- 1 - !! " !#$#% & '$"$ (' ) ! " # $ $% ! & $ ! '( ) Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - & & ) '' '( " # $% ) ) * !+ , $ & & , ) , ' ) ) - & & ! ./0/1/203245627 724./168/714./ 0064672386968&:0;/320& 36<.:=3=/>/17=/4.65 7:=4<.388/2;62;327=0/=034/0!+>?@.6<.32 3AA86<34672 168/0 >? 4./B :20/= =0/= $ :8/ 71 4./ 70/716968=7</0:=/@35=/C/<4/0 ./ 5:64 62 7 @35 168/0 17= /C/<4B/24714./0/1/2032451=7B4./5:64A=7A/=4?32017= - 3 - B/52/ A=71645 34 4./ =34/ 71 5 A/= B724. ./ 5:64 @35>35/0 724./ <724/246724.34 4./ A83624611 @35 3 4=:54=/;654/=/0623<<7=032</@64.83@3204.3464@354./ 7@2/= 71 4./ A=7A/=4? >/3=62; ?75 320 +' 71 3BA:=96883;/36<.:=38:D3/1/203247@3538573 4=:540:8?=/;654/=/032064536B53207>C/<469/5 A=7960/017=6BA3=462;/0:<34672./A83624611<836B/04.34 562</ 645 36B5 320 7>C/<45 320 4./ 36B5 320 7>C/<45 71 0/1/203247@/=/56B683=643887@/00/1/20324762 4./ 5:64 A=7A/=4? 35 3 4/2324 62 4/=B5 71 3 8/35/ 0//0 034/0 ./ 8/35/ /EA6=/0 72 +(! 320 27 54/A5 @/=/ 43D/2 17= =/2/@38 71 4./ 8/35/ 4 @35 388/;/0 4.34 4./0/1/203245 @/=/ 6==/;:83= 62 A3?B/24 71 B724.8? =/245 320 5/9/=38 <./F:/5 655:/0 >? 4./B @/=/ 065.727=/0./A836246114./=/17=/4/=B6234/04./4/232<? 320<388/0:A724./0/1/20324547F:643200/869/=93<324 A755/55672 320 72 4./? 136862; 47 <7BA8? @64. 4./ 2746</ 0/B320 4./ 6254324 5:64 @35 168/0 17= /C/<4B/24 320 17= =/<79/=?71B/52/A=71645 - 4 - + ./5:64@35<724/54/0>?4./0/1/203245@.7 0/26/04./<725464:4672714./A836246113534=:54./?3857 0/26/0 4.34 4./ 17:20/= 4=:54// .30 <=/34/0 4./ 4=:54 62 4/=B57130//0034/0' ((+./?3857<836B/04.34 4./8/35/<=/34/0@35274623<<7=032</@64.83@3204./? <724/20/04.343<69685:64@35168/0>?4./74./=4=:54//5 3;36254 4./ A/=572 @.7 <836B/0 47 >/ 4./ B323;62; 4=:54//714./A83624611627(' 4388/;/04.34 4./ 8/35/ 62 1397:= 71 0/1/20324 7 @35 /E/<:4/0 @64.7:4 4./ <725/24 71 4./ 74./= 4=:54//5 320 3;36254 624/=/54714./4=:54 43857<836B/04.344./A/=572@.7 <836B/0 47 >/ 4./ B323;62; 4=:54// 71 4./ A83624611 4=:54 .30 B65:5/0 4./ =/24 320 388/;/0 4.34 ./ .30 27 620/A/20/24 =6;.4 79/= 4./ 4=:54 A=7A/=4? ./? 3857 0/26/0 4.34 3 <35/ @35 168/0 62 65</8832/7:5 /464672 7 (>/17=/4./7:=46232;387=/17==/B793871 ==3>.3D3= 4<724/20/04.344./ 323;62;=:54// ==3>.3D3=.30:5:=A/04./7116</714./ 323;62; =:54// 320 @35 3 5/81 54?8/0 323;62; =:54// 4 3857 <724/20/04.344./4=:54@35<=/34/0>?72/ = 3883AA3 - 5 - 62;3AA3 388:= 320 64 @35 4./=/314/= 3B/20/0 >? 3 5:AA8/B/243=? 0//0 72 !'(( ./=/314/= = 3883AA3 388:= =/46=/0 320 262/ B7=/ 4=:54//5 @/=/ 30B644/0 @.6<. @35 /960/2</0 >? 