Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10754 (KAR)

KALLAPPA v. MALAKAJAPPA AND ORS

WP/201679/2024 · 2025-01-24

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#!# '& ( ! " #$%&" & '( #$%&" ' #$%&" Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ' ' #$%!"& % # #$%!"& ( % #$%!! $ " #$%!! ) ' #$%!! - 3 - !" #$%!! !! ' #$%&" !& $" #$%!! ! ' #$!! !' '( #$%&!' ! * ' #$%&!' !% '& - 4 - #$%&!' &'"!&"& % ++ +! , & ') !&!% + &&(+ + + "'"%&"&' + *&&"!! *# + - - . /01234564778!7 458&&"!!105945:6;432 <078;0 6/0 4=42 >9:0 359 + 3?3=353 3:0@394 4A3B31>;3 /05C078;6/ ;070;;09 68 3? D;432 8>;6E 4? <078;0 6/4? 8>;6 C/32205:45: 6/0 C8;;0C650?? 87 35 8;90; 93609 "'"%&"&' <B@/4C/ 35 31124C36485 8* 74209 <B /4F >590; ;90; >20 !( 87 6/0 890 87 4=42 ;8C09>;0 !)"$ /05C078;6/ ;070;;09 68 3? DE @3? ;0A0C609 - 5 - & 4 ?>46 45 8&&"!! @3? 74209 78; 90C23;36485 87 64620 359 78; 10;106>32 45A>5C6485 359 78; F359368;B 45A>5C6485 68 94;0C6 6/0 907059356? 68 ;0F8=0 6/0 C85?6;>C6485 1>6 >1 <B 6/0F <B 05C;83C/45: 4568 6/0 ?>461;810;6B 44 /0?>46@3?C8560?609<B6/09070593568?! '359% @/89054096/0C234F876/0123456477359 32?8 905409 6/36 6/0 123456477 @3? 05646209 68 6/0 ;02407? ?8>:/678; 444 3?09 85 6/0?0 C856056485? 6/0 ;432 8>;6 7;3F09 4??>0? 359 ?06 98@5 6/0 C3?0 78; 6;432 760; 6/0 0=4905C0 @3? 399>C09 359 6/0 C3?0 @3? ?06 98@5 78; 3;:>F056? 359 36 6/0 ?63:0 87 ;012B 3;:>F056? 87 6/0 907059356? 3531124C36485@3?74209<B1234564778!7 68 3F059 6/0 123456 68 45C8;18;360 6/0 3;03 05C;83C/09 <B 6/0907059356? 4= /0 ?349 31124C36485 @3? C8560?609 <B 6/0 907059356? 3596/0 ;4328>;6 4560;F? 876/0 4F1>:509 8;90;;0A0C6096/0?34931124C364851;4F3;42B856/0:;8>59 - 6 - 6/36 6/0 31124C36485 @3? <023609 359 74209 36 6/0 ?63:0 @/056/0?>46@3??0698@578;907059356?E3;:>F056? 045: 3::;40=09 <B 6/0 ?349 8;90; 123456477 8!7 4?<078;06/4?8>;6456/4?@;4610646485 ' /0 203;509 C8>5?02 78; 123456477 8!7 C856059? 6/36 6/0 123456477 /39 F05648509 6/36 6/0 907059356? /39 05C;83C/09 4568 6/0 ?>46 1;810;6B 6/36 F03?>;09 8;6/ 68 8>6/ G ' 7006 359 6/0;078;0 6/0 0H6056 87 2359 F03?>;45: 3?6 68 0?6 /39 68 <0 F05648509 /0 ?><F46? 6/36 6/0 123456477 8!7 6/0;078;0 ?8>:/6 78; 35 3F059F056 @/4C/ @3? =0;B 4558C>8>? 359 @3? ;020=356 78; 6/0 1>;18?0 87 90C4945: 6/0 94?1>60 <06@005 6/0 13;640? /0 C856059? 6/36 6/4? 