Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10666 (KAR)
RAHUL R KULKARNI AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/200730/2023 · 2025-01-21
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10666 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10666 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"
$%# & '# "
% ()*(+,-*( ,, -' % ()*(+,-*( ,,
-
'
! ""#$ "% $
"&$$$$
'
(
)
%
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
"&*&$#
!! #
"
"&*&$
'
(
%
% )
% * %
%
%
+ $
%
%% $"$! !* %
% % ,
()
%
+ $ %
"
-
'
#
"$
"&*&$#
+
%%
- 3 -
"&*&$
#
'
(
)
%
%
"&*&$#
!! #
"
"&*&$
'
(
%
% )
% * %
%
%
+ $
%
%%
$" $ ! !* %
% %
% + $
%
"# &
- 4 -
% %
-
( -)
../012
30 43 & 561 718361 49:0 3/64 :; 49101 4<3 =14:4:3;0 8:>12 /;216 1.4:3; * 38 6 <:49 5 =65?16 43 @/509 491 1;4:61 =63.112:;A0 :; 6:B1
3+ $ 61A:041612 7? 659B5=/65 3>:.1 454:3; 5>57/65A: 836 491 3881;.10 =/;:0957>1/;2161.4:3;0$$! !*5;2 38 <9:.9 :0 =1;2:;A 718361 491 3/64 38 22> :C:> /2A1 (6 ;)5;2%5>57/65A:
1562 491 >156;12 .3/;01> 836 491 =14:4:3;160 5;2 491 >156;12.3/;01>836610=3;21;4
3
# 10=3;21;4
3 952 8:>12 5 =6:C541 .3B=>5:;4 :;
3! $ 718361 491 3/64 38 22> % 5>57/65A: <9:.9<506181661243491D/6:02:.4:3;5>=3>:.15;2:;4/6;%:;
6:B1
3+ $ <50 61A:041612 7? 659B5=/65 3>:.1 454:3; 5>57/65A: 836 491 5836105:2 3881;.10 5A5:;04 491
- 5 -
=14:4:3;1609161:;1:;A5AA6:1C127?49105B1=14:4:3;160561 71836149:03/64
156;12.3/;01>836491=14:4:3;1600/7B:40495449161:05 .:C:> 2:0=/41 714<11; 5../012
30 5;2 5;2 610=3;21;4 3 ;2:0=/412>? =63=164? <9:.9 <50 A:8412 43 610=3;21;4 3 <50 0/701@/1;4>? 03>2 7? 491 23;36 B4 ;5;495 5E09B: :; 85C3/6 38 5../012
3 5;2 916 9/075;2 9:BB5==510/7B:404954.:C:>0/:48:>127?610=3;21;4
3 011E:;A21.>5654:3;:;610=1.438491=63=164?:;@/104:3;<9:.9 :0 491 0/7D1.4 B54416 38 491 :84 112 5;2 491 5>1 112 1F1./412 0/701@/1;4>? :0 04:>> =1;2:;A .3;0:21654:3; 3$#! ! $!950711;<:49265<;7?610=3;21;4
3 718361 49:0 3/64 <:49 >:7164? 43 =/60/1 491 0/:4 :;
3# $ ;>?<:495;:;41;4:3;439565005;2.316.1 491 =14:4:3;160 5 85>01 .501 950 711; 8:>12 ..362:;A>? 91 =65?0435>>3<491=14:4:3;0
& 16 .3;465 >156;12 :A9 3/64 3C16;B1;4 >15216 836 610=3;21;4
3 950 3==3012 491 =14:4:3;0 91 0/7B:40 4954 5C16B1;40 83/;2 :; 491 =6:C541 .3B=>5:;4 B5E10 3/4 5 .501 5A5:;04 491 =14:4:3;160 5;2 491 .501 :0 04:>> 54 491
- 6 -
045A1 38 :;C104:A54:3; :; 6:B1
3+ $ 4 49:0 045A1 =14:4:3;160561;341;4:4>12836491=65?16B521:;491=14:4:3;0 ..362:;A>?091=65?0432:0B:00491=14:4:3;0
! %63B 5 =16/05> 38 491 5C16B1;40 83/;2 :; 491 =6:C541 .3B=>5:;4:4:083/;24954.>5:B:0B5217?610=3;21;4
3:;
610=1.438=63=164?7156:;A? 3&$3834;336():>>5A138 5>57/65A::046:.4/;2165:8411225412$$$$&05:243 95C1 711; 1F1./412 :; 916 85C3/6 7?