3 4=:54 0//0 034/0 ./=/17=/ 64 @35 <724/20/0 4.34 4./ 5360 3883AA3 388:= <7:80 274 .39/ /E/<:4/0 3274./= =/<725464:4672 0//0 72 +'+ >? @.6<. 169/ 2/@ 4=:54//5 @/=/ 300/0 62<8:062; = =3>.3D3= ./ 0/1/203245 30B644/0 4./ 4/232<? >:4 <724/20/0 4.34 4./ 8/35/ @35 <=/34/0 62 967834672 71 /<4672 71 4./ 3=2343D3 320 /17=B5 <4 320 4.34 64 65 728? 4./320 =6>:238<725464:4/0:20/=4./A=79656725714./3=2343D3 320/17=B5<44.343872/.354./C:=6506<4672474=?4./ 065A:4/ 320 274 4./ 6968 7:=4 4 3857 <724/20/0 4.34 64 @3534/2324:20/=4./A83624611624/=B57138/35/0//0 17=3A/=670714.=//?/3=5320314/=4./83A5/ 714./5360A/=67064=/F:/54/0 ==3>.3D3=47/E4/20 4./ 8/35/ A/=670 320 4.34 4./ 5360 = =3>.3D3= /E4/20/04./8/35/A/=67017=+?/3=51=7B+( 47 7@/9/=./4./=/314/=<.32;/0.65B620320 - 6 - =/;654/=/0 64 17= 728? 4.=// ?/3=5 )64. 4./5/ 320 74./= <724/246725 4./ 0/1/203245 0/26/0 4./ <836B 71 4./ A83624611 ! 35/0 72 4./5/ <724/246725 4./ =638 7:=4 1=3B/0655:/53205/407@24./<35/17=4=63814/=) @35/E3B62/0320@./24./5:64@355/407@217=1:=4./= <=755/E3B6234672 32 3AA86<34672 @35 168/0 >? 4./ 0/1/203245:20/==0/=$ :8/714762<7=A7=34/ 4./17887@62; ! " # $ %&' %(')%%& " *+ *" "* " " - 7 - ,-. $)/'%)')%%) .-" . * * " !" $%&'%(')%%& * . - * .0 1 02 34,00, 1 + 43, 40 40.0 1 ,50 43,00 0046 ,0# 1 204, 1 .06400#40 40.0#00# )/'%)')%%)27 67 ,408 ,040# 7011 60 1408 ,449 %&'%/')%%& " * - . " + %&'%/')%%&* 2, - . " * / " * )/'%&')%%) - 8 - * * , , **)/'%&' )%%)" %&'%/')%%& :,;6:: . " -. ")/'%&')%%) * * : 6 . " " # %&'%/')%%& " : "" *" " : 6 ; * . " " *"< - 9 - :6 " " 4 " 4' # %='%/')%)= < * < < * 4 ,;5 : 6 * . >*< . ? * <*"" "*" * < " @"": "" * " *" * < 1"4'6 # A : 6 $ - 10 - %='%/')%)= < .5,'B'%%%&)')%%)=')%)) 9: B 6# .5,#/C= ,'4 .*9 < *< 4 >*< < " * <*D .65 3AA86<34672 @35 7AA75/0 >? 4./ A83624611 @.7<724/20/04.344./3B/20B/2457:;.417=@35@.788? :22/</553=?17=30C:06<34672714./065A:4/3204.3464@35 0/56;2/047A=74=3<44./A=7<//062;5 ' ./=6387:=4624/=B5714./6BA:;2/07=0/= ./80 4.34 4./ 5:64 65 168/0 62 4./ ?/3= 320 4.34 4./ 0/1/203245 060 274 5.7@ 32? ;770 =/3572 35 47 @.34 A=/9/24/04./B1=7B16862;4./3AA86<3467217=3B/20B/24 >/17=/ 4./ 655:/5 @/=/ 1=3B/0 4 3857 ./80 4.34 4./ 0/1/203245 @/=/ >7:20 47/543>865. 4.34 0/5A64/ /E/=<65/ 71 0:/ 0686;/2</ 4./? <7:80 274 5//D 4./ 3B/20B/24 34 4./ /3=86/54 A7624 71 46B/ ./ =638 7:=4 4.:5 =/C/<4/0 4./ 3AA86<34672 62 4/=B5 71 4./ 6BA:;2/0 7=0/= /62; - 11 - 3;;=6/9/0 @64. 4./ 5360 7=0/= 4./ 0/1/203245 3=/ >/17=/ 4.657:=4624.65@=64A/464672 /3=2/0<7:25/817=4./0/1/203245<724/20/04.34 4./ A836246115 624/20 47 >=62; 72 =/<7=0 4./ 138564? 