9070C6C8>29586<05864C09>56426/0C3?0@3??0698@578; 3;:>F056? /0;0?1859056? 6/8>:/?0;=09@46/6/05864C0 87 6/4? 10646485 /3=0 586 31103;09 359 6/0;078;0 6/4? 8>;6949586/3=06/0<050746876/04;?><F4??485? - 7 - % /3=0C85?490;096/0?><F4??485?F390<B6/0 203;509C8>5?0278;1234564778!7 ( /0;4328>;6/3?5864C096/366/031124C36485 4?74209<0236092B 6/36688@/056/0C3?0@3??0698@578; 3;:>F056?876/0907059356?/08>;6/3?32?85864C09 6/36 6/0 123456477 8!7 /3? 74209 F35B 31124C36485? 78; 3F059F056 /0;078;0 6/0 C859>C6 87 6/0 123456477 8!7 ?/8@? 6/36 /0 980? 586 @356 6/0 2464:36485 68 <0 ;0?82=0958;9453;BC4;C>F?635C0? 6/4?8>;6@8>29586 /3=0?/8@535B205405CB8@0=0; 456/01;0?056C3?0 46 31103;?6/366/01234564778!7 456059?68C23;47B6/366/0 3;0305C;83C/094568<B6/0907059356?F03?>;0958;6/68 ?8>6/ G ' 7006 359 03?6 68 @0?6 G &$ 7006 /4? @3? 907454602B 35 4558C>8>? 3F059F056 ?8>:/6 78; <B 6/0 123456477 8!7 359 6/0;078;0 6/0 ;432 8>;6 8>:/6 68 /3=0 3228@09 6/4? 31124C36485 ?8 3? 68 24I>49360 35B :;8>59? 6/36 6/0 20:32 ;01;0?056364=0? 87 6/0 90C03?09 # 123456477F3B>;:04535B3110326/36F3B<074209<B6/0F <078;06/0/4:/0;8>;6 /0203;509C8>5?0278;123456477 - 8 - 8!7 /3??><F466096/361234564778!7 @8>295862039 35B 7>;6/0; 0=4905C0 85 6/0 3F059F056 ?8>:/6 78; 5 =40@876/03<8=0 6/4?@;4610646485C8>29<094?18?09877 <B 10;F46645: 123456477 8!7 68 3F059 6/0 123456 3? ?8>:/6 78; 45 6/0 31124C36485 78; 3F059F056 ?><A0C6 /8@0=0; 68 13BF056 87 C8?6 359 32?8 ?><A0C6 68 6/0 C859464856/361234564778!7 ?/322586203935B0=4905C0 $ 5=40@876/03<8=0 6/078228@45: 4 /4?@;46106464854? 44 /0 4F1>:509 8;90; 93609 "'"%&"&' 13??09 <B 6/0 4=42 >9:0 359 + 3?3=353 3:0@394 4A3B31>;3 45 8&&"!!4??063?490 444 /0 31124C36485 * 74209 <B 6/0 123456477 8!7 >590; ;90; >20 !( 87 4? 3228@09 359 123456477 8!7 4? 10;F46609 68 3F0596/0123456?><A0C66813BF05687C8?6 87 ?!" """# >100? 05 /8>?359 852B - 9 - 13B3<20<B/4F686/0907059356?<078;06/0 ;4328>;6856/050H6936087/03;45: 4= /0 123456477 8!7 ?/322 586 2039 35B 0=4905C0856/03F059F056 = /0;4328>;6?/3225867;3F035B3994648532 4??>0<>6?/3221;8C0096894?18?08776/0?>46 453CC8;935C0@46/23@ =4 3=45:;0:3;9686/073C66/366/0?>464?74209 456/0B03;&"!! 6/0;4328>;64?;0I>0?609 68C85?490;35994?18?08776/0?>463?03;2B 3?18??4<20 3?1;8=4909>590;6/03;5363J3 3?0 +28@ 353:0F056 45 ><8;945360 8>;6? >20? &"" !)* '#( # 4?68-!28-&