Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10692 (KAR)

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA v. CHANDRAKANTH S/O GEMU RATHOD

CRL.A/200114/2016 · 2025-02-24

Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$ % "#$$ #!! &'(&)!*+,&* - ! " # $%& '( ) ( '*$'! ) '+' " & *, $,% *, *,! *,+ $!! ( !! !!!%!% ,,& Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) # - )# - ) ) $ # - ) ) ./010/.1234/5/44/60.72133/181917:200./;<69=/:0 3122/6 7: >'+,' 610/6 '*,$,'! ?@ 0./ 66707>:18/227>:2)<69/10 181?<4197./4/7:150/44/5/44/60> 120./A8/14:/6/227>:2)<69/BC./4/7:0./8/14:/6/227>:2 )<69/1DE<700/60./1DD<2/65>40./>55/:D/23<:72.1?8/<:6/4 /D07>:2 & *, $,% *, *,! *,+ $!! >5 0./ 1:6 /D07>:2!!!!!!!!!%!%>50./:5>4=107>: /D.:>8>9@D0,,& ./1?4769/651D02>50./34>2/D<07>:D12/14/0.10 ./D>=3817:1:0.1@1F$C121D 416<10/1:6 166707>:188@ .16 3<42</6 417:7:9 D><42/ ./ 1DD<2/6 .1:641G1:0. ?/D1=/ 1DE<17:0/6 C70. 0./ D>=3817:1:0 0.4><9. ./4 2720/4B2 547/:6 :1=/6 <;10.1 % :18871:D/C1234>3>2/60>0./D>=3817:1:0>88>C7:9C.7D. >:',,',',0./1DD<2/6.72=>0./4.72=10/4:18<:D8/1:6 - 3 - .72 C75/ .72 2720/4 1H70.1 0./ =/6710>4 <;10.1 1:6 ./4 .<2?1:6)191672.H7270/60./D>=3817:1:0B2.><2/1:62><9.01 =144719/ 34>3>218 <?2/E</:08@ C./: 0./ 51=78@ /:E<74/6 4/91467:90./1DD<2/6B26723>2707>:I0./@8/14:0>5.721DD<42/6 ?/.1H7><4 /:D/ 0./ D>=3817:1:0B2 314/:02 1:6 ! D>==<:7D10/60./741334/./:27>:1:6<:C7887:9:/22>59/007:9 0./7461<9.0/4=1447/60>0./1DD<2/650/4>:/=>:0.>50./ 2176 7:D76/:0 0./ 1DD<2/6 H7270/6 0./ D>=3817:1:0B2 .><2/ 10 1?><0''$,3=1:65>4D/6./40>/8>3/./:2./4/5<2/6 ./0.4/10/:/61:6100/=30/60>D.>G/./4:/DG?@.72.1:62 >88>C7:9 C.7D. 0./ D>=3817:1:0 2E</18/6 1:6 <3>: ./147:9 0.72 ./4 314/:02 2 1:6 ! D1=/ 0> ./4 4/2D</ 3>: C70:/227:90./1447H18>521:6!0./1DD<2/6C70.64/C.72 .1:6254>=./4:/DG1:658/60./23>0:18132/>5%0>& =>:0.2 >:D/ 1917: 0./ 1DD<2/6 /:6/1H><4/6 0> 4//201?872. D>:01D0C70.0./D>=3817:1:0?@2/:67:9./41=/2219/7:5780.@ 81:9<19/>:./4=>?78/?/147:9>2&,+*''$+!,$*&'!' 1:6 %&++$,&$ 917:20 0.72 ?1DG64>3 2./ 8>69/6 1 D>=3817:0 10 0./ 1.781 >87D/ 0107>: 181?<4197 1:6 1 D>=34>=72/ C12 1447H/6 10 7: 0./ >87D/ 0107>: 1:6 0./ 1DD<2/6 C4>0/ 1 .1:6 C4700/: ?>:6 20107:9 :>0 0> 4/3/10 0./ 21=/7:0./5<0<4/C//G1./16>58>697:90./D>=3817:00./ - 4 - 1DD<2/6 .16 =/2219/6 0./ D>=3817:1:0B2 ?4>0./4 0.10 ./ .16 <38>16/6 .72 2720/4 7/ 0./ D>=3817:1:0B2 3.>0>9413.2 >: 2>D718=/67138105>4=287G/ =1781:61D/?