Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10747 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER v. BANDAGISAB
WP/203353/2019 · 2025-01-21
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10747 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10747 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#"$
%&#!#
' !(
!"#$#
% & ''
''( &
&
'$'$#)
('$#"
*
&&
&
&
+, %
-
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
./0/121234/5.678.699/4:/;1./35;/5;61/;'$'$#) 0677/; <= 1./ 6<3>5
3>51 2?6=60>56 24 0092861234
3('$#">4;/5/81234@@
'3A1./4;>715269;270>1/781 #)(./5/246A1/55/A/55/;1367+1./81#)(
' ./5/7034;/41B.3B67/C093=/;676;52D/524 0/121234/5
3503561234 B67 ;27C277/; A53C 7/5D28/ 34 @$$"'$$ ./ 5/7034;/41 1./4 2421261/; 1./ 0538//;24:7 </A35/ 1./ 6<3>5
3>51 24 3##'$$! ./ 6<3>5 3>51241/5C73A21735;/5;61/;''$!'$$)7/1672;/1./35;/5 3A ;27C27769 64; ;25/81/; 1./ 0/121234/5 13 5/247161/ 1./ 5/7034;/41 2413 7/5D28/ B21. 834124>21= 3A 7/5D28/ 64; 31./5 8347/E>/41269 </4/A217 3B/D/5 1./ 056=/5 A35 <68F B6:/7 B67 5/?/81/; ./ 0/121234/5 1./4 8.699/4:/; 1./ 762; 35;/5 0677/;<=1./6<3>5
3>5124% 3"'''$#$.27
3>51 24 1/5C7 3A 1./ 35;/5 ;61/; '!$'$#! ;27C277/; 1./ B521 0/121234 &3993B24: 1.27 5/7034;/41 A29/; 64 60092861234 >4;/5 /81234 @@
' 3A 1./ 81 #)( 24 0092861234 3('$#" 7//F24: A35 ;25/81234 13 1./ 0/121234/5 13 06= 6 7>C 3A 7#)'"$#) B21. 241/5/71 61 1./ 561/ 3A #"G 06 </24:
B6:/7 06=6<9/ A53C 1./ ;61/ 3A 1./ 35;/5 0677/; 24 1./ B521
- 3 -
0/121234 5/A/55/; 6<3D/ 1299 217 5/692H61234 ./ 0/121234/5 8341/71/; 1./ 762; 60092861234 64; 8962C/; 1.61 1./ 0/121234/5 .6;B534:9=8962C/;1./B6:/73A7#)'"$#) 18341/4;/;
1.61 5/7034;/41 27 349= /41219/; 13 6 7>C 3A 7#)!$( A53C B.28. 7161>135= ;/;>81234 3A 7'#()!$ .6; 13 </ /AA/81/;
347/E>/419=218962C/;1.615/7034;/41B67/41219/;
1367>C3A7#(@"##( ./6<3>5
3>516A1/583472;/524: 1./6A35/762;3<?/8123470677/;1./2C0>:4/;35;/5;25/8124:
1./0/121234/51306=67>C3A7#(@"##( B21.24@C341.7 A62924: B.28. 21 ;25/81/; 1./ 0/121234/5 13 06= 241/5/71 61 1./ 561/ 3A )G 06 /24: 6::52/D/; <= 1./ 76C/ 0/121234/5 27 </A35/1.27
3>51
@ /654/; 83>47/9 A35 1./ 0/121234/5 8341/4;7 1.61 5/7034;/41 B67 /41219/; 13 8962C #( B6:/7 <= C6F24:
6005305261/ 60092861234 24 1./ B521 0/121234 5/A/55/; 6<3D/ / 7><C2171.611./5/7034;/41;2;431C6F/64=7>8.611/C0167 ./B67695/6;=/C093=/;64;./48/./83>9;431.6D/A29/;64 6AA2;6D21 ;/896524: 1.61 ./ 27 431 /C093=/; /97/B./5/ ./ 8341/4;71.611./5/7034;/4127431/41219/;1364=<68FB6:/7 64; 1./ 35;/5 0677/; <= 1./ 6<3>5
