Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10732 (KAR)

ANJALAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200113/2018 · 2025-01-27

S Vishwajith Shetty

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #!$ %! # && '(')&*+('** % ! " # $ % $ $ $ $ $ % $#& ''' ! $ % #( " Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % )* !" % $ + $ $$ % ##&)&# $ *#&#) $ % $$ $ % %$ $ + $ $ ,$+$$ !# !$ ,$+$$" -./01120345627289.:5)*!":;7./;.326<= 9-20884/260//0.3.5>9-2?46>@259056:7627:;8:5A.89.:5 056 /2592582 60926 ##&)&# 10//26 <= 9-2 :479 :; 66.9.:503 2//.:5/ 46>2 030<470>. .5 128.03 0/2 :*#&#) $20769-232075268:45/23;:79-21079.2/ 11233059 -272.5 B0/ 8-07>2 /-22926 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582/ 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5/ ** &* * :; 56.05 2503 :62 !-272.50;927 72;27726 0/ CD" 056 - 3 - 289.:5:; 89 &#0560;927011207.5><2;:72 9-27.03:479.59-2/0.680/2 011233059-06830.@269: <2 97.26 -2 17:/2849.:5 .5 :7627 9: /4</9059.092 .9/ 0332>09.:5/0>0.5/99-2011233059-062E0@.526#&8-07>2 /-229 B.952//2/ 0/ +# 9: +#& 056 >:9 @07F26 G 6:84@259/ 0/ E# 9: G ;927 9-2 2A.62582 :; 9-2 17:/2849.:5 B0/ 83:/26 9-2 /9092@259 :; 9-2 0112330590884/26 B0/ 728:7626 45627 289.:5 # :; 7$:B2A27 5:62;25822A.62582B0/326:5<2-03; :; 9-2 011233059 5:7 05= 6:84@259 B0/ >:9 @07F26 .5 /411:79:;9-262;2582 * -2 7.03 :479 0;927 -207.5> 9-2 07>4@259/ 06672//26 :5 <:9- /.62/ <= .@14>526 ?46>@259 056 :7627 :; 8:5A.89.:5 8:5A.8926 9-2 011233059 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582/ 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5/ ** &* * :; 056 289.:5 :; 89 &# 056 /25925826 9-2 0112330599:45627>:/.@132.@17./:5@259;:70127.:6:; :52 =207 056 10= ;.52 :; /# &&&H ;:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 ** :; 056 .5 62;0439 9: 45627>: /.@132 .@17./:5@259 ;:7 ;479-27 127.:6 :; - 4 - @:59-/%:79-2:;;2582145./-0<3245627289.:5&*:; 9-2 011233059 B0/ /25925826 9: 45627>: /.@132 .@17./:5@259 ;:7 0 127.:6 :; =207/ 056 10= ;.52 :; / &&&H 056 .5 62;0439 9: 45627>: /.@132 .@17./:5@259 ;:7 0 ;479-27 127.:6 :; I @:59-/ ;:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 * :; 056 45627 289.:5 :; 89 9-2 011233059 B0/ /25925826 9: 45627>:7.>:7:4/.@17./:5@259;:70127.:6:;*=207/056 10=;.52:;/# && &&&H056.562;04399:45627>:/.@132 .