Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10552 (KAR)

JAGANNATH S/O GUNDAPPA v. MIRZA KAISAR BAIG AND ANR

MFA/201374/2019 · 2025-01-27

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " !#$# % $" $" ""&&' ( ) *+ ""&& * + ! "# $ ! % #& #& '' ( %))## # (( # %%*) # %+) ! "# # ( , %$ LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.29 10:34:08 - 0800 - 2 - #( ( %-) "%$ ( # # ( # # # + +%- %)+)+%. * + ! " $ ! % #& #& ' ( %))## # (( # %%*) # %+ ! " # ( , %$ - 3 - #( ( %-) "%$ ( # # ( # # # ) +% %)+)+%. # ( ( # # /# # $! " /# # $ 01 2134345617 46 # 5 + +%- 869 # 5 ) +%- :146; 8;;741<19 := 301 >?9;@163 869 8A879 28BB19 := 301 C187619 99C 16457 4<4C ?9;1 869 # 8C8:?78;4 98319 %) +) +% 871 :1D571 304B 5?73B11E46;16086F1@1635D301F5@216B83456 + 1879 301 C187619 F5?6B1C D57 301 8221CC863B 86930171B25691635 G46B?786F1F5@286= - 4 - +) 01 F563163456B 5D 301 8221CC863B 871 3083 301 8221CC863B 017146 A05 871 301 2134345617B :1D571 301 74:?68CA171275F11946;5687?4B1711256+) +' +% 838:5?3++2 @ 5604382?7894758930147<104FC1 A8B 043 := 577= :18746; 1; 5 )%- A017146 301=089B?B38461946>?741B BB?F0301=822758F019301 74:?68CB11E46;F5@216B83456D75@3015A61786946B?717 5D3015DD16946;577= +' 01 21343456B A8B 5225B19 := 301 71B2569163 5 46B?786F1 F5@286= 8C561 B46F1 301 71B2569163 5 %71@846191H28731 0171B25691635 46B?786F1 F5@286= F56316919 3083 301 F5@216B83456 FC84@19 4B 04;0C=1H57:438634@8;4687=869?63168:C1 01974<175D 301 C577= 089 <45C8319 301 317@B 869 F56943456B 5D 301 25C4F= + 01 74:?68C D78@19 82275274831 4BB?1B 530 301 2134345617B C19 F5@@56 1<4916F1 01 2134345617 46 # 5 + +%- 8;8668308 A8B 1H8@4619 8B % - 5 - 869 301 2134345617 46 # 5 ) +%- 4308C A8B 1H8@46198B ) 01= 08<1 1H8@4619 8653017 A4361BB 8B 869301@194F8C5DD4F17B8B '35869H % 35H )+A171@87E19463011<4916F1 0171B2569163B 949653C18986=1<4916F1 + D317 018746; :530 301 B491B 301 74:?68C 08B 8A87919F5@216B8345646:530301B121343456B8B:1C5A (,* C 5 189B 5@216B83456 A87919 % 846869?DD1746; B ++++ 33169863F087;1BD559869 F56<1=86F1F087;1B B '+++ ) 5BB5DD?3?7146F5@1 B -).++ ' #194F8CH216943?71 B ++ 5BB5D46F5@19?746;37183@163 B -+++ 5BB5D8@164341B8696?3743456 D559 B %++++ 538CF5@216B83456 B %-)'++ - 6 - (,* C 5 189B 5@216B83456 A87919 % 846869?DD1746; B )++++ 33169863F087;1BD559869 F56<1=86F1F087;1B B ++ ) 5BB5DD?3?7146F5@1 B %%+++ ' #194F8CH216943?71 B )'%++ 5BB5D46F5@19?746;37183@163 B %'+++ 5BB5D8@164341B8696?3743456 D559 B %+++ - (57@194F8C1H216943?71B B %++++ 538CF5@216B83456 B )++ +- 146;8;;741<19:=301B849F5@@56>?9;@163 301 2134345617 46 # 5 + +%- 08B 822758F019 304B 5?73 46 #( 5 +%)-' +%. 869 301 2134345617 46 # 5 ) +%- 08B 822758F019 304B 5?73 46 #( 5 +%)-) +%. - 7 - + 01 C187619 F5?6B1C 82218746; D57 301 8221CC863B 46 :530 301B1 @83317B B?:@43B 3083 301 F5@216B83456 8A87919 := 301 74:?68C 4B 56 301 C5A17 B491 0174:?68C17719468BB1BB46;3016534568C46F5@1 8BA1CC8B8227527483194B8:4C43= +. 