>>G1:6182>2010/6 0.10 0./ >87D/ D><86 6> :>0.7:9 7: 0./ =100/4 /:D/ 0./ D>=3817:1:0 $ 8>69/6 1 D>=3817:0 ?/5>4/ 0./ 133/881:0>87D/ 1917:20 0./ 1DD<2/6 12 3/4 J' >: !,','' ./ 21=/ D1=/ 0> ?/ 4/9720/4/6 7: 47=/ >'!,'' 610/6 !,','' 1917:20 0./ 1DD<2/6 5>4 0./ >55/:D/2 3<:72.1?8/ <:6/4 /D07>:2 & *, $,% *, *,! 1:6$!!>50./1:6/D07>:2!!1:6!%>50./:5>4=107>: /D.:>8>9@ D0 ,,& : D>=38/07>: >5 0./ 7:H/2079107>: 0./ :H/2079107:9 557D/4 8176 0./ D.149/2.//0 1917:20 0./ 1DD<2/6 5>40./>55/:D/23<:72.1?8/<:6/4/D07>:2&*,$,%*, *,!*,+1:6$!!>51:6/D07>:2!!!!!% !% >5 0./ :5>4=107>: /D.:>8>9@ D0 ,,& ?/5>4/ 0./ D>==70018><40 $ : D>==70018 >5 0./ D12/ 0./ 8/14:/6 /227>:2 )<69/ 541=/6 0./ D.149/2 1917:20 0./ 1DD<2/6 5>4 0./ 15>4/=/:07>:/6 >55/:D/2 1:6 4/16 70 >H/4 H/4?107= 0> 0./ 1DD<2/6 ./ 1DD<2/6 38/16/6 :>0 9<780@ 1:6 D817=/6 0> ?/ 047/6 - 5 - ./34>2/D<07>:/J1=7:/612=1:@12'!C70:/22/2 12'0>'!I=14G/6'6>D<=/:0212J'0>J' 3>:D>:D8<67:90./047180./8/14:/6/227>:2)<69/4/16>H/4 0./ 7:D47=7:107:9 3>407>: >5 0./ /H76/:D/ >5 C70:/22/2 0> 0./ 1DD<2/6<:6/40./34>H727>:2>5/D07>:$'$>541:60./ 1DD<2/6 6/:7/6 0./ 21=/ 8?/70 0./ 1DD<2/6 D.>2/ 0> :>0 /J1=7:/1:@C70:/22>:.7251H><4.>C/H/4./9>0=14G/6' 6>D<=/:0212J'0>J'./6/5/:D/>50./1DD<2/672 >:/>50>0186/:7181:60.10>55182/7=387D107>: * ./ /227>:2 ><40 150/4 D>:276/47:9 0./ /H76/:D/ >: 4/D>46 1DE<700/6 0./ 1DD<2/6 5>4 0./ D.149/2 8/H/88/6 1917:20.7=./2176;<69=/:0>51DE<7001872D.188/:9/6<:6/4 0.72133/18?@0./010/ ! / .1H/ ./146 0./ 8/14:/6 66707>:18 010/ <?87D 4>2/D<0>447766187:910785>40./D>=3817:1:0 010/1:6 8/14:/6 D><:2/8 =0 /=1 <81G14:7 5>4 4/23>:6/:01DD<2/6 C/ .1H/ 182> 3/4<2/6 0./ 4/D>462 =16/ 1H1781?8/?/5>4/<2 % ./ 347=14@ D>:0/:07>: >5 0./ 8/14:/6 66707>:18 0.100.//227>:2><40.1294>228@/44/67:1DE<7007:90./ - 6 - 1DD<2/64/23>:6/:0 6/2370/ 0./ 34>2/D<07>: 381D7:9 2<557D7/:0 /H76/:D/ ?/5>4/ 0./ /227>:2 ><40 / D>:0/:6/6 0.10 0./ /H76/:D/ >5 2 0> ! 1:6 '! D><38/6 C70. 0./ /H76/:D/ >5 ' 7/ 0./ D8>2/ 4/8107H/2 >5 0./ 6/D/12/6 D10/9>47D188@ /201?872./20./9<780>50./1DD<2/6/2<?=700.10123/40./ 81C 8176 6>C: ?@ 0./ >:B?8/ 3/J ><40 C./: 0./4/ 72 1: 188/9107>: >5 7:0/4/20/6:/22 0./ 21=/ .12 0> ?/ /201?872./6 =/4/ 2010/=/:0 0.10 ?/7:9 4/8107H/ >5 0./ 6/D/12/6 0./@ 14/ 87G/8@ 0> 5182/8@ 7=387D10/ 0./ 1DD<2/6 D1::>0 ?/ 1 94><:6 0> 672D146 0./74 /H76/:D/ / 5<40./4 D>:0/:6/6 0.10 0./ D>=3817:1:0 $ .12 D8/148@ 2010/6 7: ./4 /H76/:D/ 0.10 0./ 1DD<2/6C12<:.133@C70.0./4/;/D07>:>518871:D/1:6D1=/0> 0./74.><2/1:67:2720/6>:0./4/8107>:2.731:6.12182>3>20/6 1:6D74D<810/60./3.