@17./:5@259 ;:7 0 ;479-27 127.:6 :; :52 =207 2.5> 0>>7.2A26 <= 9-2 ?46>@259 056 :7627 :; 8:5A.89.:5 056 /259258210//26<=9-27.03:479 9-2011233059./<2;:72 9-./:479 207526 8:45/23 ;:7 9-2 011233059 -0A.5> 72.9270926 9-2>7:456/47>26 .59-2 011203 @2@:70564@ /4<@.9/9-099-272./0</:34923=5:@0927.030/0>0.5/99-2 011233059 B-.8- B:436 0997089 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5*:;056:;;2582145./-0<3245627289.:5 :;9-2 89 &#$2/4<@.9/9-099-2720723:9:; .@17:A2@259/ @062 <= 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 .5 -27 /9092@259 - 5 - 9-09B0/728:762645627289.:5#I*:;7 05603/: 647.5>9-28:47/2:;-276./1:/.9.:5<2;:729-27.03:479 0/+#-:4>- 9-272./050332>09.:5:;/2E4030//0439 0>0.5/99-2011233059 456./149263= 9-2A.89.@>.73B0/5:9 2E0@.526 @26.8033= ;:7 9-2 0332>26 /2E403 0//0439 056 .5 9-2 B:456 8279.;.8092 09 EG .9 ./ ;:456 9-09 /-2 B0/ 2E0@.526<=9-26:89:7:53=B.9-050332>09.:5:;0//0439 :5-27:5&&#&#G$2/4<@.9/9-099-:4>-9-272072 @05=-:4/2/B-2729-20332>26.58.6259-0690F2513082 5:52:;9-252.>-<:4727/-20769-2A.89.@>.73/-:49.5>0/ /90926<=-27.5-27/9092@259728:762645627289.:5#I* :; 7 056 03/: 647.5> 9-2 8:47/2 :; -27 621:/.9.:5 88:76.5>3= -2170=/9:033:B9-2011203 I 27 8:5970 3207526 $.>- :479 :A275@259 320627-0/:11:/269-2170=27@062.59-2011203$2 /4<@.9/9-09A.89.@>.73-0/@062832070332>09.:5/0>0.5/9 9-2 011233059 B-.8- B:436 0997089 9-2 8-07>2 /-22926 :;;2582/0/0>0.5/9-.@-27.03:4790;927011728.09.5> 9-2:7030566:84@25907=2A.62582130826:5728:76 -0/ 7.>-93=8:5A.89269-2011233059;:79-20332>26:;;2582/056 - 6 - 2A25 9-2 /2592582 .@1:/26 :5 -.@ ./ ?4/9 056 17:127 88:76.5>3= -2170=/9:6./@.//9-2011203 ) -2 17:/2849.:5 .5 :7627 9: 17:A2 .9/ 8-07>2/ 0>0.5/9 9-2 011233059 -0/ 2E0@.526 #& 8-07>2 /-229 B.952//2/0/+#9:+#&+#./9-2A.89.@>.73 + ./ 9-2 >7056 @:9-27 :; 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 B-: B0/ 9-2 84/9:6.05 :; 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 + ./ 9-2 @:9-27 :; 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 +* ./ 9-2 52.>-<:47 :; + + ./ 9-2 1058-0 9: /1:9 @0-0J07 056 +I ./ 9-2 058-0=09 2A23:1@259 ;;.827:;?47./6.89.:503 70@058-0=09 B-: -0/ .//426 8279.;.8092 09 E B-.8- /-:B/ 9-09 9-2 -:4/2.5B-.8-.58.6259-0690F2513082/9::6.59-250@2 :; + +) ./ 9-2 ?45.:7 25>.5227 B-:-0/17210726 9-2 /1:9 /F298- 0/ 127 EI 056 + ./ 9-2 9208-27 B-:-0/.//4269-28279.;.8092E)72>076.5>9-26092:; <.79- :; 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 +G ./ 9-2 :3.82 4<H5/1289:7 B-:-0/72>./927269-2%056.5A2/9.>09269-280/2056 +#&./9-26:89:7 B-:-0/.