Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10593 (KAR)

ICICI LOMBARD GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., v. SANTOSH AND ANR

MFA/201998/2017 · 2025-01-08

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $# %$!$! ! !&& '( ) *+ ! !&&" * + ! "#$#%# & ' ! ( % ! ) ! "#$#%% %)! * !! ! "#$#% & ' )+ %$% ( Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) %, '%( ) ) - .$%, - ! ) /$/%# ) "* + %)! * !! ! & ' ( % '( ! ! "#$#% ! ) ! "#$#% & ' ! )% % ( - 3 - ) ) %, '%( ) - .$%, - ! /$/%# ) - 0 - - $ '0 - -( )1%/%, 23 42567 89 :;6 <5=2>=?: =?7 )1%$%, 23 42567 89 :;6 2?3@A=?<6 <1>B=?9 81:; 862?C =CCA26D67 89 :;6 E@7C>6?: =?7 =F=A7 2? 1/$/%# B=3367 89 :;6 56=A?67 A5 6?21A 2D25 -@7C6 =?7 !=5=8@A=C2 7=:67 .$%, F;6A689 :;6 A28@?=5 ;=3 =F=A767 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? 14 3,%%." ;6 B=A:263 F1@57 86 A646AA67 :1 =3 B6A :;62A A=?G38641A6:;6A28@?=541A3=G614<1?D6?26?<6 - 4 - ;6 4=<:@=5 >=:A2H 14 :;6 <=36 =A6 :;=: 1? %%#=:=81@:$B>F;256:;6<5=2>=?:=?7;23 8A1:;6A F6A6 C12?C 1? = >1:1A<9<56 86=A2?C 6C1!" "":;6A276AF;1F=3:;68A1:;6A14:;6<5=2>=?: A6<62D67=B;1?6<=55:;6A641A6;6B=AG67:;6>1:1A<9<56 89:;6327614:;6A1=7F;256;6F=3:=5G2?C1?:;6B;1?6 :;6 1446?72?C >1:1A<9<56 86=A2?C 6C1!"""$$$% <=>6 4A1> 86;2?7 =?77=3;67 =C=2?3: :;6 D6;2<56 F;2<; F=3 B=AG67 ? :;6 3=27 =<<276?: :;6 <5=2>=?: F;1 F=3 3:=?72?C 89 :;6 3276 14 ;23 >1:1A<9<56 3@3:=2?67 2?E@A263 =?7513:=<1?3<21@3?633>>672=:659;6F=33;24:67:1 :;6 !=>=A6779 13B2:=5 !=5=8@A=C2 F;6A62? ;6 :11G :A6=:>6?:=32?B=:26?:41A7=93?:;6?6H:7=914:;6 =<<276?:=<=36F=3A6C23:6A6789;2::=B@A152<6:=:21? 2?A2>61%/%#1?:;68=32314<1>B5=2?:4256789:;6 8A1:;6A14:;6<5=2>=?: . ;6 <5=2>=?: <1?:6?767 :;=: ;6 F=3 =C67 , 96=A3 =: :;6 :2>6 14 =<<276?: 6=A?2?C 3%" B6A >1?:; 89 712?C =CA2<@5:@A6 =?7 F1AG2?C =3 = 7A2D6A 8@: 7@6 :1 :;6 2?E@A263 ;6 23 723=8567 =?7 =3 3@<; =76I@=:6 <1>B6?3=:21?>=986=F=A767:1;2> - 5 - # ;6A63B1?76?:1%:;61F?6A14:;61446?72?C D6;2<56727?1:=BB6=A763B2:636AD2<614?1:2<6 / ? 233@=?<6 14 ?1:2<6 A63B1?76?: 1 F;1 23 :;62?3@A6A14:;6D6;2<56=BB6=A67=?7425672:318E6<:21?3 ;6 2?3@A=?<6 <1>B=?9 <1?:6?767 :;=: :;6A6 23 765=9 2? 4252?C :;6 <1>B5=2?: =?7 :;6 7=>=C63 3@3:=2?67 :1 :;6 D6;2<563 71 ?1: 2?3B2A6 <1?4276?