Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10583 (KAR)
MALLAMMA W/O LATE SHIVRAJ KAMTHANA v. SHAMUEL @ SHAMSUNDAR AND ANR
MFA/201158/2019 · 2025-01-30
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10583 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10583 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$#
%
$! $! !!&&'
( ) *
!"#
$%% & '
"
(
)#%
!*+ & , !*!+'
# ,
%
"*"""
%%
!*"
$ %
&
,#-
"*"#*# "
% '
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.03 10:58:37 - 0800
- 2 -
, ,
".&"' ,
% %% % ,
"**** & /
'
( "#0 % , %
%%
% **#*"1
!*#*"+ ,/ ,%%
% #
,,/ % "
%% ,
2
$ &% 2
'
34563 738 9::89; <= ;<=78> ?4@ 9>A<==<4B CD 738 E4B=8B74?;89@B8>E45B=8;9::89@<B6?4@C473738:9@7<8= 738A9778@<=79F8B5:?4@?<B9;><=:4=9;
3<= 9::89; <= ><@8E78> 969<B=7 738 G5>6A8B7 9B> 9H9@> >978> **#*"1 <B
4!*#*"+ :9==8> CD ;89@B8>%@<BE<:9;<=7@<E79B> 8==<4B=5>689B>%@<BE<:9;
<>9@ &38@8<B9?78@ @8?8@@8> 74 9= I738 @<C5B9;J ?4@ =34@7'
- 3 -
# D 738 <A:56B8> G5>6A8B7 9B> 9H9@> 738 @<C5B9; 39= 9;;4H8> 738 E;9<A :87<7<4B <B :9@7 9B> 9H9@>8> 9 =5A 4? =.**** 9= E4A:8B=97<4B 9B> ><@8E78> 738 4HB8@ 4? 738 9574 @<EF=39H 74 >8:4=<7 738 =9A8
38 ?9E759; A97@<K 4? 738 E9=8 <= B47 A5E3 <B ><=:578 38 :87<7<4B8@ 9 ;9>D 968> 9C457 * D89@= 9 345=8H<?8 9B> ;9C45@8@ CD :@4?8==<4B H9= 89@B<B6 = *** :8@ A4B73 9B> =38 A87 H<73 9B 9EE<>8B7 4B *"*1#*" H3<;8 =38 H9= 7@9L8;;<B6 <B 9574 @<EF=39H C89@<B64 !*!+B89@ <>39@734;;868<>9@58 74 738 B86;<68B7 >@<L<B6 4? 738 >@<L8@ 738 9574 @<EF=39H 75@B8>75@7;8H38@8=38=5??8@8><BG5@<8=9B>H9==3<?78> 74 <=7@<E7 4=:<79; 9B> 738B 74 5@5 9B9F 4=:<79;
<>9@ 38 :87<7<4B8@ H9= 7@8978> E4B=8@L97<L8;D 9B> 39> 74 79F8 7@897A8B7 ?4@ :@4;4B68> 7<A8 9B> 738@8?4@8 =38 E;9<A8>9E4A:8B=97<4B4?="!*****?@4A7384HB8@ 9B><B=5@8@4?7389574@<EF=39H
- 4 -
! 38 :87<7<4B H9= 4::4=8> CD 738 @8=:4B>8B7= E4B78B><B6 7397 738 E4A:8B=97<4B E;9<A8> <= 3<63;D 8K4@C<79B7 9B> <A96<B9@D 9B> 738D >8B<8> 738 968 4EE5:97<4B9B><BE4A84?738:87<7<4B8@8=:4B>8B74" E4B78B>8> 7397 738 L83<E;8 H9= <B=5@8> H<73 @8=:4B>8B7 4#9B>9==5E3738;<9C<;<7D74:9D738E4A:8B=97<4B<= 74C8?9=78B8>5:4B@8=:4B>8B74#B7384738@39B> @8=:4B>8B7 4# E4B78B>8> 7397 738@8 <= L<4;97<4B 4? 8E7<4B=!9B>" *4?738474@
