Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10722 (KAR)
UNION OF INDIA v. MAHABOOB BEE AND ORS
MFA/202183/2017 · 2025-01-13
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10722 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10722 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$# %! & $!!! #
'
& $!$! ! !%% ( ) *+ ! !%% "( )
+
! " # $%& $
"$
'$( $ )&*+!,! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
&*+!,! &
)&%,,,! - ! &+! '
&",!,
. . . ,%!,!% . . &",!,
. '
"
+
- 3 -
! " .# $ . $
"$
'( $ )&*+!,! '
&*+!,! &
)&%,,,! - ! &+! '
&+",!,
. . ,%!,!% . &+",!, . '
. $
- 4 -
$ / . / . . $ $ / . 0,!*+",!1234566789:6;<23::67=97=>26 ?@;=A67>37;3B3C;08>26686C67<60@C>D3446;97 0&",!, B26C65E >26 686C67<6 0@C> 234 67237<6; >26<0AD6743>9073>>26C3>6084!&,,,,,"D6C3<C6 260C;6C08>26686C67<60@C>B343<0AA07?@;=A67> 37;3B3C;34C6=3C;404&",!,&",!,&+",!, 37;*",!,
0,!*",!1234566789:6;<23::67=97= >26 ?@;=A67> 37; 3B3C; D3446; 97 0&+",!, 7 :9=2>08>26?@;=A67>37;3B3C;5697=D3446;97<0AA07 34 C6=3C;4 04&",!, 37; &+",!, 50>2 >26 3DD63:4 3C6 >3F67 @D >0=6>26C 37; 3C6 ;94D046; 08 5E 3 <0AA070C;6C
- 5 -
>94>05670>9<6;>23>>26567689<93CE23489:6;
>2646 3DD63:4 26 C6:6G37> 83<>4 A3;6 0@> 3C6 >23> >26 >3>6083C73>3F323;40@=2>>03<H@9C6:37;08>26:37; 0B76C497E0!!,"A634@C97=!3<C6!=@7>349>@3>6;
3> 3A3;3D@C G9::3=6 >3:@F 37; ;94>C9<> 39<2@C 80C 80CA3>907 08 76B C39:B3E :976 5E G9C>@6 08 70>989<3>907 @7;6C6<>907+!08>2637;<H@949>907<>!*I+37; >26 70>989<3>907 D3446; 07 !*,%,,&
0,!*+",!1
+ 74083C34 0,!*",!1>26<23::67=6 C6:3>64>0>26?@;=A67>37;3B3C;08>26686C67<60@C> C6:3>97= >0 >26 :37; 08 >26 :37; 0B76C 97 E0!*" A634@C97= 3<C64 49>@3>6; 3> 3A3;3D@C G9::3=6 >3:@F 37; ;94>C9<> 39<2@C B29<2 B34 40@=2> >0 56 3<H@9C6; 80C 80CA3>907 08 76B C39:B3E :976 5E G9C>@6 08 >26 +! 70>989<3>907C686CC6;>0350G6
& > 94 >0 56 70>9<6; >23> >26 D6<93: 37;
<H@949>907 889<6C 23; 3B3C;6; A3CF6> G3:@6 08 >26 3<H@9C6;:37;3>4***&"D6C3<C680CB6>:37;37;>294
- 6 -
234 70B 5667 67237<6; >0 4!&,,,,," D6C 3<C6 5E G9C>@608>260C;6C08>26686C67<60@C>
% 63C76;<0@746:80C>263DD6::37>)567689<93CE 4@5A9>4>23>>26686C67<60@C>23440:6:EC6:96;07>26 <07467>3B3C;3>J,D3446;B9>2C64D6<>>0:37;43> @79C353; 34 C6=3C;4 623500573=3C 39:B3E :976 B29<2 <07467> 3B3C; B34 D3446; 07 ,+!,,!