//4269-2B:4568279.;.8092 EG - 7 - -2 ;.7/9 .5;:7@09.:5 ./ @07F26 0/ E# 056 E ./ 9-2 /9092@259 :; 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 728:7626 45627 289.:5#I*:;7E./9-21-:9::;9-2/1:9:; .58.6259 E* ./ 9-2 /1:9 1058-050@0 E ./ 9-2 8279.;.8092 .//426 <= 058-0=09 2A23:1@259 ;;.827 B.9- 72>0769:9-217:1279=:;+ EI./9-2/1:9/F298- E)./9-2256:7/2@259.//426<=/8-::3B.9-72>0769: 9-26092:;<.79-:;9-2A.89.@>.73 E./9-2%.59-2 172/259 80/2 056 EG ./ 9-2 B:456 8279.;.8092 :; 9-2 A.89.@>.73 G 59-2;.7/9.5;:7@09.:50/127E#/4<@.9926 <= 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 09 0<:49 #&& :5 &G&#&#) .9 ./ /90926 9-09 :5 &&#&#) 09 0<:49 #& B-25 9-2 A.89.@>.73B0//.99.5>:49/.62-27-:4/2 9-2011233059B-: 80@2 9-272 0/F26 -27 9: 17:A.62 -.@ 0 >30// :; B0927 B-25/-272;4/269:>.A2B0927056B259.5/.629-2-:4/2 9-20112330590332>263=;:33:B26-27.5/.62-27-:4/2056 0;9270<4/.5>-274/.5>;.39-=305>40>2 14/-26-279:9-2 >7:456056;233:5-27056B-25/-270./26087=011233059 0332>263=7050B0=;7:@9-2/1:9-29-2720;927.5;:7@26 - 8 - 0<:49 9-2 0332>26 .58.6259 9: -27 >7056 @:9-27H+ 09 0<:49I&&056/4</2K42593=/-2-060117:08-269-2 1:3.82056/4<@.9926-27;.7/9.5;:7@09.:5 #& 274/03 :; 9-2 ;.7/9 .5;:7@09.:5 B:436 >: 9: /-:B 9-09 /-2 -0/ 5:9 @062 05= 0332>09.:5 0>0.5/9 9-2 011233059 0/ ;:456 .5 -27 /9092@259 728:7626 45627 289.:5#I*:;709E:7647.5>9-28:47/2:;-27 621:/.9.:5 0/ +# 5 9-2 % .9 ./ /90926 9-09 9-2 011233059 B-: 2592726 -27 -:4/2 0;927 0//0439.5> -27 72@:A26 -27 83:9-/ 056 03/: 72@:A26 -./ 83:9- 056 9-2720;927/3219:A27-275-27/9092@259728:762645627 289.:5#I*:;7 .9./;:4569-099-2011233059B-: 25927269-2-:4/2:;9-2A.89.@0;927/-272;4/269:>.A2 -.@0>30//:;B09270//043926-270569-2720;92772@:A26 -27 83:9-/ 056 03/: 72@:A26 -./ 83:9-/ 056 143326 9-2 A.89.@>.73:A27-.@47.5>9-28:47/2:;-27621:/.9.:5 9-2A.89.@>.73H+#-0//909269-099-20112330590884/26 0;92772@:A.5>-2783:9-/056-./83:9-//3219:A27-27056 B-25 /-2 70./26 0 87= 0332>263= 705 0B0= ;7:@ 9-2 /1:9 0;927B207.5>-./672// - 9 - ## -2 A.89.@ >.73 B0/ 90F25 9: 6:89:7 +#& .@@26.0923=0;9279-272>./9709.:5:;9-2;.7/9.5;:7@09.:5 +#&:89:7-0//0.69-09/-2-062E0@.5269-2A.89.@ >.73 09 0<:49 *&& :5 &G&#&#) B.9- 9-2 -./9:7= :; 0//0439 :5 &&#&#) 056 2A25 9-2 B:456 8279.;.8092 09 EG B:436 >: 9: /-:B 9-09 A.89.@ >.73 B0/ 2E0@.526 :53= B.9- 9-2 -./9:7= :; 0//0439 -272;:72 .9 ./ 2A.6259 9-09 9-272 B0/ 5: -./9:7= :; /2E403 0//0439 >.A25 9: 9-2 6:89:7 0/ .9 ./ 5:B /:4>-9 9: <2 @062 :49 0>0.5/9 9-2 011233059<=9-217:/2849.:5 # +/ 056*07203/:-207/0=B.952//2/056 9-2=B2725:9172/25952079-2/1:9:;87.