83<E;8=E7"1 9B> 738>@<L8@39>B4L9;<>>@<L<B6;<E8BE874>@<L897@9B=:4@7 L83<E;8 9= 4B >978 4? 738 9EE<>8B7 9B> 738@8?4@8 738 ;<9C<;<7D74:9D738E4A:8B=97<4B39=74C8?9=78B8>5:4B @8=:4B>8B74"4B;D
38@<C5B9;?@9A8>9::@4:@<978<==58=9B>9;=4 ?@9A8> 9B 9>><7<4B9; <==58 9B> 9;;4H8> 738 :9@7<8= 74 9>>5E8 738 8L<>8BE8 38 :87<7<4B8@ H9= 8K9A<B8> 9= %" 9B> K=%" 74 " H38@8 A9@F8> 8=:4B>8B7 4# 8K9A<B8>7H4H<7B8==8=9=="9B>#9B> K="741 H8@8A9@F8>
- 5 -
+ ?78@389@<B67389@65A8B7=CDC473=<>8=738 @<C5B9;9H9@>8>738E4A:8B=97<4B4?=.****74738 :87<7<4B8@= 9B> ><@8E78> @8=:4B>8B7 4" 74 >8:4=<7 738 E4A:8B=97<4B9A45B75B>8@><??8@8B7389>=9=C8;4H 8B79;964BD:9<B=5??8@<B6 =**** 4=:<79;8K:8B=8=9B> A8><E9;8K:8B=8= =#**** 778B>9B7 7@9B=:4@797<4B E39@68= 9B>4738@A<=E8;;9B845=8K:8B=8= =#*** 4== 4? 89@B<B6 9B> 38@ =8@L<E8 74 738 ?9A<;D A8AC8@= >5@<B6 738 :8@<4>4?@8=7 =" *** 479; =.****
,5@738@ 738 @<C5B9; ><=A<==8> 738 :87<7<4B 9= 969<B=7 @8=:4B>8B7 4# 9B> ><@8E78> @8=:4B>8B7 4" 4HB8@74:9D738E4A:8B=97<4B .
8<B6 966@<8L8> CD 738 =9A8 738 :87<7<4B8@ <= C8?4@8 73<= 45@7 =88F<B6 8B39BE8A8B7 4? E4A:8B=97<4B 9H9@>8>CD738@<C5B9;9=H8;;9=M58=7<4B<B6738;<9C<;<7D ?9=78B8>4B@8=:4B>8B74"
89@>738;89@B8>E45B=8;?4@7389::8;;9B79B> ;89@B8>E45B=8;?4@@8=:4B>8B74#B=5@9BE84A:9BD
- 6 -
1 89@B8> E45B=8; 9::89@<B6 ?4@ 738 9::8;;9B7 H45;> =5CA<7 7397 738 ?9=78B<B6 4? 738 ;<9C<;<7D 4B @8=:4B>8B74"<=B47:@4:8@9B>E4@@8E7=<BE8738E9=8 <=E4L8@8>CD738:@<BE<:;8=;9<>>4HBCD738:8K45@7<B 738E9=84? 8 =5CA<7= 7397 738 >@<L8@ 4? 738 9574@<EF=39H39>9L9;<>>@<L<B6;<E8BE8?4@
9B>738@8 H9= B4 B8E8==<7D ?4@ 3<A 74 4C79<B 9 ;<E8B=8 74 >@<L8 9 7@9B=:4@7L83<E;89B>738@8?4@8?9=78B<B64?738;<9C<;<7D4B @8=:4B>8B7 4" 9;4B8 <= B47 G5=7<?<9C;8 <= =8E4B> E4B78B7<4B<=7397738M59B75A4?E4A:8B=97<4B9H9@>8> CD738@<C5B9;<=4B738;4H8@=<>89B>738B975@84?738 <BG5@<8= =5=79<B8> 9@8 B47 :@4:8@;D 9::@8E<978> CD 738 @<C5B9;38@<C5B9;?9<;8>74E4A:8B=978738:87<7<4B8@ 5B>8@738389>4?;4==4?9A8B<7<8=<B;<?8=<BE8=3839> =5??8@8>?@9E75@84?:5C<E@9A5=
"* %8@ E4B7@9 ;89@B8> E45B=8; 9::89@<B6 ?4@ @8=:4B>8B7 4# ?9<@;D E4BE8>8 7397 738 :@<BE<:;8= ;9<>
1 #*".&"!' ++
- 7 -
>4HB <B 738 E9=8 4? 9@8 9::;<E9C;8 389;=4=5CA<77397<BL<8H4?738L<4;97<4B4? 738:8@A<7E4B><7<4B=738:@<BE<:;8=;9<>>4HB<B738E9=8 4? L=
! ! "" #9@89::;<E9C;8 9B> 9= =5E3 9B 4@>8@ 4? :9D 9B> @8E4L8@D 39= 74 C8 A9>8 869@><B6 M59B75A <7 <= =5CA<778> 7397 738 @<C5B9; <= G5=7<?<8> <B 9H9@><B6 9 =5A 4? =.**** 74 738:87<7<4B8@