<6 :;=: :;6 1446?72?C D6;2<56F=3=5312?D15D672?:;6=<<276?:?:6A"=52=2:F=3 =531 <1?:6?767 :;=: :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? <5=2>67 23 ;2C;59 6H1A82:=?:2>=C2?=A9=?7@?:6?=856C61<<@B=:21?=?7 2?<1>614:;6<5=2>=?:23=5313@3B2<21@3 , ? :;6 8=323 14 :;6 =81D6 <1?:6?:21?3 :;6 A28@?=54A=>67:;6=BBA1BA2=:6233@63;6<5=2>=?:F=3 6H=>2?67=3%=?7:F1>672<=51442<6A3F;1=3363367 :;6723=8252:9F6A66H=>2?67=3=?7H%:1%# F6A6 >=AG67 2? :;6 6D276?<6 ;6 A63B1?76?:3 ;=D6 ?1: =77@<67=?96D276?<6 - 6 - $ 4:6A ;6=A2?C 1? 81:; :;6 32763 :;6 A28@?=5 =F=A767 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? @?76A 72446A6?: ;6=73 =3 8651F" 5 1 6=73 1>B6?3=:21? F=A767 % 1F=A73B=2?=?73@446A2?C 3%" 1F=A73513314=>6?2:263=?7 6?E19>6?:2?5246 3%" 1F=A735133144@:@A62?<1>6 3.$" . 1F=A73>672<=56HB6?363 3#." # 1F=A73=::6?7=?:J3<;=AC63 4117?1@A23;>6?:=?7 <1?D69=?<66HB6?363 3%/#" / 1F=A735133142?<1>67@A2?C B6A21714:A6=:>6?: 3," 1:=5 3,%%." ;256 <1>2?C :1 :;6 <1?<5@321? :;6 A28@?=5 ;657:;=::;6723=8252:914:;6<5=2>=?:23:1:;66H:6?:14 %$K=?72?<1>6F=33"B6A>1?:;=?7;6862?C ,96=A3:;6=BBA1BA2=:6>@5:2B526AF1@5786%, % 1F :;6 56=A?67 <1@?365 =BB6=A2?C 41A :;6 =BB655=?:2? )1%/%,F1@57<1?:6?7:;=::;6 =BB655=?:<5=2>=?: ;=7 3@3:=2?67 ;6=A2?C 2>B=2A>6?: 2? 81:; :;6 6=A3 7@6 :1 :;6 ;6=7 2?E@A263 =?7 :;6A641A6 ;6 862?C = 7A2D6A :;6 4@?<:21?=5 723=8252:9 ;=3 ?1: 866? - 7 - BA1B6A59=336336789:;6A28@?=5:23<1?:6?767:;=::;6 <5=2>=?: ;=D2?C 3@446A67 :;6 ;6=A2?C 2>B=2A>6?: ;6 23 @?=856:17A2D66442<26?:59=36=A526A32?<6;6<=??1:;6=A :;631@?73141:;6AD6;2<56364@A:;6A<1?:6?73:;=::;6 <1>B6?3=:21?=F=A76789:;6A28@?=5@?76A:;6;6=714 5133 14 =>6?2:263 2? 5246 23 =531 =893>=559 51F =?7 366G3 A6=33633>6?:14:;6<1>B6?3=:21? %% ;656=A?67<1@?365=BB6=A2?C41A:;62?3@A=?<6 <1>B=?9 F;1 23 =BB655=?: 2? )1%$%, 3@8>2:3 :;=: :;6 ?=:@A6 14 7=>=C63 :1 :;6 D6;2<563 =?7 :;6 2?D63:2C=:21? B=B6A3 F1@57 <A6=:6 71@8: =81@: :;6 2?D15D6>6?: 14 :;6 D6;2<56 6 B12?:3 1@: :;=: :;6A6 23 765=9 2? 4252?C :;6 <1>B5=2?: ;6A641A6 4=3:6?2?C :;6 52=8252:91?:;62?3@A=?<6<1>B=?9236AA1?61@364@A:;6A B12?:3 1@: :;=: :;6 A28@?=5 ;=3 =3363367 :;6 2?<1>6 14 :;6<5=2>=?:1?:;6;2C;6A3276=?7:;63=>6?6673:186 A6=3363367 % ?:;652C;:14:;6=81D63@8>23321?3:;6B12?: :;=: =A236 41A <1?3276A=:21? 23 :;=: F;6:;6A :;6 D6;2<56 2?3@A6789A63B1?76?:1F;2<;231F?6789A63B1?76?: 1%;=3<=@367:;6=<<276?: - 8 - % : 23 A656D=?: :1 ?1:6 :;=: 2? :;6 ) <56=A59 >6?:21?67 :;6 ?