@2099-29.@2 :; .58.6259 + 80@2 9: F5:B 0<:49 9-2 .58.6259 :53= 0;927 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 .5;:7@26 0<:49 9-2 /0@2 9: -27 :5 &&#&#) 09 0<:49 I&& 056 9-2720;927 + 0332>263= .5;:7@26 0<:49 9-2 089 8:@@.9926 <= 011233059 9: + B-: B0/ 09 $=6270<06 A25+* /9092/9-09 -2 80@2 9: F5:B 0<:49 9-2 .58.6259 0;927 -2 B0/ 9:36 0<:49 9-2 /0@2 <= + -272;:72 9-2 2A.62582 :; - 10 - +/ 9: * 6:2/ 5:9 .5 05= B0= 0.6 9-2 80/2 :; 17:/2849.:5 # 5 @= 8:5/.62726 :1.5.:5 9-272 ./ 5: @0927.03 0A0.30<32:5728:769:8:5A.899-2011233059;:79-2:;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 * :; :7 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<3245627289.:5:;9-2 89:8:5A.89 9-20884/26;:7:;;2582145./-0<3245627289.:5:;9-2 89 9-20884/26/-:436-0A28:@@.9926050890/ /90926 .5 9-2 289.:5 ) :; 9-2 89 B.9- /2E403 .59259 B-.8- .5A:3A2/ 1-=/.803 8:59089 B.9-:49 12529709.:559-280/2:5-056/48-050332>09.:5./5:9 ;:456.59-2.5.9.03/90>2:;72>./9709.:5:;%0>0.5/99-2 011233059:7099-2/90>2:;9-2A.89.@>.73<2.5>17:64826 <2;:729-26:89:7;:7-272E0@.509.:59011207/9-09 .9 ./ ;:7 9-2 /0.6 720/:5 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 B0/ 5:9 @26.8033= 2E0@.526 B.9- 72>076 9: 05= 0332>09.:5 :; /2E403 0//0439 0562A259-2011233059B0/5:9@26.8033=2E0@.526.59-2 172/259 80/2 -2 17:/2849.:5 -0/ 03/: 5:9 /2.J26 9-2 672//9-099-2A.89.@>.730569-2011233059B272B207.5> 09 9-2 9.@2 :; .58.6259 %:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 - 11 - 289.:5*:;9-20884/26/-:436-0A20//043926:7 4/26 87.@.503 ;:782 0>0.5/9 9-2 B:@05 B.9- .59259 9: :4970>2-27@:62/9=:/48-@0927.03./;:4560/0>0.5/9 9-2011233059.59-2172/25980/20569-272;:720@:;9-2 :1.5.:59-099-27.03:479B0/5:9?4/9.;.26.58:5A.89.5> 9-2 011233059 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582/ 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 *:;056289.:5:; 89 #* 5/:;070/9-20332>09.:5/0>0.5/99-2011233059 ;:79-2:;;2582/145./-0<3245627289.:5**056289.:5 &* :; ./ 8:5827526 9-2 A.89.@ >.73 .5 -27 ;.7/9 .5;:7@09.:5 0/ B233 0/ .5 -27 /9092@259 728:7626 45627 289.:5 #I* :; 7 056 647.5> 9-2 8:47/2 :; -27 621:/.9.:5 -0/ 8:5/./92593= /90926 9-09 :5 &&#&#) 0;927 /-2 -06 72;4/26 9: >.A2 0 >30// :; B0927 9: 9-2 011233059 -2 -06 2592726 -27 -:4/2 056 0;927 0<4/.5> -27 -2-0614/-26-279:9-2>7:4560560/072/4399-2 A.89.@ -06 ;03325 9: 9-2 >7:456 $:B2A27 /-2 -0/ 5:9 /4;;272605=.5?47=.59-2/0.6.58.6259056.5EG.9./ 832073=/909269-095:.5?47=B0/;:456:505=1079:;9-2 <:6=:;9-2A.89.