71 3 =/<725464:4/00//05/4:A>?4./57271 ==3>.3D3=23B/0 =:A/5.@.7A:=A7=4/08?@35620:<4/03534=:54//62 4/=B5 71 3 =/<725464:4/0 0//0 034/0 / 5:>B6454.344.//E/<:4672714./=/<725464:4/00//0@353 5:>5/F:/24 13<4 @.6<. @35 274 @64.62 4./ 2746</ 320 D27@8/0;/714./0/1/2032453204./=/17=/4./=6387:=4 B:54.39/A/=B644/04./0/1/20324547A8/304.6513<4 4./8/3=2/0<7:25/817=4./A83624611 <724/20/04.344./0/1/203245.39/274065A:4/04.344./? @/=/ 620:<4/0 6247 4./ 5:64 A=7A/=4? 62 4/=B5 71 3 8/35/ 0//0 0:8? =/;654/=/0 / <724/205 4.34 4./ 0/1/203245 .39/3857274065A:4/04./13<44.34 ==3>.3D3=@.7 @35 4./ /3=86/= B323;62; 4=:54// .35 /E/<:4/0 3 8/35/ 0//0 62 4./6= 1397:= 35 B323;62; 4=:54// / 4./=/17=/ <724/2054.34@.34/9/=6557:;.447>/A8/30/0>?@3?71 - 12 - 32 3B/20B/24 65 38=/30? 4./=/ 62 4./ @=644/2 5434/B/24 168/0 >? 4./ 0/1/203245 / 5:>B645 4.34 4./ 5:>5/F:/24 =/<725464:4672314/=4./0/34.71 ==3>.3D3=3204./ 620:<467271.65572 =:A/5.07/5274384/=4./0//0 320 <32274 311/<4 4./ 5:64 168/0 ./=/17=/ ./ <724/205 4.34 4./ 3B/20B/24 57:;.4 17= 65 274 2/</553=? 17= 4./ A:=A75/ 71 30C:06<34672 71 4./ 5:64 /560/5 4.65 ./ <724/2054.34383=;/A7=4672714./3B/20B/2457:;.417= 653=/A/464672714./A8/3062;538=/30?72=/<7=03204./ 0/1/203245 .39/ 168/0 4./ 3AA86<34672 728? 47 A=74=3<4 4./ A=7<//062;5320D//A4./8646;346723869//5:>B6454.34 62 96/@ 71 4./ A=79657 47 =0/= $ :8/ 71 27 3B/20B/24<32>/3887@/0314/=655:/53=/1=3B/0:28/55 4./ A3=4? 5//D62; 3B/20B/24 65 3>8/ 47 /543>865. 4.34 0/5A64//E/=<65/710:/0686;/2</./7=5./<7:802745//D 17=4./3B/20B/24344.//3=86/54A76247146B/ ( .39/<72560/=/04./5:>B6556725B30/>?4./ 8/3=2/0 <7:25/8 17= 4./ A83624611 320 4./ 8/3=2/0 <7:25/8 17=4./0/1/203245 - 13 - ./ 5:64 65 168/0 17= /C/<4B/24 72 4./ A=/B65/ 4.344./A=7A/=4?>/872;5474./A836246114=:543204.3464 620:<4/0 4./ 0/1/203245 35 3 4/2324 62 4/=B5 71 3 8/35/ 0//0 0:8? =/;654/=/0 ./ 0/1/203245 060 274 065A:4/ 4./ 13<44.344./5:64A=7A/=4?>/872;/0474./4=:543203857 4.3464@35620:<4/03534/2324:20/=4./4=:540//00:8? =/;654/=/0 ./ 0/1/203245 .39/ 43D/2 3 B:4:388? 0/54=:<469/ A8/3 62 4./6= @=644/2 5434/B/24 ).68/ 72 4./ 72/ .320 4./? <724/20/0 4.34 = =3>.3D3= @35 3 54=32;/= 47 4./ 4=:54 320 4.34 ./ @35 274 620:<4/0 35 3 4=:54// >:4 72 4./ 74./= .39/ <836B/0 4.34 4./ 5360 ==3>.3D3=.30/E/<:4/0 3 8/35/ 0//0 621397:=71 4./ 0/1/203245 7@ >? 96=4:/ 71 32 3AA86<34672 168/0 >? 4./ 0/1/203245 :20/= =0/= $ :8/ 71 4./ 0/1/203245 5//B 47 =/64/=34/ @.34/9/= 4.34 @35 38=/30? 5434/0 62 4./ @=644/2 5434/B/24 ./ 728? 