@>86A =?7 ?=>6 14 :;6 A276A 14 :;6 1446?72?C>1:1A<9<564<1@A36:;6A623=765=914%7=9 8@: 3@<; 765=9 23 3@442<26?:59 6HB5=2?67 2? :;6 <1>B5=2?: 2:3654;63=27<1>B5=2?:26H%F1@573;1F:;=::;6 <5=2>=?: F=3 @?<1?3<21@3 =?7 :;6A641A6 :;6 <1?<6A?67 B152<6 ;=D6 :=G6? :;6 <1>B5=2?: 4A1> :;6 8A1:;6A 14 :;6 <5=2>=?: =?7 A6C23:6A67 :;6 <=36 ;6A641A6 :;6 765=9 <=??1: 86 = CA1@?7 :1 <1?<5@76 :;=: :;6 =<<276?: 23 71@8:4@5 %. ;6 B6A@3=5 14 :;6 2?D63:2C=:21? B=B6A3 F1@57 3;1F :;=: D6;2<56 F=3 362L67 1? :;6 ?6H: 7=9 14 :;6 6H=>2?=:21? 14:;6 3=>6 89 :;6 1:1A 6;2<56?3B6<:1A ;23<=??1:86=CA1@?7:171@8::;62?D15D6>6?:14:;6 D6;2<56 2:3654 ;6 ) F=3 A6C23:6A67 1? :;6 ?6H: 7=9 14 :;6 =<<276?: =?7 :;6A641A6 24 :;6A6 23 =?9 5=<@?= 2? :;6 2?D63:2C=:21? :;=: <=??1: 86 = CA1@?7 :1 3=9 :;=: :;6 D6;2<56F=3?1:2?D15D67;6A641A6:;63@8>23321?14:;6 56=A?67 <1@?365 41A :;6 =BB655=?:"?3@A=?<6 1>B=?9 1? :;23=3B6<:<=??1:863@3:=2?67 - 9 - %# ;636<1?7=3B6<::186<1?3276A6723F;6:;6A :;6<1>B6?3=:21?=F=A76723BA1B6A=?7<1AA6<:M %/ D276?:59 :;6 7A2D2?C 52<6?<6 BA17@<67 89 :;6 <5=2>=?: =: H%. F1@57 3;1F :;=: :;6 <5=2>=?: F=3 = :A=<:1A 7A2D6A =?7 :;6A641A6 ;6=A2?C 2>B=2A>6?: ;=3 = 72A6<: 2>B=<: 1? ;23 6442<26?<9 :1 7A2D6 :;6 D6;2<56 : 23 =531A656D=?::1?1:6:;=::;6A28@?=5;=3<1?3276A67:;6 :63:2>1?9 14 3 =?7 F;1 ;=D6 3:=:67 F2:; :;6 3@BB1A: 14 :;6 723=8252:9 <6A:242<=:63 :;=: :;6A6 23 ;6=A2?C 2>B=2A>6?:2?:;6564:6=A:1:;66H:6?:14#K=?72?:;6 A2C;: 6=A :1 :;6 6H:6?: 14 .#K B=A: 4A1> :;=: :;6 <5=2>=?: ;=7 =531 3@3:=2?67 4A=<:@A6 14 A7 3;=4: 14 A2C;: <5=D2<56 ;1@C; :;6 4A=<:@A6 14 :;6 <5=D2<56 <=??1: <1?:A28@:6 :1 :;6 723=8252:9 ;6=A2?C 2>B=2A>6?: 7642?2:659 <1?:A28@:63:1:;6723=8252:9;6<5=2>=?:862?C:;67A2D6A 2:<=?3=4659863=27:;=::;6723=8252:9F1@5786#K? :;=: D26F 14 :;6 >=::6A :;6 1B2?21? 14 :;6 A28@?=5 :;=: :;6A623%$K723=8252:9=BB6=A3:1861?:;651F6A3276 - 10 - %, ;6<5=2>=?:;=3?1:BA17@<67=?9>=:6A2=5:1 3;1F:;=:;6F=36=A?2?C3%"B>;6A641A6:;6 A28@?=5;=7:1:=G6:;6?1:21?=52?<1>6:;=3:=G6?:;6 2?<1>6 =: 3" B> ;6 C@27652?63 233@67 89 :;6 !=A?=:=G=:=:66C=56AD2<63@:;1A2:92?A63B6<:14:;6 36::56>6?: 14 :;6 <5=2>3 =A232?C 1@: 14 :;6 >1:1A D6;2<56 =<<276?:3 8641A6 :;6 1G 7=5=:; BA63<A286 :;6 ?1:21?=5 2?<1>641A:;696=A%#=:3$"B>?@>B:66? ?