3>51 5/24716124: 1./ 0/121234/5 2413 7/5D28/ 27 248355/81 /72;/7 1.27 ./ 8341/4;7
- 4 -
1.615/7034;/41;2;4315/0351131./;>1=64;./48/./27431 /41219/;1364=B6:/7
/654/; 83>47/9 A35 5/7034;/41 .3B/D/5 34 1./ 31./5.64;8341/4;/;1.611./0/121234/5.6;3<1624/;6435;/5 3A716=3A1./35;/53A5/247161/C/413A5/7034;/41/7><C217 1.61 67 6 5/7>91 5/7034;/41 83>9; 431 5/0351 13 ;>1= 64; ./ 5/125/; A53C 7/5D28/ 34 @$$'$#! / 8341/4;7 1.61 6A1/5 ;27C277693A1./B5210/1212345/7034;/41B67/41219/;13B6:/7 1.61./B3>9;.6D//654/;2A1./0/121234/5.6;5/247161/;1./ 5/7034;/4124137/5D28/
! .6D/ 83472;/5/; 1./ 7><C2772347 3A 9/654/; 83>47/9A351./0/121234/564;9/654/;83>47/9A355/7034;/41
./ 6B65; 0677/; <= 1./ 63>5
3>51 ;61/;
''$!'$$) 7.3B7 1.61 1./ 35;/5 3A ;27C27769 3A 5/7034;/41 A53C 7/5D28/ B67 7/1 672;/ 64; 1./ 0/121234/5 B67 ;25/81/; 13 5/247161/ 1./ 7/5D28/7 3A 1./ 0/121234/5 B21.
699 </4/A217 64;
834124>21= 3A 7/5D28/ 3B/D/5 1./ 8962C A35 <68F B6:/7 B67 5/?/81/; .27 35;/5 B67 8.699/4:/; 24 % 3"'''$#$ ./5/A35/ 5/7034;/41 B67 05/D/41/; A53C 5/035124: <68F 13 ;>1= ./ B521 0/121234 5/A/55/; 6<3D/ B67 ;27C277/; <= 1.27
- 5 -
3>5134'!$'$#!<>11./5/7034;/415/125/;A53C7/5D28/ 34 @$$'$#! ./5/A35/ 1./ 0/121234/5 .6; 7>88/77A>99= /47>5/; 1.61 1./ 5/7034;/41 ;2; 431 5/0351 13 ;>1= A53C 1./ ;61/ 3A 35;/5 3A 5/247161/C/41 <= 1./ 6<3>5
3>51 1299 1./ ;27C27769 3A 1./ B521 0/121234 A29/; </A35/ 1.27
3>51 ./ 5/7034;/41 B67 ;/052D/; 3A 1./ B6:/7 1299 1.27 0/523; 64;
./48/ 5/7034;/41 B67 ?>712A2/; 24 242126124: 1./ 0538//;24:7 >4;/5/81234@@
'3A1./81#)(
( 1 27 7//4 A53C 1./ 2C0>:4/; 35;/5 1.61 1./ 0/121234/5 217/9A .6;C6;/ 6 7161/C/41</A35/1./6<3>5 3>51 1.61 1./ 5/7034;/41 27 /41219/; 13 6 7>C 3A 7#(@"##( 6A1/5 ;/;>8124: 6 7>C 3A 7'#()!$ 13B65;77161>135=;/;>812347./5/A35/1./6<3>5
3>51 B67 ?>712A2/; 24 ;25/8124: 1./ 0/121234/5 13 06= 6 7>C 3A 7#(@"##( B21.241.5// C341.7 A53C 1./ ;61/ 3A 1./ 35;/5./5/A35/1./5/2743/5535241./2C0>:4/;35;/5 B65564124:241/5A/5/48/241.27B5210/121234
" /48/ 1./ 0/121234 27 ./ 0/121234/5 27 ;25/81/; 13 83C09= B21. 1./ 35;/5 ;61/;
- 6 -
'$'$#)0677/;<=1./5/72;24: AA28/56<3>5
3>51 2?6=60>56 24 0092861234 3('$#" 24 9/11/5 64; 702521 B21.2460/523;3A34/C341.A53C13;6=A62924:B.28.1./ 5/7034;/41276192</51=1316F/7>8.71/076765/6D6296<9/ 2496B
!)*
'#( #
I0656#13 I0656(J"
# $