17 F56378 301 C187619 F5?6B1C 82218746; D57 301 71B2569163 5 46B?786F1 F5@286= 91D16F1 301 4@2?;619301>?9;@163F56316946;3083301F5@216B83456 8A879194B>?B3869275217 %+ 217?B8C 5D 301 748C 5?73 71F579B A5?C9 71<18C3083301D8F35D3018FF49163869301F5<178;15D301 5DD16946; <104FC1 := 301 46B?786F1 25C4F= 4BB?19 := 301 71B2569163 5 4B 653 46 94B2?31 3 4B 56C= 301 8BB1BB@1635D301F5@216B83456A04F04B?7;19:1D571304B 5?73B11E46;718BB1BB@1635D301B8@1 - 8 - %% 301 2134345617 8;866830 089 B?B384619 D78F3?71 5D 74;03 :59= 5D @8694:C1A430D78F3?719B=@204B4B5D@8694:C1:530D4H19 A430 2C831 869 BF71AB 91B2431 5D A04F0 301= 71@84619 @8C?64319 3A8B3718319A430#(A430 ( % HF123304B46>?7=30171A171655301746>?741B A04F0 A171 D5?69 82873 D75@ 53017 B4@2C1 46>?741B 5A1<17301A5?69F1734D4F83183H 95653B05A301 D78F3?71 5D 301 @8694:C1 :?3 43 B05AB C1D3 B4919 2C1?78C 304FE1646;A4302C1?78C 1DD?B456 A04F0 4B 8 B4@2C1 46>?7= 6 217?B8C 5D 301 8:5<1 46>?741B F5?2C19 A430 301 31B34@56= 5D 301 @194F8C 5DD4F17 A05 089 8BB1BB19 301 94B8:4C43= B 217 94B8:4C43= F1734D4F831 A04F0 4B 83 H . A5?C9B05A3083301714B894B8:4C43=5D%+I35%I5D301 74;03@8694:C1@?BFC18693013538C94B8:4C43= 4B8BB1BB19 83+I35I5D301A05C1:59= %) 04B5?734B?68:C1358FF123301F5631634565D 301 C187619 F5?6B1C 82218746; D57 301 8221CC863 3083 301 94B8:4C43= 8BB1BB19 := 301 74:?68C 83 % )79 8B B38319 := - 9 - ' 4B 46F5771F3 :?3 30171 A5?C9 :1 04;017 D?6F34568C 94B8:4C43= <49163C= 301 2134345617 8;866830 FC84@B 3083 01 4B 86 8;74F?C3?74B3 := 275D1BB456 8;19 8:5?3 =187B 8694665A8=301D78F3?715D301@8694:C1A5?C9F5@146 301 A8= 5D 04B 187646; F828F43= 01 46>?7= A5?C9 56C= 8DD1F304BF01A46;F828F43=869653046;1CB1A5?C9F5@146 301A8=5D04BD?6F34568C8:4C43=35A57E8B868;74F?C3?74B3 0171D571A016301714B652755D5D46F5@13012134345617 4B16343C19D57F5@216B8345656C=D576534568C46F5@1 %' 01 ;?491C461B 4BB?19 := 301 D57 B133C1@163 5D 94B2?31B :1D571 5E98C830 271BF74:19 8 6534568C 46F5@1 5D B -+ 217 @5630 D57 301 =187 +% 6 ?@23116 6?@:17 5D >?9;@163B 304B 5?73 08B 01C9 3083 301 ;?491C461B 4BB?19 := 301 871 46 ;16178C F56D57@43= A430 301 A8;1B D4H19 ?6917 301 #464@?@ 8;1B F3 0171D571 301= 871 8FF1238:C1 16F1 301 6534568C 46F5@1 5D 301 2134345617B 871 F56B491719 83 B -+ 16F1 301 4B F8CF?C8319 8B B -+ H % H %% H I J !"#:=38E46;8@?C342C4175D%%D573018;15D =187B - 10 - % 0174:?68C08B8A87919301F5@216B834565D B -+++ 35A879B $% &$ ' ' $ 01 B849 F5@216B83456 6119B 35 :116086F19 35 !(#3718346;B?F0C849?22174598B+@5630B % 01 74:?68C 08B 8A87919 718B568:C1 F5@216B83456 8@5?63 35A879B )& &$ %! &$& *&%! $ &$ +,& *&%! &$& *&%! $ &$ +,& *&%! $& -'$ &$ & &$ $ 01B8@16119653:194B3?7:19 %- 0171D571 301 2134345617 4B 16343C19 D57 3538C 16086F19 F5@216B83456 5D B .+++ ?6917 301 D5CC5A46;0189B C 5 189B 5@216B83456 A87919 % 846869?DD1746; B ++++ 33169863F087;1BD559869 F56<1=86F1F087;1B B '+++ ) 5BB5DD?3?7146F5@1 B .'