@>.73$:B2A27 9-2;08972@0.59-09 9-2 - 12 - A.89.@ >.73 B0/ 90F25 9: 9-2 6:89:7 B.9- 9-2 -./9:7= :; 0//0439 <= 9-2 011233059 056 0332>09.:5 .5 9-2 ;.7/9 .5;:7@09.:5./9-09011233059-0625927269-2-:4/2:;9-2 A.89.@ >.73 09 0<:49 #& :5 &&#&#) 056 0;927 0<4/.5> -27 4/.5> ;.39-= 305>40>2 -2 -06 14/-26 -27 9: 9-2 >7:456 -2 0;:72/0.6 0332>09.:5/ 0/ 0>0.5/9 9-2 011233059 B-.8- ./ 8:5/./92593= ;:456 .5 9-2 ;.7/9 .5;:7@09.:5 09 E# /9092@259 45627 289.:5 #I* :; 709E05603/:.59-2621:/.9.:5:;+# B:436 09<2/909970899-2:;;2582/145./-0<3245627289.:5** :;056289.:5&*:;0/0>0.5/99-2011233059056 9-272;:72 0@:;9-2:1.5.:59-099-27.03:479B0/5:9 ?4/9.;.26 .5 8:5A.89.5> 9-2 011233059 ;:7 033 9-2 8-07>2 /-22926:;;2582/ # 5627 9-2 8.784@/90582 0@ :; 9-2 :1.5.:5 9-09 9-09 9-2 ?46>@259 056 :7627 :; 8:5A.89.:5 056 /259258210//260>0.5/99-2011233059.5/:;070/.9723092/ 9: 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 * :; 056 289.:5 :; 89 5226/ 9: <2 /29 0/.62 056 /0@2 - 13 - 5226/9:<28:5;.7@26;:7:;;2582/45627289.:5**056 289.:5&*:; #I 5/:;07 0/ 9-2 :7627 :; /2592582 ./ 8:5827526 .9./<7:4>-99:5:9.82:;9-./:4799-099-2011233059B0/ .584/9:6=;:79-2127.:6:;*@:59-/##60=/647.5>9-2 8:47/2 :; 97.03 056 -2 ./ 0 @077.26 @05 -0A.5> 8-.36725 -272;:720@:;9-2:1.5.:59-09 .;9-2:7627:;/2592582 10//26 0>0.5/9 9-2 011233059 ;:7 9-2 :;;2582/ 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 ** :; 056 289.:5 &* :; ./ 7264826 9: 9-2 127.:6 :; /2592582 037206= 45627>:52 <= 9-2011233059 <=@0.590.5.5>9-2;.52.@1:/26<=9-27.03 :479 9-2 /0@2 B:436 /27A2 9-2 256/ :; ?4/9.82 88:76.5>3= 10//9-2;:33:B.5>( !." -287.@.503011203./ !.." -2 ?46>@259 056 :7627 :; 8:5A.89.:5 056 /2592582 .5/:;07 0/ .9 723092/ 9: 8:5A.89.5> 056/259258.5>9-2011233059;:79-2:;;2582/ 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5 * :; 056 289.:5:;9-2 89.//290/.62056 - 14 - 9-2 011233059 ./ 08K4.9926 ;:7 9-2 0;:72/0.6 :;;2582/ !..." -2?46>@259056:7627:;8:5A.89.:510//26 <=9-2:479:;66.9.:5032//.:5/46>2 030<470>..5128.030/2:*#&#)60926 ##&)&#.5/:;070/.9/723092/9::;;2582/ 145./-0<3245627289.:5**056&*:; ./8:5;.7@26 !.A" %:7 9-2 :;;2582 145./-0<32 45627 289.:5/ **056&*:; 9-2/2592582./@:6.;.26 05672648269:9-2127.:645627>:52<=9-2 011233059 056 -2 /-033 10= ;.52 :; /I &&&H056.562;0439-2/-03345627>: ;479-27/.@132.@17./:5@259;:70127.:6:; @:59-/ !A" -22E82//;.520@:459 .;05= 621:/.926<= 9-2011233059/-033<272;456269:-.@ ,+ '$ %! * ! ./9:#3:*#