2/@ 5434/B/24 4.346557:;.447>/62<7=A7=34/0624./@=644/25434/B/24 65 =/;3=062; 4./ 138564? 71 4./ =/<725464:4/0 4=:54 0//0 034/0 62 4/=B5 71 @.6<. 4./ 572 71 = =3>.3D3= @35 620:<4/0 35 3 4=:54// @.7 @35 - 14 - <720:<462;4./ 8646;3467272 >/.381 714./ 4=:5455434/0 3>79/4./3AA86<34672168/017=3B/20B/24714./@=644/2 5434/B/24 65 =/A8/4/ @64. 4./ 13<45 @.6<. 3=/ 38=/30? 5434/0 62 4./ @=644/2 5434/B/24 320 4./=/17=/ @/=/ 274 =/388?2/</553=?17=4./A:=A75/71<72560/=62;4./5:6472 B/=6455=/;3=054./=/F:/54714./0/1/20324547A/=B64 4./B47A8/303>7:44./138564?71 4./=/<725464:4/00//0 034/04.34477B3?2743=65/17=<72560/=34672 562</ 4./ 0/1/203245.30 30B644/04.34 = =3>.3D3= .30 /E/<:4/0 3 8/35/ 0//0 62 1397:= 71 4./ 0/1/203245 @.6<. 4./=/>? B/324 4.34 = =3>.3D3= @35 3857 3 4=:54//:20/=4./=/<725464:4/00//0320:A72.650/B65/ .65572.35>//2620:<4/03534=:54//./=6387:=4.35 <3=/1:88? <72560/=/0 4./ A8/3062;5 72 =/<7=0 320 .35 =6;.48?./804.344./3AA86<34672650/56;2/047A=74=3<44./ A=7<//062;5320D//A4./8646;34672386D/./=6387:=4 @35 4./=/17=/ C:54616/0 62 .78062; 4.34 4./ 3B/20B/24 57:;.417=@35274320<32274>/3887@/03564 1/8817:8714./A=79657477=0/=$ :8/71 - 15 - ./ =/8632</ A83</0 >? 4./ 8/3=2/0 <7:25/8 17= 4./A/464672/=5624./<35/71 3204./C:0;B/24714.65 7:=4624./<35/71 ! " 3=/ <8/3=8? 065462;:65.3>8/7213<45./C:0;B/24=/86/0:A72>?4./ A/464672/=62 4./A/E7:=4@35 <72560/=62;35/47113<45@./=/72/714./0/1/203245.30 57:;.4 47 A83</ 72 =/<7=0 3 =/8/9324 320 <=:<638 13<4 =/;3=062; 620/A/20/24 /543>865.B/24 71 >:562/55 35 @/88 35 4./ =/862F:65.B/24 /E/<:4/0 @.6<. 13<4 @35 =/<7=0/0 >/17=/4./3=>64=347= 24.34<6=<:B5432</4./:88/2<. 71 4./ 72G>8/ A/E 7:=4 ./80 4.34 4./ 3AA86<34672 17= 3B/20B/247:;.447.39/>//23887@/0354./53B/@35 =/8/9324 17= 4./ A:=A75/ 71 0/<6062; 4./ 065A:4/ >/4@//2 4./ A3=46/5 2 57 13= 35 4./ C:0;B/24 71 3 77=06234/ /2<. 71 4.65 7:=4 62 4.65 7:=4 ./804.344./0/1/2032465/24648/047=365/384/=234/A8/35 "#$!%! & '(# ") "#* "+* - 16 - 7=/9/262<725654/24A8/35@.6<.624./6254324<35/65274 4./ 564:34672 ./=/17=/ >74. 4./ C:0;B/245 =/86/0 :A72 >?4./8/3=2/0<7:25/817=4./0/1/203245652743AA86<3>8/ 47 4./ 13<4 564:34672 62 4.65 <35/ 320 ./2</ 4./ A/464672 83<D5B/=6432065 62</4./5:6465168/0624./?/3=4./=638 7:=4 65 =/F:/54/0 47 065A75/ 711 4./ 5:64 35 /3=8? 35 A7556>8/320623<<7=032</@64.4./3=2343D3#35/87@ 323;/B/2462:>7=06234/7:=45%:8/5 + 6>/=4? 65 =/5/=9/0 47 4./ 0/1/203245 47 F:/54672 4./ 6BA:;2/0 7=0/= 62 32 3AA/38 4.34 B3? >/ 168/03;3625432?C:0;B/244.34B3?>/A355/0 "*+ ($) $! 654787+