B<>3 :23 5C3 <F >?;:?E :25: 23 H545E?=<B5::23:?E3<F?=;?@3=:=4A;2;?B;AE4:5=;34:23 ?>?4?<= 3=;2 <F :2?4 <AB: ?= B?E?=57 66357 <))"). )"% @5:3@ )!"")% 237@ B3C5B@?=C @3:3BE?=5:?<=<F:235C3<F:23>?;:?E5:65B5CB562<4%)5=@ %"54A=@3B
. +
#
/
0
0
/ 1 /
2 +3
)
4#
5,%! "
)) ,&!6
,! /7
.,! 8
9
,
/ /#
/ /
# /
:#
/#
#
/
/ /# /
2 #
# /
9
,
,%%"
9#
3
; #
(
&
2
3
<
! 9
,
3 = #
- 16 -
9
,! '#
9
,!# 3
#
3 >
2
/
'
9
,!# >
' # #
*
#
9
,! '
#
#
*
#
9
,! ? #
#
/
1
#
/
'
# 9 ,! #
@
=
9
,
9#
/7
., (
/
+A B33
! '
/ /#
>
- 17 -
C
#
# )
1 A
> #
D
/ D
D / D
D@
"!
= 63BA457 <F :23 58<>3 DA@CE3=: 65443@ 89 :23 ?>?4?<= 3=;2 <F :2?4 <AB: ?: ?4 B375:?>379 ;735B :25: 54 63B A73"<F:23$A>3=?73$A4:?;3A734?=<B@3B:<6B<>3:235C3 <F :23 ;2?7@ <B DA>3=?73 :23 6B<;3@AB3 :< 83 F<77<H3@ 5=@ :23 @<;AE3=:4:<83B37?3@89:236B<43;A:?<=5B3:23E5:B?;A75:?<= <B3KA?>573=:;3B:?F?;5:34?F5>5?75873?=:235843=;3:23@5:3<F 8?B:2;3B:?F?;5:3FB<E:234;2<<7<:23B:25=56594;2<<7F?B4:
5::3=@3@ 5=@ ?= :23 5843=;3 :23 8?B:2 ;3B:?F?;5:3 C?>3= 89 5 <B6<B5:?<= <B 5 A=?;?657 A:2<B?:9 <B 5 5=;2595: 3=;3 ;<=4?@3B?=C :23 58<>3 5463;: H3 5B3 <F :23 ;<=4?@3B3@ >?3H :25::236B<43;A:?<=574<F5?73@:<6B<>3:25::23>?;:?EH545 E?=<B54<=:23@5:3<F?=;?@3=:
- 18 -
"/ &AB:23B :23 <=,873 63I <AB: ?= :23 ;543 <F
! " #$237@?=65B5CB5624<":<"/54A=@3B
M
'
/
!- (*)*
+# E- +#
,%$
# 2 3
/7
.E-
( < #
) C#
+
# )
C
/
> -
!&#
#
/ /
,
'
# ) C
/
#
) C# #
1 # 1
0
# >
3 C#
D
D
D
#
- 19 -
) C7
(
)
C
/
! 2
)
C
#
+#
@
! '
/
/
3
(*)*
+#
1
E- +
2
/
+
>
/
7
. # >
3 C#
D
D
D
#
) C@
E-,
+
>
- 20 -
3
/
)
F + (
. @ . @
#
)
C
)
'
#
#
>
/
83
)# #
/
%"EE"
#
/
/#
#
) <
2 /
/ D #
1 /
:
#
G <!# 9
* G
2
EE"
/
/
E-,
/ #
83
)<
F
/
/
H
%
'
#
9
1
= ( #!
/ / >
2 / / 9
, /
9
/
/
E- +# /7
.,%
9
, 9#
,%%" /
/ 2
/ /
#
#
C
- 21 -
>
) C
/
1 7
>
#
/ D
D
/ D
*
# #
F C
'
/ /
/
#
/
/
@
$
1
+#
E-,
+#
I
J
2 = (
7
.)