@>86A 14 <=363 :;23 1@A: ;=3 ;657 :;=: :;6 3=27 C@27652?63233@6789:;6!=A62?C6?6A=5<1?41A>2:9 F2:; :;6 F=C63 42H67 @?76A :;6 2?2>@> =C63 <: ;6A641A6 :;6?1:21?=5 2?<1>6 14 :;6 <5=2>=?: ;=3 :1 86 <1?3276A67=:3$"B6A>1?:; %$ ;6A28@?=5;=3<1?3276A67:;6>@5:2B526A14%, 8=367 1? :;6 =C6 14 :;6 2?E@A67 =3 96=A3 ;6A641A6 :;6 3=27 >@5:2B526A =BB6=A3 :1 86 <1AA6<: =?7 :;6A6 23 ?1 723B@:62?A63B6<:14:;6>@5:2B526A - 11 - % ;6A641A6 :;6 5133 14 4@:@A6 6=A?2?C3 14 :;6 <5=2>=?: 23 <=5<@5=:67 =3 3$ H % H %, H #K N 3.$" 1?3276A2?C :;6 ?=:@A6 14 2?E@A263 B=A:2<@5=A59 :;6;6=72?E@A93@446A6789:;6<5=2>=?:2:<=?3=465986 3=27:;=:;6<1@57?1:A63@>6:1F1AG=:56=3:41A=B6A217 1432H>1?:;3;6A641A6:;65133142?<1>67@A2?C5=27@B B6A21723=3363367=:3.$" % ;6A28@?=5;=3=F=A767=3@>143%" @?76A:;6;6=714513314=>6?2:2632?5246F;2<;=BB6=A3 :1 86 1? :;6 51F6A 3276 =?7 :;6A641A6 = 3@> 14 3"23=F=A767@?76A:;23;6=7 ;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =F=A767 89 :;6 A28@?=5 @?76A :;6 A6>=2?2?C ;6=73 7163 ?1: <=55 41A =?9 2?:6A46A6?<689:;231@A:6?<6:;6<5=2>=?:236?:2:567 41A :;6 >1724267 <1>B6?3=:21? @?76A 72446A6?: ;6=73 =3 8651F - 12 - =2?=?73@446A2?C 3%" )117 =?7 ?1@A23;>6?: <1?D69=?<6 =?7=::6?7=?:<;=AC63 3%/#" 672<=56HB6?363 3#." 133 14 2?<1>6 7@A2?C :;6 5=27 @B B6A217 3.$" 133144@:@A66=A?2?C3 3.$" 13314=>6?2:2632?5246 3" 1:=5 633=F=A76789A28@?=5 ?;=?<6>6?: 3$,$." 3,%%." ,"" ;@3 :;6 B6:2:21?6A 23 6?:2:567 41A 6?;=?<67 <1>B6?3=:21? 14 3%%$#" F2:; 2?:6A63: =?7 :;6A641A6 :;6 =BB6=5 42567 89 :;6 ?3@A=?<6 1>B=?9 2? ) 1%$%, 7636AD63 :1 86 723>23367 =?7 :;6 =BB6=5 42567 89 :;6 <5=2>=?: 2? ) 1%/%, 7636AD63:186=551F672?B=A:6?<6:;641551F2?C - 13 - '2( )1%$%,23723>23367 '22( )1%/%,23=551F672?B=A: '222( ;6 2>B@C?67 E@7C>6?: =?7 =F=A7 B=3367 89 :;6A28@?=523>1724267 '2D( ;6=BB655=?:2? )1%/%,<5=2>=?: 23 6?:2:567 :1 = 3@> 14 ,"* 2? =772:21? :1 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =F=A767 89 :;6 A28@?=5:1C6:;6AF2:;2?:6A63:=:/KB=4A1> :;67=:614B6:2:21?:2552:3A6=52L=:21? 'D( ;6 =BB655=?: 2? ) 1%$%, " ?3@A=?<6 1>B=?9 23 72A6<:67 :1 76B132: :;6 6?:2A6<1>B6?3=:21?=>1@?:F2:;2?=B6A21714 32HF66G34A1>:;67=:614:;231A76A 'D2( 63: 14 :;6 1A76A B=3367 89 :;6 A28@?=5 A6>=2?3@?=5:6A67 - 14 - 'D22( ;6 =>1@?: 76B132:67 8641A6 :;23 1@A: 2? )1%$%, 23 1A76A67 :1 86 :A=?3>2::67:1:;6A28@?=5 7" '$! ) $ !-- 23:1%51./ !