"" :8@5=9; 4? 738 >@<L<B6 ;<E8BE8 4? @8=:4B>8B7 4" H34 9;=4 39::8B= 74 C8 738 4HB8@ 4? 738 L83<E;8 :@4>5E8> 97 K=. 9B> 9B> 9;=4 738 4@<6<B9; >@<L<B6 ;<E8BE8 97 K%" H45;> =34H 7397 @8=:4B>8B7 4" H9= 95734@<=8> 74 >@<L8 9 B4B7@9B=:4@7 L83<E;8 ?@4A
"+"#"11 74""##*" 4H8L8@738L9;<><7D74>@<L8 7387@9B=:4@7L83<E;8<89E9CH9=4B;D?@4A#*"#**" 74 ##*"#**! 38 9EE<>8B7 39L<B6 39::8B8> 4B *"*1#*"@8=:4B>8B74"H9=B4739L<B69;<E8BE874
2 &#*" '. - 8 -
>@<L8 9 7@9B=:4@7 L83<E;8 4B 7397 >9D L<>8B7;D 738 E97864@D 4? 738 L83<E;8 <= 9B 9574 @<EF=39H 738 5B;9>8B H8<6374?H3<E3<=;8==739B.**F6=38@8?4@8<BL<8H 4?738:@<BE<:;8=;9<>>4HBCD738:8K45@7<B738E9=84? <7 39= 74 C8 38;> 7397 738@8 H9= B4 =5E3 L<4;97<4B 4? 738 78@A= 9B> E4B><7<4B= 4? 738 :4;<ED8=:4B>8B74"H9=95734@<=8>74>@<L87389574 @<EF=39H 9B> 738@8?4@8 738 ;<9C<;<7D 39= 74 C8 ?9=78B8> 5:4B@8=:4B>8B74#B=5@9BE84A:9BD
"# 38=8E4B>9=:8E7H3<E39??8E7=738M58=7<4B4? ;<9C<;<7D<=@869@><B6738L<4;97<4B4?738:8@A<7E4B><7<4B= 38 @<C5B9; 39= @<637;D @8;<8> 5:4B 738 G5>6A8B7 4? 738 :8K 45@7 <B 738 E9=8 4? H38@8<B <7 <= 38;> 7397 <? 738@8 <= L<4;97<4B 4? 738 :8@A<7 E4B><7<4B= 738 <B=5@8@ <= ;<9C;8 74 :9D 738 E4A:8B=97<4B 9B> 738B <= 97 ;<C8@7D 74 @8E4L8@ 738 =9A8 ?@4A 738 <B=5@8> 38@8?4@8 @8=:4B>8B7 4# <= ;<9C;8 74 :9D 738 E4A:8B=97<4B74738:87<7<4B8@9B>738B@8E4L8@738=9A8 ?@4A@8=:4B>8B74"4HB8@4?738L83<E;8
- 9 -
" 4A<B6 74 738 M59B75A 4? E4A:8B=97<4B 738 @<C5B9; 39= >8>5E78> E8@79<B 9A45B7 8L8B 734563 738 @8E8<:7=?4@A8><E9;8K:8B=8=H8@8:@4>5E8>B9E9@8?5;
8K9A<B97<4B 4?
738 @8E8<:7= :@4>5E8> <7 E9BB47 C8 =9<> 7397738D9@8738?9F8@8E8<:7=34563738:87<7<4B8@H9= 9>A<778> 74 5@5 9B9F 4=:<79; =38 A<637 39L8 79F8B 738 A8><E<B8= ?@4A L9@<45= 4738@ :39@A9E<8= 38@8?4@8 738 4C=8@L97<4B 4? 738 @<C5B9; 7397 E8@79<B C<;;= 9@8 B47 :8@A<==<C;8 E9BB47 C8 9EE8:78> 7 <= :8@7<B8B7 B478 7397 7387479;A8><E9;C<;;=:@4>5E8>CD738:87<7<4B8@9EE@58> ?4@ 9C457 =*** 38@8?4@8 738 =9A8 39= 74 C8 9H9@>8> 74 738 :87<7<4B8@ 5B>8@ 738 389> 4? A8><E9; 8K:8B=8=
"! 38:87<7<4B8@39>=5??8@8>E57;9E8@978>H45B> 4B 738 ?4@8389> 9B> ?@9E75@8 4? @<637 =5:8@<4@ :5C<E @9A5=34563738:87<7<4B8@39>E4B78B>8>7397=3839> 5B>8@64B8 =5@68@D 738 B975@8 4? 738 7@897A8B7 H9= E4B=8@L97<L8 9B> 738@8 H8@8 B4 =5@68@<8= 3<= 9=:8E7 <= 9;=4 4C=8@L8> CD 738 @<C5B9; <B >879<; 38@8?4@8 H38B