C6:3>97= >0 9CC9=3>6; :37;4 G3:@6; 3> 4!&,,,,," D6C 3<C6 > 94 4@5A9>>6; >23> >3F97= 70>6 08 4@<2 <07467> 3B3C; B9>2 C64D6<>>0:37;80C3;9886C67>>3:@FA3E70>56DC0D6C37;
B0@:; 70> 567689> 69>26C >26 :37; 0B76C4 70C B0@:; 9> C68:6<>>263DDC0DC93>6A3CF6>G3:@6>948@C>26CD097>6; 0@>>23>34C6=3C;449A9:3C<07>67>907C3946;B9>2C64D6<> >0:37;480C>2643A6DC0?6<>B26C697>26686C67<60@C> 23;3B3C;6;4!&,,,,,"D6C3<C634C6=3C;49CC9=3>6;
:37;4 37; 43A6 B34 >3F67 @D 5680C6 >294 0@C> 97 0,,111",!& 37; 0>26C <0776<>6; A3>>6C4 >26 <0 0C;973>6567<208>2940@C>;94D046;08>26439;3DD63:4 5E 0C;6C ;3>6; !&!,,, 37; 23; 70>9<6; >23> A6C6
- 7 -
C6:937<607>26<07467>3B3C;A3E70>563<<@C3>638>6C 70>9<97= 46G6C3: ?@;=A67>4 08 >26 D6J 0@C> 37;
3<<0C;97=:E 9> 94 4@5A9>>6; 5E :63C76; <0@746: 3DD63C97= 80C >26 3DD6::37>567689<93CE >23> 97 :9=2> 08 >26 439; 3DD63:423G97=5667;94D046;085E46>>97=349;60C;6C408 >26 686C67<6 0@C> >3F97= 70>6 08 37 9;67>9<3: :6=3:
<07>67>907 37; C6A37;97= >26 A3>>6C 53<F 80C 8C642 <0749;6C3>907 97 :9=2> 08 >26 ;9C6<>9074 A3;6 >26C697 >26 DC6467> 3DD63:4 A3E 3:40 56 ;94D046; 08 07 43A6 =C0@7;4
1 >94>05670>9<6;>23>>26:37;0B76C4>20@=2 46CG6;23G6C6A3976;35467>6C@46;>260C;6CD3446;
97 0,,111",!& 37; <0776<>6; A3>>6C4 26 D097>80C<0749;6C3>907943480::0B4$ 26>26C<34694A3;60@>>046>349;6>260C;6C08 >26686C67<60@C>37;>0C6A37;>26A3>>6C53<F 80C8C642<0749;6C3>90797:9=2>08>260C;6CD3446;97 0,,111",!&37;<0776<>6;A3>>6C4K
* D6C@43: 08 >26 0C;6C 08 >26 686C67<6 0@C> B0@:;97;9<3>6>23>>26686C67<60@C>234C6:96;07>26
- 8 -
<07467> 3B3C; >20@=2 <07467> 3B3C; B34 D3446; 07 ,+!,,! 26 439; <07467> 3B3C; 234 5667 A3CF6;
5680C6>26 C93:0@C>3>J,D6C@43:08>260C;6C 5E >26 686C67<6 0@C> B0@:; <:63C:E 97;9<3>6 >23> >26 89J3>907 08 A3CF6> G3:@6 B34 40:6:E 07 >26 53494 08 >26 <07467> 3B3C; D3446; 5E >26 37; <H@949>907 889<6C 08 @79C353; > 94 3;A9>>6;:E >26 D049>907 >23> J, C6:3>64 >0 :37;4 D6C>39797= >0 0DD3: >3:@F B29:6 >26 DC6467><346C6:3>64>0:37;408 3A;3D@CG9::3=6>20@=2 97 C64D6<> 08 39<2@C >3:@F > 94 >0 56 70>9<6; >23> >26 686C67<60@C>>20@=2234>3F6770>6084@<283<>234 0546CG6;>23>0DD3:>3:@F37;39<2@C>3:@F3C63;?09797= >0 63<2 0>26C 23G97= 9CC9=3>907 83<9:9>E 37; >26E <37 56 >C63>6;3>D3CB9>263<20>26C37;DC0<66;6;>0D34437 3B3C;C6:E97=07>26<07467>3B3C;
I 29434D6<>234566770>9<6;5E>26<00C;973>6 567<2 08 >294 0@C> 97 0,,111",!& 37; 234 0D976; >23> A3CF6> G3:@6 08 63<2 :37; B9:: 23G6 >0 56 3446446; ;9886C67>:E ;6D67;97= 07 >26 A3>6C93: 07 C6<0C;
- 9 -
37; A6C6 C6:937<6 07 <07467> 3B3C; A3E 70> 56 3DDC0DC93>6 26C6:6G37>6J>C3<>408>26?@;=A67>97 0,,111",!& 8C0A D3C3=C3D24 !% >0 >9:: 67; 3C6 34 80::0B4$
! "
"
"! "" #
$#
% &! '
"
(
" )$*
+ ! ,$*)$*#
% &
, ' #
! - %. % &
" ! '
! " " #
" -
"
'
/ #
% & 0-12 !