>0>2C70.><0./4D>:2/:00.4><9.7:0/4:/0 1:6 1D/?>>G 1:6 ./:D/ ./ .12 D>==700/6 0./ >55/:D/2 D.149/6 C.7D. .12 ?//: D>44>?>410/6 ?@ 0./ /H76/:D/ >5 =10/4718 C70:/22/2 : 2370/ >5 2<D. =10/47182 0./ 8/14:/6 /227>:2)<69/.121DE<700/60./1DD<2/6C70.><01334/D7107:9 0.//H76/:D/1:6=10/47182>:4/D>4670.0./2/2<?=7227>:2 ./341@20>188>C0./133/181:60>D>:H7D00./1DD<2/65>40./ D.149/28/H/88/61917:20.7= - 7 - & /5<07:90./1?>H/2<?=7227>:0./8/14:/6D><:2/8 5>4 0./ 4/23>:6/:021DD<2/6 2<?=700/6 0.10 0./ 8/14:/6 /227>:2 )<69/ >: 6<8@ 1334/D7107:9 0./ /:074/ /H76/:D/ >: 4/D>46 3122/6 1 C/88 4/12>:/6 ;<69=/:0 C.7D. 6>/2 :>0 D188 5>4 1:@ 7:0/45/4/:D/ 10 0./ .1:62 >5 0.72 ><40 ./ 5<40./4 2<?=700/6 0.10 0./4/ 72 1: 7:>467:10/ 6/81@ 7: 8>697:9 0./ D>=3817:0?@0./D>=3817:1:0./7:D76/:0188/9/68@0>>G381D/ 10 1?><0 ''$, 3= >5 /?4<14@ ,', 0./ D>=3817:1:0 1334>1D./6 0./ >87D/ >: !,','' ./:D/ 0./4/ 72 1: 7:>467:10/ 6/81@ 7: 8>697:9 0./ D>=3817:0 1:6 0./ 34>2/D<07>: 5178/60>/J3817:0./4/12>:5>42<D.7:>467:10/6/81@7:8>697:9 0./D>=3817:0./5<40./4D>:0/:6/60.100./34>2/D<07>:.12 5178/6 0>34>6<D/0./=/67D18/H76/:D/>50./>D0>42> 120> 34>H/ 0./ 7:;<4@ 2<2017:/6 >: 0./ :/DG >5 0./ D>=3817:1:0 10 0./07=/>5188/9/6=<46/4100/=302>182>0./=>?78/3.>:/2 >5 D>=3817:1:0 1:6 0./ 1DD<2/6 2/D<4/6 ?@ 0./ >87D/ 18>:9 C70. 27= D146 ./ 182> D>:0/:6/6 0.10 27:D/ 0.72 133/18 72 1917:20 1DE<70018 12 3/4 0./ 2/008/6 347:D738/ >5 81C 75 1 381<27?8/ H7/C 72 01G/: ?@ 0./ /227>:2 ><40 0./ 33/8810/ ><40 2.188 :>0 7:0/45/4/ 7: 0./ 1DE<70018 >46/4 ./ 182> D>:0/:6/6 0.10 0./ /:074/ D12/ 4/202 >: 0./ /H76/:D/ >5 7:0/4/20/6 C70:/22/2 1:6 1=>:9 0./= 0./ 7:6/3/:6/:0 - 8 - C70:/22/2 7/ 2% 0> ' 1:6 2' 1:6 '$ 0./ 2/7K<4/ 31:D.12 2> 182> 2' 1:6 0./ 31:D. C70:/22/2 5>4 23>0 =1.1K14 .1H/ 0<4:/6 .>2078/ 0./ 34>2/D<07>: D12/ : 2<D. D74D<=201:D/2 0./ /227>:2 )<69/ .12 479.08@ 1DE<700/6 0./ 1DD<2/65>40./D.149/28/H/88/61917:20.7=DD>467:98@./ 341@20>672=7220./133/18 + / .1H/ 97H/: ><4 1:J7><2 D>:276/4107>: ?>0. >: 0./149<=/:016H1:D/6?@0./?>0.0./8/14:/6D><:2/85>40./ 31407/2 2> 182> D>=34/./:27H/8@ 3/4<2/6 0./ /H76/:D/ >: 4/D>46./3>7:00.102<451D/5>4><4D>:276/4107>:72 ', 2D><86?/2//:54>=0./4/D>4627:>46/40>34>H/ 0./ D.149/2 8/H/8/6 1917:20 0./ 1DD<2/6 0./ 34>2/D<07>: .12 34/6>=7:1:08@4/87/60.//H76/:D/>5$FD>=3817:1:0H7D07= : D14/5<8 3/4<218 >5 ./4 /H76/:D/ 2./ .12 4/70/410/6 0./ D>:0/:02>5./4D>=3817:0J'>C/H/412479.08@D>:0/:6/6 ?