- 10 -
738@8 9@8 7H4 <BG5@<8= <8 4B8 =<A:;8 9B> 9B4738@ 6@<8L45= 738 9H9@> 4? =**** 74H9@>= :9<B 9B> =5??8@<B69::89@=74C84B738;4H8@=<>89B>738=9A8<= 8B39BE8>74=!****
" 38 :87<7<4B8@ <= 968> * D89@= 9 345=8H<?8 9B> 738 @<C5B9; 39= 9H9@>8> 9 =5A 4? =" *** 74H9@>= ;4== 4? 89@B<B6 9B> 38@ =8@L<E8 74 738 ?9A<;D A8AC8@=38B47<4B9;<BE4A8E4B=<>8@8>CD738@<C5B9;
9::89@= 74 C8 4B 738 ;4H8@ =<>8 739B 738 H968= ?<K8> 5B>8@ 738 <B<A5A 968= E7 38@8?4@8 738 =9A8 <= E4B=<>8@8>97= ***KN=#!***
"+ 38@<C5B9;39=9H9@>8>9=5A4?=#*** 4B;D74H9@>= 9778B>9B7 7@9B=:4@797<4BE39@68= 9B>4738@ A<=E8;;9B845= 8K:8B=8= 8L8B 734563 738 :87<7<4B8@ H9= <B:97<8B7?4@9C457?<L8>9D=79::89@=7397738@<C5B9;
39= E4B=<>8@8> 738 <B:97<8B7 7@897A8B7 97 5@5 9B9F 4=:<79;4B;D38@8?4@8<7H45;>C89::@4:@<978749H9@> 9=5A4?=***5B>8@73<=389>
- 11 -
". 38 @<C5B9; 39= B47 9H9@>8> 9BD E4A:8B=97<4B5B>8@738389>4?;4==4?9A8B<7<8=<B;<?8 CL<45=;D 738 :87<7<4B8@ 39= B47 E;9<A8> 9BD ><=9C<;<7D 38@8?4@8 =38 39= 74 C8 E4A:8B=978> 9>8M5978;D 5B>8@ 738389>4?;4==4?9A8B<7<8=<B;<?8F88:<B6<BL<8H7397 =38<=64<B674=5??8@738<BG5@D?4@738@8=74?38@;<?89B> =38 C8<B6 968> 9C457 * D89@= 8BE8 9 =5A 4? =****<=9H9@>8>5B>8@73<=389>
" 38@8?4@8 738 9::8;;9B7 <= 8B7<7;8> ?4@ 738 A4><?<8>E4A:8B=97<4B5B>8@><??8@8B7389>=9=C8;4H 8B79;964BD:9<B9B>=5??8@<B6 =!**** 4=:<79; 8K:8B=8= 9B> A8><E9; 8K:8B=8= =*** 778B>9B7 7@9B=:4@797<4B E39@68= 9B>4738@A<=E8;;9B845=8K:8B=8= =*** 4== 4? 89@B<B6 9B> 38@ =8@L<E8 74 738 ?9A<;D A8AC8@= >5@<B6 738 :8@<4>4?@8=7 =#!*** 4==4?9A8B<7<8= =**** 479; 8==9H9@>8>CD@<C5B9; B39BE8A8B7 ="!*** =.**** +,
35= 738 9::8;;9B7 <= 8B7<7;8> ?4@ 8B39BE8> E4A:8B=97<4B 4?
=+!*** H<73 <B78@8=7 9B> 738@8?4@8
- 12 -
738 9::89; >8=8@L8= 74 C8 9;;4H8> <B :9@7 8BE8 738 ?4;;4H<B6
&<'389::89;<=9;;4H8><B:9@7
&<<' 38 <A:56B8> G5>6A8B7 9B> 9H9@> :9==8> CD 738 @<C5B9; <= A4><?<8> CD 9H9@><B6 9 =5A 4? +,<B9>><7<4B74H39739=C88B9H9@>8>CD738 @<C5B9;7468738@H<73<B78@8=797+0:9?@4A738>9784? :87<7<4B7<;;<7=@89;<O97<4B &<<<' 8=:4B>8B7 4# B=5@9BE8 4A:9BD <= ><@8E78>74>8:4=<77388B7<@8E4A:8B=97<4B9A45B7H<73<B 9:8@<4>4?=<KH88F=?@4A738>9784?73<=4@>8@9B>738B @8E4L8@738=9A8?@4A@8=:4B>8B74" &<L'8=74?7384@>8@:9==8>CD738@<C5B9;@8A9<B= 5B9;78@8>
> '
$! ) $
<=74" ;4!+