%
3 (
+ 4 3
! !" ! - % 55+
" % /55+
% 655+
"
- 10 -
"
+
"654 #
% &
! ! 0-126 ! " 3" &
" % 3 + ! &
-
#+0-12! "
3" & %
! ) #
- ! -
- ! 4 + #
7 ! % *655 +
"
" % 655 + ! + 4 ( #
% & ! +
! "
"
" 1
! % &
! 8 9
" ! "
! +0-&' :
" #
0- 0 7'* & ' 3 ; &
, $'*'$*
! ! " "
#
- 11 -
" ! <
"
")$*
,
# <+&#
"! ! "
"
"! ! "
! "
"
'- %.'
" "
"
" 9 # '-
"
"
% &
+% /55+
-
#
"
% 655+
! " # % & ! ! ! ! "
! ! "
- &
%
= >1 ?*5@:&&)?))6@6&&$:?'/@ *5 "
& %!" % &
!" ! 4 (
#+ ! %
+ +
! " ! ! " *
! +
A BC & ! ! +"
- 12 -
& +
! ! " !" % & #
BC &
&B7 B%(=733 = 10& 73 &D>#7 EE&0% ?)//@ 2 && $6 ! ! 8 92 < +
" + # &
"
!"
A ! "
- #
, 6 # ! 8 9?@% /
! +
"
! ?*@
! A
-
%
"
"
"
+
"
! "
"
! ?2@ #
%
+
?:@#
! ! ! " +
?6@#
+
:
? ) @
- 13 -
?@ #
? :@
" ! +
"
" ! ?$@ " +
! - +
?/@"
+ ? @ ?)@ 0 '
+?@
""- ?*@ ?2@
"
?5@ #
! 8 ?@-"
?@-"
?@ B ! - +
" +
+
"
" +
A
'F'
"
!A- ?*@ '
" ! "
! ?2@#
+
"
+
?:@#
- ?@ ?2@
+
! !
."
?-
@
8
1
,
* -" *
- 14 -
2 E 2 7! ! "
:
: ! 6
6 %
"
'F'
! ! $
! A
" ! "
"
?6@#
#
"
& E +
,
" 655 555
" ! +
" 5 555 " E " ! ! " +
! ""
! ?! "!+@
,
#
" + " !" ! -"!*5 65
#
! - ! ! " + ! ! ! ! + ! , ?@ 0" ! ! ! A
- 15 -
?$@ #
! ! **# '-A BC & "
BC-&
>77 E 73 = 3;( 30= ?*5/@ / && :/6 ! BC & ! 8 6 < ! -
"+
! A ! !" & ! ! <"
!" "
! "
" "
&! &
B G& B ?)//@2&&$6H
& ! ! &
! ! + +
$:
A
&! " $ ! ! 8 ?&
B G& B ?)//@ 2 && $6H && $6:'6 :@ 9?@'?:@III ?6@ #
+
:
? ) @ ?@#
? :@
" ! + "
" ! - 16 -
?$@ " +
! - +
?/@ "
+
? @?)@0 '
+ ?@
" " - ?*@?2@
"
?5@#
! 8 ?@-"
?@-"
?@B ! - +
"+
+
"" + A
'F' " !A-
?*@
" ! "
! ?2@#
+
"
+
?:@#
- ?@?2@ +
! ! . "
? -
@
8 1
,
- 17 -
*-" *
2E 2 ! ! "
: 7
: ! 6 6
" 'F'
! ! $
! A
" ! "
"
?6@#
#
"
' ' & E +
,
" 655 555 " ! +
"5 555 "E "! ! " +
! ""
! ?! "!+@
,
#
" + " !" ! -"!*5 65
#
! - ! !