@ 0./ 8/14:/6 D><:2/8 5>4 0./ 4/23>:6/:0 0./4/ 72 1: 7:>467:10/6/81@>51@/147:8>697:90./D>=3817:0<40./47072 ./423/D757D1H/4=/:0?>0.7:0./D>=3817:01:67:0.//H76/:D/ - 9 - 0.10 0./ 1DD<2/6 0.4/10/:/6 ./4 1:6 =16/ 1: 100/=30 0> ><0419/./4=>6/20@?@3>207:9./43.>0>9413.21:6>?2D/:/ =/2219/2 .>C/H/4 0./ 34>2/D<07>: 5178/6 0> 381D/ 2<D. D188 6/01784/9720/42 >50./=>?78/3/4017:7:90>0./1DD<2/6 >40./H7D07=<40./4>:3/4<218>5J'1:6./4D>=3817:0 0./4/72:>D>9/:01:6?/87/H1?8//H76/:D/0>34>H/0./123/D0 0.10 0./ 1DD<2/6 =16/ 1: 100/=30 0> D>==70 ./4 =<46/4 6=700/68@2./.12:>02<2017:/61:@7:;<47/2>:./43/42>: ./>0./4=10/4718C70:/22/20<4:/6.>2078/0>0./34>2/D<07>: D12/ ./ >=:7?<2 188/9107>: =16/ 7: 0./ D>=3817:0 4/H/182 0.102./.161:<80/47>4=>07H/0>7=387D10/0./1DD<2/67:0./ D47=/ 5>4 0./ 4/12>: 0.10 ./4 =144719/ 34>3>218 C12 4/;/D0/6 ?@ 0./ 1DD<2/6 : 2<D. D74D<=201:D/ 0./4/ 1472/ 1 6><?0 7: 0./0/207=>:@>5$ D>=3817:1:0.//227>:2><40C.78/ 1DE<7007:90./1DD<2/6>?2/4H/67:31419413.>'!12<:6/4 ! ! !!"#$! "#% & ! " #' #(& ! ! " #) " #* " #+ , ! " #(- . " #(- / ! #( / - 10 - #0 1 #(0 2 ! #($ 3 4 " 5 6 ! " 6 ((7$-8 0-(- ! !" ! 0&7-(70-(( ! 5 ! ! ! 9$-) : # ;! 6 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! " ! "5 ! " " < " = '' : 4/ 1334/D7107>: >5 0./ /:074/ /H76/:D/ C/ 57:6 :>2<D.D>=3/887:94/12>:0>01G/167H/49/:0H7/C120.10>5 /227>:2><40 ' /H/40./8/220.72?/7:91:133/181917:201DE<70018 0./ >:B?8/ 3/J ><40 7: 0./ D12/ >5 4/3>40/6 7: 2<==147K/6 0./ 347:D738/2 0> /J/4D72/ 0./ 3>C/4 ?@ 0./ - 11 - 33/8810/><400>7:0/45/4/7:0./>46/4>50.//227>:2><40 7:31419413.>+12<:6/4 2! " > ;5 " > ; > ; ! ? " > ; 5 ! ! ! 6 > 7 ! " > ; ! ;@ > ; 7 " A > ; " > ;! 6 ; 6 : 6 ; " > ; 6 = '$ <40./4 0./ >:B?8/ 3/J ><40 7: 0./ D12/ >5 !""## $ 4/3>40/6 7: %%%C.78/2<==147K7:90./347:D738/27:6/187:9 C70. 0./ 133/18 1917:20 1DE<70018 7: 31419413. > ./86 12 <:6/4 - 12 - %A! ! ! > ! " ! +>:/(+&( ;)(' ! !! 4 B CD > ! ! ! ! E " ! F CD # ! ! F CD : ;" " " F CD: ; " ! F CD : ; 7 " ! ; ! F CD: ! " ; ! ! " ;= ' /:D/>:D>88>D107:90./347:D738/22<==147K/67: 0./ 1?>H/ ;<69=/:0 0> 0./ 51D02 1:6 D74D<=201:D/2 >5 0.72 D12/ C/ 14/ >5 0./ D>:276/4/6 H7/C 0.10 0./ 34>2/D<07>: .12 - 13 - 5178/60>381D/2<557D7/:0/H76/:D/0>34>H/0./D.149/28/H/88/6 1917:200./1DD<2/6?/@>:64/12>:1?8/6><?0 '* :0.10H7/C>50./=100/4C/6/D87:/0>7:0/45/4/7: 0./ ;<69=/:0 3122/6 ?@ 0./ /227>:2 ><40 DD>467:98@ C/ 1:2C/40./3>7:04172/61?>H/7:0./15574=107H/1:634>D//60> 31220./5>88>C7:9 ./47=7:1833/1872 &'& .+ & %* $ .+ &$ * $ # 720>'8>*!