++ ' #194F8CH216943?71 B ++ 5BB5D46F5@19?746;37183@163 B %-++ 5BB5D8@164341B8696?3743456 D559 B %++++ 538CF5@216B83456 1BBA87919:=30174:?68C B +'++ B %-)'++ 538C6086F1@163 B .+++ - 11 - % 301 2134345617 4308C FC84@B 04@B1CD 35 :1 86 8;74F?C3?74B3 869 8;19 8:5?3 % =187B 1 089 B?DD1719 D78F3?71 5D 301 57:43 K=;5@834F D78F3?71 68B8C :561 D78F3?71 @8694:?C87 D78F3?71 869 D75638CD57A04F0H78=869F865D:7846A8B9561 A04F0 B05A19 D78F3?71 5D 68B8C :561 869 @8694:?C87 D78F3?71 01H )A5?69F1734D4F83186930194BF087;1 B?@@87=83H 'A5?C99124F3301B8@1 5A1<17301 7 #8CC4E87>?6 46 04B 94B8:4C43= F1734D4F831 4BB?19 83 H -B383193083301D8F186965B1B05AB018C19BF87B 869 91D57@19 65B1 4B 65319 01 91384C19 1H8@4683456 B05AB F56;1B319 @?F5B8 5D 301 B123?@ 869 C83178C A8CC 8C56; A430 ;75BB 91<483456 5D 68B8C B123?@ 65319 A430 F7?B3D57@83456 6B21F48CFC464F8C1H8@4683456A430B@1CC 9131F3456 A430 F5DD11 25A917 F8@2057 75B1 A8317 2834163A8B6538:C1359131F3B@1CCA430FC5B191=1B 01 53017 71F579B 5D 301 5B2438C 8CB5 B05A 301 B8@1 3 4B 1<4916330833012134345617:146;8;74F?C3?74B308BB?DD1719 94B8:4C43=5D30165B186930168B8C:561B 665A8=301= F86 3786BF169 4635 301 D?6F34568C 94B8:4C43= A04F04B @571 - 12 - 3086 I 5A1<17 301 74:?68C 08B F56B491719 301 94B8:4C43= 83 I 869 08B 8A87919 301 F5@216B83456 01 74:?68C 08B D84C19 35 6531 3083 301 6534568C 46F5@1 :1 F56B491719 83 B -+ 217 @5630 8B 5:B17<19 8:5<1 16F1 301 4B F8CF?C8319 8B B -+ H%H%HIJ !( !#:=38E46;8 @?C342C4175D%D573018;15D%=187B %. 01 $% &$ ' 4B F56B49171956C=D57+@5630B 0171D57130121343456174B 16343C19D57 !(#?6917304B0189 + 3 4B A5730 35 6531 3083 301 2134345617 08B B?DD1719 C5BB 5D B@1CC46; 8:4C43= 83 301 8;1 5D % =187B 0171D571301 &B05?C908<1:116 @571 16F18B?@5D (!#4B8A87919?6917301 01895DC5BB5D8@164341B % 01 74:?68C 08B 8A87919 718B568:C1 F5@216B83456 8@5?63 35A879B )& &$ %! &$& *&%! $ &$ +,& *&% &$ $& -'$ 01 B8@1 6119 653 :1 94B3?7:19 - 13 - 0171D571 301 2134345617 4B 16343C19 D57 3538C 16086F19 F5@216B83456 5D B ')-++ ?6917 301 D5CC5A46;0189B C 5 189B 5@216B83456 A87919 % 846869?DD1746; B )++++ 33169863F087;1BD559869 F56<1=86F1F087;1B B ++ ) 5BB5DD?3?7146F5@1 B %%++ ' #194F8CH216943?71 B )'%++ 5BB5D46F5@19?746;37183@163 B %-++ 5BB5D8@164341B8696?3743456 D559 B +++ - (57@194F8C1H216943?71B B %++++ 538CF5@216B83456 1BBA87919:=30174:?68C B )++ B )++ 538C6086F1@163 B ')-++ ) 16F1 82218CB 91B17<1 35 :1 8CC5A19 46 2873 0171D571301D5CC5A46;, - 14 - ! 0182218CB8718CC5A19462873 018221CC86346#( 5 +%)-' +%.4B16343C19D57 8 B?@ 5D B .+++ 46 89943456 35 A083 08B :116 8A87919 := 301 74:?68C 8C56; A430 463171B3 83 301 78315DI2 8 D75@98315D2134345634CC30198315D 9125B43 018221CC86346#( 5 +%)-) +%.4B16343C19D57 8 B?@ 5D B ')-++ 46 89943456 35 A083 08B :116 8A87919 := 301 74:?68C 8C56; A430 463171B3 83 301 78315DI2 8 D75@98315D2134345634CC30198315D 9125B43 1B3 5D 301 57917 28BB19 := 301 74:?68C 71;87946; 9125B4313F 71@846?68C31719 9 ' $" ) $! 4B35 %C5 -