" + ! ! ! ! + ! ,
?@ 0" ! ! ! J
- 18 -
?$@ #
! ! 9 /#
"+" ! +
? > %A 4 <
G> %A 4 < ?*5:@5&&:**8?*56@&&?&@$H@ )
& ! ! +
" ! +
A + ! -
"
! 5K/K
+
! ! -
! +
+
+ +
" ! # &
! +
"
#
& !" "
!+
-A +
*2 ? #
J >
G#
J
>
?*5@&&:$8?*5@2&& ?&@ $/H =
% G=
% ?*5$@/&&66/8?*5$@:&&?&@66H@ #
!"
BC&
-A ! +
! %
/?@
*2#
% &
"
! "
- & ' - A
"
!"
-&
- 19 -
+
! !" *:#
% &
! + # &
! ! A
A
"
! !(
654 %
#+?! @
554 1
% &! ! ! "
"
" ! ! !"
-& A4 = B" ?*5/@2&&) ! -&
! 8 9
B
& ! G! B" *5* && 1LB )5::H ! #
! A M! " ! B! ! G! B" *5* && 1LB )5::H ! A
"
B
&
+
! ! ! +A ! -
! - 20 -
! ! ,
A M! ! * . ! B
& #
! "
"
! "
:
#
"
" ! !MA
"
" #
"
A
! ! ! #
"
!MA
65"
2#
! A
%" ! ! " "
" # !"!"
A
! + " +
!""
:#
! MA
"
! #
"
" AM! +"
-
!MA - ! - 21 -
!MA
"A + ! !N
" " !MA ! ! "
6 #
"
"
! A ! 5 * "
"
J! #
" ! :
" #
"
! #
"
#
!MA AM! " A
" ! A " "
+ " !MA
+ M
!MA
! "A
-
"! !
" "
"9
! "
BC &
A A M! ! ! ! %
! ! - 22 -
*61
"
! + ! "! !*2
/):
A BC & B ?@ 3" 3?@A4?@ *
! !"
"
! ! % &
+ % &
" ! ! A
BC & B%(=733 = 10&73&D>#7EE&0%?)//@ 2 && $6 >77 E 73 = 3;( 30= ?*5/@ / && :/6 7J 4>% 73 #B0% = ##0 E B%;7 73 #B0% ?*5/@2&&) *$ E ! !8 %30% ?@ E 7*55$$$M*56 E 7*5*5*M*5 E 7*55$$*M*56 E 7*55$$:M*56 E 7*55$$M*56 E 7*5*5*$M*5 E 7*5*5*:M*5 E 7*5*5*6M*5 E 7*5*522M*5 E 7*5*52*M*5 E 7*5*52:M*5 E 7*55$$6M*56 E 7*55$$M*56 E 7*55$$5M*56 E 7*55$$2M*56 E 7*55$$/M*56 E 7*5*52M*5 E 7*5*525M*5 ! % &&7 :)M*55) $M*55 /M*55) /)M*55) M*55) $*M*55) /:M*55) 62M*55) $/M*55 )M*55) 5:M*55 6$M*55) 6M*55) 6)M*55) 66M*55 6$M*55 5$M*5 /6M*55) ?*@ E 7*5*22M*5: E 7*5*25M*5: E 7*5*2)M*5: E 7*5*2M*5: E 7*5*2$M*5: E 7*5*2/M*5: E 7*5*26M*5: E 7*5*2*M*5: E 7*5*2M*5: E 7*5**)M*5: E 7*5**:M*5: E 7*5*2:M*5: E
- 23 -
7*5***M*5: E 7*5**2M*5: E 7*5**6M*5: E 7*5**M*5: E 7*5**$M*5:
E 7*5**/M*5:
?2@#
+
% &
" ! !"
BC&
B%(=733 = 10& 73 &D>#7 EE&0% ?)//@ 2 && $6 >77 E 73 = 3;( 30= ?*5/@/&&:/67J4>%73#B0%= ##0EB%;773#B0%?*5/@2 && ) ! -
"
?:@ #
% " 1
% &
?6@ # ! % & ?@! !L
! ! ?$@#
O
!, > A@4> 56 70>9<6; >23> >26 <00C;973>6 567<2 234 <:63C:E 0546CG6; 38>6C C686CC97= >0 ?@;=A67>4 08 @DC6A60@C>>23>686C67<60@C>D:3<97=5:97;C6:937<6 07 <07467> 3B3C; B9>20@> <0749;6C97= 83<>4 37; <346 5680C69>B346CC0760@4 26<00C;973>6567<22343:40 0546CG6;>23>>269AD@=76;0C;6C4420B>23>>26A3CF6> G3:@6 234 5667 ;6>6CA976; B9>20@> >3F97= 70>6 08 >26 DC97<9D:64:39;;0B7976<>90708>2637;<H@949>907
- 24 -
<>!*I+37;;94D046;08>263DD63:45E46>>97=349;6>26 0C;6C08>26686C67<60@C>
!!