E-,
>
3
'
#
'
E-,
/
/ 9
,! 9
,%%"
+
,%%% = 9 ,! > /
/
- 22 -
# '
E-,
/
>
@
"- C5?=4: :2?4 85;J@B<6 56679?=C :23 F?=@?=C4 <F :23 <=,873 63I <AB: ?= :23 58<>3 DA@CE3=: :< :23 F5;:4 5=@ ;?B;AE4:5=;34<F:2?4;543H35B3<F:23;<=4?@3B3@>?3H:25: :236B<43;A:?<=254F5?73@:<675;35=94A;2;B3@?873@<;AE3=:4 :<6B<>3:235C3<F:23>?;:?E:25:23H545E?=<B5::23:?E3 <F?=;?@3=:=4A;2;?B;AE4:5=;34:2<AC2:236B<43;A:?<=254 4A;;344FA7796B<>3@:235;:<F;5B=57?=:3B;<AB43;<EE?::3@89 :235;;A43@<=":2345?@5;:<F:235;;A43@4KA5B379F5774 H?:2?=:235E8?:<F3;:?<=(--<F?=4:35@<F3;:?<=4%5=@ / <F :23
;: = <B@3B :< 5::B5;: :23 6B<>?4?<=4 <F 3;:?<= % 5=@ / <F
;: :23 >?;:?E EA4: 83 5;2?7@ 54 @3F?=3@A=@3B3;:?<=@<F:235;:?3837<H:235C3<F" 935B4 >3= <= ;5B3FA7 63BA457 <F :23 ?E6AC=3@ DA@CE3=: 65443@89:23344?<=4<AB::23735B=3@344?<=4DA@C3254 574<F5?73@:<C?>34A;2F?=@?=C4B3C5B@?=C:235C3<F:23>?;:?E :25: 23 H54 5 E?=<B 5: :23 :?E3 <F ?=;?@3=: 3=;3 ?= <AB >?3H :23 ;<=>?;:?<= 5=@ 43=:3=;3 ?E6<43@ 89 :23 344?<=4 <AB:F<B:23<FF3=;346A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=4%5=@/<F:23
;: =33@4 ?=:3BF3B3=;3 5=@ ?4 7?5873 :< 83 43:054?@3
- 23 -
<H3>3B <= 63BA457 <F 3>?@3=;3 <F " 4 :< % 5=@ .0<;:<B H3 5B3 <F :23 ;<=4?@3B3@ >?3H :25: :23 6B<43;A:?<=2544A;;344FA7796B<>3@5=@34:587?423@:23CA?7:<F :23 5;;A43@ F<B :23 <FF3=;34 6A=?425873 A=@3B 3;:?<=4 (-- ((5=@!)/<F<H3>3B:23735B=3@344?<=4$A@C3254 43=:3=;3@ :23 5;;A43@ F<B 7?F3 ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B :23 <FF3=;3 6A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=(--236A=?42E3=:@3F?=3@A=@3B 3;:?<= (-- <F ?4 G:23 ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B 7?F3 <B H?:2 ?E6B?4<=E3=:<F3?:23B@34;B?6:?<=F<B5:3BEH2?;2E593I:3=@ :<:3=935B45=@42577574<837?5873:<F?=3,=:2?4;5434?=;3 8<:2:235;;A43@5B3?=?=;5B;3B5:?<=F<B563B?<@<F935B4/ E<=:2454<=@5:3H35B3<F:23>?3H:25:?:?44AFF?;?3=::< 43=:3=;3 :23 5;;A43@ F<B :23 63B?<@ :239 25>3 57B35@9 A=@3BC<=3F<B:23<FF3=;36A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=(--<F 89?E6<4?=CB354<=5873F?=35E<A=:
" = :25: >?3H <F :23 E5::3B ?=:3BF3B3=;3 ?= :23 ?E6AC=3@ DA@CE3=: ?4 ;5773@ F<B 5=@ 5;;<B@?=C79 H3 5=4H3B <?=:<"?=:23=3C5:?>35=@<?=:<?=65B:795FF?BE5:?>3 5=@6B<;33@:<6544:23F<77<H?=C
? 23B?E?=576635745B3&& '
- 24 -
?? 23 DA@CE3=: <F ;<=>?;:?<= 5=@ <B@3B <F 43=:3=;3 @5:3@ )/)-)". 65443@ ?= 63;?57 543
<!! )"/ 89 :23 <AB: <F @@?:?<=57 344?<=4 $A@C3 5758AB5C? ?4 43:054?@3 F<B :23 <FF3=;34 6A=?425873 A=@3B 3;:?<=4/5=@%<F:23
;:)"
???
235663775=:4 5;;A43@<"5=@5B35;KA?::3@ F<B:23<FF3=;346A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=4/5=@ %<F:23
;:)"B3463;:?>379
?> 23 ;<=>?;:?<= 5=@ 43=:3=;3 ?E6<43@ 89 :23 344?<=4$A@C3F<B:23<FF3=;36A=?425873A=@3B 3;:?<=(--<F?4E<@?F?3@235;;A43@5B3 43=:3=;3@F<B563B?<@H2?;2:23925>357B35@9 A=@3BC<=3?3935B4/E<=:245=@:23942577 659 5 F?=3 <F 4"))))) 0 35;2 A6334 =3 5J2 <=79 83F<B3 :23 344?<=4 <AB: 5=@ ?= @3F5A7: <F 659E3=: <F F?=3 :239 42577 A=@3BC< 4?E673 ?E6B?4<=E3=: F<B 5 63B?<@ <F :H< 935B4 F<B:23<FF3=;36A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=(--<F
> F :23 F?=3 5E<A=: ?4 @36<4?:3@ 89 :23 5;;A43@ :23 735B=3@ 344?<=4 $A@C3 ?4 @?B3;:3@ :< =<:?F9 5=@@?48AB43:2345E3:<"54;<E63=45:?<= 4:?6A75:3@A=@3B3;:?<=(!-"<FB<=@A3 ?@3=:?F?;5:?<= 23 8575=;3 5E<A=: 42577 83 4A8E?::3@:<:23:5:3B354AB9
- 25 -
>? 2343=:3=;3?E6<43@89:23344?<=4<AB:F<B :23<FF3=;346A=?425873A=@3B3;:?<=4((5=@ !)/<F5C5?=4:5;;A43@5B3J36:?=:5;:
>?? 77:2343=:3=;3442577BA=;<=;ABB3=:79
>??? 235;;A43@4257783B373543@<=659E3=:<FF?=3 5E<A=: 54 58<>3 <B 42577 A=@3BC< :23 @3F5A7: 43=:3=;3
?I 3C?4:B9?4@?B3;:3@:<43=@85;J:23B?57<AB: B3;<B@457<=CH?:2;<69<F:2?4DA@CE3=::<:23 B?57<AB:F<B:2H?:2
-+
&
%* $
-+
&$ * $
?4:<"7<(%