B4 ;5;495 5E09B: ;2:0=/412>?05:2;5;4955E09B:9500/701@/1;4>?1F1./412 55>1112:;610=1.438491C16?05B1=63=164?:;85C3/638 5../012
35;29169/075;2"9:BB5==5/;216561A:041612 5>1 112 25412 $+$$& 91 05:2 05>1 :0 836 5 C5>/57>1 .3;0:21654:3; 38 0$#+$$$ " 95>>1;A:;A 491 61C1;/1 1;46:10B5213;7195>838491=/6.950160/;21649161A:041612 5>1 112 25412 $+$$& 610=3;21;4
3 952 8:>12 3*# $$71836149:03/64<9:.9<502:0=3012387? 49:0 3/64 .3;8:6B:;A 491 36216 38 491 1=/4? 3BB:00:3;16 25412$#$*$$<9161:;9195237016C124954491=564:10561 61@/:612 43 5A:4541 491:6 6:A940 718361 491 D/6:02:.4:3;5> :C:> 3/6445==156049544916158416610=3;21;4
39528:>12
3& $ 718361 491 D/6:02:.4:3;5> :C:> 3/64 <9:.9 <50
- 7 -
2:0B:0012 50 ;34 =610012 <:49 >:7164? 43 8:>1 5 86109 0/:4 3; #$$ 916158416 610=3;21;4 3 952 8:>12
3+ $$ 5;2 :; 491 05:2 0/:4 5; 5==>:.54:3; <50 8:>12 7? 2181;25;40 /;216 6216 />1 (5) 5;2 (2) 6152 <:49 1.4:3; & 38 43 61D1.4 491 =>5:;4 91 05:2 5==>:.54:3;
<50 5>>3<12 7? 491 3/64 38 22> 1;:36 :C:> /2A1 5>57/65A: 7? 36216 25412 !$#$ 5;2 491 =>5:;4 :;
3+ $$ <50 61D1.412 4 5==1560 4954 491 05:2 36216 38 61D1.4:3; 38 =>5:;4 :; 3+ $$ 950 5445:;12 8:;5>:4? 916158416 5 86109 0/:4 :;
3# $ 5==1560 43 95C1 711;8:>127?610=3;21;4
3<9:.9:0=1;2:;A.3;0:21654:3;
3$#! ! $!<9:.9<50=1;2:;A71836149:03/64<50 0/701@/1;4>? 2:0B:0012 50 <:49265<; 3; $$ <:49 >:7164? 43 610=3;21;4 3 9161:; 43 =6301./41
3# $ <9:.9 :0 =1;2:;A 718361 491 D/6:02:.4:3;5> 3/64 ; 491 B15;<9:>1 =6101;4 =6:C541 .3B=>5:;4 <50 8:>12 5>>1A:;A 4954 :; C:3>54:3; 38 491 :;416:B 36216 =50012 :;
3$#! ! $!61C1;/161.362038491>5;20:;@/104:3; <161865/2/>1;4>?.95;A127?5../012=1603;0
=16/05>38491B5416:5>3;61.362<3/>2A343093<4954 49161 <50 ;3 :;416:B 36216 2:61.4:;A 491 =564:10 43 B5:;45:;
- 8 -
0454/0"@/3:;
3$#! ! $!5;23;4913491695;27? 3621625412$+$+$!49:03/64:;
3$#! ! $!952 2:61.4124954.95;A1:;49161C1;/11;46:10095>>61B5:;0/7D1.4 43 491 8:;5> 3/4.3B1 38 491 <6:4 =14:4:3;
3< 4954 491 <6:4 =14:4:3; :0 2:0B:0012 50 <:49265<; <:49 >:7164? 43 610=3;21;4 3 43 =6301./41 491 0/:4 :; 3# $ :4 :0 836 610=3;21;4
3435001649166:A940:;610=1.438491=63=164? :; 2:0=/41 718361 491 .3B=141;4 :C:> 3/64 718361 <9:.9
3# $ :0 =1;2:;A 10=3;21;4
3 <93 950 5>>1A12 4954 491 5../012 =1603;0 :; C:3>54:3; 38 491 :;416:B 36216 =50012 :;
3$#! ! $! 95C1 .95;A12 491 61C1;/1 1;46:10 38 491 >5;20 :; 2:0=/41 950 /;2:0=/412>?
;34 :;:4:54125;?.3;41B=4=63.112:;A0505A5:;045../012=1603;0 836 95C:;A C:3>5412 491 :;416:B 36216 =50012 :; 3$#! ! $! 5;2 3; 491 34916 95;2 091 950 8:>12 5 =6:C541 .3B=>5:;4 0454:;A 4954 7? .6154:;A 23./B1;40 491 61C1;/1 61.3620 38 491 >5;2 :; @/104:3; <161 .95;A12 7? 5../012 =1603;0 58416 5; :;416:B 36216 <50 =50012 :;
3$#! ! $! %63B 491 5836105:2 50=1.40 38 491 B54416:4:0C16?.>15649544912:0=/41714<11;491=564:10:0 =/61>? .:C:> :; ;54/61 5;2 7? A:C:;A 5 .6:B:;5> 41F4/61 43 491
- 9 -
05B1:B=/A;12.6:B:;5>=63.112:;A0:0:;:4:54127?610=3;21;4 3;522:4:3;434915836105:21.4:3;+!3849156;545E5 5;2 1C1;/1 .4 +! =63C:210 836 =6341.4:3; 43 5../012 30#43&;216491.:6./B045;.105B384913=:;:3;4954 .3;4:;/54:3;38491:B=/A;12.6:B:;5>=63.112:;A05A5:;04491 =14:4:3;160 <3/>2 5B3/;4 43 57/01 38 =63.100 38 >5< 5;2 4916183614301./614911;2038D/04:.1:4:0;1.10056?43@/509 49105B1..362:;A>?49183>>3<:;A"
(:) 91 =14:4:3;0 561 5>>3<12 91 1;4:61=63.112:;A0 :; 6:B1
3+ $ 61A:041612 7? 659B5=/65 3>:.1 454:3; 5>57/65A: 836 491 3881;.10 =/;:0957>1 /;216 1.4:3;0 $ $ ! !* 5;2 38<9:.9:0=1;2:;A7183614913/64 38 22> :C:> /2A1 (6 ;) 5;2 % 5>57/65A: 50 5A5:;04 491 =14:4:3;160 9161:; :0 91617?@/50912
(::) 3;01@/1;4>? 491 =63.112:;A0 :;
3! $ =1;2:;A 718361 491 3/64 38 22> % 5>57/65A:5>03045;20@/50912
.-
( & '# ", #
:04
3>
3