7 >26 DC6467> <346 3:40 3 ;6>39:6; D6C@43: 08 >263B3C;08>26686C67<60@C>B0@:;97;9<3>6>23>>26 <:97<297=D097>>3F6770>680C<0749;6C3>90794>263A0@7> 89J6; 97 >26 <07467> 3B3C; ;A9>>6;:E 34 >26 <07467> 3B3C;C6:3>64>0:37;970DD3:>3:@FB29:697>26DC6467> <346:37;497 3A3;3D@C83::B9>29739<2@C94>C9<> 26 A6C6C6:937<640:6:E07>26<07467>3B3C;340546CG6;5E >26 <00C;973>6 567<2 B0@:; 70> 56 4@889<967> 3>>6C C6H@9C64 <0749;6C3>907 5E >3F97= 70>6 08 0546CG3>9074 A3;6 5E >26 <00C;973>6 567<2 97 0,,111",!& 6:937<6 07 3 <07467> 3B3C; 08 :37; 3<H@9C6; <3770> 56 597;97=3497<346083<07467>3B3C;>26<0AD6743>90794 3=C66; @D07 5E <07467> 37; 70> 3;?@;9<3>907 26 <0AD6743>907 >0 56 ;6>6CA976; 80C 63<2 :37; ;6D67;4 @D07G3C90@483<>0C43467@A6C3>6;5E>26D6J0@C>97
! " !#$%
- 25 -
&! 26 0@C> B29:6 >3F97= 70>6 08 G3C90@4 83<>0C4 <0@:;70>23G69=70C6;>266G9;67<608>26<:39A37>97>26 80CA 08 J4! >0 &, B29<2 97<:@;64 3B3C; D3446; 97 >26 <346 08 <0AD3C35:6 :37;4 34 3446C>6; 5E >26 <:39A37>4 26 C6<67> ;6<94907 08 >26 D6J 0@C> 97 ! " !#$% &! %
% B0@:; 3:40 56 C6:6G37> 974083C 34 0546CG3>9074 3C6A3;6>23><07467>3B3C;4<3770>56C63;9:E>3F6734 L<0AD3C35:64M 80C 89J97= <0AD6743>907 <<0C;97=:E >26 3DDC03<208>26686C67<60@C><3770>563<<6D>6;37;
>26 A3CF6> G3:@6 08 :37; B9:: 23G6 >0 56 3446446; 97;6D67;67>:E:00F97=97>0>266G9;67<607C6<0C;:6>975E >26 <:39A37> >3F97= 70>6 08 >26 DC97<9D:64 >0 56 F6D> 97 A97; 34 26:; 5E >26 <00C;973>6 567<2 7 :9=2> 08 >26 43A6>26D097>80C<0749;6C3>90794>056374B6C6;97>26 3889CA3>9G6
! <<0C;97=:E>2680::0B97=$
?)//@2&&$6 **5**!?&@2
- 26 -
9 263DD63:43C63::0B6; 99 26 ?@;=A67> 37; 3B3C; 08 >26 686C67<6 0@C> 94 46> 349;6 37; >26 A3>>6C 94 C6A9>>6; 80C 8C642 <0749;6C3>907 >0 >26 686C67<60@C>B29<294>03;?@;9<3>6>26 C686C67<6 >3F97= 70>6 08 >26 0546CG3>9074 A3;6 5E >26 <00C;973>6 567<2 97 0,,111",!&
6=94>CE>0467;53<F>26 C93:0@C>C6<0C;4
26C6 423:: 56 C68@7; 08 <0@C> 866 97 >6CA4 34 4>9D@:3>6; @7;6C 6<>907 %+ 08 >26 3C73>3F3 0@C> 664 37;@9>43:@3>907<>!I&*
!,*
(!! #
') $
!,*
($! ) $
94>0$!:0$1